jallan
Member
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2003
- Messages
- 630
Foehammer posted:
Yet if you yourself will not listen, what reason have you to complain?
If you had read further you would see that I did not miss your point. I was strongly addressing your point.
It seems to me a most Sauronic philosophy that there is only one kind of good and that good can be rated only and solely by monetary profit, that, for example, the National Enquirer must be one of the best newspapers in the world by all standards (since in fact only one standard counts according to you) and that books or films and music that I esteem highly and which speak to me are objectively of little value except insomuch as they correspond with those books or films or music which have made the highest profits.
Aragil posted:
In fact Sam doesn’t know how Boromir died though movie-Sam now claims he does. Yet Movie-Faramir, though grieving for his brother, surprisingly shows no curiosity on the issue, no interest in what Sam knows or how Sam knows it and no curiosity about what other matters might have been hidden from him.
I suppose that could be justified on the assumption that movie-Faramir wrongly believes movie-Sam and would rather not know, at least at the moment, such sorry details as Sam might provide. Of course, if movie-Faramir had asked, “Yes! I would know the worst. Tell me how my brother died! then movie-Sam, careless in his words, would have been hard put to it to explain them.
I don’t mean that movie-Sam is supposed to be dishonest. I think the scriptors, and seeming yourself, forgot that Sam has no knowledge of how Boromir died.
For all Sam knew Boromir went mad mad and was slain by Aragorn. But for movie-Sam to present idle and unsupported speculation as fact is very odd.
Your suggestion that Boromir was driven to this almost hopeless task only by his guilt about Frodo is suppositious. Yes, it would seem hopeless. But would one expect Legolas or Gimli or Aragorn in a similar position not to undertake the same apparently hopeless task though not driven by guilt?
No direct connection of that kind appears in Tolkien’s tale. Boromir dies redeeming himself ... but with no indication that he would have acted any differently in other circumstances. Frodo was planning to sneak off in any case. In the book it is by chance more than anything that Aragorn has Boromir especially go after Merry and Pippin. (Well not altogether by chance, since Aragorn suspects something of the truth of what happened between Frodo and Boromir and so gives him a task that is not directly connected to searching for Frodo. But it is purely by chance that the Orcs first meet Merry and Pippin rather than any others of the Fellowship.) In the film it is chance rather than anything else, so far as we can see, that Boromir comes upon Merry and Pippin at that particular moment.
In the films Merry and Pippin also fight hard, Merry even cutting off the hands of several of the Orcs. Cowardly movie-Merry and cowardly movie-Pippin stand inactive as Boromir dies defending himself against incompetent Orcs who largely throw themselves on his blade.
Why was Aragorn not also killed when surrounded by Orcs? I’ve heard it suggested that it was because the movie-Orcs don’t care about Aragorn, being only interested in finding the Halflings. But when the Orcs do find two Halflings they ignore the Halflings and focus all their efforts on the man even when he lies wounded and helpless and is no threat to them at all and the Hobbits might have fled.
Foehammer, you complain that others insult you yet you continually insult others, especially for not listening to you.Again, I stopped reading here, because you have completely missed the point.
Yet if you yourself will not listen, what reason have you to complain?
If you had read further you would see that I did not miss your point. I was strongly addressing your point.
Totally true in this circular definition in which monetary profit is the only criteria of excellence.Movies are made to make money. They make money by being popular. They are popular because they appeal to a broad portion of the population. The more popular the movie the better it is.
It seems to me a most Sauronic philosophy that there is only one kind of good and that good can be rated only and solely by monetary profit, that, for example, the National Enquirer must be one of the best newspapers in the world by all standards (since in fact only one standard counts according to you) and that books or films and music that I esteem highly and which speak to me are objectively of little value except insomuch as they correspond with those books or films or music which have made the highest profits.
Aragil posted:
Movie-Sam states:I don't agree that this was a lie, and I gave you my reasons before without a response (that I recall). There is no reason to assume that Sam's reference is a literal one. He never says "The Ring killed Boromir" (one would assume by swallowing it). He said (among other things) that the Ring drove Boromir mad (not a lie). Boromir then (out of a sense of regret and seeking redemption) died defending the Hobbits- a relatively hopeless task that he probably would not have attempted had he not been racked by guilt for his own attack on Frodo and subsequent curse upon all halflings.
This is not why Boromir died except in a very tortuous, indirect fashion. It would be just as sensible to claim that Boromir died because he let Frodo get away with the Ring.You wanna know why your brother died? He tried to take the ring from Frodo. After swearing an oath to protect him, he tried to kill him. The ring drove your brother mad.
In fact Sam doesn’t know how Boromir died though movie-Sam now claims he does. Yet Movie-Faramir, though grieving for his brother, surprisingly shows no curiosity on the issue, no interest in what Sam knows or how Sam knows it and no curiosity about what other matters might have been hidden from him.
I suppose that could be justified on the assumption that movie-Faramir wrongly believes movie-Sam and would rather not know, at least at the moment, such sorry details as Sam might provide. Of course, if movie-Faramir had asked, “Yes! I would know the worst. Tell me how my brother died! then movie-Sam, careless in his words, would have been hard put to it to explain them.
I don’t mean that movie-Sam is supposed to be dishonest. I think the scriptors, and seeming yourself, forgot that Sam has no knowledge of how Boromir died.
For all Sam knew Boromir went mad mad and was slain by Aragorn. But for movie-Sam to present idle and unsupported speculation as fact is very odd.
Your suggestion that Boromir was driven to this almost hopeless task only by his guilt about Frodo is suppositious. Yes, it would seem hopeless. But would one expect Legolas or Gimli or Aragorn in a similar position not to undertake the same apparently hopeless task though not driven by guilt?
Boromir is presented throughout Tolkien’s writing and in the film as an honest and brave and guileless man, except in the matter of the Ring, exactly the kind of person who would die in defense of his comrades whether he had reason to feel guilty or not.If he had not first been driven mad by the Ring, he would not later have sacrificed his life in trying to save others.
It isn’t. I occasionally encounter similar statements but never with supporting analysis. I expect that statement arises because Boromir’s death is associated closely with his madness chronologically and because a strong causal connection between ill-deeds arising from pride or anger or possessiveness and a subsequent death so often does occur in tales.I thought this was the generally accepted reading of the book- that Boromir's madness brought around his own demise.
No direct connection of that kind appears in Tolkien’s tale. Boromir dies redeeming himself ... but with no indication that he would have acted any differently in other circumstances. Frodo was planning to sneak off in any case. In the book it is by chance more than anything that Aragorn has Boromir especially go after Merry and Pippin. (Well not altogether by chance, since Aragorn suspects something of the truth of what happened between Frodo and Boromir and so gives him a task that is not directly connected to searching for Frodo. But it is purely by chance that the Orcs first meet Merry and Pippin rather than any others of the Fellowship.) In the film it is chance rather than anything else, so far as we can see, that Boromir comes upon Merry and Pippin at that particular moment.
In the films Merry and Pippin also fight hard, Merry even cutting off the hands of several of the Orcs. Cowardly movie-Merry and cowardly movie-Pippin stand inactive as Boromir dies defending himself against incompetent Orcs who largely throw themselves on his blade.
Why was Aragorn not also killed when surrounded by Orcs? I’ve heard it suggested that it was because the movie-Orcs don’t care about Aragorn, being only interested in finding the Halflings. But when the Orcs do find two Halflings they ignore the Halflings and focus all their efforts on the man even when he lies wounded and helpless and is no threat to them at all and the Hobbits might have fled.
Last edited:
