• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

My God, It Was Horrible (Part III)

joxy said:
btw: to Greenwood, in persuance of your disbelief in my claim not to dislike PJ's films: I just noticed, in a thread directly adjacent to this one, Powerful Moments, what amounts almost to a paean of praise - yes, I know the "of praise" is redundant! -from me about a scene in FOTR.
I looked through that thread. Below are your posts, except for one or two Latin diversions.

joxy said:
Yes, I'll give you that one, as it stands above.
On a different level, but pretty powerful, I think: Pippin and Merry realising in Fangorn that there'll be no Shire to go back to. post 46
joxy said:
Thanks for the warning!
And another welcome member from Beograd? post 51
joxy said:
I didn't reply before, when you asked why I took your note about the music at Mount Doom as a "warning", so this gives me an excuse to reply now.
Those choirs are way "over-the-top" in my opinion, and I was glad to be warned that they will be in full cry again at Mount Doom, so that I can be ready with the "volume down" control!
As you like the falling staircase music best of all, maybe you can answer a question I've asked several times before: are those guys really yelling "doo-wah, doo-wah", which is what it sounds like to me? Now you tell me it's Maori?! How weird is that?
Sorry I can't translate "chacun a son gout" into Srbski, but I do want you to know that I hope I'll be no less of a prijatel for not having quite the same taste (gout) in music. post 57
joxy said:
Well, that's certainly what it OUGHT to be, though there's a problem in the fact that, apart from place names, Tolkien gives only
a grand total of THREE words in dwarfish/Khazad!
joxy said:
And Great Grey Wizard: Can you assure me that your eponymously coloured Havens are presented well in the film? If that scene
IS a good one, I'll have some incentive to watch the film all the way through after all.... post 60
joxy said:
OK then: opening of TTT - panorama across mountains, flicker of light through mountain-side, reprise of breaking Bridge, fall seen from all angles, F wakes, pan to F&S descending cliff, up to Sam dropping his silly box. Great.
English, en effet, but with a soh allowed?
btw: As this is about all three films, why is it in the ROTK area?
Do we need a new area now for all three, taken together? post69
joxy said:
But did we see much of ALL of them, or even MUCH of any of them, at that stage?
To me, the scene OUT of Moria was the real emotional one, giving each character the opportunity to show their emotions - and to transmit them to us - well, to me, certainly. The brilliant light, the vast expanse of the surroundings, in contrast to what they had left behind, adds enormously to that effect also. I'm not sure that it has much to do with the book at that point, but for once I don't mind one way or the other.
And also just for once, I won't describe the one little PJ'ism in the scene that detracts from it post 75
I suppose you are referring to that last post. Yes sir, quite a "paean".
 
Greenwood said:
If I get a chance I'll look. In my last post I used the definition you posted. I guess you are now saying it was incorrect. I used your definition since I assumed it was based on your extensive Greek reference library and would be more authoritative than anything I could quickly find.

I was defining the concept to which the word applied, in response to your continued uninformed charges of misuse of the term. The meaning of the word itself shou,ld provide you some assurance that it is not incorrect to say that an act of hubris may be committed against someone.
 
rs691919 said:
I don't have the book handy, but my recollection is that the Rohirrim order their ranks before they blow their horns. The horns are blown only after they begin their charge. The attack is thus a total surprise to armies of Mordor, with the exception of the few Orcs who were manning the ruined Rammas. In the movie, the charge is not a surprise as the Orcs line up opposite them and pig-head has time to order his archers.
Yes and no. As you read the book, the horns are blown, then (in a later chapter) the ordering of the Rohirrim is described. Chronologically, the ordering occurs first, but describing it first would totally blow the drama and the 'nick of time' surprise of the Rohirrim's arrival. In order to capture the tension from the book, the horns have to be blown before we see the Rohirrim ordering their forces. I actually agree with what you say about the importance of the surprise arrival, and I am ultimately confounded as to how you can say that the movie version inverts this. Minas Tirith is at its absolute worst moment when the Rohirrim arrive- orcs are actually inside the city, a 'lower' moment than when the Rohirrim arrive in the books. At that point the Gondorian forces are in total disarray, fleeing to the second level. Gandalf and Pippin's chat occurs during a relative moment of peace- the panicked desperation from the earlier scene is replaced with quiet determination. The Gondorians in the second level may be facing death, but I would not say it was a lower moment than when the Rohirrim arrive- certainly from a tactical standpoint they were in a much better position, with only a small, easily defendible point from which their enemies could attack them, and a relatively small pool of enemies that can attack, as the Rohirrim had cut off any reinforcements and temporarily were preventing any more enemies from approaching the city.

