chrischarlton said:
So basically you've gone and spent more money (as have I) either hiring or buying the EE version of TTT. And you've found the EE version better.
Yep, sure did, more than I ever expected to!!! And in my renaissant LOTR madness (starting when these films came into theaters) I bought the EEs, plus the big LOTR book with the +/-50 Alan Lee watercolors (which I don't like, I think Lee's painting's colors are insipidly weak, and the book is too damned heavy to read comfortably without a bookstand), and eventually the
Gandalf/
Bilbo bookends bundled with a really cheap 3-in-1 LOTRbook. I bought most of the Houghton Mifflin movie
books too. My little "
Tolkien corner" now occupies almost an entire bookshelf! But what the hey...

And I know that I will shell out even more buckolas when the theatrical and the subsequent extended versions duly come to DVD...*sigh* (
God save us from what we might find as the final Easter eggs thereon...)
So as I said originally why not release the EE edition if it is fundamentally better? Instead they released a movie that was second best.
I wish I knew their motives. They were probably mostly New Line's and mainly financial. And somebody had an eye to the big "side businesses" of badges, statuary, books, pins, etc.
Previously I mentioned that three hours was probably max for an audience's willingness to sit without heading to the head, and possibly because of present technological limits: You can get a 3-hour movie on one side of a DVD, but anything more calls for two of them.
I just take all of this foofaraw as it comes. I'm being fleeced, I know it, and I spend the money anyway.
Lotho