• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Should 👁️Sauron take form in the movie ROTK?

Should Sauron take form in the movie?

  • Yes, it's essential to the plot, and J.R.R. Tolkien should have had him take form at the end.

    Votes: 1 3.3%
  • It might make the story better, and it would be fun to see him in form again.

    Votes: 4 13.3%
  • It doesn't matter to me one way or the other...it's still a classic story!

    Votes: 4 13.3%
  • It might end up making the story worse, but I'll wait and see the film to decide.

    Votes: 8 26.7%
  • No, it isn't essential to the plot, and Peter Jackson shouldn't meddle with a classic.

    Votes: 11 36.7%
  • Other

    Votes: 2 6.7%

  • Total voters
    30

Valdarmyr

Member
Joined
Dec 25, 2002
Messages
432
To tell you the truth, I'll be glad if we see Sauron in physical form in ROTK, if even for just a few seconds. I love the book, but while everything about Sauron in the entire book leading up to the climax works for me, when you have such a climactic ending as is in LOTR, I need to see the most evil rotten bad guy fighting, having actual physical contact with the forces that are fighting him, again, if only for a few seconds. It's true, he does have people and creatures doing his dirty work for him, so he doesn't actually need to take form on the battlefield or somewhere else.

Let's just say--what if Mr. Tolkien had written the book so that the Ring got much closer to Sauron, so that he was almost able to put it on, that would've been better for me, but of course the ending in the book would've had to be changed a bit, and the way the Ring's very final fate is written is perfect, a classic. I admit that having book-Sauron in Barad-dur makes him more remote, mysterious and threatening in a disembodied way, but he just seems like a bit of a ghost to me at the end. Of course, if he had gotten the Ring, he would have instantly been "SUPER BAD."

Who knows...maybe Peter Jackson will show a ghostly image of Sauron in Barad-dur near the very end, like energy swirling around his spirit to start to give him form or something. I'm just saying it works in the book, but for a movie, I think you need the ultimate evil to be a little more tangible.
 
I like that ghostly idea, but if he embodies him in this movie I'm gona hurt someone. Also, if he doesnt give the Morgul King his spotlight he deserves as the second most powerful force of evil in middle earth I'm gona go balistic.

Anywhoo, back to the Sauron topic, I think that if he changes it, it would be too much. If he changes it, I'm starting a PJ haters club haa
 
to a certain extend

i LOVE the book ending to death with "suddenly, the great eye was upon mount doom" & every orc/wraith/creature suddenly charging the mountain

then afterwards the Hand of Sauron forms in the sky to grasp our heroes but falters with the wind & sunlight

i don't mind if he wants to show Sauron in some form, but i heard a rumour about Aragorn clashing swords with Sauron in front of the gates of Barad-Dûr

& if that happens...
 
I believe they should, not because its would look good, but because i think it is necissary cinematically. There have been so many plot deviations so far that i think this one wont really cause to much of a stir. We already know PJ isnt true to the books.
 
It doesnt matter to me one way or the other. It's a classic story. I would have liked to see the movie just like the book, but all three are still good movies.
 
I don't care if he shows up or not. Or even if he becomes a substantial being if just for a few seconds.

There is only one plot I am concerned with - the Destruction of the ring. I don't care how it's done, which cities Frodo is dragged to, if Arwen falls in love with Legolas, Saruman joins a 3 ring circus, etc... - as long as Frodo tosses the ring into the Volcano, I'm happy.
 
I think it would seriously damage the integrity of the movie(s) for all Tolkien fans if Sauron came riding up looking overdressed and cliché.. It's bad enough he's shown as an electrically buzzing holographic eye on top of a tower with two antennae poking out the sides!!
He is never shown that way in the novel, so there is absolutely no reason to do so in the movie. It might be impressive special-effects-wise and might bring in more cash from the non-fans, but to mess with such a technical part of the story which is at the same time extremely ambiguous would, in my opinion, ruin the film in some respects.
 
I wouldn't mind if it went like this....

