Well, I for one strongly believe
Sauron had a physical form in LotR, ever since TA 1000 when he constructed and dwelt in
Dol Guldur as the Necromancer. Because when you (or at least I) think about it, how could he not have had his body back and still have been a menacing presence? For when even the
Valar would traverse without shape or form (physically) the Eldar could not clearly percieve there presence; Indeed, they might go totaly unnoticed (i.e. not being realized as being
Ainur). And yet all around Dol Guldur there was an unbreakable aura of malice, strong enough to even be palpable. And yet this is Sauron, not even a
Vala but a
Maia, and without even having
the Ring with him. Thus, even though the presence of
evil is far more greatly felt by the good than the presence of good is felt by the good, still Sauron was far less powerful than the average Vala and even Maia at that time. Therefore, it is my belief that Sauron would have had to have a body in order to be percieved so clearly. Indeed, a passage detailing this has already been quoted above:
in a tale which allows the incarnation of great spirits in a physical and destructible form their power must be far greater when actually physically present.
Also, how could he have built anything if he didn't have a body? I am fairly sure that the
Nazgûl were not yet in that general vicinity and indeed would not come to Dol Guldur at all until many years afterward. But moving on, I picture Sauron as he was in the end of the
second age, for in order for
Gollum's words to be true ("He has only four fingers on the Black Hand, but they are enough"), then Sauron would need to have reconstructed the body he lost in his fall in the
battle of the Last Alliance. And that, in my opinion, fits perfectly, as it is my belief that Sauron would not have had the strength to make a new body in such short a time without the Ring, but
did have the strength to rebuild his old one in that time. Therefore, It is my belief that, though not as strong and really even as solid (i.e. his flesh could be pierced more easily, a bone broken, etc.) as he was in the Last Alliance, he was in the same body and it was entirely the same shape (with two armes, two legs,
two eyes, etc.), save only, of course, his one missing finger. And whoa, I just had a thought... What if Sauron recieved the Ring and, upon his touch, the Ring expands and within is formed anew his finger of old, and it mystically reconnects to his hand in its proper place? I don't know... Maybe it's just totally off and wrong. Craziness. Well, anyway, I also think that
the one Eye wreathed in flame is just something that is seen in the spiritual world, as has previously been suggested. Of course, it has also been an insane thought of mine that there were, indeed, two eyes wreathed in flame in the spiritual world, but that his far-seeing powers were also nothing to do with Sauron himself, but rather the Palantîr which he possessed. Thus he would use the Palantîr to look far off, and that the image thus projected upon those who whould see would be of a great eye, the combination of the two into one (two eyes into one palantîr), more powerful than either one alone. And this image would be spiritual, and thus seen by any and all who might so happen to have an encounter with the spiritual world (i.e. a dream, a vision, a look into a
palantír, and also seen by an
Elf from
Valinor, all of whom were in both worlds).
Finaly,
Aman in a separate plain of existance? But how then could
Ar-Pharazon sail
and land upon the shores of Aman? How then could the
Elves set sail from Aman and arrive upon the shores of
Middle-Earth when they were (to me) obviously within the same plain of existance the entire time? In the beginning of Eä, all of the world existed in the same number of
plains (however many that be), and Aman was chosen to be the Ainur's home only because they, after many years of toiling and labouring, they just so happened to like its terrain moreso than anywhere else. Granted, many things to come after would most suredly be in both plains (i.e. the Elves that dwelt there, having learned much of the wisdom of the Valar and grown great and power and majesty, as well as strength of body and soul), but that doesn't mean that they aren't in the other plain as well. And after the fall of
Numenor, did
Eru just magically transport them into another plain? How then did
Glorfindel come to the shores of Middle-Earth in
the third age? How did the ship carrying
Curumo,
Olórin,
Aiwendil,
Alatar, and
Pallando (i.e. the
Istari) come to and arrive upon the shores of Middle-Earth? And how would the ship upon which went
Frodo, Biblo,
Elrond,
Galadriel, and Olórin come at last to the land of Aman? It seems to me that there is a great void in this theory, but perhaps there is something you know that I do not? Ah well, whatever.