• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Return of the King Reviews Thread

What did you think of RotK?

  • I am completely speechless due to its glory

    Votes: 54 37.2%
  • Extremely Impressive

    Votes: 48 33.1%
  • Great movie

    Votes: 23 15.9%
  • Alright, but not the best movie I've seen

    Votes: 14 9.7%
  • Boring

    Votes: 1 0.7%
  • Complete waste of my time and money

    Votes: 5 3.4%

  • Total voters
    145
Pippin/Frodo said:
Sorry Rhi, but I must beg to differ, I thought he was ruggedky handsome in the first to and Kingly handsome in the last one.

Do the looks of a guy really make the character (well, maybe, but I can't tell if he's handsome or not)?
I thought Viggo played a great Aragorn and an alright (King) Elessar. I dunno, he just wasn't "kingly" enough. Maybe, if he had Andruil through most of the story like he should've...... :rolleyes::D
 
So maybe I'm just against a lot of facial hair. I really can't put my finger on why I didn't like him in the third film, when I thought he was so wonderful in the first two. I just wasn't drawn to his character and didn't enjoy his performance as an actor. My response was 'blah'.

David Wenham, now...
 
Rhiannon said:
So maybe I'm just against a lot of facial hair. I really can't put my finger on why I didn't like him in the third film, when I thought he was so wonderful in the first two. I just wasn't drawn to his character and didn't enjoy his performance as an actor. My response was 'blah'.

David Wenham, now...

Remind me, Is he Eomer or Fairamir?

I liked both of them.
 
Pippin/Frodo said:
Remind me, Is he Eomer or Fairamir?

I liked both of them.

Faramir. The guy that played Eomer actually looks a lot like my brother (or did in the cast interviews). It was scary :eek:
 
Did anyone notce that in the final battle in front of the gates, they are on horseback( as they should be) and then they CHARGE on foot? Where did the horses go folks?
The other thing is that the battle of pelennor is climaxed when Aragorn's ship arrives, unfurls banner and he and Eomer meet in the battlefield. But the movie doesn't build to this , doesn't show that everyone really thought Aragorn was dead until he shows up in triumph. The movie shows the dead disposing of the orc army and switches directly to planning a diversion at the black gate.
But considering the enormity of the project, PJ did a wonderful job. Alot of detail was given to clothing, arms,edoras,bag end, and minas tirith, but other parts were rushed. I felt they tried too hard attimes to make 'drama' and to get the audience to care about the people instead of letting the story tell itself . I hope this brings more attention to New Zealand , now I want to go there.
 
emeldir said:
The other thing is that the battle of pelennor is climaxed when Aragorn's ship arrives, unfurls banner and he and Eomer meet in the battlefield. But the movie doesn't build to this , doesn't show that everyone really thought Aragorn was dead until he shows up in triumph. The movie shows the dead disposing of the orc army and switches directly to planning a diversion at the black gate.

Yeah, the Dead arriving and basically taking care of the entire battle did kill the climax of the battle.
What would have been nice was Aragorn and co. jumping outta the Corsair ships with a few thousand Gondorian soldiers (thus showing the true might and valor of Gondor), making the great and amazing battle last longer and seeing Legolas, Gimli, Aragorn + Gondorians and Rohirrim + Éomer really kicking butt.
Because, if you think about it, you only see a hundred or less Gondorians blocking and ready to fight the Orcs and Trolls. These must be the last of Gondors soldiers since none could have survived anywhere else in the City.
Then at the Black Gate we see a few thousand Gondor troops, so where did they come from?

And no Easterlings! Arrrrgh.....
 
This is the best movie I have ever seen. What a great film!!!! Well I know the EE will be even better I can hardly wait for it. The best part of the movie for me was when Gandalf used his magic(White Light). In the EE there will be a Gandalf vs. Witch King thing. *Possible Dumb Spoiler* It is rumored that The WK will break Gandalf's staff. I pray that will not happen mainly because it never happened.

10.0 I give this film nothing will ever top this well ok maybe tie :p
 
ROTK Review

Visually - extremely impressive
Special Effects - extremely impressive
Music Score - Good
Acting - Very Good
Editing - Average

Did it live up to expectations?
It was close.

I wanted to see the Houses of Healing, Parley at the Black Gates, Parley at Orthanc, Parley at the gates of Minas Tirith between Gandalf and the Whitchking, and of course the Scouring of the Shire.

I also wanted to see Theodan ride through the Southron cavalry, and characters such as Prince Imrahil come to life.

I thought it silly that Pippin light the beacons.

The Last Debate was utterly pathetic.

I didn't like the defenses of Minas Tirith being on the brink of colapse when Aragorn arrives. In the book I thought it was important (and seemd natural) that Minas Tirith go on the offensive when the Riders of Rohan come, when the attention of the Nazgul is elsewhere.

The Aragorn / Arwen love story throughout the movies was poorly portrayed. Lets face it there wasn't much to draw from in the book.

Finally, the character I've disliked the most throughout all the movies is Elrond - Why a 3000 odd year old half man half elf, renouned for his wisdom, has a problem with men being weak (considering his brother, and father were men) is beyond me. Peter Jackson you lost the plot on that one.
 
chrischarlton said:
Finally, the character I've disliked the most throughout all the movies is Elrond - Why a 3000 odd year old half man half elf, renouned for his wisdom, has a problem with men being weak (considering his brother, and father were men) is beyond me. Peter Jackson you lost the plot on that one.
Didn't you know? Elrond thinks hobbits are a virus.
 
emeldir said:
The movie shows the dead disposing of the orc army and switches directly to planning a diversion at the black gate.


Thats poor editing. The Last Debate scene (I wont call it a sequence, it was too short for that), was to put it simply ridiculous.
 
??? Where was the Ramas ???

I don't remember seeing the Ramas Echor in the movie.

Was it there?

And if it wasn't, why take it out?
 
chrischarlton said:
I don't remember seeing the Ramas Echor in the movie.

Was it there?

And if it wasn't, why take it out?

I believe that the entire defense outside the city was reduced to Osgiliath. Why? I dunno for certain- it is certainly easier to focus the action in a single city (even if it was a big city) than to have it spread around the entire wall.

chrischarlton said:
Finally, the character I've disliked the most throughout all the movies is Elrond - Why a 3000 odd year old half man half elf, renouned for his wisdom, has a problem with men being weak (considering his brother, and father were men) is beyond me. Peter Jackson you lost the plot on that one.
Actually, in the movies I don't believe Elrond is ever referred to as 'half'-elven, nor is there any relationship implied between Elrond and Aragorn (nor is Elros mentioned)! I believe that for all intents and purposes, Elrond in the movie is full-Elven.
Why the problem with men? My guess is that he is supposed to be slightly upset that Men (in the form of Isildur) did not destroy the Ring after the Last Alliance, thus inflicting Sauron upon Middle-earth for another 3,000 years. I believe Elrond in the books was somewhat upset about that matter, too.
 
aragil said:
I believe that the entire defense outside the city was reduced to Osgiliath. Why? I dunno for certain- it is certainly easier to focus the action in a single city (even if it was a big city) than to have it spread around the entire wall.

But they did include a rather high bank, which the riders formed up upon.

aragil said:
Actually, in the movies I don't believe Elrond is ever referred to as 'half'-elven, nor is there any relationship implied between Elrond and Aragorn (nor is Elros mentioned)! I believe that for all intents and purposes, Elrond in the movie is full-Elven.
Why the problem with men? My guess is that he is supposed to be slightly upset that Men (in the form of Isildur) did not destroy the Ring after the Last Alliance, thus inflicting Sauron upon Middle-earth for another 3,000 years. I believe Elrond in the books was somewhat upset about that matter, too.

I think Elrond was referred to as half elven at some stage (although I cannot remember when). And my opinion of Elrond in the movie did not involve Aragorn's kinship with him.

Furthermore any angst Elrond (from the book) may have felt in relation to what Isildur failed to do was directed at Isildur and the ring, not men in general.
My impression from the book was Elrond had an understanding of the capacity of men in general but certainly felt no anger or thought pooly of them. I simply felt the movie portrayed Elrond as bitter and angry. And for someone who headed up a council of the wise, who's had quite a long time to get over the Isildur incident, those emotions didn't fit right.
Again I say Peter Jackson lost the plot and tried to create something from nothing.
 
I thought that they did a pretty good job of sticking to the book, with some discrepancies, like the Houses of Healing and the Scouring of the Shire. One thing that I didn't like was Faramir being dragged to Minas Tirith by his horse. In the book, Gandalf went out and rescued him. I wanted to see that and I wanted to the sequence where Aragorn healed Eowyn and Merry. I also wanted to see the guard that helps Pippin when he first starts as a guard in Minas Tirith. Oh well. I still think that they did a good job.
 
King Aragorn said:
...some discrepancies, like the Houses of Healing and the Scouring of the Shire....

....In the book, Gandalf went out and rescued him. I wanted to see that and I wanted to the sequence where Aragorn healed Eowyn and Merry....

The Houses of Healing scenes will be included in the RotK:EE. I can't wait!

Gandalf did rescue Faramir and men at one point during the movie, as they ride back to Minas Tirith and are under attack by the Nazgul.
 

Today's events

Back
Top