Aragorn gives his rousing speech, then the Black Gates open. We see Sauron at the head of hundreds of thousands of orcs. A horn blows and the whole army but Sauron charges.

I know a lot of purists will hate this idea with a passion, but it would work in the movie, I think. I don't know if I would want this, but it's the best example I can come up with. Purists must realize that in the film Jackson has to show Sauron. This is a movie, not a book, it works differently. That's just my opinion.
 
Originally posted by Lantarion
It's bad enough he's shown as an electrically buzzing holographic eye on top of a tower with two antennae poking out the sides!!
He is never shown that way in the novel, so there is absolutely no reason to do so in the movie.
With all due respect, I believe I disagree:
from the book
Bilbo drew his hand over his eyes. I am sorry,’ he said. ‘But I felt so *****. And yet it would be a relief in a way not to be bothered with it any more. It has been so growing on my mind lately. Sometimes I have felt it was like an eye looking at me.
...
And if he often uses the Ring to make himself invisible, he fades: he becomes in the end invisible permanently, and walks in the twilight under the eye of the dark power that rules the Rings.
...
But suddenly the Mirror went altogether dark, as dark as if a hole had opened in the world of sight, and Frodo looked into emptiness. In the black abyss there appeared a single Eye that slowly grew. until it filled nearly all the Mirror. So terrible was it that Frodo stood rooted, unable to cry out or to withdraw his gaze. The Eye was rimmed with fire, but was itself glazed, yellow as a cat's, watchful and intent, and the black slit of its pupil opened on a pit, a window into nothing.
Then the Eye began to rove, searching this way and that; and Frodo knew with certainty and horror that among the many things that it sought he himself was one. ... `Yes,' she said, divining his thought, `it is not permitted to speak of it, and Elrond could not do so. But it cannot be hidden from the Ring-bearer, and one who has seen the Eye. ... You have perceived my thought more clearly than many that are accounted wise. You saw the Eye of him that holds the Seven and the Nine.
...
Then at last his gaze was held: wall upon wall, battlement upon battlement, black, immeasurably strong, mountain of iron, gate of steel, tower of adamant, he saw it: Barad-dûr, Fortress of Sauron. All hope left him.
And suddenly he felt the Eye. There was an eye in the Dark Tower that did not sleep. He knew that it had become aware of his gaze. A fierce eager will was there. It leaped towards him; almost like a finger he felt it, searching for him. ... The two powers strove in him. For a moment, perfectly balanced between their piercing points, he writhed, tormented. Suddenly he was aware of himself again. Frodo, neither the Voice nor the Eye: free to choose, and with one remaining instant in which to do so.
...
Wise fool. For if he had used all his power to guard Mordor, so that none could enter, and bent all his guild to the hunting of the Ring, then indeed hope would have faded: neither Ring nor Bearer could long have eluded him. But now his eye gazes abroad rather than near at home; and mostly he looks towards Minas Tirith. Very soon now his strength will fall upon it like a storm.
...
'All this about the Orcs of Barad-dûr, Lugbúrz as they call it, makes me uneasy,' said Aragorn. 'The Dark Lord already knew too much and his servants also; and Grishnákh evidently sent some message across the River after the quarrel. The Red Eye will be looking towards Isengard. But Saruman at any rate is in a cleft stick of his own cutting.'
...
Yes, we have won, but only the first victor and that in itself increases our danger. There was some link between Isengard and Mordor, which I have not yet fathomed. How they exchanged news I am not sure; but they did so. The Eye of Barad-dûr will be looking impatiently towards the Wizard's Vale, I think; and towards Rohan. The less it sees the better.'
...
'So do I,' said Frodo; 'but he's not my chief trouble. I wish we could get away from these hills! I hate them. I feel all naked on the east side, stuck up here with nothing but the dead flats between me and that Shadow yonder. There's an Eye in it. Come on! We've got to get down today somehow.'
...
Lots of His people will be there looking out for guests, very pleased to take them straight to Him, O yes. His Eye watches that way all the time. It caught Sméagol there, long ago.' Gollum shuddered.
...
`No, no indeed,' said Gollum. `Hobbits must see, must try to understand. He does not expect attack that way. His Eye is all round, but it attends more to some places than to others. He can't see everything all at once, not yet.
...
All things about him now were not dark but vague; while he himself was there in a grey hazy world, alone, like a small black solid rock and the Ring, weighing down his left hand, was like an orb of hot gold. He did not feel invisible at all, but horribly and uniquely visible; and he knew that somewhere an Eye was searching for him.
