- Joined
- Jun 28, 2022
- Messages
- 5,027
Yes. The incident subtler. The development of Frodos character more consistent…especially so early in the story. And to allow for a bit of a “darker” element of intrigue to the building of the tension.To make the incident subtler, if I read your above posts correctly.
Which would have annoyed the most prominent and (so far!) most blatant second-guesser of JRRT, PJ. One thing, as far as I can see, that no one can accuse him of is subtlety ... 😈
I don’t think Frodo prancing around unnecessarily adds to the story. In some ways for me it detracts. At best it just carries it along.
it’s one of Tolkiens very few spots that isn’t distinctly additive…which should be the goal of every scene written.
Butterbur is enough comic relief into the atmosphere and the existing circumstances.
Again, all my opinion.
