• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Leaf by Niggle

Originally posted by Walter
Eledhwen: Ain't that sad, all these early documents of the Sumerian, Babylonian, Assyrian, etc. cultures now destroyed or lost ...
Did anyone make copies of any of them, I wonder, for safe keeping outside Iraq (no doubt if they were copied onto local computers, those have gone). I suspect not. Saddam would not have anticipated his downfall (and may have destroyed everything in his wake if he did ... remember the previous Gulf War?). Like Sauron's Ring, he would have thought Iraq was wrapped around his finger.

Much of the loss (of information, not actual parchment) is, I fear, down to professional greed. I remember the trouble academics had in getting access to the Dead Sea Scrolls, because of the risk of an outsider making a great discovery. I think I remember that someone had to illicitly photograph them.

Thinks... how do I tie this post in with Leaf By Niggle?
Sidles off quietly...
 
Walter posted:
What is still nagging me, though, is that Christopher Tolkien dates the writing of tree and leaf 1938-9, "when the Lord of the Rings was beginning to unroll itself", whereas Carpenter dates it around 1943, when Tolkien seemed stuck with his work on the LotR.
Those were J.R.R. Tolkien’s words at the beginning of Tree and Leaf, not Christopher Tolkien’s, so the discrepency is between to accounts given by J.R.R. Tolkien..

I suspect the 1945 letter that dates it to more than two years ago is more accurate than Tolkien’s introduction written for republication of the work in 1964.

Eledhwen posted:
Much of the loss (of information, not actual parchment) is, I fear, down to professional greed. I remember the trouble academics had in getting access to the Dead Sea Scrolls, because of the risk of an outsider making a great discovery. I think I remember that someone had to illicitly photograph them.
There is a good summary of the history of the scrolls at The Dead Sea Scrolls.

Scholarship is filled with such stories of non-publication and restriction of access to the materials. Fortunately the opposite occurs at least as often, partly because most ancient texts are are of no interest outside of very small circles of academics and enthusiasts.

How much commentary will you find on J.R.R. Tolkien’s edition of Ancrene Wisse, for example?

For an edition of the work on the web, not Tolkien’s, see Ancrene Wisse.

It is gratifying to note how many universities and special scholarly projects and individual initiatives have been set up to produce web editions of texts, providing a true wealth of information for no commerical return.

Of course, since published editions of most texts usually don’t make a profit ...., why not?

Also, whatever the actual case in law, there is a general perception that the contents of old documents ought to be the property of people in general, and it will be increasingly difficult to justify their not being made available on the web for anyone to consult.
 
I just finished Leaf by Niggle after about three nights reading (I don't get much time to read :(). Anyhow, I can't help but wonder, what is it?

I concur with most people that it is an allegory. I believe that it is a man's journey through life, death, purgatory, and heaven.

His painting (in general, not specifically his opus -- as I shall call it) represents his life. His constant good deeds throughout life -- stopping to help Parish -- are what in the end brings him to the heaven.

The point of his opus was to make himself known and remembered. He seemed lonely. His painting was the story of his life, his autobiography. He wrote it just before the journey that he was supposed to go on.

Then suddenly, death turns up on his doorstep. He comes to take him away, without giving him a chance to pack and set things straight.

He's put through hard work. He needs to prove that he belongs in heaven. His good deeds for Parish are mentioned. My only question is, who are the Two Voices? Perhaps it's Tolkien's fictional representation of God. Instead, the setting is a ditheistic place...

Finally, he gets to heaven. He gets to what he worked on his whole life. His purpose has been fulfilled, and he gets to enjoy it...

I would have to (humbly) disagree with the insinuation that Leaf by Niggle is based on Tolkien's life. As I understand, it was written shortly before WWII, so he would have been in his mid 40s....This would be too early to base an allegorical biography on, don't you agree? He still had another 30 to 40 years in his life.

The point of the single leaf leftover was almost Niggle's headstone. It told what he was dedicated to. It was even marked with his name (put in a museum). Finally, the headstone disintegrated.

So...that's my opinion of Leaf by Niggle. What do you think of it? Who were the Two Voices?

- Mike
 
I believe that the two Voices represent (perhaps among other things) Justice and Mercy. As usual with God, Mercy prevails.

Niggle's painting represents the life's work that God intended for him. He did not "finish" it or even get as far as he should have done not only because of his "good deeds" for his neighbor but because he was a rather disorganized man who did not put the time allowed him to good use, nor did he "prepare" for the journey that he knew he would have to take. You see, Niggle (as a "religious" man) knew that there would be a journey with a destination. People know that they are going to die, but unless they have some belief system, many assume that there is no need to prepare for it other than their obligations on "this side" of the journey. Niggle knew better, yet he did not prepare and so found himself in the "hospital" in which he was being "healed" of his former character failures - none of which was severe enough to prevent his reaching a good end in his journey. However, until his term in this "hospital of the soul", he would not have been able to successfully continue his journey because he was, in fact, "ill".

Interestingly enough, in the end Tolkien has the remnants of Niggle's life's work reduced to one leaf from his huge painting and even that is eventually destroyed in a "fire". In this, the author is saying that however powerful and important we are on earth, it will all turn to dust in the end. Preparation for the "journey" is all important and that includes the "kindnesses" that we do for even our most annoying "neighbors".
 
Originally posted by Walter
Mike, I don't think Leaf by Niggle was ever meant as an "autobiography" when Tolkien wrote that story. Rather, he was stuck during the writing of "The new Hobbit" and probably wondering if he ever would be able to find the time and energy to finish what evenually became The Lord of the Rings and to complete and revise The Silmarillion. Humphrey Carpenter describes this in his Tolkien biography:
But then, in a way, Niggle is autobiographical. Certainly, it is Tolkien's reflection on "Everyman", his "here and now" life and its effects upon his "ultimate journey" - and that, perforce, must include the author himself.
 
Originally posted by Walter
Of course it is "autobiographical" in an allegorical way, I think, but not an "autobiography" in the sense that it would give a more or less detailed account of his life, works, etc.
Not unless Tolkien had more friendly neighbors than is suggested in his biography! Somehow, I can't see him climbing about fixing anyone's roof, can you? :p
 
If only Tolkien had the royalties of, say, JK Rowling. Would the 'painting' ever have got finished, even if he didn't have to mend tyres or mark exam papers I wonder? Can a mythology (Legendarium) ever be finished?
 
Walter posted:
In either case, Tolkien probably would have finished his legendarium one way or the other, but as it was, he seemed rather frustrated at first, ...
Possibly.

But The Lord of the Rings already has in its background a “Myths Transformed” legendarium in which Durin awakes under Sun and Moon (though unstained Moon) and Treebeard gives an account of the Elder Days that doesn’t fit with anything Tolkien wrote elsewhere.

Perhaps, especially with his academic load, Tolkien would have been equally bogged down then as he became latter, simply unable to adapt what his younger self wrote in a more freely imaginative mode without constraints that the later Tolkien felt were necessary. Eventually his proposed publishers might have given up on him and The Lord of the Rings might have been set aside in a closet and been forgotten.
Another important point is, that many of the European "mythological" tales seem to have been deliberately changed - in the process of being put to paper - by the Christian monks, who were not pleased with the heathen contents and their possible influence on the peoples reading those tales.
This is very pertinent. And it was not only Christian monks who had problems with older material.

It is probably not accidental that almost none of the earliest Greek mythological tales survive outside of Homer and the Homeric hymns and Hesiod though we get odd references here and there to material that the later Greeks were uncomfortable with and generally didn’t repeat.