...
For it seems clear that our Enemy has opened his war at last and made the first move while Frodo was still free. So now for many days he will have his eye turned this way and that, away from his own land.
...
‘I deemed that the time was ripe, and that the Stone had come to me for just such a purpose. It was then ten days since the Ring-bearer went east from Rauros, and the Eye of Sauron, I thought, should be drawn out from his own land. ... ‘His doubt will be growing, even as we speak here. His Eye is now straining towards us, blind almost to all else that is moving. So we must keep it. Therein lies all our hope. This, then, is my counsel. We have not the Ring. In wisdom or great folly it has been sent away to be destroyed, lest it destroy us. Without it we cannot by force defeat his force. But we must at all costs keep his Eye from his true peril.
...
For if the Ring-bearer had indeed attempted that way, then above all they should not draw the Eye of Mordor thither.
...
He could never come back. Without any clear purpose he drew out the Ring and put it on again. Immediately he felt the great burden of its weight, and felt afresh, but now more strong and urgent than ever, the malice of the Eye of Mordor, searching, trying to pierce the shadows that it had made for its own defence, but which now hindered it in its unquiet and doubt.
...
The Dark Power was deep in thought, and the Eye turned inward, pondering tidings of doubt and danger: a bright sword, and a stern and kingly face it saw, and for a while it gave little thought to other things; and all its great stronghold, gate on gate, and tower on tower, was wrapped in a brooding gloom.
...
Anxiously Sam had noted how his master’s left hand would often be raised as if to ward on a blow, or to screen his shrinking eyes from a dreadful Eye that sought to look in them.
...
Thence, turning and encircling all its wide girth from south to north, it climbed at last, high in the upper cone, but still far from the reeking summit, to a dark entrance that gazed back east straight to the Window of the Eye in Sauron’s shadow-mantled fortress. ... The Eye was not turned to them: it was gazing north to where the Captains of the West stood at bay, and thither all its malice was now bent, as the Power moved to strike its deadly blow; but Frodo at that dreadful glimpse fell as one stricken mortally. His hand sought the chain about his neck.
...
The Dark Lord was suddenly aware of him, and his Eye piercing all shadows looked across the plain to the door that he had made; and the magnitude of his own folly was revealed to him in a blinding flash, and all the devices of his enemies were at last laid bare.
This long list is comprised of many (by no means all) references to Sauron. In each he is either referred to as the eye, or else described mostly as an eye (sometimes even an eye in a tower!). Clearly this is a motif that Tolkien put a considerable amount of effort into establishing- Sauron as the disembodied eye, forever searching for the Ring. Of course, we know from Gollum's nine finger comment (and probably from Pippin's interogation in the Palantir) that in the book Sauron had once again taken form as more than just an eye. However, in the books whenever his presence is felt it is not as a dark figure, but as a red eye. IMO it only makes sense for the filmakers to retain this motif. There are several key points in the story where Sauron exerts his will- in a movie (i.e. visual medium) some image of Sauron MUST be shown. I suppose that it could be argued that the offensive point is not the eye per se, but the holographic eye on the top of the tower. Again, some of the quotes above have the eye in the tower, and there is of course the view that Frodo has of Barad-dûr from Orodruin:
Frodo clambered on to it, and then moved as if by some compulsion he turned slowly to face the East. Far off the shadows of Sauron hung; but torn by some gust of wind out of the world, or else moved by some great disquiet within, the mantling clouds swirled, and for a moment drew aside; and then he saw, rising black, blacker and darker than the vast shades amid which it stood, the cruel pinnacles and iron crown of the topmost tower of Barad-dûr. One moment only it stared out, but as from some great window immeasurably high there stabbed northward a flame of red, the flicker of a piercing Eye; and then the shadows were furled again and the terrible vision was removed. The Eye was not turned to them: it was gazing north to where the Captains of the West stood at bay, and thither all its malice was now bent, as the Power moved to strike its deadly blow; but Frodo at that dreadful glimpse fell as one stricken mortally. His hand sought the chain about his neck.
The 'antennae' in the film are of course the 'cruel pinnacles and iron crown of the topmost tower of Barad-dûr', and personally I prefer to see the Eye on top of the tower rather than staring out of a window.
 
