• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Return of the King Reviews Thread

What did you think of RotK?

  • I am completely speechless due to its glory

    Votes: 54 37.2%
  • Extremely Impressive

    Votes: 48 33.1%
  • Great movie

    Votes: 23 15.9%
  • Alright, but not the best movie I've seen

    Votes: 14 9.7%
  • Boring

    Votes: 1 0.7%
  • Complete waste of my time and money

    Votes: 5 3.4%

  • Total voters
    145
chrischarlton said:
I would prefer the best not second best, rather than have it compromised by the profit aspect. Their justifications are really only that.........their motives on the other appear to profit driven rather than quality driven.
Is your opinion of 'poorer' universal?

If their motives were purely profit-driven, why didn't they release a two-hour version of all three movies, thus allowing more showings per day?

If a longer version is necessarily better, then why do so many people complain about the extra 20 minutes in RotK?

Is it even remotely possible (IYO) that the majority of the people prefer to sit through a shorter version?

Has it occurred to you that if Lotho didn't want to pay money for the EE, he could have just rented it?
 
aragil said:
Has it occurred to you that if Lotho didn't want to pay money for the EE, he could have just rented it?
But....then he'd still be paying money for it.

He could borrow it from a friend...but then the friend would be paying money for it...Or the friend could borrow it from a friend, so that the friend of the friend would be paying money for it, but the friend wouldn't be paying money and Lotho wouldn't be paying money, unless they broke it and had to buy a new one, or someone could give it to Lotho as a gift, only then that person would be paying money, or Lotho could get it as a gift in a secret exchange, so that a person would still be paying money for it, only Lotho wouldn't know who the person was, so Lotho would be unconnected to the source of the paying of the money and still get to see the EE.
 
I believe that my point was that if Lotho did not want to pay more than $7 for the TTEE, then he probably wouldn't have bought the EE- he would have rented it, or borrowed it from friend Sharkey, or been gifted it by Momma Lobelia, or slipped it from under Pappa Otho's Pillow, or any other manner of acquisition.

What it sounded like to me is that chrischarlton was saying that New Line was unfairly extorting money from Lord of the Rings fans. I think it sort of undermines this point when the fans are willingly paying more than they have to- presumably because they enjoy the product.

Is there something surprising about the fact that money needs to change hands before Lotho can see the film?

{I hope Lotho doesn't mind all these ridiculous examples in his name}
 
I point was that I didn't have a point. I was taking the opportunity to amuse myself It occured to me that I was taking myself too seriously, so I got a prescription to watch two Monty Pythons and call myself in the morning.
 
aragil said:
If their motives were purely profit-driven, why didn't they release a two-hour version of all three movies, thus allowing more showings per day?

Don't you think that would have been a consideration if the storyline flowed logically and made sense over 2 hours? I think the answer to that is: absolutely.

New Line have made an obscene amount of money from these movies. Enough was made from the first and second that could have covered losses if the third was a complete flop. And the hype has been also been incredible.

When my wife and I go to the movies we tend to try and make a night of it. Dinner, movie, drinks. That sort of thing. So I don't appreciate continuity flaws (the Eowyn/Faramir look) and rushed sequences (the Last Debate and jump to the Black Gate) in an effort to keep within time limits. And when I see fundamental flaws such as these, knowing full well that an extended edition will tie up loose ends and expand the rushed sequences, I get little annoyed.

The cinema released movies have flaws. Don't get so wrapped up in seeing LOTR come to life on the big screen that you lose your objectivity.

aragil said:
If a longer version is necessarily better, then why do so many people complain about the extra 20 minutes in RotK?

You know, I've asked that question of several people who haven't read the book. Their complaint is the ending (at the havens) and that it drags on.

If 20 mins in the middle of the movie had dragged but the end was fast paced, not nearly as many people would have thought it too long.
 
Last edited:
chrischarlton said:
If 20 mins in the middle of the movie had dragged but the end fast paced, not as many people would have thought it too long.
Based on the races to the restrooms I have witnessed everytime I saw the film, I disagree.
 

This is something that chafes me as well. When I finally saw the TT EE, I was pleasantly surprised with the additions, but they all seemed so INTEGRAL to the story, why were they left out in favor of expanding Helm's Deep to 1/3 of the movie and adding stupid warg riders? Faramir is uncomprehendable without the EE...his and Boromir's scene is so important, I'm mystified why this was ever left out to begin with.
 
Ummm, a fast-paced ending would be horrible....

