Orodreth and Gil-galad's parentage

[Gil-Galad]

Orodreth's parentage and Gil-galad

[color=sky blue]I split this thread from Elendil3119's 'Geneaologies' thread. -ithrynluin[/color]

Nice site Elendil3119,but I have to add that actually my dad is not Fingon but Orodreth. Can you imagine how I felt when I realized that-awful,cause I don't like Orodreth's character.But Tolkien changed his plans later in the years.

 

[Inderjit S]

you imagine how I felt when I realized that-awful,cause I don't like Orodreth's character.But Tolkien changed his plans later in the years.

*pats G-G on the back* There, there my friend. I understand your sorrow, you were once a decendant of Feanor, the son of Finrod, VERY briefly a son of Fingon, and Tolkien goes and chooses the idiot king of Nargothrond as you father. (P.S Can I have your sister, Finduilas's number )

 

[Gil-Galad]

Originally posted by Inderjit S
*pats G-G on the back* There, there my friend. I understand your sorrow, you were once a decendant of Feanor, the son of Finrod, VERY briefly a son of Fingon, and Tolkien goes and chooses the idiot king of Nargothrond as you father. (P.S Can I have your sister, Finduilas's number )

hehehe of course you can.her mobile phone is
[color=sky blue]editted[/color] !But I've got to tell you that if you do something bad to my sis I'm gonna kick you at least.....and then .......!

[color=sky blue]Public display of phone numbers is not allowed for security's sake. Especially concerning minors.
-ithrynluin[/color]

 

[Ithrynluin]

Originally posted by Inderjit S
and Tolkien goes and chooses the idiot king of Nargothrond as you father.

Why is Orodreth an idiot? He was just a bit weak-willed and should have taken a stand when the sons of Fëanor tried to usurp Nargothrond. He was a kind and just ruler. It's very sad you should call Orodreth an idiot and yet lionize other Elves who obviously qualify as idiots - you know who I'm talking about.

 

[Inderjit S]

G-G, I wan't being seriosu and I didn't want your sisters phone number but it was a jokey reference to wanting the book Finduilas's non-existent phone number.

Why is Orodreth an idiot? He was just a bit weak-willed and should have taken a stand when the sons of Fëanor tried to usurp Nargothrond. He was a kind and just ruler. It's very sad you should call Orodreth an idiot and yet lionize other Elves who obviously qualify as idiots - you know who I'm talking about.

Ithrynluin, my opinion is my own. And I think you may be right in a sense, I will have to have a better view of my prespective father in law.

 

[Gil-Galad]

Originally posted by ithrynluin
Why is Orodreth an idiot? He was just a bit weak-willed and should have taken a stand when the sons of Fëanor tried to usurp Nargothrond. He was a kind and just ruler. It's very sad you should call Orodreth an idiot and yet lionize other Elves who obviously qualify as idiots - you know who I'm talking about.

.......hmhmhmmh why I think you have Feanor in mind when you talk about idiots?!!He could be everything but not idiot!

 

[Ithrynluin]

Originally posted by Gil-Galad
.......hmhmhmmh why I think you have Feanor in mind when you talk about idiots?!!He could be everything but not idiot!

I didn't even mention Fëanor. How come it comes to mind so quickly in association with the word 'idiot' ?

But let's keep opinions on Fëanor in the other thread.

 

[Gil-Galad]

Originally posted by ithrynluin
I didn't even mention Fëanor. How come it comes to mind so quickly in association with the word 'idiot' ?

But let's keep opinions on Fëanor in the other thread.

Because I know your attitude towards him.And I thought you ment him.