I agree that he is depicted in the books as both an Eye and a Person. One of my thoughts has been that he could switch between forms; he could inhabit his body, or he could leave it and stare out as a spirit alone, taking form as of a great eye, so that he might see better and farther. However, another thought was that Sauron's body, though physically present, is not as solid as it once was; that his body is almost just a shell composed of fire and shadow, such as the Balrogs; not weak, by all means; just not normal. I have pictured him thus as he was in the movie in the prologue, though without the armour, and in his eye sockets flare two piercing eyes, each wreathed in fire, each a penitrating glare. An alternitive to that would be that, as his body might not be completely intact, his head is rather ambiguous, only identifiable by an area of dense shadow, and directly in between where the eyes should be, a single, piercing eye glares out, wreathed in shadow and flame, seeing all that is before him. These are just some conjectures of mine, though all may be untrue. All I do know is that he had a body as the Necromancer of Dol Guldur, and he also needed a finger to put the Ring on when he would find it. Thus, I quote what I have posted on another forum, and the post does, in fact, concern this very thing:

Indeed yes, JS9. However, that does not mean that I wouldn't LOVE to see Sauron fighting Aragorn. I mean, come on! It would be AWESOME!! Imagine the coolness (or hotness because of Sauron's body) of such an Epic battle as that!

Okay, to clear up some discrepencies here...

Sauron had a body (obviously) when he went to Numenor, but he lost it when Eru blew it all to heck. So even though he escaped, his body didn't, and i quote: "After the ruin of his body in the destruction of Numenor, Sauron had the form of a man; his skin was black and burning hot." He then went on to fight in the battle of the Last Alliance, during which he and Gil-galad wrestled, and Gil-galad died from the heat. The Ring contained much of Sauron's power so that he would have that much power over the other Rings, so when the Ring was cut from his hand, the loss of power was so great that Sauron's body was destroyed in the fury. Weakened and without a body, Sauron retreated to the South-East, where he had total dominion over the inhabitants. For the next 1000 years he built up his strength, until he finally had the power to create a body for himself. However, this body was weak and had little physical strength, but rather served Sauron merely as a shell within which he could collect his old strength, and also upon which he could wear the Ring when found. His body was probably so weak that, were it pierced by a weapon, would be destroyed. However, over time, he increased in strength even more and began to grow stronger in body and power. And I quote:

"Some here will remember that many years ago I myself dared to pass the doors of the Necromancer in Dol Guldur, and secretly explored his ways, and found that our fears were true: he was none other than Sauron, our Enemy of old, at length taking shape and power again." - Gandalf.

