H
Originally posted by Harad
No, Aragorn would have stayed as Chieftain of the North. That was his duty and he was a noble man. He would not abandon his duty to wrest the Kingship of Gondor. He would continue as his ancestors did for 800 years. He would not disrput needlessly the 1000-yr stable government of Gondor. Either his love for Arwen would be unrequited or they would wed despite Elrond.
This all changed with the finding of the Ring and the War of the Ring. Even then, Aragorn would not wrest the Kingship of Gondor. He would win it by deeds. In the absence of the War, in the absence of those deeds, the noble Aragorn would never have become King of Gondor.
Originally posted by greypilgrim
Anyone notice Aragorn's sword after they all left Rivendell?
It doesn't look like...it is not Narsil, the sword that was re-forged.
Why? It should have been re-forged again in Rivendell. Why has Peter Jackson CHANGED the story like that? And in all the other ways he has altered it? He has changed this story too much, it is not the original.
At first, I was pumped about the movie.
After 4 times seeing it, I think is is a joke.
Not very funny, though.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?