Greenwood said:
Based on the races to the restrooms I have witnessed everytime I saw the film, I disagree.

Good lord I hate those! The second time I saw it, me and my little brother had to go so bad; we broke all speed records (and limits) on the way there and back. The worst part is 'going,' though, it feels like you're in the restrooms for an hour...
 
chrischarlton said:
hehe.............I miss intermission.
So do I! And not just because of restroom breaks. I have a bad knee and sitting in a cramped theater seat for three hours causes severe pain. I have yet to see any of the three films in a theater without being in excrutiating pain by the end of the film.

As for the restroom issue, I try to drink nothing before the film. One reason the studios are reluctant to release long films is that the theaters don't like them. It is not just because longer films have fewer show times during the day. It is also because they cut down on concession stand sales. THe film theaters actually make a larger percentage of their profits from their concession stands than they do from the ticket sales.
 
I have my "break" timed with a least favorite part of each movie...
FOTR Arwen and Aragorn proclaiming their love

TTT warg riders, or actually anytime during the Deep of Helm

ROTK lembas

so actually, as many times as i've seen the movies, I've magaged to see these scenes only a few times
 
chrischarlton said:
So basically you've gone and spent more money (as have I) either hiring or buying the EE version of TTT. And you've found the EE version better.

Yep, sure did, more than I ever expected to!!! And in my renaissant LOTR madness (starting when these films came into theaters) I bought the EEs, plus the big LOTR book with the +/-50 Alan Lee watercolors (which I don't like, I think Lee's painting's colors are insipidly weak, and the book is too damned heavy to read comfortably without a bookstand), and eventually the Gandalf/Bilbo bookends bundled with a really cheap 3-in-1 LOTRbook. I bought most of the Houghton Mifflin movie books too. My little "Tolkien corner" now occupies almost an entire bookshelf! But what the hey... And I know that I will shell out even more buckolas when the theatrical and the subsequent extended versions duly come to DVD...*sigh* (God save us from what we might find as the final Easter eggs thereon...)

So as I said originally why not release the EE edition if it is fundamentally better? Instead they released a movie that was second best.

I wish I knew their motives. They were probably mostly New Line's and mainly financial. And somebody had an eye to the big "side businesses" of badges, statuary, books, pins, etc.

Previously I mentioned that three hours was probably max for an audience's willingness to sit without heading to the head, and possibly because of present technological limits: You can get a 3-hour movie on one side of a DVD, but anything more calls for two of them.

I just take all of this foofaraw as it comes. I'm being fleeced, I know it, and I spend the money anyway.

Lotho
 

Certainly sorry to hear about that! Can you sit on the end of a row, so you can stretch out? (If you're like me however, you get in the house early enough so that you can sit in the dead center of the screen.)


Speaking of all the above, a really canny entrepreneur would have set up a catheter rental (or at least bedpan or bedbottle) concession! Hee hee!

Lotho
 
Lotho_Pimple said:
Speaking of all the above, a really canny entrepreneur would have set up a catheter rental (or at least bedpan or bedbottle) concession! Hee hee!
Well, my wife says really canny theater owners would push for the revival of the intermission so that they could sell stuff during the break and people would not be avoiding buying sodas before the movie. I suppose alll they really see though is the idea that the more showings they can have during the day the more people they can get in the theater to buy stuff at the concession stands.
 

We have a small number of indepedant movie houses here in Melbourne Australia that have retained the intermission. But by the time they get their hands on blockbusters the extended editions are out for sale on DVD.

During summer Melbourne Botanical Gardens have an outdoor theatre. No need for intermission, just go in the bushes, there's plenty of them about.
 
chrischarlton said:
During summer Melbourne Botanical Gardens have an outdoor theatre. No need for intermission, just go in the bushes, there's plenty of them about.

So that's why they call it the "outback"... Who cleans up?

Lotho
 
Wow I am like the only one here who is in the middle. I didn't hate it but I didn't die when I saw it.
It was flawed and my friends and I talk about how if we had everything PJ had we could have directed the last movie better.
He can keep the first two but the last one I should have directed. LOL
You guys are all bringing up really good points here.
 
I'm completely speechless due to it's glory. No movie is perfect but this one comes close!
And I think I like the movie even more as my admiration towards Tolkien grows. As well as many actors of the movies.

LotR is THE movie trilogy of this decade.
 
Length

As to why scenes were left out of the theatrical release and then put in for the EE, listen to Jacksons commentary next time you watch the DVD.
 
Last edited:
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…