rs69191 said:
Indeed, it would be a challenge for the horsemen to drive the Orcs out of the city, but the Orcs were not in the city in the book. Thus, the movie does not follow the book;
Yes and no again. The movie does not follow the veneer of the book, but stays true to the spirit. The Rohirrim arrive in the nick of time to save the city (if not the first level of the city). By their heroic charge the city is temporarily made safe until Aragorn wins the battle with other unlooked-for allies. The move does not follow the superficial details of the book, but the strategic and thematic principles of the scene remain intact.

rs691919 said:
Why then, after saving Faramir from Denethor, do Gandalf and Pippin have their discussion about death if it's clear that the Rohirrim have saved the day and given them the ability to hold out? It appears that Jackson and his writers are trying, in this scene, to make this moment the one in which the West is at the nadir of its fortunes.
Again the movie is following the dramatic pattern of the book here. The city has been given temporary respite by the Rohirrim, but the end is still inevitible- whether at the hand of the orcs already in the city, or by the Haradrim once they finish off the Rohirrim. The city is still doomed until Aragorn shows up with the converted Corsair fleet. If you like, re-read the book, and I'm sure you'll find a second nadir:
It was even as the day thus began to turn against Gondor and their hope wavered that a new cry went up in the City, it being then midmorning, and a great wind blowing, and the rain flying north, and the sun shining. In that clear air watchmen on the walls saw afar a new sight of fear, and their last hope left them.
Eomer's song for the moment also calls it hope's ending. Having a second moment of doubt (as related by the Gandalf-Pippin dialogue) follows the book quite well, IMO.
 
I can agree that it is impossible for the filmmaker or author to be in two places at once. That is, he cannot simultaneously show the confrontation at the Gate and the ordering of the Rohirrim. A choice must therefore be made to emphasize one over the other.

First, let us consider Tolkien's choice. He chose to relate the story initially from the perspective of the defenders of the City. Thus both the reader and the characters within the story are surprised when the Rohirrim charge in at cockcrow. He then goes back to explain to the reader how the Rohirrim got their in the first place. But all the while you are reading Chapter V of Book V, you know what is going to happen. The suspense, then, is not in the Ride of the Rohirrim, but in the Siege of Gondor. Tolkien quite obviously wanted to emphasize, both thematically and from a pure plot standpoint, the confrontation at the Gate. Consider three comments he makes in the Letters.

From Letter #328: “As if indeed the horns of Hope had been heard again, as Pippin heard them suddenly at the absolute nadir of the fortunes of the West.” (I didn't just make up this nadir stuff)

From Letter #294: “If it is of interest, the passages that now move me most – written so long ago that I read them now as if they had been written by someone else – are the end of the chapter Lothlorien, and the horns of the Rohirrim at cockcrow.”

And from Letter #156 while discussing the nature of Gandalf: "He alone is left to forbid the entrance of the Lord of the Nazgul to Minas Tirith, when the City has been overthrown and its Gates destroyed -- and yet so powerful is the whole train of human resistance, that he himself has kindled and organized, that in fact no battle between the two occurs: it passes to other mortal hands."

The passages demonstrate the importance that Tolkien himself placed on this scene. The hopelessness of the Men of the West as the Nazgul Lord overthrows the Gate, the solitary presence of Gandalf upon Shadowfax defying the Enemy, the Horns of Hope at cockcrow "far above the shadows of death", and the ultimate indomitable resistance which the White Rider has set into motion: heavy stuff, that.

Now consider Jackson's choice. Rather than choosing one or the other (i.e. the ordering of the Rohirrim or the confrontation at the Gate), he chooses both of them, and he chooses neither of them.

In lieu of the confrontation between the Witch-King and Gandalf, he gives us a horde of Orcs pouring into the City, hell-bent on pillaging as missles hurled aloft pound tower after tower into rubble. Yes, from a strict standpoint of measurement, this places the City at a much "lower" point than is demonstrated in the book. It is, perhaps, a lower nadir. Yet it still does not carry the weight that I described above. This is not Nazgul set against Maia, Darkness against Light, Despair against Hope; it is rather a ravenous army of pillagers set against an impotent force. It robs Gandalf of the power and majesty and goodness that organized resistance such that the City would never truly fall.

Then, in the midst of destruction, we hear the horns of the Rohirrim. It is a surpise, yes, but rather than carrying through the momentum gained through surprise, Jackson chooses to have his Rohirrim order up their forces in full view of the Orc armies. Then Theoden can ride in front of them and give them a rousing speech, the armies can eye each other, and then the battle can resume. Forgive me, but I've already seen Braveheart several times. The charge of the Rohirrim proceeds, but it does not have the effect of securing the Gate; Gandalf and Pippin still face death (or a trip to Valinor, I can't tell) as the Orcs are poised to invade the second level (never mind that in the book they couldn't even get into the first because of the suddeness and ferocity of Theoden's charge).

Then we return (somewhat) to the book with the massing of the armies of Mordor and the arrival of the Ghostbusters. The Orcs are then driven out of the City (and the battle won) by the arrival of the Dead and their sweep through the Enemy's armies. Yes, Aragorn's arrival turns the tide of the battle again (and a battle certainly may have many turns) and from that standpoint, the book is marginally followed.

But ultimately, the decision to delete the confrontation at the gate and the sudden onslaught of the Rohirrim diminishes the power of the scene and the beauty of the writing. It creates a nadir which is too "low" and which prevents victory from being achieved by any but the most ridiculous means.
 
I still disagree. There is NO coordination between the Rohirrim and Minas Tirith which brings succor to the city at the fateful moment. You might see Olorin acting as the hand of the One and therefor providence providing the timing, but I see only happy chance. A shift in the wind, a fifteen minute delay during the muster at Meduseld, and the ride of the Rohirrim would have come too late to save the first gate, though they probably would have saved the city exactly as in the movie. To me the thematic element is exactly matched by the movie depiction, whether or not the Rohirrim arrive before or after the Orcs enter the city.
And, before you yet again compare the Theoden speech to Braveheart, you might pause to consider that it does come from the books. Not only Theoden's verse (minus the last line), but the entire tone and purpose. In the books before the Rohirrim charge they are first completely cowed by the carnage on the field. It is the sudden words of the King ("more clear than any there had ever heard a mortal man achieve before") which rekindles their hearts. Blather on about Braveheart all you want- the inspirational speech was in LotR long before it was in that other movie, and omitting it for a more sudden charge would be a huge mistake, IMO.
I don't understand why you bother to harp on the Orc reaction to the arrival of the Rohirrim. The fact that the Orcs are reacting to the Rohirrim changes absolutely nothing about the symbolism or thematic content of the scene. The Orcs are ultimately unable to stop the riders- whether their archers are ordered against the Rohirrim or no. The Rohirrim still completely decimate the Orcs and route them to the river, just as in the books. If anything the charge is made a little more impressive- the Orc route can not be blamed on the surprise factor, it is due only to the sheer scale of the mounted assault.

Finally, though I'm sure that it is no comfort for you, the Gandalf-Witch King confrontation was filmed (and heavily foreshadowed in the TC) and will be in the EE. In fact, the scene was impressive enough to be the climax of the early trailers, which ended with a nice pan in slow motion from Gandalf over to the Witch King. I have no idea why it was removed from the theatrical cut, but it will play out in a slightly different manner from the book version- the Witch King will still be mounted on his fell beast, as opposed to his horse, and it will be on top of a wall, rather than under the gate. Personally this makes a little more sense to me in regards to what the Witch King is riding- I never understood why in the books he continually shifted mounts, especially when the Fell Beast was so effective a means of transport.

{blech. Edited to try and make sense of my opening statement}
 
Last edited:
Greenwood said:
I suppose you are referring to that last post.
Yes, that last one only.
I don't know why you quoted all the others, word for word, including the parts that have nothing to do with praise, but thanks!
 
rs691919

Your post is not really a criticism of Jackson's ROTK as a movie. It is just the usual criticism of many "purists" that the movie is not the book and that you like the book better. So do I. I was looking forward to seeing the confrontation between Gandalf and the Witch-King and was disappointed when it wasn't there. I hope it will be in the EE, but the movie version, as Aragil has pointed out, is true to all the general plot and basic themes from the book and I have absolutely no problem with it while recognizing the differences.

