• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Return of the King Reviews Thread

What did you think of RotK?

  • I am completely speechless due to its glory

    Votes: 54 37.2%
  • Extremely Impressive

    Votes: 48 33.1%
  • Great movie

    Votes: 23 15.9%
  • Alright, but not the best movie I've seen

    Votes: 14 9.7%
  • Boring

    Votes: 1 0.7%
  • Complete waste of my time and money

    Votes: 5 3.4%

  • Total voters
    145
I really love the movie. I just wish they would have left a bit more in. Some of it left me confused and kind of "did I miss something?" I wish they would have put the house of healing it a little. I was a bit confused when Merry was on the battle field and hurt and then the next time I see him he is riding off to battle. What happened to Saurman? He could have left a bit more in on that part right? And there was nothing concerning Eowyn and Faramir's love.
One other thing I found kind of wierd was when Pippen looked into the pl---- thing that I can't spell and he started going crazy around the room. I expected him to shake or something but not that.
Anyway, just what I think. Can't wait to see the EE. So long to wait. (Wonder how long w/ all the extras it'll be?!)
 
Hey RHI, I just found something that could have made ROTK worse:


In the words of Keanu Reeves, "Woah."

Just imagine how much worse it would have been if that wooden indian disguised as an actor had been in ROTK.....
 
To all those who hate or dislike the movie: In all seriousness I am very sorry you didn't enjoy it. Although I do not understand how you could feel this way, I respect your views and hope, perhaps, that you will like the EE better.

Knowing how brilliant I find it without the EE and with the minor gaps, I simply cannot wait to get my hands on a copy of the aforesaid EE. It will totally rock.

Mirkwoodwarrior: All of the things you speak of will be in the EE!

I nearly got my mom to take me back today, but she held out. This weekend, though. Cannot wait!
 
Good but has it's faults

I thought I will post my opinion before I read all the others.

The movie is great. It went off in a very nice pace (except the ending!). I loved the Eyown and Witchking scene, Eyown picking up Merry scene, all of Pippin's scenes and Faramir's. I also liked Frodo and Sam's thread.

What I didn't like:

1. Arwen's scenes: I don't know why PJ added this twist of Arwen going to Grey Havens in the first place. Arwen's comeback is totally silly.

2. Ending: Ending could have been better compressed. The camera lingers on the crying hobbits too long. And I am sure people who didn't read the books would have got completely lost on why Frodo and Co. are going on a ship and where. A word or two about why this is important would have helped.

3. Coming of the Dead: Dead come too fast and everything seems to be over in few seconds. And there are no survivors left on the field after that. What happened to all those Rohanovians??? Did the dead kill both the friend and foe??

4. Cirith Ungol: Sam killing 3 orcs single handedly is little unbelievable.

5. Aragorn and Arwen: There should have been a giving of hand of Arwen by Elrond in a real cermonic way rather than Aragorn just running, jumping and kissing... It should have been more kingly.

6. Gadndalf's white light is a little cheesy and why couldn't he do that again in the battle?
 
Wow! Some of you make us purists FADs!

There were many things that bothered me, and a few things that did make my skin crawl, but it stayed much more true to Tolkien, it didn't have continual cheesy dialogue, and it gave way more depth and emotion to both character and plot than the other two theatre versions put together. For that at least I can be thankful, even as a purist.With the other two, we were subjected to nonsense after nonsense. With this, a bit of nonsense, then it returned to the book. Much easier on the purist heart. Now TTT? Well, hoom-hom.....

Lighten up some of you! Quite a bit of your comments are not purist-should-have-been-more-like-the-book, but plain old NPW. I can't see how anyone can truly find favor of the other two movies over this one (from a purist perspective and as an adaptation). It was a better movie and adaptation overall.

There was too much missing, no doubt, but hopefully it will be on the DVD. Nonetheless, the editing and flow was heads above the dreck called TTT.

And no, I'm not turning FAD!!
 
I know if I had someone in the theatre yelling "Where's my contact?" at the eye of Sauron, there would be a cup full of coke coming in that direction. I despise when people feel so righteous that they have to ruin the experience for everyone else.
 
Re: Good but has it's faults

Go Thorin! A true FAD at heart!

Originally posted by GoldenWood
6. Gadndalf's white light is a little cheesy and why couldn't he do that again in the battle?

I don't know, perhaps you should ask Tolkien...

FAD stands for 'Film Adaptation Defender.'

A cup-full of Coke, some choice words (of the four-letter variety) and maybe a meeting after it's over. Show some maturity and don't ruin other's enjoyment...
 
Go ahead my sister!


I thought it was ok, not too disappointed because I had no real expectations.

THINGS I DID NOT LIKE
So what about Gandalf taking orders from Aragorn about the plan to storm the Black Gate and asking dumb A about Frodo and Sam? Umm....I think falling through fire and returning from the dead make G a little more knowledgable, especially when A can't even figure out what to do with his girlfriend.

Denethor was riduculous. We were hit over the head with the 'glutton' thing, one tomato would have been plenty. Why exactly did he leap off the pyre when he was engulfed in flames?
I think I'll be waiting for an answer to THAT one until the elves return to ME.

Rhi, glad someone else thought the elephants were tooStar Wars for words. Basically a les cool version of Luke with the Ad Ats (or whatever those things were called). What about Theoden's death speech...E: "I'm going to save you", T: "You already have". Is PJ hoping no one remembers Return of the Jedi?

Legolas on the Elephant? No, absolutely not. We've gone from one of the greatest action shots of all time in FOTR (Legolas shooting arrow after arrow at the orcs, even using one to stab an orc and then shoot it) to the skateboard move in TTT, to the surfboard move off the elephant's snout. He walks lightly upon the earth, but he can't defy gravity! He can't walk up walls (or elephants).

All I can say is that the EE BETTER include E and F. Leaving her on the field and then having her smile next to F is right up there with leaving Saruman hanging around in Orthanc.

There would have been plenty of time if PJ had left out THE WORST SCENE IN THE MOVIE, Frodo teling Sam to go home. I defy anyone to explain it away. Frodo trusting Gollum over Sam? Never, never, never. Their friendship is the bond that holds LOTR together. Could you ever imagine a reality when you would choose someone you were repulsed by but pitied over your closest friend who has sacrificed their life to help you (and gives you all the food and water)? Does Frodo think Sam is going to call a taxi from Mordor?

THINGS I LIKED
Faramir. Every scene, but especially with his father. Right on the money of what he should be.

Lighting the beacons of Gondor gave me chills.

Sam carrying Frodo up Mount Doom. Sean Astin did the best acting in the movie (of course, he was given ample time to act, unlike many of the other wonderful actors). But he was great.

Less Arwen.

Pippin's character was well done, too.

Gandalf galloping with the flash of his staff!!! Wooo!

Shelob was IMHO the best CG of all three movies.

OTHER RANDOM COMMENTS

What the ___ was that Elephant Man, marshmellow head orc all about? I never thoughI would miss Lurtz...

Frodo bitten by Shelob... The wrapping and the makeup made him look like he belonged in a David Bowie video.

Pacing seemed erratic at the beginning but much better towards the end...
 
I think falling through fire and returning from the dead make G a little more knowledgable, especially when A can't even figure out what to do with his girlfriend.
Just because someone's love life needs ironing out doesn't mean that person has impaired judgement, especially when he is the next king of man...

Denethor slightly disturbed me, probably from my reading of the books. Leaping off the pyre and falling to his death is the natural thing to do--in the books he had the "nobility" to compose himself and burn to death, but since he lacked that in the movie he sought to end his agony. Hey, now you don't have to wait 'til the elves return!

Except for the fact the RotJ sucked and RotK rocked? What exactly did you want the oliphaunts to do?

When did he defy gravity? Not going up the oliphaunts legs...

From the book POV there is no way that would happen...I was not at all surprised when it happened in the theatre, and rather liked it. I could explain in more depth...

I suggest you read Thorin's review. A purist, yes, but able to review the movie with incredible fairness, managing to look at it as an adaptation and a film.
 
I'm Proud of the Movies

What i am most proud of these movies is this: They brought a whole new generation to the books....LOTR outsold Harry Potter last year, not a small feat.....because of that, IMHO, the movies have done their jobs
 
Originally posted by Gandalf White
I suggest you read Thorin's review. A purist, yes, but able to review the movie with incredible fairness, managing to look at it as an adaptation and a film.

GW! I am addressing it as a film (does Thorin seem fairer because he liked it more?)! Sam and Frodo have some tense moments in TTT, but there is no excuse for telling Sam to go home - nothing to do with adaptation. It just doesn't make sense. Frodo knows Gollum is a liar, whether Sam putting him down makes him mad or not. Why would Sam want the ring more than Gollum? Why would Sam give Frodo all the food and then eat the lembas?

Gandalf crowns Aragorn because (in the movie) he's the most powerful force in ME. Why would he need A's advice on an attack plan? How would A have more info about Frodo than G?

OK, I'll concede the Denethor thing. But I still say it looked stupid.

Legolas can climb vertically up an oliphaunt without holding onto anything? Doubt it! Will inspect this more closely next time...

You are completely right, ROTJ sucked! the Empire Strikes Back is another story...
 
I'm a 5th grade teacher, and today we took a field trip to see Cat in the Hat (we rented out the theatre). About half way through the movie I realized that three of the students, not mine, had been gone a loooong time to the bathroom. I walked to the bathroom and they weren't there. I started to wig out...then on a whim I poked my head into the RoTK theatre. There they were lol. I walked up next to them and they all jumped...one let slip an exclamation of, "sh*t!". Then I blew their minds by saying, "Mind if I join you?" Hehe they couldn't believe I wasn't going to tear their heads off.

Unfortunately the movie times are way to different, so I made them come back to our movie after about 20 mins.


Back to the RoTK...for all you complaining about "the eye", for some reason it really didn't bug me. First off, I didn't need to see Sauron in "mortal" form. And the eye thing worked for me for some reason. Not mind-blowing, but not stupid either.

The only scene that really bugged me was Legolas's elephant attack. Overdone, and unnecessary.
 
I enjoyed it but it wasn't all that it was blown up to be. The pellenor wasn't that great, there was no Mouth of Souron, and some of the battle special effects sucked. I was also dissapointed that they didn't show the ugly pink headed orc(Grishnakh I presume, though probably wrong) get killed. It was a great movie but I guess the purist side of me kinda took over when I was wathching it.
 
Originally posted by simbelmyne
GW! I am addressing it as a film (does Thorin seem fairer because he liked it more?)!

Yes!

It is important to remember that the Ring weighs heavily on Frodo, and he is not really thinking straith. Those tense moments are part of it. Then Sam constantly puts down Gollum. Frodo sees himself becoming more and more like Gollum, he sees what Gollum is, and is trying desparately to convince himself that it is possible to come back. But Sam's 'mistreatment' hinders this effort, in essence frightening Frodo and causing him to be short tempered with Sam. Gollum plays this perfectly, putting little whispering doubts in Frodo's head. Remember, Frodo has the Ring dominating his thoughts, so when Sam asks to help bear it, Gollum's little comments no longer seem little. Compound that with the apparent fact that Sam is eating the supplies while pretending to give his portion to Frodo.

Gandalf crowns Aragorn because (in the movie) he's the most powerful force in ME. Why would he need A's advice on an attack plan? How would A have more info about Frodo than G?
There isn't necessarily a connection with being the most powerful and the best strategist.

Legolas can climb vertically up an oliphaunt without holding onto anything? Doubt it! Will inspect this more closely next time...
Legolas made monstrous good use of the arrows/javelins sticking from the oliphaunts legs. (No pun intended ) This was nicely set up by a previous shot of a falling oliphaunt literally peppered with ranged weapons.

You are completely right, ROTJ sucked! the Empire Strikes Back is another story...
Whoops, haven't watched them in while, messed up episodes there. I dislike all Star Wars, though.
 
Even though I read the books, PJ did an excellent job with creating a tense scene at the cracks of Doom. I was on the edge of my seat until that blasted ring finally fell in! I was so worried PJ would destroy it, but he remained very close to the book (I'm glad Gollum didnt stumble in- I have a feeling that would have looked horrible on cinema).

The ending was perfect... "Well, I'm back!" The bowing was excellent as well. Touching and emotional, both of which emotions were missing from the first two movies.
 
Originally posted by Dáin Ironfoot I
The ending was perfect... "Well, I'm back!" The bowing was excellent as well. Touching and emotional, both of which emotions were missing from the first two movies.

