Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.
Register
How about Pippin dropping that rock in the well in Moria, just when the Fellowship was almost past the danger? Even if Pippin was the happy-go-lucky hobbit early in his travels, after all the danger he'd seen (Weathertop, the Ford of Bruinen, etc.) it seems like he would have been much more careful in a scary place like Moria. Since he dropped the rock, now basically, Gandalf's fall with the Balrog can be blamed on Pippin! That's terrible!
How about Pippin dropping that rock in the well in Moria, just when the Fellowship was almost past the danger? Even if Pippin was the happy-go-lucky hobbit early in his travels, after all the danger he'd seen (Weathertop, the Ford of Bruinen, etc.) it seems like he would have been much more careful in a scary place like Moria. Since he dropped the rock, now basically, Gandalf's fall with the Balrog can be blamed on Pippin! That's terrible!
But Pippin's primary trait is his indomitable spirit. If he suddenly started being subdued and cautious it would be out of character.
Besides, this is very much exaggerated in the films. He's not quite so much comic relief in the book.
How about Pippin dropping that rock in the well in Moria, just when the Fellowship was almost past the danger? Even if Pippin was the happy-go-lucky hobbit early in his travels, after all the danger he'd seen (Weathertop, the Ford of Bruinen, etc.) it seems like he would have been much more careful in a scary place like Moria. Since he dropped the rock, now basically, Gandalf's fall with the Balrog can be blamed on Pippin! That's terrible!
It would SEEM to me that anyone who responds to this indicating they would change something, would be one who has then no cause to grieve over the 'changes' made in the Hobbit and LoTR movies, and upcoming 'rings of power' series.
It would SEEM to me that anyone who responds to this indicating they would change something, would be one who has then no cause to grieve over the 'changes' made in the Hobbit and LoTR movies, and upcoming 'rings of power' series.
It would SEEM to me that anyone who responds to this indicating they would change something, would be one who has then no cause to grieve over the 'changes' made in the Hobbit and LoTR movies, and upcoming 'rings of power' series.
Pippin drops the stone. Within several minutes they hear the noises from below (the first indication of enemies actively present in Moria), "tom-tap, tap-tom..."
"'Yes', said Gandalf, 'and I do not like it. It may have nothing to do with Peregrin's foolish stone; but probably something has been disturbed that would have been better left quiet.'"
100% certainty that Pippin's stone alerted the enemies...no.
However, according to Gandalf/Tolkien Pippin's stone probably alerted the enemies.
Pippin drops the stone. Within several minutes they hear the noises from below (the first indication of enemies actively present in Moria), "tom-tap, tap-tom..."
"'Yes', said Gandalf, 'and I do not like it. It may have nothing to do with Peregrin's foolish stone; but probably something has been disturbed that would have been better left quiet.'"
100% certainty that Pippin's stone alerted the enemies...no.
However, according to Gandalf/Tolkien Pippin's stone probably alerted the enemies.
AHA. If Gandalf chose to phrase it as "speculation" I give it to our Chief Cellrog and his Great Halls... 😁
(That said, I do agree with the Big G that it is 'probably' directly connected.)
Note that T said "Peregrin's foolish stone' rather than 'foolish Peregrin's stone.'
AHA. If Gandalf chose to phrase it as "speculation" I give it to our Chief Cellrog and his Great Halls... 😁
(That said, I do agree with the Big G that it is 'probably' directly connected.)
Note that T said "Peregrin's foolish stone' rather than 'foolish Peregrin's stone.'