• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Second-guessing and Misunderstanding Tolkien

"Second Guessing Tolkien"

So staying on the "2nd guessing" line.... it is Gollum that awakens the Orcs, padding along behind them through the place, thinking if he stirs up trouble and they get killed maybe he can get at the ring again...especially in the deeps of the dark..! Not the foolish stone.
 
I'm starting to wonder if I'm being trolled by a tree (ok..."Enting". But I like the way "trolled by a tree" sounds). 😉
If memory serves, I think they've been in Moria for many days with Gollum following. Then, the noises from below come immediately after the stone dropped by the "fool of a Took".

Do you really think Pippin's stone wasn't the trigger? Or, are you just messin' with me? Either way, it's OK.
 

I'm just messin'. The weight of evidence is with that darned foolish stone.
But I'm always willing to toss things out there for the Cellrog's Great Halls....
 
I'm just messin'. The weight of evidence is with that darned foolish stone.
But I'm always willing to toss things out there for the Cellrog's Great Halls....
Effective messin'. You had me until the last post about Gollum.

Based on the comments after my "Pippin" post, I'm starting to wonder if the subject of this thread is a non-starter. The consensus seems to be: Tolkien's words are perfect. He who entertains the notion of improving upon them shall surely be given a stern talking to.
 
I don't doubt that the orcs hear the stone, but I'm less than sure that it's the first thing they hear of the Fellowship, who made a lot of noise on the way to the Chamber. Their very entrance is marked by a crash of crumbling masonry. My guess is that the stone merely defines the position of the Fellowship more clearly to the orcs of Moria.

In any case, if the stone did alert the orcs to the Fellowship, it's as much Gandalf's fault as it is Pippin's. Gandalf never calls for the Company to be silent at any point and certainly doesn't make it clear that nobody should touch anything. Such might be obvious to seasoned adventurers like Gandalf and Aragorn, but not to green Pippin.
 
Last edited:
I think they've been in Moria for many days with Gollum following.

Just as a note this roused my curiosities.
It "cannot be less than 40 miles" straight through, and Gandalf says it will take "3 or 4 marches."

The text says: "It was after nightfall when they had entered the Mines. They had been going for several hours with only brief halts, when Gandalf came to his first serious check." (multiple passages). They decided to "rest for the rest of the night". Gandalf says "the late Moon is riding westward and the middle-night has passed.

They found a chamber just off this hall. Gandalf cries "Steady! Steady!" as Merry and Pippin push forward into it. "I will go first".
There they find the well.

So it's the first day just after 'several hours' between "nightfall" when they entered, and "the middle-night passing" that they come to the well.

Now THERE's some inconsequential trivia for us...!😃
 
Then, I was mistaken in my memory, thinking they were almost free and clear when Pippin dropped the stone. So, that does detract from my way of thinking just a little bit.

Either way in my second-guessing of The Master, I'd have Pippin not drop the stone and possibly have Gimli's grief at seeing Balin's Tomb be the trigger that alerts the enemies.

"Tho Gimli, Gloin's son, is made of the stern stuff of earth and stone, in that moment his dwarven heart could not contain his grief, and the wail of his despair came forth. Thus Durin's Bane was reawakened by Gimli the Dwarf as in ages past it was awakened by the Dwarves of Old."

--Thus writes Eljorahir, wannabe editor of The Master--
 
Reactions: Ent

A much better alternative than would Gollum's great risk (to both himself and the ring) be should he contrive to 'rat them out.'
I like it...
 
A much better alternative than would Gollum's great risk (to both himself and the ring) be should he contrive to 'rat them out.'
I like it...

I guess if I really, really wanted to do something differently with Tolkien's text, it would be to re-write portions of the Bree scene. There's just something about it I don't quite like as well as I should.

Pippin behaves perfectly in character...incautious, getting into his cups, being loose-lipped and acting thoughtlessly.
Frodo on the other hand, in 'resolving' the situation, takes a very 'unlike Frodo' direction (to me) to handle it.

Does it really seem, given his otherwise cautious and thoughtful character, and as the oldest and also a 'respectable' Hobbit, that he'd jump up on a table and start a speech? And then get carried away with his further uncharacteristic antics, and end up 'accidentally' slipping on the ring?

He's well older than Pippin (who is the youngest of them.) It's far more likely he'd just go out, (symbolically) 'grab the rascally youth by the scruff of the neck', drag him back to the table, sit him down, and tell him to be more cautious... at which the ever-aware and on-target Pippin, being well into his cups, would undoubtedly say something loudly and stupidly, like "I wasn't going to say anything about the ring...I would NEVER say anything about the ring" which would of course have been overheard, with corresponding results following out from it.

Bree is a nice place to have the events. I'm just not overly fond of the manner of their unfolding, I guess.
Too little Frodo, too much 'somebody else in his body' for me. And I don't think for him his off-character behavior could be laid off to 'the cups.'
 
Last edited:
I see your point. Pippin was simply (perhaps unwisely) retelling the story of Bilbo's birthday party and disappearance. I think everyone in the Shire and possibly all the Hobbits of Bree knew the story already. Frodo definitely made the situation worse (out of character) by intervening the way he did. I guess the whole sequence is just designed to get Frodo to put on the ring and raise the danger level.
 
I guess the whole sequence is just designed to get Frodo to put on the ring and raise the danger level.
Yeah, there's that. Every story needs conflict, even in places where you might not expect it. If Frodo does the sensible thing, whatever that might be, or if Strider instead causes the diversion, we likely end up with a boring chapter.
 
Yep, I see what you're saying. I think maybe Enting's point is there may have been a better way to ratchet up the conflict (danger level) in Bree than having Frodo pretending to be drunk and singing the Cow Jumps Over The Moon song.
 
Reactions: Ent

Indeed, that's pretty much my point. I do think with a less obvious "incident", the ratcheting of the intrigue would be far from 'boring' and could be very well done (by someone like Tolkien) without loss to the story. Even with the pressure of the scenario and Strider's prompting, I don't think a 'thoughtful' Hobbit like Frodo would go for a method leaving them all right at the 'center of attention' - even if it's just jumping on a table, making a speech, and being 'pushed' into doing some singing.

He of them all knew that laying low was paramount.

All that said, there's nothing 'wrong' with the way it is... it's just one of my least favorite spots, and feels a little more out of place than it should.
 
Lurking in the background - or Frodo's pocket (with the benefit of the hindsight of many re-readings, and lots of help by people like Tom Shippey) - is the One Ring. So while Frodo Baggins might well have been acting out of character, Frodo-the-Ring-bearer might have been nudged in that direction by subtle promptings of the One Ring. JRRT leaves the issue of how "exactly" it influences its bearer unresolved - on purpose, is my guess. But the Ring could be construed to have sensed the proximity of some of the Nazgûl in the Shire, and that they were not far away from Bree. The Ring would then have quite the opposite intent to Frodo's not wanting to attract attention to himself and his companions ... certainly very speculative.
 

Indeed there are many ways to consider it. And there’s nothing wrong with the way it is.

but with a string question that says “if you could change anything in his writing what would you change”, I gave my response.

The question is speculative. By nature, most all answers are going to be speculative.
Personally I would rewrite it.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…