Foe-Hammer
Member
- Joined
- Dec 20, 2001
- Messages
- 984
Mrs. Maggott said:Frankly, F. H., for someone who posts that purists give their opinion as "Gospel", it seems that you are the one who does that! You state categorically and apparently with full knowledge that Tolkien's Aragorn "wouldn't work" in the film and that only Jackson's pale imitation could. Would you please give us the benefit of what palantir you used to make that determination? As Tolkien's Aragorn was never presented, how can you be sure that he would not have worked? As Yoda might say, "Prescient are we? Able to see what others cannot, can we??"
We know that Jackson's Aragorn didn't work for many devotees of the book, so that, at least, is an objective finding. There is proof of that contention. However, we have no way of knowing if in fact, Tolkien's Aragorn would not have worked simply because he was never presented! Yes, even you cannot credibly claim that you would not have liked the character had he been presented in the film as he was in the book. You may guess that you wouldn't have liked it, but in my humble opinion, had Jackson presented Tolkien's Aragorn, you would have been just as happy as you were with Jackson's character. True, that is a "guess" on my part, but you have nothing more going for you than a "guess" as well since you never saw the other character. Any declaration of dislike on your part of something which you never had an opportunity to see sounds like 20-20 hindsight to me!
jallan said:Of course I don’t think it was a mistake by Tolkien. May have indicates that we don’t know what would have happened had Boromir remained true, that is we don’t know what Tolkien would finally have written if Tolkien had decided not to have Boromir fall for the lure of the Ring.
In fact, of course, it is pretty certain Tolkien would have had the quest come out all right regardless of what he might have done with Boromir.
Ah, another example of "circuitous reasoning". Something is so because it is so; that isn't an answer. You have no proof that had Mr. Jackson decided to offer Tolkien's Aragorn, the results would not have been the same - or better.Foe-Hammer said:Again, since PJ was the genuis behind the absolute success of these movies and he chose not to shoot aragorn that way I will defer to his infinite wisdom that book aragorn would not work on fiilm and film aragorn is infinitly better.
Mrs. Maggott said:
I will withdraw nothing! I have only stated that no one can know if Tolkien's Aragorn would have been "unsuccessful" - your contention - in the films. That is a perfectly legitimate comment because it merely states something that is true: in fact, no one can "know" because as it was not done, it is an unknown quantity. As a result, no "absolute" statement such as you made can be made referable to it. Had another film or films been made alike in every way to the three that Jackson made but with Tolkien's character, then you would be in a position to compare the success rate of the two - and draw your conclusion. However, absent that "control factor", your declarative statements either wishful thinking or simply nonsense! You have no proof nor can you get any to support your allegations.Foe-Hammer said:Is only appears to be circular reasoning because refuse to accept what makes for good cinema. Aragorns "Mr Perfect" persona would have been fimable and YOU may have enjoyed it, but that is where guessing ends. Since the npw are the ones who are claiming the changes WOULD have been better, the burden of proof is theirs. I only offered the experience and skill of a professional filmaker and the huge success he has had with this film as a contrast to the npw's lack of skill, experience and success.
So you see my dear, you started this and I am finishing it. If you cannot in fact support your outrageous claims you must withdrawl them and then I will withdrawl mine.
Book-Aragorn has no bow. I was talking about the book:Morgaphry said:
From the book:Morgaphry said:
It may be that Boromir has retreated to the place where had “slain many of them”. That the horn is shattered suggests that the Orcs were understandably concerned to stop Boromir from blowing that horn. An arrow-shot would be unlikely to shatter the horn (despite the film version). So there was likely some hand-to-hand fighting in an attempt to destroy the horn. Object accomplished, the Orcs fled, leaving Boromir to die from the arrow wounds.Then Boromir had come leaping through the trees. He had made them fight. He slew many of them and the rest fled. But they had not gone far on the way back when they were attacked again. by a hundred Orcs at least, some of them very large, and they shot a rain of arrows: always at Boromir. Boromir had blown his great horn till the woods rang, and at first the Orcs had been dismayed and had drawn back; but when no answer but the echoes came, they had attacked more fierce than ever. Pippin did not remember much more. His last memory was of Boromir leaning against a tree, plucking out an arrow; then darkness fell suddenly.
We learn here that the shield was also cloven.Beneath Amon Hen I heard his cry. There many foes he fought.
His cloven shield, his broken sword, they to the water brought.
Aragil once asked me what I meant by a Jackson purist. I replied than that a full Jackson-purist was only mythical.Foehammer said:Again, since PJ was the genuis behind the absolute success of these movies and he chose not to shoot aragorn that way I will defer to his infinite wisdom that book aragorn would not work on fiilm and film aragorn is infinitly better.
Mrs. Maggott said:I will withdraw nothing! I have only stated that no one can know if Tolkien's Aragorn would have been "unsuccessful" - your contention - in the films. That is a perfectly legitimate comment because it merely states something that is true: in fact, no one can "know" because as it was not done, it is an unknown quantity. As a result, no "absolute" statement such as you made can be made referable to it. Had another film or films been made alike in every way to the three that Jackson made but with Tolkien's character, then you would be in a position to compare the success rate of the two - and draw your conclusion. However, absent that "control factor", your declarative statements either wishful thinking or simply nonsense! You have no proof nor can you get any to support your allegations.
Mrs. Maggott said:I point to those who didn't. You say because of the popularity of the films, you have more in favor than against, but I say that many of those who "loved" the films were frankly disinterested in characterization.
Mrs. Maggott said:But be that as it may, I stand by my contention that you simply cannot declare as an absolute fact that Tolkien's character would not have worked in the films or that Jackson's was superior in that medium. There is simply no proof of eitehr statement.
jallan said:Foe-hammer of course will not attempt to prove infinite. Normally the phrase infinite wisdom except when used of God, is used sarcastically. I think this is the first time I’ve seen someone not use it sarcastically when referring to another person.
jallan said:Foe-hammer, you’ve lost it altogether and become an ultimate crank, drooling cultist.
