Foe-Hammer
Member
- Joined
- Dec 20, 2001
- Messages
- 984
Mrs. Maggott said:Frankly, F. H., for someone who posts that purists give their opinion as "Gospel", it seems that you are the one who does that! You state categorically and apparently with full knowledge that Tolkien's Aragorn "wouldn't work" in the film and that only Jackson's pale imitation could. Would you please give us the benefit of what palantir you used to make that determination? As Tolkien's Aragorn was never presented, how can you be sure that he would not have worked? As Yoda might say, "Prescient are we? Able to see what others cannot, can we??"
We know that Jackson's Aragorn didn't work for many devotees of the book, so that, at least, is an objective finding. There is proof of that contention. However, we have no way of knowing if in fact, Tolkien's Aragorn would not have worked simply because he was never presented! Yes, even you cannot credibly claim that you would not have liked the character had he been presented in the film as he was in the book. You may guess that you wouldn't have liked it, but in my humble opinion, had Jackson presented Tolkien's Aragorn, you would have been just as happy as you were with Jackson's character. True, that is a "guess" on my part, but you have nothing more going for you than a "guess" as well since you never saw the other character. Any declaration of dislike on your part of something which you never had an opportunity to see sounds like 20-20 hindsight to me!
Again, since PJ was the genuis behind the absolute success of these movies and he chose not to shoot aragorn that way I will defer to his infinite wisdom that book aragorn would not work on fiilm and film aragorn is infinitly better.