By the time of the War of the Ring, his power and strength of body was so great that it nearly rivalled himself of old. He was, however, still very weak of spirit without the Ring, though its mere existence empowered him.When he was driven from Dol Guldur, Sauron's physical presence was great, and more than enough to carry him in secret to Mordor. Throughout the LotR, he was reffered to constantly as the 'lidless eye'. This is not without reason, mind you. His body as weak as it was, Sauron could more than easily abandon it, allowing his spirit to be unhindered by the corporeal form, and allowing his spirit to see farther deeper than it otherwise could. The most efficient form in doing this was to become a great and lidless eye. However, a great misconception is that he was a huge eye wreathed in flame sitting on the top of Barad-dur. That was not so. He was located in a high room within the pinnacle of the Barad-dur, a room with one window, which looked out directly upon Orodruin. Within the room was his body which he had long labored to build, the Palantir with which he communicated to his servants, And of course, the nine Rings of the Nazgul. With these Rings he increased yet more in power, and it is likely that he wore one upon each of his nine fingers. For his body was not just a random body being made from scratch. No, because he did not have the power to do that. Rather he was rebuilding his body as it was when he lost the Ring. Therefore he had only nine fingers upon his hand, and conveniently he also had the nine Rings o his servants. It is also known that he had at least a few of the Rings of the Dwarves, and he more than likely drew the power that he had placed into them back out, and used them to increse his strength even more. He did not draw the power from the nine Rings of Men because he would then destroy his precious Nazgul, and besides, he only needed to wear the Rings to have there power.

So picture him thus: His body rebuilt as it was in the Last Alliance, save missing one finger. He had similar armour to what he was wearing before, and, in fact, probably the same helmet. Upon each of his remaining fingers he wore one of the nine rings of men, and in his hands he held his great mace. Through his armour a great stench arose, do to is burning flesh, and his armour was noticeably redder in color than it should be, as a result of the heat. In the sockets of his eyes flared two great eyes, each wreathed in fire, and with such a piercing glance that one mere look could almost drive a mortal man insane. Indeed, the stare contained such heat and power that one under such a glance would feel as if he were on fire. Each step he took was an earthquake, each breath he took was a whirlwind, and each word he spoke was as a bolt of lightning. From within his mouth and nostrals eminates a pale glow, as if each were about to explode in a torrent of fire and death. The aura of his presence was of standing amid a graveyard whose inhabitants rise from their graves and attack you, full of fear and malice of unknown years, of power so immeasurable that one is overwhelmed with a need to smite himself just to end the pain. His every thought seemed to take being, his every whim a command to his servants. To deny would be to endure an eternity of pain and suffering, yet to follow would be the same. Such power of will he had that when his will is bent upon something, that thing crumbled into dust and burst into flame. A blow from his mace meant a surge of suffering and agony greater than any could imagine, a mix of fire and ice and thunder and death unlike any that has ever been known before. To match his will was not possible, rather to try would be certain destruction. None could survive his onslaught, none could withstand his strength and seming omnipotence. When his mace would make contact with a weapon of another, that wheapon would shatter and its wielder be broken. Only a God would have the strength to oppose him, only a God would have the strength to match him. A Hero, perhaps; but only for a short time. To win was not an option. Merely to live was the goal of all who come face to face with his likeness.

Okay, so maybe I got a little carried away with the picture, but you get the point.
I should note that this was all only in theory, and I only stated it as if true for certain because it was easier to right that way.
 
It might end up making the story worse, but we'll just wait and see. The whole idea of Sauron was that he was hardly able to have a physical form, due to the fact that he didn't have the Ring. So fighting Aragorn in full armor will be seriously disturbing. Aragorn and the host of the West were important to distract Sauron, but I don't see why the whole eye buisiness (IMO not too bad from what I've seen so far) should change.
 
I completely agree, all I said was that it would be a cool fight if they had it. Everything else was just me theorizing; just arguing both sides of the case, so to speak.
 
It would be cool to see Sauron take form again but I think PJ should just stick to the storyline in the book.
 
Originally posted by Kahmul
It would be cool to see Sauron take form again but I think PJ should just stick to the storyline in the book.
I fear that you are already two films late on that request.

Now as to Sauron's form: he had regained physical form at the time of LOTR. Gollum notes that he had only "four fingers" on the hand from which Isiludur cut the Ring, so he had to be visible to Gollum and he had to have a physical form that was constant with the form he had possessed before his defeat by the Last Alliance. As to the Eye: this is Sauron's mental projection; it sort of "signifies" and "defines" him. Hence, those who have the Ring see not Sauron's physical form, but his "eye" which is his essence. Of course, he doesn't go round like the beings in that old sci-fi film (The Crawling Eye) but rather, his eye is in fact, the "window to his soul" as it says in the Gospel and is therefore altogether evil and extremely powerful. But you certainly wouldn't see it on the top of Barad dur like some kind of direct TV antenna! It would be merely a "mental" projection perceived by the Ring bearer (and the user of the palantir or Galadriel's mirror) rather than some sort of actual physical presence.

Sauron does not stir from Barad dur. Like the Witch King, he sends his servants before him into battle. He would hardly be found on the field before the Black Gates, especially as that would not be considered a real battle. Remember, in the book that army goes forth knowingly to its death in hopes of providing the Bearer a little more time to fulfill his quest. No one going forth to Mordor believes that he will return alive; it is a sacrificial host. Now, Sauron does not know the real reason for this insignificant group's open assault against him. He believes that Aragorn or even perhaps Gandalf possesses the Ring and in the new Ring Lord's pride, is declaring open war on the old Ring Lord. That being the case, Sauron has no fear of the armies of the upstart nor does he fear the new Lord because he knows it takes time to master the Ring. Therefore, he sends a large force (more than sufficient to destroy the attackers) but wishes to cruelly play with them before he strikes. Doubtless, he also intends to take any possible Ring Lord candidate prisoner (rather than merely killing him) in order to retrieve the Ring. He not only wants to keep it away from his untrustworthy servants but doubtless wishes to torment his adversary - .especially if he turns out to be the heir of hated Isildur. Therefore, Sauron's "fall" (not death as he is a spirit) is portrayed as it is in the book. Of course, what Jackson will do with it cannot even be guessed.
 
Originally posted by mirkwoodwarrior
Even though I would love to see Sauron in a physical form, I think PJ should just stick to the book.
You're too late! Frankly, if Tolkien's most exciting parts of the book are not exciting enough for Mr. Jackson and he has to "invent" warg riders etc., then you may be sure that Tolkien's more subdued climaxes (Gollum's accidental fall into the Fire and Sauron's shadow departure) will not be enough either. Unfortunately, the fellow seems to feel the need to constantly beat his audience over the head with things lest we be too stupid to understand the point being made. So I will predict that the climax/ending of the films will be very much a "Jacksonian" rather than a Tolkien one. Takers, anyone?
 
I said that I think PJ should stick to the book, not that he would. I agree with you though, Mrs. Maggot.
He probably will make up his own ending to the film as can be expected(in my opinion). I do think that PJ will probably mess with the whole storyline more than in the other two.
 
Well, of course, he can hardly revert to that from which he departed at the beginning of the first film! That's why with each subsequent film, the deviations become more obvious and numerous; Jackson has to "fill in the gaps" in the "story" he has created and hung upon the bones of Tolkien's tale. It took Tolkien decades to fill in the holes and smooth out the bumps of his very involved and complex story. Jackson believed (foolishly) that he could come along and tinker here and there and the consequences would be miniscule - or, rather, that they would lead to a better, more exciting story! Wrong! And now he has to go around and try to capture every loose thread of plot and characterization. That's what messed up TTT (among other things) and I cannot possibly see how that same unravelling process is not going to continue in ROTK! It is my guess that Jackson hopes that the visuals and the huge battle sequences will keep everyone's mind off whether or not the story makes sense!
 
aragil, what I had meant by my statement was that I hardly think that Sauron had rigged up an electrical system of a couple of antennae and produced a digitally enhanced holographic image of a huge Eye on top of a tower!! :rolleyes:
I am, obviously, aware that Sauron took the form of a fiery eye; but it has long been my own deductive observationary opinion that this Eye was only seen in the minds of those who beheld Sauron in their thought, or through some 'magical' artefact (e.g. the Ring, Galadriel's Mirror). I do not for a second believe that Tolkien intended for there to actually be a blazing Eye atop Barad-dûr in physical reality; it is a phantom created by Sauron to strike fear into, well, everybody. It is not, I believe, an image of himself but rather a frightening representation of his Valinorean stature as a Maia.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top