Looking at the specifics of your criticism, you agree that a choice must be made about the sequence of portrayal of events to the reader/viewer since different events cannot be presented simultaneously. I agree with Tolkien's choice of first following the defenders of the beleaguered city, but it is after all a rather obvious choice for any storyteller to make. Where is the tension of following the Rohirrim to the moment of their charge and then switching back to follow the defenders up until a moment we already know is coming? Tolkien is merely exhibiting the skills of a competent storyteller. If my goal was to tear down Tolkien as your goal is to ridicule and tear down Jackson I would point out that the sound of the horns (usually bugles) of the cavalry riding to the rescue in the nick of time is a rather old cliche. But such an attack on Tolkien would be as fallacious as your attack on Jackson. That something has been done before, that it is a "cliche", does not automatically make it "banal" and "unoriginal" as you like to put it in reference to Jackson's work. The crucial question is how well it is done. Tolkien's writing ability is impressive and we are swept up into his world and his characters so it does not matter that we have all heard the bugles of the rescue cavalry arriving in countless other stories. Jackson's presentation of the same material is visually impressive as it must be in a visual medium and uses most of the same elements as Tolkien. Therefore the large percentage of the film audience who are not familiar with the books are as swept up and carried along as most of us readers were when we first read the book.

Turning to some of your other points, you grandly write: "This is not Nazgul set against Maia, Darkness against Light, Despair against Hope; ...". Kindly cite for me where in LOTR the term Maia appears? I don't remember it. You are bringing in parts of Tolkien's Middle Earth cosmogony that are not part of LOTR and that the movie audience has no knowledge or need of. (I too can throw around fancy words like "cosmogony" in an effort to make my view look learned and lofty.) Next you criticize Jackson for not "carrying through the momentum gained through surprise" of hearing the horns of Rohan, but instead "Jackson chooses to have his Rohirrim order up their forces in full view of the Orc armies". I am with Aragil in that I do not understand this continual complaint of yours about being in view of the Orc armies. That the Rohirrim can see that they are vastly outnumbered merely heightens the tension, it does not diminish it or them. Eowyn's and Merry's reactions of horror are a reasonable version of Merry's reaction in the book: "They were too late! Too late was worse than never! Perhaps Theoden would quail, bow his head, slink away to hide in the hills." As for your criticism of Jackson failing to carry through the momentum, what does Tolkien do? He takes us all the way back to just after the Rohan set off for Minas Tirith. Once again, I am not criticizing Tolkien, merely pointing out that your criticism of the movie by comparing it to the book is invalid. In the book there is no "sudden onslaught of the Rohirrim" as you claim. In the end, your criticisms are not of the movie as a movie, but rather that the movie is not the book and you are unable to view it as a movie separate from your knowledge of the book. (Witness your snide comment about not being able to tell whether Gandalf and Pippin are facing death or a trip to Valinor. Movie audiences have no knowledge of Valinor. To them it is a moving moment as two characters they have come to care about face possible death.)
 
joxy said:
I don't know why you quoted all the others, word for word, including the parts that have nothing to do with praise, but thanks anyway!
The point was that most of your posts are negative. Even your "paean" as you call it, ends with a slap at Jackson. Your protests about not disliking the movies ring hollow in light of the full record.
 
Greenwood said:
The point was that most of your posts are negative. Even your "paean" as you call it, ends with a slap at Jackson. Your protests about not disliking the movies ring hollow in light of the full record.
This is so ridiculous!
This is so ridiculous!
A "slap"?! The "full record"?! Substitute "tickle"; look at the full record - it isn't only in the "favourite" thread that I praise.
You quoted three examples of my fulsome praise for complete scenes, to which I had added, at the end of two of them, comments about tiny features, that I still think are not worthy of the majestic quality of those three scenes.
As the tiny features, I mentioned Sam's box, which has baffled mightier critics than me; and the item I deliberately didn't specify was Frodo's itty-bitty-tear, which, along with several other effluents, has amused or bemused numerous other contributors here. The films don't have to be perfect to be enjoyed, they can bear any number of blunders and sillinesses without my disliking them.
I thoroughly enjoy a large part of them, which is as much as the producer of any product, or as the supporter of any such producer, could reasonably ask for. This area of the forum does not exist solely to praise the films; it's quite reasonable that many, or indeed the majority, of the entries here relate to the defects rather than the high points of them.
Of course, they are not "horrible" -I'm sure even the originator of these threads doesn't think that.
Of course, I don't "dislike" them - I'm telling you for a fact, I do NOT dislike them.
 
aragil said:
There is NO coordination between the Rohirrim and Minas Tirith which brings succor to the city at the fateful moment. You might see Olorin acting as the hand of the One and therefor providence providing the timing, but I see only happy chance.

Well, this is interesting and unexpected! Do you feel, then, that chance plays a greater role in Tolkien's world (and writing) than the hand of the One? And if so, how do you reconcile that sentiment with Tolkien's statement in Letter #156 while he discusses the nature of Gandalf: "He alone is left to forbid the entrance of the Lord of the Nazgul to Minas Tirith, when the City has been overthrown and its Gates destroyed -- and yet so powerful is the whole train of human resistance, that he himself has kindled and organized, that in fact no battle between the two occurs: it passes to other mortal hands."

aragil said:
Not only Theoden's verse (minus the last line), but the entire tone and purpose. In the books before the Rohirrim charge they are first completely cowed by the carnage on the field. It is the sudden words of the King ("more clear than any there had ever heard a mortal man achieve before") which rekindles their hearts.

Yes, the verse is included in the movie. The last line, as I have pointed out, is lifted from Eomer, and the tone of that in the movie differs greatly from the book. Eomer went on a suicide charge seeking death and seeking to kill in revenge for his sister. Theoden (in the book) went to the aid of Gondor knowing that death was certainly possible, but wilfully seeking it out.

But again, I am quite mindful of the adaptor's dilemma regarding this scene: it is impossible to be in two places at once. So therefore, one must look at the scene and determine what is more important in mainting the thematic integrity of the text. The ordering of the Rohirrim and the speech of Theoden, moving as they are, do not have the potency to match the confrontation at the Gate and the Horns of Hope at cockcrow. Tolkien created a moment almost frozen in time where Gandalf and the Lord of the Nazgul face each other. This is a crucial moment in the narrative, and it is swept away for reasons that I don't really understand.

aragil said:
I don't understand why you bother to harp on the Orc reaction to the arrival of the Rohirrim. The fact that the Orcs are reacting to the Rohirrim changes absolutely nothing about the symbolism or thematic content of the scene. The Orcs are ultimately unable to stop the riders- whether their archers are ordered against the Rohirrim or no. The Rohirrim still completely decimate the Orcs and route them to the river, just as in the books. If anything the charge is made a little more impressive- the Orc route can not be blamed on the surprise factor, it is due only to the sheer scale of the mounted assault.

Actually, that's exactly what diminishes the charge of the Rohirrim! The West is not supposed to win this battle because of scale; but rather because of the manner in which the organization of resistance takes place. That is, Gandalf returning to life to heal Theoden, convincing him to defeat the threat of Saruman, encouraging him to ride to the aid of Gondor. And Gandalf's efforts are coupled with Aragorn's look into the palantir, ride through the Paths of the Dead, defeat of the Corsairs of Umbar, and sailing up the Anduin to the battle. It is not "sheer scale" that wins the battle (and the war)!

It is the "surprise attack", totally unsuspected by the forces of Mordor and their leader--focused only on that impenetrable Gate--that turns the tide. By having the armies square off against each other, that surprise is gone. My objection is not to pig-head nor to the fact that he readies his archers, but rather to the loss of the element of surprise and sudden-ness.


aragil said:
Finally, though I'm sure that it is no comfort for you, the Gandalf-Witch King confrontation was filmed (and heavily foreshadowed in the TC) and will be in the EE. In fact, the scene was impressive enough to be the climax of the early trailers, which ended with a nice pan in slow motion from Gandalf over to the Witch King.

My question, which you anticipate, is if it's so impressive, why leave it out of the theatrical cut? I've seen the trailer, I've seen a picture of this mini-confronation; we shall see if it happens just as the Rohirrim arrive. But we know that it will not take place at the Gate, and the follow-up question is: why? Why change this around. I can't think of a more cinematic scene that the one which Tolkien writes at the end of Chapter IV, Book V. I can't wait to listen to the Boyens and Walsh explain that one.
 
Greenwood said:
Your post is not really a criticism of Jackson's ROTK as a movie.

