• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Rotk Ee Dvd Will Be 5 Hours Long!

Éomond said:
Gandalf White is right, there will be no Scouring of the Shire. PJ never liked that part in the book so he didn't even film it. Grrr....

I always said that the SotS was anti-climactic, in films at least, but I never realized how true this was until I saw RotK. It just wouldn't work.
 
I have to admit, I was not overly impressed with the editing of TRoTK, though only really due to the fact so much was obviously missing. I am extremely keen to see the EE DVD as I feel it may draw a parallel to the EE DVD of The Fellowship of the Ring, which was magnificent. The Two Towers did not really redeem itself, but 2 outta 3 aint bad
 
Éomond said:
Gandalf White is right, there will be no Scouring of the Shire. PJ never liked that part in the book so he didn't even film it. Grrr....
Are you sure he didn't like it, or that it just wasn't feasable to fit into the film?

Ancalagon said:
I have to admit, I was not overly impressed with the editing of TRoTK, though only really due to the fact so much was obviously missing.
But do you think it would have seemed as if there was so much missing to one not familiar with the books?
 
CraigSmith said:
But do you think it would have seemed as if there was so much missing to one not familiar with the books?

From those people I know who have not read the books but have seen the film, the ending was choppy and rushed in places.

I agree. It was like there was the mass effort to tie up all of the loose ends in the last 15 minutes of the film.

I hope P.J. allows the EE to go beyond 4 hours. It isn't like anyone who would go out of the way to purchase the EE would mind a greater length.
 
I was given a LotR Movie Version Trivial Pursuits game for Christmas. Looking through the questions, there is stuff like "Who killed Saruman?" and "Who threw the Palantir out of Orthanc?"

The game is New Line Cinema endorsed... do the game manufacturers know something we don't?
 
Maybe the people at New Line have read the books? But that's odd, when they weren't even in the film... I reckon, though, that at the very least Wormtongue is going to throw the palantir out of the tower during the confrontation, and perhaps someone is going to kill Saruman? *shudders*

From those people I know who have not read the books but have seen the film, the ending was choppy and rushed in places.
That's probably fair enough then. I've only seen it once, and the gaps get filled up with my own knowledge I'll pay more attention to it when I see it again next week
 

LOL! Looks like another one got by!

Lotho
 
Are you sure he didn't like it, or that it just wasn't feasable to fit into the film?

I can't find my Newsweek, but in the article about editing out certian parts of the movie it said PJ never liked the SotS. Once I find it, I'll post it.
 
ee

if all of that is in the extended edition, then the movie will be amazing! i like how they're at least trying to stick more towards the book
 
if all of the stuff that is listed is in the extended version, then that will make it follow a lot better, and that will make me a little bit happier. the theatrical version was good, but i'd like to see the extended edition
 
Word is that New Line are balking at the price for another Extended Edition, and may be farming out the FX to El Cheapo American FX House Inc rather than the high-quality excesses of WETA.

I find that VERY hard to believe considering the Trilogy has had to have cleared a billion dollars profit minimum between worldwide movie tickets sales, video/DVD & merchandise already.

On The Scouring Of The Shire:

It's just too long to work after the big climax for a movie......

It would almost be half as long as some regular movies are in themselves (45 minutes) between setting it up earlier in TFOR & afterwards in ROTK.

Besides, if you think it just might get in the EE, forget it. Sam's gift from Galdriel was a rope, not a box of dirt with a mallorn seed.
 
Bucky said:

Besides, if you think it just might get in the EE, forget it. Sam's gift from Galdriel was a rope, not a box of dirt with a mallorn seed.


I had a small leap of faith when I saw TTTEE and saw that box fall from sam and he begged Frodo to catch it. I thought it was galadriel's box. But it's just a box of seasoning for roast chicken
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…