There is a tendency later not to speak about Zeus’s rise to power over his father Kronos and sometimes to deny that any such thing could have occurred. But too much had been written down for that mythology easily denied. Instead it had to be misinterpreted as poetic allegory, with Kronos taken to be Khronos ‘Time’ who devours all.

It became rather impious to recall such tales that originally redounded to the god’s glory. Philosophers mostly believed in the gods in general and in following customs but decried the traditional tales as scandalous lies of the poets.

In the Hindu Vedas Indra is obviously the greatest and highest of the gods. Yet even the Mahabharata contains references to the fact that Indra is no longer worshipped. He has sunk to being an icompetent trickster, lord of the lesser gods of this world, dependant on the more powerful super-gods Vishnu and Shiva to maintain his power. Yet in some sense Indra had to remain king of the gods because it was so written.
 
Last edited:
Niggle fiddled with and altered the great painting all through his life in his attempt to capture the imaginings of his mind. Like Niggle, Tolkien's work was his alone; the rest of the world unaware of its existence until, little by little (hobbit by hobbit) it was unfolded before the world. If Tolkien's tale had been written years ago, no doubt the Chritianity would have been interwoven with it, and we would have had a much diluted tale. Thankfully that can not happen for another thirty years (I'm glad that I'm unlikely to be around for the Disney version!).

I like to think of Tolkien arriving at the equivalent of Niggle Parish and finding himself in his own 'last homely house' - a place of rest and healing, with the final journey through his own imagined mountains laid out before him. Maybe C S Lewis would be waiting, Bilbo-style by the tale fire.
 
It's my humble opinion that "Leaf by Niggle" is the most poignant book of JRRT and is, in effect, an autobiography. JRRT was obsessed with LOTR and ME (much to our benefit) and, like Niggle, couldn't leave it alone. The "leaf" that he drew became a tree within a field which had a background and mountains and people.

Anyone else out there care to share their thoughts on this theory ?
Yes, an incredibly poignant and personal metaphor for himself, this was Tolkien expressing so much.

Written completely in one sitting, it tells the story of Niggle who only wants to work on his masterpiece and resents and neglects other parts of his life because of it, then the associated regret and the period of consequence before the assured redemption.

I understood completely and I felt closer to Tolkien the man upon reading this. I would recommend reading or particularly even experiencing in audiobook format. Leaf By Niggle is an experience.
 
It's my humble opinion that "Leaf by Niggle" is the most poignant book of JRRT and is, in effect, an autobiography. JRRT was obsessed with LOTR and ME (much to our benefit) and, like Niggle, couldn't leave it alone. The "leaf" that he drew became a tree within a field which had a background and mountains and people.

Anyone else out there care to share their thoughts on this theory ?

I loved leaf by niggle and I fully agree it appeared to be an autobiography. And i think if anyone has read Tolkiens letters and carpenter, then there can be no doubt to that fact.
 
It's really a story about his 'smoking addiction' - his little niggling distraction from time to time.
Seems that most fans prefer to make his story more complex than it really is, because they need Tolkien's Leaf by Niggle to appear more sophisticated than it really is.
 
It's really a story about his 'smoking addiction' - his little niggling distraction from time to time.
Seems that most fans prefer to make his story more complex than it really is, because they need Tolkien's Leaf by Niggle to appear more sophisticated than it really is.
Do you really think so? Or is it a joke?
Maybe I wouldn't call Leaf by Niggle allegorical (as Tolkien didn't like allegory) but I would call it symbolic and mythical. IMO, the story has nothing to do with smoking.
 
Last edited:
No joke. Sorry to say. But Tolkien was a heavy 'piper' and even comments in LOTR about Pippen 'smoking too much'.
Leaf by Niggle is basically about his 'vice'. Surely as The Old Man of the Sea is about Hemingway's own 'addiction' to alcohol and Silence (song) by Delerium (ft Sarah McLachlan) is about the vice of addiction. Read it again, with this in thought and you'll see how everything 'simply' makes sense of the short work.
 
