AaronAzrael
Æon
- Joined
- Dec 28, 2020
- Messages
- 211
How does the Gift of Mortality shape the purpose and meaning of life for Men in The Silmarillion, and in what ways does this contrast with the Elves’ immortality, particularly in terms of freedom, suffering, and destiny?
What's its advantage and deep hidden meaning - of the gift of men?
Try to decipher the prophecy hahaha
"But the gift of death that you [Men] have been given is not a curse. It is a gift, a gift that will take you out of the world and return you to Eru. For you were made to be free, to go forth into the unknown, and to seek the undying lands. And for this gift, the Elves have no part."
Brainstorm ideas:
1. In what ways does mortality give Men a sense of freedom that immortality doesn't provide to the Elves?
2. How does the knowledge of death influence the choices and actions of Men in The Silmarillion?
3. Why is mortality considered a "gift" in contrast to the Elves’ unending life?
4. How does the concept of suffering differ between the immortal Elves and the mortal Men?
5. What role does destiny play in the lives of Men compared to the Elves, given their differing fates?
What's its advantage and deep hidden meaning - of the gift of men?
Try to decipher the prophecy hahaha
"But the gift of death that you [Men] have been given is not a curse. It is a gift, a gift that will take you out of the world and return you to Eru. For you were made to be free, to go forth into the unknown, and to seek the undying lands. And for this gift, the Elves have no part."
Brainstorm ideas:
1. In what ways does mortality give Men a sense of freedom that immortality doesn't provide to the Elves?
2. How does the knowledge of death influence the choices and actions of Men in The Silmarillion?
3. Why is mortality considered a "gift" in contrast to the Elves’ unending life?
4. How does the concept of suffering differ between the immortal Elves and the mortal Men?
5. What role does destiny play in the lives of Men compared to the Elves, given their differing fates?