Very observant. Originally I had responded to a post by aragil which stated that the scene was great because it followed the books. I obviously disagree with that statement.

Greenwood said:
Tolkien is merely exhibiting the skills of a competent storyteller.

Something that Jackson, Walsh, and Boyens cannot apparently do.


Greenwood said:
That something has been done before, that it is a "cliche", does not automatically make it "banal" and "unoriginal" as you like to put it in reference to Jackson's work. The crucial question is how well it is done.

That is an excellent point. However, it is also clear that no storytelling is truly original. We are all affected by what he have read and seen and loved; Tolkien in that respect is no different from Jackson. It is the degree of derivative filmmaking that Jackson engages in, as well as the poor quality of the screenplay, that makes his movies banal and unoriginal. It is easy to appropriate the "general" plot and the "basic" themes; it is difficult to evoke the more subtle nuances of emotion and story. Jackson took the former route.


Greenwood said:
Turning to some of your other points, you grandly write: "This is not Nazgul set against Maia, Darkness against Light, Despair against Hope; ...". Kindly cite for me where in LOTR the term Maia appears? I don't remember it.

No, the term Maia does not appear in The Lord of the Rings. In the appendices, I believe he is called an emissary of the Valar. Regardless, Gandalf is a Maia clothed in a mortal's body, according to Tolkien's mythology.


Greenwood said:
You are bringing in parts of Tolkien's Middle Earth cosmogony that are not part of LOTR and that the movie audience has no knowledge or need of.

The audience may or may not have knowledge of Gandalf's nature. But it does need to understand that Gandalf is not Man or Elf, but a spirit of great power shrouded in a mortal form, sent by the Valar (or by the One himself) to organize resistance in this Middle-earth.


Greenwood said:
In the end, your criticisms are not of the movie as a movie, but rather that the movie is not the book and you are unable to view it as a movie separate from your knowledge of the book.

My criticisms regarding this scene are indeed criticisms of the filmmakers inability (or refusal) to stay true to the book. I have, however, been able to separate the movie from my knowledge of the book. And in doing so, I have found the movie lacking.
 
joxy said:
Of course, I don't "dislike" them - I'm telling you for a fact, I do NOT dislike them.
And I am telling you that what comes through is your apparent unending dislike for the films. Take for example (from today) on this section of the Forum dealing with the ROTK film (which you haven't seen) some one posts a list of things he doesn't like about the movie and you pop in with (found here):
joxy said:
You've given examples that many of us here have tried before, only to be consigned to outer darkness because we don't appreciate the full glory of PJ's masterpiece.
Far from being repetitious, your recalling of them brings a welcome breath of fresh air into the proceedings, so thank you for that.
In TTT, aren't Theoden and Denethor PJ's characters rather than Tolkien's?
Doesn't that vase remain as shattered as before as far as dwarf humour is concerned?
I could go on - but I invite you to give more examples from TTT instead.
 
Greenwood said:
And I am telling you that what comes through is your apparent unending dislike for the films. Take for example (from today) on this section of the Forum dealing with the ROTK film (which you haven't seen) some one posts a list of things he doesn't like about the movie and you pop in with....
If that is what comes through to YOU, then it says more about YOU than it does about me! Plenty of other people believe me!
The posting I commented on IS in the ROTK section, but I replied only to the part that concerned FOTR and TTT.
Certainly the poster dislikes those features of those two films, and so do I. I don't know if that makes him dislike the films without reservation.
They certainly don't have that effect on me: I think the features shouldn't be there, but they do NOT make me dislike the films as a whole.
 
Last edited:
rs691919 said:
No, the term Maia does not appear in The Lord of the Rings. In the appendices, I believe he is called an emissary of the Valar. Regardless, Gandalf is a Maia clothed in a mortal's body, according to Tolkien's mythology.

