Éomond
Rider of Rohan
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2002
- Messages
- 881
Gandalf White is right, there will be no Scouring of the Shire. PJ never liked that part in the book so he didn't even film it. Grrr.... 

Éomond said:Gandalf White is right, there will be no Scouring of the Shire. PJ never liked that part in the book so he didn't even film it. Grrr....![]()
Are you sure he didn't like it, or that it just wasn't feasable to fit into the film?Éomond said:Gandalf White is right, there will be no Scouring of the Shire. PJ never liked that part in the book so he didn't even film it. Grrr....![]()
But do you think it would have seemed as if there was so much missing to one not familiar with the books?Ancalagon said:I have to admit, I was not overly impressed with the editing of TRoTK, though only really due to the fact so much was obviously missing.
CraigSmith said:But do you think it would have seemed as if there was so much missing to one not familiar with the books?
That's probably fair enough then. I've only seen it once, and the gaps get filled up with my own knowledgeFrom those people I know who have not read the books but have seen the film, the ending was choppy and rushed in places.
Are you sure he didn't like it, or that it just wasn't feasable to fit into the film?
Bucky said: