mirkwoodwarrior
confused
- Joined
- Feb 1, 2003
- Messages
- 99
Originally posted by GoldenWood
6. Gadndalf's white light is a little cheesy and why couldn't he do that again in the battle?
A cup-full of Coke, some choice words (of the four-letter variety) and maybe a meeting after it's over. Show some maturity and don't ruin other's enjoyment...I know if I had someone in the theatre yelling "Where's my contact?" at the eye of Sauron, there would be a cup full of coke coming in that direction. I despise when people feel so righteous that they have to ruin the experience for everyone else.
Just because someone's love life needs ironing out doesn't mean that person has impaired judgement, especially when he is the next king of man...I think falling through fire and returning from the dead make G a little more knowledgable, especially when A can't even figure out what to do with his girlfriend.
Except for the fact the RotJ sucked and RotK rocked?Rhi, glad someone else thought the elephants were tooStar Wars for words. Basically a les cool version of Luke with the Ad Ats (or whatever those things were called). What about Theoden's death speech...E: "I'm going to save you", T: "You already have". Is PJ hoping no one remembers Return of the Jedi?
When did he defy gravity? Not going up the oliphaunts legs...Legolas on the Elephant? No, absolutely not. We've gone from one of the greatest action shots of all time in FOTR (Legolas shooting arrow after arrow at the orcs, even using one to stab an orc and then shoot it) to the skateboard move in TTT, to the surfboard move off the elephant's snout. He walks lightly upon the earth, but he can't defy gravity! He can't walk up walls (or elephants).
From the book POV there is no way that would happen...I was not at all surprised when it happened in the theatre, and rather liked it. I could explain in more depth...There would have been plenty of time if PJ had left out THE WORST SCENE IN THE MOVIE, Frodo teling Sam to go home. I defy anyone to explain it away. Frodo trusting Gollum over Sam? Never, never, never. Their friendship is the bond that holds LOTR together. Could you ever imagine a reality when you would choose someone you were repulsed by but pitied over your closest friend who has sacrificed their life to help you (and gives you all the food and water)? Does Frodo think Sam is going to call a taxi from Mordor?
Originally posted by simbelmyne
GW! I am addressing it as a film (does Thorin seem fairer because he liked it more?)!
It is important to remember that the Ring weighs heavily on Frodo, and he is not really thinking straith. Those tense moments are part of it. Then Sam constantly puts down Gollum. Frodo sees himself becoming more and more like Gollum, he sees what Gollum is, and is trying desparately to convince himself that it is possible to come back. But Sam's 'mistreatment' hinders this effort, in essence frightening Frodo and causing him to be short tempered with Sam. Gollum plays this perfectly, putting little whispering doubts in Frodo's head. Remember, Frodo has the Ring dominating his thoughts, so when Sam asks to help bear it, Gollum's little comments no longer seem little. Compound that with the apparent fact that Sam is eating the supplies while pretending to give his portion to Frodo.Originally posted by simbelmyne
Sam and Frodo have some tense moments in TTT, but there is no excuse for telling Sam to go home - nothing to do with adaptation. It just doesn't make sense. Frodo knows Gollum is a liar, whether Sam putting him down makes him mad or not. Why would Sam want the ring more than Gollum? Why would Sam give Frodo all the food and then eat the lembas?
There isn't necessarily a connection with being the most powerful and the best strategist.
Legolas made monstrous good use of the arrows/javelins sticking from the oliphaunts legs. (No pun intended
Whoops, haven't watched them in while, messed up episodes there. I dislike all Star Wars, though.You are completely right, ROTJ sucked! the Empire Strikes Back is another story...
Originally posted by Dáin Ironfoot I
The ending was perfect... "Well, I'm back!" The bowing was excellent as well. Touching and emotional, both of which emotions were missing from the first two movies.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?