Now you've done it.eth.
Your contradiction is fallacious for reasons I cannot disclose, or if you do I will face grave repercussions, like say, another poor satirical post.
That's a toughie-do Orks etc really have the "free will" that
other races have? I suppose I can counter this by saying Orks aren't born at all but are a product of the misogynist Elven shell-fish collectors with a fetish for deep fat fried chicken, canto X of Dante’s Divine Comedy written in Sanskrit on marble tablets in Lithuanian villages whose names begin with R and end with T.
Can something be born
evil? Something can be born to do evil deeds, but can it be born intrinsically evil? Did baby Orks get breast fed? Did they tear up everything and poke each other's eyes out? Did they play some kind of sick, maniacal version of peek-a-boo? Did they watch back to back episodes of "Teletubbies Go Erotic'?
And what is evil? If you ask an Ork to define 'evil' what would he/she define 'evil' as? Would his definition be homogenous with say, a
Hobbit, or would a Hobbit's definition be homogenous with say a
Númenórean's? No, evil is by no mean ubiquitous. Evil is fundamentally heterogeneous. No one can have the same opinion on what "evil" is since "evil" by definition is relative for each person.
What then, is "evil" according to the Orks. Is "evil" doing something good? No? Why? Because in our eyes it is a paradox, you an evil act cannot be labelled as being 'good' unless the evil act (unintentionally) leads to a greater good. Such instances occur time and time again in
Middle-Earth. But what may seem oxymoronic to is the norm for the Orks. The Orks are the product of their society. Their society happens to be rather more psychotic then the other staple societies of Middle-Earth. Naturally they follow the conventional "rules" of their society, just like the Hobbit follow their own conventions. The
Orkish conventions happen to include things which repulse the "pious"
race of Middle-Earth. But are the Orks evil if they follow the norm of not only their society but also of their "race". If the Orks are intrinsically "evil" as a race then is a perfidious Ork (by "our" standards) 'evil' or is he the 'normal' by-product of his race, just like the norm amongst
Hobbits is to be fat and stupid with a hidden seed of watermelon (courage?) sowed somewhere in their expansive stomach.
So the Orks are resigned to be "evil" because that is their "fate" in Middle-Earth. To be a paradigm of all that is bad and ugly, though one could say the same thing about
Celeborn. And what of the 'good-guys' in middle-earth-are they not a product of their "fate" in Middle-Earth or a product of the music? What would the world be like if there was no
Manwë Súlimo,
Ulmo or
Fingolfin? Or
Elendil,
Aragorn or
Frodo Baggins? Were they chosen to be "good" by
god? Was it their fate to follow their predestined plan in Middle-Earth? If so then how can they be any different from the Orks who were 'programmed' to be "evil"? Aren't they both such mechanisms of
Eru's grand plan? Can one help if their actions lead to a certain event? Or if they are intrinsically programmed to do this or that?
Melian's attempts to battle the fate of her husband and her foster son's family failed. Why? Because she couldn't battle against "fate or rather the manifestation of fate, the infallible Eru. Aren't they just the product of the same thing, except they are polarized because of the difference of their "role" in the general scheme of things? Is it glib to simply say, Orks are bad and let's say the Hobbits are good? No, that would be too simple. Unless you are talking about one individual such a statement would always be fallacious. Pluralized, or talking about the race as a whole you cannot prove it to be true. There were evil Hobbits, evil
Men and even evil
Elves and
Ainur. Wait a minute-aren't these people products of the "music" and of “divine providence” and so are their actions bereft of 'free will' because it was their 'role' to do such and such a thing. But you could argue that they could have done something completely different. But wouldn't this have changed the whole
history of Arda? Where would
Arda be without the treachery of
Morgoth or the
Balrogs, or
Sauron and
Ar-Pharazôn’s perfidy?
And were Orks wholly "evil". Superficially one can conclude that yes they were wholly evil, but superficially one can conclude that Don Quixote was crazy and Akhilleus arrogant. Are judgements based on superficial analysis useless? Not entirely, of course, Quixote was crazy, Akhilleus was arrogant (or should that read embittered with Agamemnon?) and Orks "evil". But delve deeper into their characters and you can unearth some interesting facts. For example, the Orks have a sense of comradeship and loyalty. Maybe they even care for each other.
The great goblin's death sure angered his Orks. Aragorn tells us that Orks usually avenge their fallen captains. The
Moria Orks state to the
Uruk-Hai and Mordorians that they came for revenge All that way! And whilst the sun was shining and elven
bows singing! Not only admirable, but also very brave of them. Upon finding
Frodo's body
Snaga, or one of his lackeys or maybe it was Shagrat, when talking about his other companions (they think it may be an
Elf) supposed abandonment of Frodo as being a "regular
Elvish trick". So are they able to recognise treacherous actions such as the abandonment of your comrade? And are they indoctrinated against Elves and Men and are they told lies about the base deeds of Elves and Men? So are they able to differentiate between "good and bad" acts, in their own sphere of morals? Then again 'Quendi and Eldar' states that no captured Ork ever showed any moral scruples.
If Orks are a product of their 'role' in Middle-Earth as decreed by the infallible Eru, then are they really evil, since all of Eru's actions are a direct result of what he thinks will lead to the "greater good" of Arda (can things such as
Melkor's discord be classified under the "it was fate" argument?) and so are the Orks in fact carrying out (albeit unwittingly) Eru's grand plan for the improvement of Arda and the re0vamping of the postal system? Is Brad Pitt H-O-T? Are you asleep yet? If so, why not? Am I the most pedantic casuist ever? Or is my fastidious casuistry a product of my upbringing....

am I spewing forth nonsense because I know nobody will ever get this far whilst reading by dreary post? Maybe a nice
sentence in Lemon Chiffon will catch everyones attention or maybe a
different font or
small fontwill.