An answer from the King himself?
The longer I think about it, the more likely Gothmog's suggestion seems to me.
Ulmo was a lot to do with the whole thing, getting
Turgon to build the
city there, and helping the people move away in secret. I don't see any reason he would not have put some encouragement to go there in the sound of the water.
Beleg, the problem I have with your suggestions, and I touched this in opening, is that I did not really see that fear of
Morgoth could have been cause enough for these people to leave the land they loved. They were just leaving to a beautiful white city with the music of fountains, but a life of hiding and who knows when hiding would end?
But all of this reminds me, what do you suppose Turgon
and especially his people were thinking about the more distant future? I say they must have had a vague idea of something. Did they maybe think that
Gondolin would come out to war eventually? Think Gondolin would be dicovered eventually? I mean, lets be realistic, it could not remain hidden forever in
any case, could it? When Morgoth would get full victory outside in the lands, would the Gondolin have
any chance? And as for Morgoth defeating all the other
realms of
Beleriand, I think there could be no doubt this would happen. If the people believed Morgoth can be defeated by the Eldar, then Turgon's folk had no reason to hide in that way... at least safety from Morgoth cannot have been the primary reason for hiding. So here these people are thinking Morgoth will be victorous outside. They must have had some vague idea about their own survival. Just how would they? Turgon knew that the
Valar were needed. I wonder if he had expressed this to his people even from the early time in Nevrast.
Turgon, I think you are right about others besides the King wanting to stay in the city and fight. I wonder if a lot of readers would disagree with you? But I hadn't thought before about how having had to leave Nevrast in the past might make the Gondolindrim less willing to leave their new city, that's a good idea.
...and I'm with you on the Lost
Tales version of the coast. And the Land of Willows! I like how CT puts it,
drowsy beauty. Wish I was there right now

...maybe lead by
magic and destiny.