Prince of Cats
Among the Trees
- Joined
- Nov 27, 2007
- Messages
- 786
I thought he was still the eldest after Thorin
I know I don't have the book knowledge that I used to, and that even back then it was inferior to many or most here. But I read and reread (and reread) The Hobbit in my childhood and onward, and I cannot shake the fact that this move "feels" like The Hobbit to me, in a way that none of the LotR movies did. So much of the little stuff that made an impression on me as a child reading the novel was brought back to my memory watching this movie that I walked out smiling more than I have in quite a while. I can't wait to see what's coming next.
Thorin wasn't even in Erebor during Smaug's attack and he wasn't the one that fought and defeated Azog. Thorin in the movie is a completely different character than the one in the book. So it's no surprise that Balin or any of the other dwarves are completely different characters.
We see in Lord of the Rings the tomb of Balin in Moria. Balin was the second oldest in the Erebor company but still a couple decades younger than Thorin. He seems much more elderly in this movie. It would be weird that this old dwarf who readily questioned the need to even try to retake Erebor, as portrayed in PJ's Hobbit, is the one that took off after the Erebor quest to try and reclaim Moria.
5.) What else am I missing?
Finally, I have a note to add:
How is PJ going to address Azog in the upcoming movies ? We all know that Azog was slain in the Battle of Azanulbizar by Dain. In the Battle of Five armies scene, we see Dain and his host come to the aid of Thorin.
THE QUESTION IS : Would PJ let Dain kill Azog as mentioned in the book (not entirely accurate in the context of timeline, but still... ) OR would he let Thorin have his revenge and kill Azog himself ?
This whole situation is messed up... thoughts?
As far as I read Bolg was the orc heavily draped with fur-mats at Azanulbizar. It would be thrilling to see an orcish family-relationship. If Bolg still is Azog's son, what about his mother? Or do orcs spawn somehow? And I wonder what orc-children would look like. Anyway, the goblin scribe is also meant to be a son of the Goblin King.
It really does not make a lot of sense. Somewhere in creating the Hobbit Tolkien must have thought of the orcs as more than just evil faces, individuals with relations and history. In The Lord of the Rings this was surely abandoned. The only hint at them being more than moving mass-weapon is Gandalf, I think, mentioning they will travel far if they have a captain to avenge.
Eggs? Cloning?
Humans are currently perverting the human way to multiply. I trust Morgoth to work a much more massive change to the natural process intended by Illuvatar.
star wars?????? sorry, don,t get the joke.
orcs do not 'come from' men or elves at least not evolutionary. they were evolved by Melkor and we simply do not know how or to what degree he corrupted them. fact is that in The Hobbit Tolkien introduces Bolg son of Azog - Bolg is in the movie, btw - and grants the goblins finer feelings, likes and dislikes, while in The Lord of the Rings he does not, although he mentions orcs by name there. if an orc has a son thee is a hint at family ties, that's all. Tolkien did not pursue that motive any further though. even a son does not necessarily mean that orcs multiply the same way men and elves do. an argumentum ex nihilo - he didn't say it wasn't therefore it was - isn't helpful.
And, there is no 'evolution' in Tolkien's world. Not even a 'theory' like our's.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?