Afraid I waited only half a minute to answer that one!aragil said:Wait a minute joxy, if a norm can be objectively quantified....
This is one of the most absurd statements I have ever seen on this Forum. If you want to say something meets what you consider the norm, that is fine because it is clearly subjective. If you just refer to a norm without making it clear you are defining the norm yourself you have left the realm of subjectivity. It is not necessary for me to define "Hollywood norm", all I need do is point to the many awards that are given out each year in and outside the movie industry for what the presenters consider the year's best and show that these films were nominated for many of these awards. The nominations alone, never mind all the awards actually won, show that the presenters of these awards consider these films above the norm. More objectively, I have no idea what the average gross (the "norm") of all Hollywood films released in a given year is, but since the first two films in the LOTR trilogy each came in second for the year of their release and ROTK came in first, they all clearly left the "norm" far behind.joxy said:Whether the films exceed any norm is not a matter that can be proved by "evidence". It can be no more than a matter of opinion.
I noted recently with pleasure that you had borrowed a sense of humour, and hoped that you would be allowed to keep it.Greenwood said:This is one of the most absurd statements I have ever seen on this Forum.
It is not necessary for me to define "Hollywood norm", all I need do is point to the many awards....
I have no idea what the average gross (the "norm") of all Hollywood films released in a given year is, but since the first two films in the LOTR trilogy each came in second for the year of their release and ROTK came in first, they all clearly left the "norm" far behind.
I guess hubris is catching. Now you know what the "real, wide, world" considers the "Hollywood norm". Would you care to enlighten the rest of us as to where you gained this knowledge? Do you have some scientifically conducted polls to cite?joxy said:The norm that is defined by those who decide on awards is theirs alone.
You may accept that norm as your norm, but I attach no importance at all to those people's opinions, and refer to a norm that is based far wider - on a knowledge of the way in which the products of Hollywood are regarded in the real, wide, world. (emphasis added)
But now we come to what you're really talking about - the "gross", which you apparently equate with the "norm" - correct me if I've misunderstood the quotation above.
You are using the word "gross" in its secondary meaning: gross monetary income? If so, we are certainly back to matters that can be quantified, but they're not the matters I think about when I hear and use the word "norm".
Well, please enlighten the rest of us what this "generally accepted concept worldwide" is? Also please explain how you know that the "norm" you perceive is the same everyoen else means.joxy said:I certainly do think there's a generally accepted concept worldwide as to what the "Hollywood norm" for films is. It's not something that I've devised; it's something that I see expressed in all areas of the media.
Greenwood said:Aragil, and to a lesser extent I, have shown that the movie version does follow the book fairly closely except in relatively minor points.
Greenwood said:Admittedly, it is possible for such a short passage to be that important, but as exciting as this scene is I don't see it rising to that level of importance. There is a about to be a confrontation between two powerful characters in the book and it doesn't happen. You argue the fact confrontation doesn't happen makes the scene that much more important. I don't buy it.
You can yada, yada, yada all you want. The facts remain the story line is all there in the movie. The Gate crumbles, all appears lost but the West triumphs. And it triumphs through the same sequence of events as in the book, even if small details are telescoped or changed.rs691919 said:You have shown that the movie follows the book in the sense of getting from point A to point B. The Rohirrim charge...yada, yada, yada....Theoden dies....yada, yada, yada...Aragorn arrives...yada, yada, yada...they win the day.
The moment at the Gate of Minas Tirith, then, takes up prominent importance within the tale, at least as regards the defense of Gondor (which does represent the bulwark against the power of Mordor). It is the moment in which the reader believes all is lost: the Gate crumbles, the Lord of the Nazgul rides through that archway, the armies of Mordor are poised to surge into the City. It is the moment at which the West is at its nadir. It is the moment in which that train of human resistance which Gandalf (sent by Iluvatar) has set into motion proves utterly indomitable.
Greenwood said:You can yada, yada, yada all you want. The facts remain the story line is all there in the movie. The Gate crumbles, all appears lost but the West triumphs. And it triumphs through the same sequence of events as in the book, even if small details are telescoped or changed.
"Exceed any norm"? The fact that ROTK is the first film in the 76 (?) year history of the Academy Awards to sweep 11 categories plus all the other awards the films received prove they exceed the norm of such things for films. The fact that these three films are three out of the top ten films of all time in box-office gross receipts prove they exceed the norm of box-office success for films. These are all objective pieces of evidence. You say that these are not the "norms" you are referring to. The problem is you made a sweeping statement that there could be no "evidence" of the films exceeding any norm. You did not specify that you were referring to some nebulous "norm" that is only defined in your own mind. Of course no one can say anything about the norm in your head because we can't know what it is.joxy said:Whether the films exceed any norm is not a matter that can be proved by "evidence". It can be no more than a matter of opinion.
Whether the films exceed any norm is not a matter that can be proved by "evidence". It can be no more than a matter of opinion.
Greenwood said:ROTK is the first film in the 76 (?) year history of the Academy Awards to sweep 11 categories
So now your ill-mannered statement depends on emphasising a three letter word, "any".Greenwood said:It continues to be one of the most absurd statements I have seen on TTF.
Which immediately goes to the top of my list of the disagreeable features of the films!Gandalf The Grey said:PJ's films indubitably exceed the norm when it comes to the number of cast members from a single film or trilogy of films all going out and getting Elvish tattoos!
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?