More insults.Foe-hammer said:That is a completely accurate discription of how I was ACTING, but it is also a completely accurate discription of what you ARE because you REALLY believe the nonsense you spew.
Was this also ACTING?Movies are made to make money. They make money by being popular. They are popular because they appeal to a broad portion of the population. The more popular the movie the better it is.
We're not talking about whether the broken staircase scene was bad or good; we're talking about whether is a favourite ofFoe-Hammer said:Go do a search on "favorite scenes fellowship of the ring" and tell me how many claims you get that the moria scene was bad and how many you get that say it was good. There are over-whelmingly positive. So, as I have stated, anyone who thinks that scene was just awful, then their opinion is in fact in the minority.
jallan said:More insults.
jallan said:How many of your posts are now to be taken as fraudulent?
joxy said:We're not talking about whether the broken staircase scene was bad or good; we're talking about whether is a favourite of
"the majority". Your web sites will tell us, I don't doubt, that it is a favourite scene of the majority of the tiny minority of people who bother to visit these sites. Nothing more, nothing less.
joxy said:There is no way in which the statistics which would be required to show an overall majority could be obtained.
joxy said:I don't know anyone who thinks that scene was awful;
joxy said:my own opinion is that it was extremely good, one of the most exciting and impressive, bar the comedy line, in the film. The problem I have with it is that it was in the wrong film! It has nothing to do with the story, and it's bad story-telling AND bad film-making, because it interrupts the flow of the story AND of the film.
Mrs. Maggott said:That claim was made because you claimed that jrr's aragorn would have worked better than PJ's did. A claim which fits your exact discription above. So, if you are going to demand that I quite making my claim, you by your own circular reasoning MUST demand that you stop making your claim. <quote Foe Hammer>
Again, I wonder what you are reading! I said that Jackson's Aragorn was different from (and, in my opinion, inferior to) Tolkien's and, furthermore, that there was no logical reason why it should have been so. I did not say that Jackson's characterization of Aragorn "didn't work" in the films. Obviously, it did - as did his characterization of Faramir, Denethor, Saruman, Theoden, Elrond, Treebeard etc. etc. etc., all of which I found equally inferior (which is why I personally found the films inferior to the book).
However, when taken together, the films are what they are: popular with many people, less popular with others. But I never said that Tolkien's Aragorn would have "worked better"! Rather, I simply pointed out that it would have in fact, worked - a contention that you outright rejected. The assessment of "better" would be entirely up to the judgment of the person viewing the films. I daresay had Jackson actually presented Tolkien's Aragorn, we would not be having this debate! I doubt that you would have had a problem with the character if Jackson had in fact presented Tolkien's Aragorn. After all, you had no problem with Gandalf and that character was certainly true to Tolkien (until the last film, that is). From what I am able to glean from your posts, it is enough that Jackson does it that it is acceptable, right, true and the best that could have possibly been done!
My point is that I could no more say Tolkien's character would work "better" than you can say that it wouldn't work at all! I merely said that I would have preferred Tolkien's Aragorn (as would many others, I'm sure) and that Jackson had no real reason to make the changes that he did other than he wished to do so. Looking at both characters and the opportunities that existed in the films to "backfill" their histories, I don't think either one was "impossible" for the audience to understand nor do I think that either was more difficult or easier than the other; as far as the difficulties of character exposition are concerned, it was a toss up. I know you don't believe that, but then......
Mrs. Maggott said:Forgive me, but I find this absolute fixation with the "popularity" of the films a bit tiresome and certainly not germane to much of what has been posted. Yes, they're popular - and why not? They have everything that today's movie going public wants: action, adventure, violence, fantasy, low necklines, handsome dudes in danger and sucking face, tragedy, comedy, victory of the good guys and the boat sailing off to Avalon, er, excuse me, Valinor! Goodness, these films are a very cornucopia of every possible emotion and situation with "state of the art" special effects, fantastic scenery and plenty of feminine and masculine pulchitrude! It is hardly necessary to state the obvious; that is, that they are wildly popular and critically acclaimed!
Mrs. Maggott said:But that does not answer the questions and criticisms that have been raised by those of us who are not nearly as infatuated with the films and especially with the director and his writers as are apparently the rest of mankind. Our contentions are valid enough since they have managed to detract from our enjoyment of the films. I would hardly complain of something that did not take place. For instance, I have yet to criticize Jackson for making Arwen a man (he didn't) or Gandalf a woman (he didn't) or Frodo six feet tall (he didn't). I have only found fault with those things that he did or failed to do which negatively influenced my opinion of the works.
Mrs. Maggott said:As far as the "popularity" issue is concerned, I think that is only contested by those of us who find fault with the films because it is used to dismiss our criticisms. After all, we are assured, why should we find fault when so many others have accepted the films wholeheartedly and uncritically! But that argument holds no water. That's like dismissing a Red Sox fan's loyalty to his team because more people like the Yankees!
Mrs. Maggott said:I think that every film critic and/or purist is congnizant of the present popularity of the films. How it will play out in time has yet to be determined, but for now, these films are wildly popular and critically acclaimed. Nonetheless, neither of those facts changes at all the problems that I (and others) have with them. This isn't an election. We cannot be "voted" into liking what we do not like or accepting what to us is unacceptable. I'm afraid that those using the "huge popularity" argument to deflect our opinions are just going to have to live with that.
I think this discussion would be more appropriately placed in the book forum. Please join in at: http://thetolkien.forum/showthread.php?t=15165jallan said:No. See in Appendix F
jallan said:
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?