The Never Asked Question

[Manveru]

maybe it's one of those never answered questions...?

 

[Gil-Galad]

Does anybody have a suggestion??

Does anybody have an idea or a theory???

 

[Manveru]

apart from silly (unserious) ones... nope

 

[Eriol]

They rode on Oromë's horse. It seems a reasonable theory to me. How would Oromë go from Valinor to Middle-Earth, after all?

That horse was a very good horse .

 

[Gil-Galad]

I didn't know that a definition of " a very good horse" was "flying horse" or "horse with wings".

And what is more how did three elves managed to ride with Orome.Four persons riding a horse?It should be very big one

 

[Starflower]

they may have indeed walked, as they were only just recently awakened, thus were in the prime of their strenght and endurance... we do not know how long the journey took.. maybe Orome summoned other horses for the three elves?

 

[Gil-Galad]

maybe Orome summoned other horses for the three elves?

Hmmhmm that seems possible answer to me.

 

[Morgoth]

Ok, this is mainly because I dont know Quenya, but what does Valaraukar mean in the common tongue?

 

[Morgoth]

Ok, from a bit of botching together with help from the appendices in The Silmarillion, I got it down to 'power demon'. Panic over

*********
EDIT- Or as the case may be 'Demon of Might', which I could've just found out from looking up the definition of Valaraukar in the appendix. Duh.

 

[Lhunithiliel]

Ok, from a bit of botching together with help from the appendices in The Silmarillion, I got it down to 'power demon'. Panic over

*********
EDIT- Or as the case may be 'Demon of Might', which I could've just found out from looking up the definition of Valaraukar in the appendix. Duh.

It happens to me sometimes, too. I "panic" and rush to ask...

But on the other hand, it's good to know what's been "troubling" our minds. Thus we learn more, right?

 

[Maedhros]

But on the other hand, it's good to know what's been "troubling" our minds. Thus we learn more, right?

That we do. Greetings my dear Lhun. A blast from the past.

 

[Lhunithiliel]

That we do. Greetings my dear Lhun. A blast from the past.

My sonny !!!
Oh, ... it could be a present again, my friend! It can be!!
I've returned ... Master Grond has come out of the underworld ... Why don't you, too?

Don't you think it'd be wonderful?

 

[Grond]

Maedhros, I'm picking on Feanor in the most horrible way in the Silmarillion forum. You better get over there and set me straight. The thread is the poll thread on who was the rightful king. If Feanor is to win, you'll need to vote in a hurry. You know that I voted for my boy, Fingolfin.

Cheers,

grond

 

[Maedhros]

My sonny !!!
Oh, ... it could be a present again, my friend! It can be!!
I've returned ... Master Grond has come out of the underworld ... Why don't you, too?

Jeje. Grond has to come out of the underworld, after all his master is from there.

Maedhros, I'm picking on Feanor in the most horrible way in the Silmarillion forum. You better get over there and set me straight. The thread is the poll thread on who was the rightful king. If Feanor is to win, you'll need to vote in a hurry. You know that I voted for my boy, Fingolfin.

You never learn do you. Arguing about Fëanor in the Sil Forum would seem like the good ole days, but alas those are gone and the reason that I left is still there.

It was good to exchange post nevertheless.

 

[Lhunithiliel]

Jeje. Grond has to come out of the underworld, after all his master is from there.

You never learn do you. Arguing about Fëanor in the Sil Forum would seem like the good ole days, but alas those are gone and the reason that I left is still there.

Sonny, whatever that reason might be, I am sure it is not within the community of the Guild. Right?
So, I think that it will be wonderful to have you and your valuable knowledge shared with us and here, too.

 

[Maedhros]

Sonny, whatever that reason might be, I am sure it is not within the community of the Guild. Right?
So, I think that it will be wonderful to have you and your valuable knowledge shared with us and here, too.

Only if you make me guilmaster emeritus. Jeje

I posted in there for ole times sake.

 

[Lhunithiliel]

Only if you make me guilmaster emeritus. Jeje

I posted in there for ole times sake.

All right, Community of the GoT, here is a Never-asked Question for you all:

Shall Maedhros be a GuldMaster Emeritus of the GoT?

 

[Manveru]

completely lost in the thickets of this "event" but having no objections

 

[Lhunithiliel]

A new question

Why were there Hobbits of different welfare?

Reading about their community and about the arrangement of the Shire, the social, economy and political life in it, one would expect all of the Hobbits to be more or less equal.
Yet, there were wealthier and poorer Hobbits; there were masters and servants ... or at least Hobbits who worked for other Hobbits (not as slaves of course! )

I am waiting with interest to read some info about this in that "Ecoonomy of ME"- project of Gil-Galad!
But meanwhile ...
Thoughts?

 

[Barliman Butterbur]

As far as I know, Balrogs had wings, but didn't fly — like ostriches or kiwis. What was the problem?

Barley