No, he is not called an emissary of the Valar. Once again you are adding your knowledge from The Silmarillion and later books to LOTR and demanding it be included in the movies. The quote from Appendix B is: "When maybe a thousand years had passed, and the first shadow had fallen on Greenwood the Great, the Istari or Wizards appeared in Middle-earth. It was afterwards said that they came out of the Far West and were messengers sent to contest the power of Sauron, and to unite all those who had the will to resist him: but they were forbidden to match his power with power, or to seek to dominate Elves or Men by force and fear." No mention of the Valar there. In any event the Appendices are not part of the narrative of the story. The Valar are only mentioned twice in LOTR The first is in TTT during the encounter between Faramir's men and the Haradrim: " 'Ware! Ware!' cried Damrod to his companion. 'May the Valar turn him aside! Mumak! Mumak!' " The second is in ROTK as Theoden leads the Rohan in their charge: "Fey he seemed, or the battle-fury of his fathers ran like new fire in his veins, and he was borne up on Snowmane like a god of old, even as Orome the Great in the battle of the Valar when the world was young."



rs691919 said:
The audience may or may not have knowledge of Gandalf's nature. But it does need to understand that Gandalf is not Man or Elf, but a spirit of great power shrouded in a mortal form, sent by the Valar (or by the One himself) to organize resistance in this Middle-earth.
The audience has already been told in TTT that Gandalf was "sent back" to continue the fight. I think the audience is already quite aware of his special nature.
 
Greenwood said:
....the Appendices are not part of the narrative of the story.
....which doesn't stop PJ and company from using them.
 
I stand corrected. He is indeed not called "emissary of the Valar" but instead is named as a messenger from the Far West, where the Valar happen to reside. Again, regardless of where it appears in Tolkien's written works, Gandalf is a Maia within his mythology.
 
rs691919 said:
I stand corrected. He is indeed not called "emissary of the Valar" but instead is named as a messenger from the Far West, where the Valar happen to reside. Again, regardless of where it appears in Tolkien's written works, Gandalf is a Maia within his mythology.
Where it appears in Tolkien's writing is relevant. From the two mentions of the Valar in LOTR there is no way to know who or what the Valar are much less that they are resident in the Far West. There is certainly no way for any reader of LOTR to associate them with Gandalf. The point here is your seemingly total inability or unwillingness to separate your knowledge of Tolkien's mythology from the film. Your criticisms of the film are merely a laundry list of differences between the books and the films; in many cases inconsequential or even non-existent differences. Your dislike of the films (and it is your right to dislike them) is completely based on the fact that they are not Tolkien's LOTR to the letter. (And as we have seen you sometimes can't even distinguish LOTR from other "writings" of Tolkien.) Every incident in the books that is changed in the movies now takes on great meaning in the book (no matter how minor the incident was in the book), as a way of showing how badly the movie portrayed the books. When someone demonstrates how closely the movies follow the book the charge becomes: "No!, those things are all superficial! The real plot and meaning of the book is in these other incidents" (most of which are really relatively minor and inconsequential). Rather than just stating your dislike of the films is based on their not being Tolkien's LOTR (which I could respect) you feel the need to "prove" how terrible they are by denigrating them as films. You have no interest in actually discussing them as films despite all your claims to the contrary. You say that you want to know why others enjoy the films, but as soon as they mention anything about the films they like you merely say no, these things were really terrible. It is of course impossible to carry on any meaningful discussion when one side knows their opinions are the Truth.
 
Greenwood said:
Where it appears in Tolkien's writing is relevant.
....you feel the need to "prove" how terrible they are by denigrating them as films. You have no interest in actually discussing them as films....
Or is it IRrelevant?
And isn't denigration a form of discussion?
I know that wasn't to me, and I don't think the films are "terrible", and I still don't dislike them, but I do think that many aspects of them, purely in film terms, are nowhere near as brilliant as their supporters, as well as all those critics and awards-presenters, claim for them.
 
joxy said:
And isn't denigration a form of discussion?
No, it is not. Going to the good old Random House Websters again: denigration -- 1. to speak damagingly of; defame or disparage: to denigrate someone's character. 2. to make black; blacken. Denigration hampers any reasonable discussion. Perhaps your constant denial of the nastiness and bashing that goes on against Jackson and the films is based on your lack of comprehension of the meaning of such words as denigration.
 
joxy said:
I still don't dislike them, but I do think that many aspects of them, purely in film terms, are nowhere near as brilliant as their supporters, as well as all those critics and awards-presenters, claim for them.
As long as we're on the subject joxy, what did you think of the charge of the Rohirrim? I thought it was brilliant and followed the books quite well. rs691919 thought otherwise. Mrs. Maggott roundly criticized it before seeing it, then quietly shifted her RotK criticism to Denethor afterwards. What's your opinion of this scene in particular?

