• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

👁️Sauron's form: your thoughts

What exactly do you mean by
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
the form of 'The Eye of Sauron'


I mean this, straight from The Sil, Of The Rings Of Power & The 3rd Age:


....Sauron had also returned..... There now he brooded in the dark, until he had wrought for himself a new shape; & it was terrible, for his fair semblance had departed for ever when he was cast into the abyss at the drowning of Numenor....... and the malice of the Eye of Sauron few even of the great amoung Elves & Men could endur.'

The Eye is his actual shape as well as the 'image' he projects in the 'spirit' realm......

Couple that with Gollum's comment "He has only 4 fingers on one hand but they are enough" & you can be sure that you are talking about a REAL physical being. I believe it was this Dark Lord who created a 'terrible form' (JRR says so) with one eye smack in the middle of the forehead ala the Cyclops......

Then, there's also 'The Eye' that is seen in the 'Unseen' realm, aka 'The wraith' world, where Gandalf tells Frodo that High Elves that have seen the light of The Two Trees have great power against both "The Seen and The Unseen"; There 'The Eye of Sauron' comes across as a thundercloud upon Amon Hen as Frodo has the Ring on. It pops into the mirror of Galadriel; It comes into the palantir when Pippin peaks in, but "then HE came" as Pippin says. "He came" - not "The Eye popped up."

Make NO mistake - although PJ takes artististic license to increase the power of the Ring by having Sauron not be able to regain physical shape without possessing it - Sauron has a body at the time of The War Of The Ring in The Lord Of The Rings Books.
 
One also wonders if they mock statue of Sauron at the crossroads bared any resemblance to him, or was it just the Ork's drawing a picture of the "symbol" of the eye of Sauron on the King's forehead, to show his dominance.

Whilst were on the subject there is a interesting comment in Laws and Customs of the Eldar (HoME 10) about the ability of Sauron and his Necromancer in taking over peoples bodies, and controlling their actions.

The Haradrim also took him to be as a 'god and king' because he surrounded his 'abode with fire' and Isildur commented on the heat of Sauron's body killing Gil-Galad. He sure loved fire.
 
That's a very interesting comment about the statue with the one eye.

I never thought of that, but it makes perfect sense.
 
I always thought of him like a dark lord dressed in black, like Ganandorf, except with a helmet on. Don't ask me why I don't even know.
 
Well, I for one strongly believe Sauron had a physical form in LotR, ever since TA 1000 when he constructed and dwelt in Dol Guldur as the Necromancer. Because when you (or at least I) think about it, how could he not have had his body back and still have been a menacing presence? For when even the Valar would traverse without shape or form (physically) the Eldar could not clearly percieve there presence; Indeed, they might go totaly unnoticed (i.e. not being realized as being Ainur). And yet all around Dol Guldur there was an unbreakable aura of malice, strong enough to even be palpable. And yet this is Sauron, not even a Vala but a Maia, and without even having the Ring with him. Thus, even though the presence of evil is far more greatly felt by the good than the presence of good is felt by the good, still Sauron was far less powerful than the average Vala and even Maia at that time. Therefore, it is my belief that Sauron would have had to have a body in order to be percieved so clearly. Indeed, a passage detailing this has already been quoted above: in a tale which allows the incarnation of great spirits in a physical and destructible form their power must be far greater when actually physically present.

Also, how could he have built anything if he didn't have a body? I am fairly sure that the Nazgûl were not yet in that general vicinity and indeed would not come to Dol Guldur at all until many years afterward. But moving on, I picture Sauron as he was in the end of the second age, for in order for Gollum's words to be true ("He has only four fingers on the Black Hand, but they are enough"), then Sauron would need to have reconstructed the body he lost in his fall in the battle of the Last Alliance. And that, in my opinion, fits perfectly, as it is my belief that Sauron would not have had the strength to make a new body in such short a time without the Ring, but did have the strength to rebuild his old one in that time. Therefore, It is my belief that, though not as strong and really even as solid (i.e. his flesh could be pierced more easily, a bone broken, etc.) as he was in the Last Alliance, he was in the same body and it was entirely the same shape (with two armes, two legs, two eyes, etc.), save only, of course, his one missing finger. And whoa, I just had a thought... What if Sauron recieved the Ring and, upon his touch, the Ring expands and within is formed anew his finger of old, and it mystically reconnects to his hand in its proper place? I don't know... Maybe it's just totally off and wrong. Craziness. Well, anyway, I also think that the one Eye wreathed in flame is just something that is seen in the spiritual world, as has previously been suggested. Of course, it has also been an insane thought of mine that there were, indeed, two eyes wreathed in flame in the spiritual world, but that his far-seeing powers were also nothing to do with Sauron himself, but rather the Palantîr which he possessed. Thus he would use the Palantîr to look far off, and that the image thus projected upon those who whould see would be of a great eye, the combination of the two into one (two eyes into one palantîr), more powerful than either one alone. And this image would be spiritual, and thus seen by any and all who might so happen to have an encounter with the spiritual world (i.e. a dream, a vision, a look into a palantír, and also seen by an Elf from Valinor, all of whom were in both worlds).

Finaly, Aman in a separate plain of existance? But how then could Ar-Pharazon sail and land upon the shores of Aman? How then could the Elves set sail from Aman and arrive upon the shores of Middle-Earth when they were (to me) obviously within the same plain of existance the entire time? In the beginning of Eä, all of the world existed in the same number of plains (however many that be), and Aman was chosen to be the Ainur's home only because they, after many years of toiling and labouring, they just so happened to like its terrain moreso than anywhere else. Granted, many things to come after would most suredly be in both plains (i.e. the Elves that dwelt there, having learned much of the wisdom of the Valar and grown great and power and majesty, as well as strength of body and soul), but that doesn't mean that they aren't in the other plain as well. And after the fall of Numenor, did Eru just magically transport them into another plain? How then did Glorfindel come to the shores of Middle-Earth in the third age? How did the ship carrying Curumo, Olórin, Aiwendil, Alatar, and Pallando (i.e. the Istari) come to and arrive upon the shores of Middle-Earth? And how would the ship upon which went Frodo, Biblo, Elrond, Galadriel, and Olórin come at last to the land of Aman? It seems to me that there is a great void in this theory, but perhaps there is something you know that I do not? Ah well, whatever.
 
The land of the Valar was indeed in a seperate plain of existence. After the fall of Numenour Eru bent the earth and raised Valinor up out of it. However, people can still go between it and Arda with the will of the Valar, at least, I believe so.
 
I always thought that Elves could go but no one else really could. . .though I suppose this was at the will of the Valar so basically the same thing as what you said.
 
I agree with Khôr’nagan.

In his writing Tolkien makes Sauron vague figure, a looming presence whom we never see. Tolkien plays Sauron likey a bogey in a horror film where what you don’t see is worse than what you do see. A result is that we don’t see Sauron and so can’t well know what his form was. In the tale this doesn’t matter at all. It is enough that Sauron is terrible.

However in the chapter ‘The Black Gate is Closed’, Gollum uses another name for Sauron:
But master is going to take it to Him, straight to the Black Hand, if master will go this way.
A little later we find: It seems that Sauron’s form contains at least an eye and a hand and that the hand lacks a finger which Isildur cut off. Sauron must have (wholly or in part?) regained his old form as it was after Isildur cut off the finger.

The blackness of Sauron’s hand is also mentioned in Isildur’s scroll which Gandalf found:
The Ring misseth, maybe, the heat of Sauron’s hand, which was black and yet burned like fire, and so Gil-galad was destroyed; ...
The emphasis on Eye in the singular and Black Hand in the singular has suggested to some that Sauron’s form was intended by Tolkien to be like one of the Formorians, the demons of Irish mythology, who are sometimes described as having one eye, one arm and hand, one leg and foot. Such half-persons occasionally appear in other mythologies also though not as demons so far as I know, simply as oddities of the supernatural world.

But the only surviving description of Sauron in his post-Númenorian shape appears in Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien, Letter 246, where Tolkien disusses Aragorn’s battle of will with Saruman for control of the Palantír and states: This prosaic description is somewhat disappointing. But nothing here suggests Sauron was missing limbs.

It might be that the hand on which Sauron wore the One Ring was blackened by his use of its power. I think with Lantarion that the Eye more likely references Sauron’s spirit rather than his physical form, to an ability to look out and perceive things afar and to hold others under his power. Recall the third eye of Shiva in Hindu tales and the uraeus-serpent on the forehead of Egyptian kings, sometimes equated with the Eye of Re.

Remember what is said of Morgoth in The Silmarillion, chapter 18 concerning captive Noldor:
... for Morgoth used some of these for his evil purposes, and feigning to give them liberty sent them abroad, but their wills were chained to his, and they strayed only to come back to him again.
Would such power used by Sauron be perceived as the power of his Eye? Morgoth also was able to give to Húrin the power to perceive, at least at times, the dire fates of his children under Morgoth’s curse. Morgoth says:
Therefore with my eyes thou shalt see, and with my ears thou shalt hear; ...
Might Morgoth in such circumstances reasonably have said eye and ear instead?

Then, there is Tolkien’s own artistic interpretation of Sauron.

Yes, J.R.R. Tolkien actually included a pictorial rendition of Sauron’s form for what was intended to be the design for the dust jacket of The Return of the King. This design has been used on some British editions and can be seen at The Return of the King - UK. Unfortunately the image is not very clear on this scan.

In the upper left the shape of Sauron appears, hooded with arm and hand stretched out over the central throne and tree image. Under the hood a single red eye shows, but the hood obscures the exact direction in which Sauron’s head is turned so one cannot tell whether the eye is central in Sauron’s forehead or to one side and in a normal position for a right eye.
 
Last edited:
Seeing that Tolkien is SUCH a stickler for minute details, I would tend to stick to my 'one eye ala Cyclops' theory until someone finds a shread of evidence to the contrary......

Remember, we are ONLY talking AFTER going down in Numenor that Tolkien coins the phrase 'The Eye Of Sauron' as Sauron wrought a new shape (and it was terrible).
 
I don't think Sauron was an Eye. I think he had an ordinary body, with two legs, two arms, etc. All of the references to an Eye are metaphorical -- they refer to Sauron's far-seeing power.

I agree that Sauron didn't actually take the shape of an Eye. But I don't think the references to the Eye were necessarily metaphorical.

A couple of you mentioned that it was the form he projected in the spirit world. I think this is most likely, but there might be another possibility.

Could it not have been a construct of some kind, created by dark magic, like someone might build a telescope? Perhaps it only existed in the wraith-world, and thus could only be seen by wraiths (or anyone wearing a Ring of Power, or looking into a palantir, or Galadriel's mirror, etc.)

The difference is subtle, but I like the idea of the Eye as a tool of Sauron which he created or manifested rather than a form he took - whether in the spirit-world or the physical world. Of course, it would have a psychic link to him, and so in that sense it could actually be said to have been part of him...

But a good analogy would be a real eye, the organ of sight; your eyes are part of you, yet they are not you, so if you lost them you could continue to live, you just wouldn't be able to see.

Or is that in essence what some of you were saying after all?
 
I know there is a similar pic in this thread in a post by Luthien Séregon, but i found this a long tme ago and at the time I laughed my head off(as I did when I saw the Luthien's pic). I believe it was pre-PJ.

So...knock yourself out

The website was The Tolkien Sarcasm page (I don't remember the URL). Just pop "Tolkien Sarcasm" into your search engine.
 

Attachments

  • sauron.gif
    6.3 KB · Views: 42

LoL... that's too funny...

Interesting idea, Mouth of Sauron.
 
The passage I keep thinking about is when Pippin looked into the palantir: "Then he came. He did not speak so that I could hear words. He just looked, and I understood." It also said that he (Sauron) laughed and gloated.

It seems to me from this as though Pippin saw a face, a person, and I keep wondering what he looked like.

Than much later, when I read The Silmarillion, and the fall of Numenor, it said that Sauron's body was destroyed and his spirit could only take unpleasant forms. So I guess it's completely up to our imagination.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…