Sôval Phârë
Our Bog is Dood
- Joined
- Feb 2, 2004
- Messages
- 52
Mrs. Maggott said:...although not necessarily those who like the films but dislike Jackson's adaptation of the tale
I consider myself in this category, although I don't dislike the adaptation outright; I just think it's flawed in places.
Hence, many of the things which Mr. Jackson and his writers might/would see as inexplicable and/or nonsensical, make their own sense when viewed within the context of the myth itself. Therefore, when Jackson sees fit to "change things" to create "realism" within Tolkien's fantasy world, all he manages to do is make nonsense of the meaning of the myth - albeit, it may make sense to those for whom the myth is non-existent or unimportant.
I'm interested in your idea that Jackson wanted to make Tolkien's story more "realistic." Could you give some examples of the changes he made to accomplish that? The only one I can think of at the moment is Faramir's behavior toward the ring.
For Jackson to have presented LOTR on film he would have had to be as true as possible to the characters of the story for it is through them and their interaction that the tale is told, not through the plot line or the outward, superficial appearance of their world. Unfortunately (at least for those for whom it was important), he chose to do otherwise.
Yes, the characters are important! But why do you think they're of the greatest importance? I think this might be a matter of opinion from reader to reader. Since the story sprang up out of Tolkien's invented languages, for example, one could make a good argument that language is the most important. Jackson would have failed if we looked at it solely in that respect, I admit, because the movie's dialogue and variations of speech between characters is nowhere near as nuanced as Tolkien's.