Slightly off topic, but you though FotR lacked touching, emotional moments???
 
Not the tingly, make you feel warm and satisfied fuzzy kind of emotional moments.

FOTR was more awe-inspiring by bringing us into the great world of Middle-earth, but I think ROTK's 'fuzzy' moments surpassed the awe easily.
 
Question

I just returned from my first wiewing of 'The prince of egypt', and boy, I cried constantly. It was so moving I could not speach..
In this early period of my life I just understood so clearly, like a flash from a bright sky, what is worth to me in this life.

It´s not what you have, what you achieve, what you own or how much money you have -It´s about taking care of this world, your friends, family and all other lovely creatures, fill ourselves with love, empathy and visions. To reach out my hand for those who need help, to hug little baby animals when their vulnerbility is shown in their little eyes.
To be brave enough to throw your hate away, and choose to be constructive instead of destructive.
What if everyone loved everyone no matter who you were? And respected our differences...Anyway this seems to be the theme of The return of the king, and I wonder if I need a napkin or so.
The scene were Frodo kisses Sam on the forehead I really long for, because it really shows the beaty of sharing your feelings without feeling insecure...I really need to learn myself to shut up at cinemas as I do really strange noises when I cry
 
It was a great movie..MUCH better than I expected. Yes, there were parts that didn't coincide 100% with the book and a few fabrications here and there but all in all they got it right. I was impressed. To be able to sit for well over 3 hours and enjoy every bit of it says something in itself. I plan to see it again in the theater..something I wasn't eager to do with TTT.

The opening with Smeagol murdering Deagol was totally unexpected..but IMO it worked. I do feel that those of us who have read the books and know the storyline have a big advantage here because I can see someone who hasn't read the book scratching their head and saying "Huh?". But it worked for me!

I do wish they had elaborated on Gandalf's & Co's visit to Isengard. It's a shame that they didn't do "The Voice of Saruman" in it's entirety. Not having Saruman at ALL in the ROTK was a real puzzler. I was really looking forward to seeing the exchange between Saruman and Gandalf and got nothing. I do see this as being a real opportunity for the EE. I guess PJ had to have them go to Orthanc to pick up the Merry and Pippin and somehow get the Palantir but in the great scheme of things it seemed rather pointless..and what was with Aragorn not being able to hold the Palantir?

At any rate what we had in the film was Saruman just wandering around in the end...Completely unresolved. Talk about a loose end! Without the SOTS you really don't know what to make of Saruman at all. Shame because he was a major character in the first two films and now he's a nonentity. IMO that's a real lack of consistency there.

I was wondering about how they would work in the Paths of the Dead. I wasn't surprised that the Dunedain were omitted but I'd assumed that Aragorn had been carrying Anduril since he left Rivendell but that wasn't the case! So what we had was Arwen begging Elrond to reforge the sword and deliver it to him. I guess it worked well enough because it was Elrond who told him to seek out the Army of the Dead..I guess it was a good way for PJ to tie Elrond into the story..and put in another scene with Arwen. But at least it wasn't as "In Your Face" as in the TTT..No ridiculous 20 minute flashbacks or crazy fabrications..Thank goodness! After TTT I expected to see a lot more of that in ROTK.

At any rate I know the Army of the Dead didn't actually help out at Minas Tirith but I liked it anyway. I loved the scene where Aragorn, Gimli and Legolas climb out of the ships and the Orcs look all smug thinking that they are going to slice and dice 'em..and then all those dead soldiers come out and they freak. Good scene!

One of my favorite scenes was where the Rhohirrim come up over the hill and descend on the Orcs at Minas Tirith..Made me want to stand up and yell "FORTH EORLINGAS!" I'm really glad that they finally got Theoden right. I thought it was very inspiring and liked how they took on the Mumakil. I even liked when Legolas climbed up and took one out.

The scene with Eowyn, Merry and the Nazgul was really good. I just wish they had kept Eowyn's identity a secret until the moment she actually faces the Witch King and says "But no living man am I! You look upon a woman." I don't understand why they gave away her identity when she pulled Merry up on her horse as they rode out to battle..Why not wait until her big moment when she faces the Nazgul? It was an incredible surprise in the book and could've been just as effective in the movie. I'm still puzzling over that one.