No joke. Sorry to say. But Tolkien was a heavy 'piper' and even comments in LOTR about Pippen 'smoking too much'.
Leaf by Niggle is basically about his 'vice'. Surely as The Old Man of the Sea is about Hemingway's own 'addiction' to alcohol and Silence (song) by Delerium (ft Sarah McLachlan) is about the vice of addiction. Read it again, with this in thought and you'll see how everything 'simply' makes sense of the short work.
This interpretation is new to me. And it's interesting to hear of something new. Thanks for sharing. However, what about these qoutes (especially the last one)?
Screenshot_20221010-014439_Chrome.jpg
 
So he 'dislikes' allegory, but doesn't really say he didn't use it and sublimely says "its not really or properly..." (an allegory) as if it was in a way. He also says "I tried to show allegorically...". Guess the old pipe smoking compromised his scruple against allegory?
 
So he 'dislikes' allegory, but doesn't really say he didn't use it and sublimely says "its not really or properly..." (an allegory) as if it was in a way. He also says "I tried to show allegorically...". Guess the old pipe smoking compromised his scruple against allegory?
Just read his 1936 lecture to the British Academy, "Beowulf: The Monsters and the Critics", published by Christopher Tolkien in the collection of essays "The Monsters & the Critics and other Essays" in 1983 by George Allen & Unwin (I have a 1997 paperback by Harper Collins). JRRT without the slightest doubt uses allegory here - strict allegory! What he was allergic to was the all-too-widespread sloppy allegory (as he was allergic to sloppiness in anything that pretended to be philology).

He may have grown ever more allergic to any attempt to read anything he published starting with LoTR as allegory as the huge majority perpetrated was the allegorical slush he so detested - so occasionally overreacting. He did not deny that parts of what he wrote might be open to allegorical interpretations, but unless these complied with his strict view on the use of allegory, his reply was likely to be a snort of derision.

And as was the case on other matters, he occasionally - in writing! - had a "running argument with himself" (Tom Shippey quoting Verly Flieger in the former's 2003 third edition of his "The Road to Middle-earth"), not necessarily arriving at a conclusion ...
 
What he was allergic to was the all-too-widespread sloppy allegory (as he was allergic to sloppiness in anything that pretended to be philology).
I think we begin to edge up against JRRT's feeling here. I've also read his distaste was for "intentional" allegory - adding my own words, 'the blatant kind that hits you upside the head whether it's necessary to be used or not.'

I'm looking out for where I ran across that reference so I can set it aside when I find it again. The issue seems to resurface with a certain unpredictable regularity.

Is there a reference at hand sir Olorgando, regarding his distaste being for 'sloppy' allegory? If so can you provide it? (Or is it to be found in The Monsters and the Critics you spoke of? I've just added that book to my library recently, and can be on the lookout for it if so.

(This may be one I DO choose to write an essay on to pull things together regarding his viewpoint. I had set the concept of writing my own book and essays aside in favor of other things, but I may change my mind. Essays may become a matter of WHAT the subjects are about rather than whether or not to do them. Everything is worth an essay. But only some things are REALLY worth an essay.)
 
I've also read his distaste was for "intentional" allegory -
...
Is there a reference at hand sir Olorgando, regarding his distaste being for 'sloppy' allegory? If so can you provide it? (Or is it to be found in The Monsters and the Critics you spoke of? I've just added that book to my library recently, and can be on the lookout for it if so.
The only direct statement on allegory by JRRT that I can think of off the cuff is that in the foreword to the Second Edition, where he states his "cordial dislike" for it. There might be more comments in "Letters", but none come to mind spontaneously.
What you will find in "The Monsters ...", in the first essay with gives the book its title, is precisely intentional allegory (pointed out by Tom Shippey in his books), about the state of Beowulf criticism at the time he held the lecture in 1936 that is the basis for this essay.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top