rs691919 said:
Well, this is interesting and unexpected! Do you feel, then, that chance plays a greater role in Tolkien's world (and writing) than the hand of the One? And if so, how do you reconcile that sentiment with Tolkien's statement in Letter #156 while he discusses the nature of Gandalf: "He alone is left to forbid the entrance of the Lord of the Nazgul to Minas Tirith, when the City has been overthrown and its Gates destroyed -- and yet so powerful is the whole train of human resistance, that he himself has kindled and organized, that in fact no battle between the two occurs: it passes to other mortal hands."
My view is that the "hand of the One" is seldom felt in LotR- perhaps in an event like Gollum stumbling. If the whole of events in Arda are supposed to play out to his glory, then I would not find it very glorifying if he is consistently loading the dice. I think I agree with the professor's letter in quite a different sentiment than you do- what is striking to me is the non-necessity of the confrontation. Gandalf is there, but the strength of the mortals is enough that the confrontation never develops beyond verbal sparring. Being a Maia, I'm sure he is quite capable of (again) battling the Witch King, but it is not his fight. Gandalf inspires the West to fight- he does not combat Sauron alone. In that respect I think that the emphasis of the movie is quite correctly placed- the forces of the West (represented by the Rohirrim) in apposition to the forces of Mordor, NOT Maia vs. Nazgul.
rs691919 said:
But again, I am quite mindful of the adaptor's dilemma regarding this scene: it is impossible to be in two places at once. So therefore, one must look at the scene and determine what is more important in mainting the thematic integrity of the text. The ordering of the Rohirrim and the speech of Theoden, moving as they are, do not have the potency to match the confrontation at the Gate and the Horns of Hope at cockcrow. Tolkien created a moment almost frozen in time where Gandalf and the Lord of the Nazgul face each other. This is a crucial moment in the narrative, and it is swept away for reasons that I don't really understand.
Sidestepping the last line of Theoden's verse (personally I thought he was chanting for the death he'd unleash on the Orcs, not his own), in my opinion the horns at cockcrow came through in the movie as they came through in the book- at the lowest point. Whether this was as the forces of Mordor were sweeping through the city and the Gondorians were desperately trying to escape to the second level, or when Gandalf and the Witch King were standing off- the effect for me is the same. I will agree that the standoff itself would have had more tension than what we saw, but I think that the Horns, Theoden's speech, and the eventual charge (all of which DID occur in the film) more than compensated for the omission.
rs691919 said:
It is the "surprise attack", totally unsuspected by the forces of Mordor and their leader--focused only on that impenetrable Gate--that turns the tide. By having the armies square off against each other, that surprise is gone. My objection is not to pig-head nor to the fact that he readies his archers, but rather to the loss of the element of surprise and sudden-ness.
Doubtlessly surprise helps, but also the arrogance of Mordor (both in assuming the Rohirrim would not arrive and that the Corsairs would) also plays a major role. The arrival of the Rohirrim is still a surprise, and the 1-2 minutes of re-ordering that Gothmog is allowed is still not enough to offset the fact that he was surprised and outmanoveured.
By "sheer scale" I did not mean that the forces of the Rohirrim were so large that they could not be stopped- I meant that however many thousands of Orcs were still no match for a full charge of 6000+ cavalry. That fact is as true in the books as it is in the film. The initial onset (in the books) catches the Northern half of the Pelannor by surprise, but the momentum of the charge carries through almost to the Anduin. Even the forces of Mordor that were further to the South, who had time to recover from the surprise of the assault, even they were pushed back from the gates. The only thing that saved Mordor in the books (and in the films) were the Oliphaunts, which allowed for pockets of troops to hold out against the charge, absorb the energy of the charge, and then slowly force the Rohirrim back with overwhelming numbers.

As for the confrontation scene, again I have no idea why it was removed. Having reviewed the trailer, I can give my interpretation of when it occurs- Pippin is riding right behind Gandalf on Shadowfax, and the surrounding architecture appears to be the same as what is around the House of the Dead where Denethor is about to be burned. In the theatrical edition Pippin finds Gandalf after the horns are heard, but there is no particular reaction by Gandalf (who is only present in voice-over) or any of the Gondorian troops to that sound. I would guess that the EE will mess slightly with the time frame- allowing Pippin to catch Gandalf before the Horns, and then having the Horns break up the confrontation (as in the book). But of course, that is just a guess, and we won't know the answer for another 7 months.
 

Today's events

Back
Top