Joxyjoxy said:Balrog:
1. No-one ever expected the books in their entirety, or in anywhere near their entirety, to be included in the films, so tranquillise yourself first, over that point.
2. The point of Beorn's thesis was "you didn't see J. R. R. Tolkien's The Return of the King. You saw Peter Jackson's The Return
of the King". What's so irrational about that? It reads to me like a simple statement of fact. You don't disagree with it, do you?
Mrs. Maggott said:Alas, this subject is becoming fraught with futility. The major problem lies - as I see it - in the fact that the two sides are stuck in a battle not about the films themselves, but about whether or not what was done in the films was necessary. Purists say no, FADs (in many instances), say yes. I don't think that the arguement can be won by either side, so why continue it?
1. No I haven't noticed, because none, that I know or have ever read here, did so.balrog said:1. tolkien fans did....or have'nt you noticed?
2. what am i disagreeing with again?
But, again, this is not what is in dispute here.joxy said:1. No I haven't noticed, because none, that I know or have ever read here, did so.
2. That people who saw the films didn't see Tolkien's ROTK, and that they did see Jackson's ROTK.
joxy said:1. No I haven't noticed, because none, that I know or have ever read here, did so.
2. That people who saw the films didn't see Tolkien's ROTK, and that they did see Jackson's ROTK.
Mrs. Maggott said:But, again, this is not what is in dispute here.
Most FADs agree that this was Jackson's LOTR. However, many also believe that Jackson was able to "translate" enough of Tolkien into his own interpretation of the story for the films to be acceptable as at least one version of Tolkien's LOTR.
Purists, on the other hand, do not believe that Jackson was able to translate enough of Tolkien's meaning - not appearance - to make the films acceptable as a version of Tolkien's LOTR.
And that, to my mind, is where the crux of the dispute lies. Everything else - including debates about whether or not certain plot changes characters and/or scenes are good bad or somewhere in between is simply an extension of the basic argument, an argument as I posited before, that cannot be won by either side and thus has become a study in futility.
And finally, you have FADs who believe that Jackson's version is superior to Tolkien's at least as film and sometimes even when considered vis a vie the book! Therefore, there is no reason for any defense of the Director's actions. In this extreme case, there is no reason for any kind of debate simply because the two positions lack what is necessary for any debate to take place: a common ground from which both sides "start". In this case, purist and FAD are too far apart for anything akin to a reasonable debate and we're right back to that "study in futility" mentioned above.
Foe-Hammer said:They are able to accept that the professional filmakers know their business and bow to their infinite wisdom concerning filmaking.
Iluvatar said:Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha
Stop it. I can't breathe! Stop it.
Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha
Whoo. That was a good one. I think I may have actually broken a rib laughing.
I thought this was the generally accepted reading of the book- that Boromir's madness brought around his own demise.
and jallan again (in message 510):It isn’t. I occasionally encounter similar statements but never with supporting analysis. I expect that statement arises because Boromir’s death is associated closely with his madness chronologically and because a strong causal connection between ill-deeds arising from pride or anger or possessiveness and a subsequent death so often does occur in tales.
No direct connection of that kind appears in Tolkien’s tale.
The idea that Boromir’s attempt on the Ring directly caused his death also occasionally appears in commentary but never with analysis. As I mentioned above I think this a careless subsitution of a common motif but one one that Tolkien happens not to use in respect to Boromir’s death.
Aragorn knelt beside him. Boromir opened his eyes and strove to speak. At last slow words came. 'I tried to take the Ring from Frodo,' he said. 'I am sorry. I have paid.' His glance strayed to his fallen enemies, twenty at least lay there. 'They have gone: the Halflings: the Orcs have taken them. I think they are not dead. Orcs bound them.' He paused and his eyes closed wearily. After a moment he spoke again.
'Farewell, Aragorn! Go to Minas Tirith and save my people! I have failed.'
(emphasis added)
The word "infinite" was emphasised from your phrase "infinite wisdom", to point out the actual cause for hilarity. I assume you meant the phrase to be humorous, and thus to cause laughter - though the hysterical quality of the laughter was rather more than the standard of humour deserved.Foe-Hammer said:....explain to the group why professional filmakers do not know what they are doing. We wait on pins and needles for your response.
Greenwood said:Thus it would seem that Aragil's (and mine, and just about everyone else's I know who has read LOTR) understanding that Boromir's attempt to take the Ring from Frodo led to his death comes directly from the text of the book. Boromir himself thought so. And lest we forget this is a work of fiction, therefore we can conclude the author, good old JRRT, wanted his readers to think so or he would not have put the above lines in Boromir's mouth. I hope this constitutes what jallan calls "analysis".
joxy said:The word "infinite" was emphasised from your phrase "infinite wisdom", to point out the actual cause for hilarity. I assume you meant the phrase to be humorous, and thus to cause laughter - though the hysterical quality of the laughter was rather more than the standard of humour deserved.
Professional film-makers, like professional anything, do not have infinite qualities; they are mere mortals like all of us, and as such they inevitably make occasional mistakes.
That's an interesting metaphor from the world of needlework; I haven't come across it before, and don't quite grasp its origin, so, again:
Somewhere between the needlework and the Silmarillion you've lost me.Foe-Hammer said:Joxy= The mouth of Iluvatar.
I agree with you entirely.Sôval Phârë said:I agree, and I believe this is another beautiful nuance of Tolkien's writing. His characters have a pre-scientific worldview, one in which the moral, aesthetic world and the physical world are not separate, but intertwined. Their decisions are often "illogical," in terms the way that we today would conceive of "logic." Frodo leaves for Rivendell on his 50th birthday, not because that's the most expedient time for him to do so, but because it's aesthetically pleasing to him. Again, Elrond's appointing of nine members to the Fellowship is an aesthetic choice, not a "logical" one, meant to symbolically counteract the nine Black Riders. Indeed, Tolkien's world, not just his characters, happens to work that way as well. If I'm not mistaken, everyone who attempts (or succeeds in) harming Frodo later gets his or her karmic comeuppance by being killed or injured. That a bad moral decision should lead to a bad physical event (Boromir's death) would be taken for granted by Sam.
The movie paid tribute to this aspect of Tolkien in Sam's (invented) tirade against Faramir. Granted, I think this scene was done a little sloppily, so its meaning is probably lost on most viewers.
Sôval Phârë said:Indeed, Tolkien's world, not just his characters, happens to work that way as well. If I'm not mistaken, everyone who attempts (or succeeds in) harming Frodo later gets his or her karmic comeuppance by being killed or injured. That a bad moral decision should lead to a bad physical event (Boromir's death) would be taken for granted by Sam.
The movie paid tribute to this aspect of Tolkien in Sam's (invented) tirade against Faramir. Granted, I think this scene was done a little sloppily, so its meaning is probably lost on most viewers.
The results of Faramir being a part of the Fellowship rather than Boromir is a very interesting matter to consider. One assumes, to begin with, that if Denethor indeed sent his son to bring the Bearer with the Ring or, if necessary only the Ring itself, back to Minas Tirith, Faramir would not have agreed to be part of any such plan (and hence, Denethor sent his "true" son who was no "wizard's pupil). But even had Denethor laid no such duty upon his son, Faramir would most probably have not attempted to take the Ring.simbelmyne said:The moral choice/act thing has always bothered me concerning the Gondor brothers. Usually a bad moral decision in JRRT leads to bad physical event. Denethor exerts his will and insists on sending Boromir to Rivendell, even though Faramir desperately wants to go (and has had the halfling dream many times). Denethor is not making this decision based on good motives. But if he had sent Faramir instead, Frodo and Sam would have faced Boromir in Ithilien, which would have meant complete disaster. I can't reconcile this!
That scene with Sam yelling about Boromir and the ring in front of all the soldiers has all the subtlety of a sledge-hammer. "If you try to take the ring you die" basically. Not really the professor's style...
simbelmyne said:Usually a bad moral decision in JRRT leads to bad physical event.
Denethor exerts his will and insists on sending Boromir to Rivendell, even though Faramir desperately wants to go (and has had the halfling dream many times). Denethor is not making this decision based on good motives. But if he had sent Faramir instead, Frodo and Sam would have faced Boromir in Ithilien, which would have meant complete disaster. I can't reconcile this!
That scene with Sam yelling about Boromir and the ring in front of all the soldiers has all the subtlety of a sledge-hammer. "If you try to take the ring you die" basically. Not really the professor's style...
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?