Denethor..He was portrayed as entirely loony, one dimensional and quite evil...not that he's a likeable character to begin with but I think it should've been explained that he had looked into the Palantir and that was what was messing up his head. I do have to admit that I cheered when Gandalf smacked him upside his head..but having him go down in a fiery ball off the cliff..that was a bit unsettling. Tolkien portrayed him as being more pitiful than nasty.

I loved the battle scenes. I was grateful that the Battle of the Pelennor Fields wasn't as drawn out as Helm's Deep but just as effective. I did miss the confrontation between the Witch King and Gandalf..I kept waiting, waiting, waiting for it. Nothing. Bummer.

Houses of the Healing..Gone. Not surprised but it seems a shame not at least touch on the romance between Eowyn and Faramir. In TTT the writers were fabricating all sorts of love scenes and now they had one right out of the book and didn't use it.

I thought the scenes with Gollum, Sam and Frodo were great. While I didn't love the idea of Frodo telling Sam to "Go Home" and wouldn't have done it that way myself.. I can see why it was done. It added tension and set things up for Gollum's betrayal. I STILL think that Shelob should've been in TTT. I know the directors and writers say it would've been anticlimatic after Helm's Deep but IMO having Sam find Frodo all limp and white and taken for dead..and then hauled off by Orcs.. would've made for a great cliffhanger for TTT. In ROTK it was kind of lost with all the other stuff but still made for good action and suspense. I love how Sam comes into his own at this point.

A real poignant scene is when Sam shows Frodo that he has the ring and Frodo keeps saying "Give it to me" and Sam is thinking about it..Brings out the power of the Ring and how difficult it is to give it up..a reminder that it's no ordinary ring.

I thought the scene where Aragorn, Gandalf & Company ride to the Black Gate was interesting..but in a sense it was more of the same in that they went right to battle. I enjoyed the part of the book where Sauron's Messenger (The Black Numenorean) comes out and speaks with Aragorn and Gandalf. I was looking forward to seeing who it was that came out of the Gate itself. Part of me was wondering if it would be Sauron himself. It would've been better than sending out the usual bunch of Orcs and Trolls. We had plenty of those up to this point. IMO it was an opportunity lost.

Mount Doom..Well done but I had to admit watching Gollum wrestle with an invisible Frodo for the ring was rather amusing.

So then there was the reunion of the Fellowship and the coronation, Arwen marrying Aragorn..all that was great. I liked how everyone bowed to the Hobbits in the end..Put everything into perspective because that is what the story is about..the heroism and courage of simple, good people winning over evil.

I do wish they had done the Scouring of the Shire. I know it would've added length and maybe appeared "tacked on" but I do think it's an important component in the development of the Hobbit's characters..and it also wraps up what happened to Saruman and Wormtongue.

I am impressed that the movie ended with Frodo, Bilbo, Gandalf, Elrond and Galadriel going to the Grey Havens (yes, I know Celeborn wasn't supposed to be there..but why not?). It was a good enough way to end things, along with Sam marrying Rosie..No complaints there.

I look forward to the EE (which will probably be about 5 hours!) and hope and pray that PJ takes on The Hobbit. I'm totally bummed that next December will come and there will be NO LOTR.

At any rate..I do think that if you don't get nit picky about the details The Return Of The King was really great..Incredible action, good character development, wonderful, wonderful scenes, special effects and IMO it was fairly true to the book. No it didn't toe the line word for word but I think they got the storyline faily accurate. After TTT it was a welcome surprise.

ROTK was definitely not the herky jerky fabrication that The Two Towers was. I didn't find myself getting annoyed or frustrated like I was LAST December when I watched that movie. TTT had good and bad..I feel that The Return Of The King is 97% good. I liked it a lot. I walked out of the theater saying "WOW..GREAT MOVIE!" I don't often do that. I think PJ & Co deserve a "Two Thumbs Up" for this one. If you take this movie by itself and don't compare every nut and bolt with the book it holds up very nicely indeed.

However I will say that when it came to capturing the spirit of Tolkien, Middle Earth and the essence of the books The Fellowship Of The Ring still has the #1 spot in my heart. ROTK is a great movie....FOTR is Great Tolkien.
 
Last edited:
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…