• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Return of the King Reviews Thread

What did you think of RotK?

  • I am completely speechless due to its glory

    Votes: 54 37.2%
  • Extremely Impressive

    Votes: 48 33.1%
  • Great movie

    Votes: 23 15.9%
  • Alright, but not the best movie I've seen

    Votes: 14 9.7%
  • Boring

    Votes: 1 0.7%
  • Complete waste of my time and money

    Votes: 5 3.4%

  • Total voters
    145
Originally posted by MacAddict
The Eye of Sauron was soo freakin cheesy!! I burst out laughing when that thing started darting around looking for stuff, and made comments like "I can't find my keys!" And "Where's my Contact?!". The movie had it's high points but overall it was just like lame. The Battle of Pelanor Fields was uh, how can I say this, cheap, it was nothing like the grand fight that it is in the books. As far as the movies go I prefer FotR over TTT and RotK.


~MacAddict

I'm with MacAddict on this one. It had it's moments, but overall, it felt rushed and there were those unexpected twists to characters that had me wondering why.

Need I say more than Frodo and Sam on the stairway?

Arwen's connection with the fate of the ring?

Denethor being all bad and not a least bit wise.

Overall, it had a more modern feeling to it. All characters (except perhaps Gandalf) have flaws. I missed the heroism, the honor, the sacrifice for the common good.

Elrond ends up bringing Andúril only because he worries about the health of his daughter.

That's why I love the books. I can thank the films for causing me to read the books three more times. I love the books because of the grandeur of scale and heroism that no longer exists today.

I liked parts of the film and I'm sure I will warm up to it over time and enjoy more of it. I already have a date to see it again in 10 days time.

I can understand why many people will love the film. Enjoy! For those of us who love and cherish the books, it's often more of a mixed-bag.

Oh yes- this film needs an intermission! I'm sure that I'll enjoy the second half of the second viewing more because I will know when it's a good time to take a pee break!
 
Originally posted by Brytta
I'm with MacAddict on this one. It had it's moments, but overall, it felt rushed and there were those unexpected twists to characters that had me wondering why.

the eye was bad, very true.

Need I say more than Frodo and Sam on the stairway?

Please do, that is quite vague. Personally I loved that scene, Sean Astins performance was gold.

Arwen's connection with the fate of the ring?

just some nonsense that was forgotten nearly instantly, didn't bother me.

Denethor being all bad and not a least bit wise.

like someone said earlier in the thread, he's in serious need of EE, until then I won't judge him.

Overall, it had a more modern feeling to it. All characters (except perhaps Gandalf) have flaws. I missed the heroism, the honor, the sacrifice for the common good.

yup, everyone was just in it for their own good. Frodo was just sacrifising everything to save his own skin. sheesh :rolleyes:

Elrond ends up bringing Andúril only because he worries about the health of his daughter.

That's not the only reason. He comes because he believes in Aragorn, he even encourages him and says that he believes in him. "I gave my hope to the dunedain, for myself I got none" he says to aragorn, hinting that he believes in Aragorn.

That's why I love the books. I can thank the films for causing me to read the books three more times. I love the books because of the grandeur of scale and heroism that no longer exists today.

That is true. But the films IMO bring that heroism alive in a fantastic way.

I liked parts of the film and I'm sure I will warm up to it over time and enjoy more of it. I already have a date to see it again in 10 days time.

Great! I hope you enjoy it more!

I can understand why many people will love the film. Enjoy! For those of us who love and cherish the books, it's often more of a mixed-bag.

So it's an entirely impossible idea that a person loves and cherises the books but also the movies?

Oh yes- this film needs an intermission! I'm sure that I'll enjoy the second half of the second viewing more because I will know when it's a good time to take a pee break!

That would be horrible, nothing would ruin the mood better than an intermission during it. I would hate that beyond anything..
 
I really liked it. It was so much better than TTT.
My favourite part from the book is the battle of Pelennor Fields and we saw a lot of that. But it didn’t dominate the film the way Helm’s Deep did TTT.
I didn’t get nearly as annoyed at unnecessary changes this time round, because there were less of them. I didn’t like what they did to Denethor’s character though. He is not all bad in the book but now he was almost totally bereft of any noble qualities.
I still think the first film was the best of the three, but this one worked out really well.
 
Ol'gaffer asked:

quote Brytta:
Need I say more than Frodo and Sam on the stairway?

quote Ol'gaffer:
Please do, that is quite vague. Personally I loved that scene, Sean Astins performance was gold.

I did like Sean Astin's performance and the way his character was portrayed.

About the stairway- Frodo ditches his closest friend whom he has known for decades and hitches his pony to Gollum/Sméagol.

Frodo to Sam:

"Go home!"

Didn't this plot twist jump out at you and make you just a little bit uncomfortable? Granted, we all make mistakes in life, but this is a doozy.

I recently read Shelob's Lair from TT. Sam and Frodo actually hold hands in the book as they pass through the tunnel. They need that support so badly.

Once again, please enjoy the film. This particular change had me rolling my eyes in disbelief.
 
I have seen it TWICE already, and the second time was even better. Everytime when I see Aragorn charge towards to orcs by himself at the black gate, I wet myself everytime. IT was so freaking intense! The Battle of Pelenor fields were intense every single socond. One thing i had a tiny problem with was that in the beggining how the Story of how Smeagol became who he is never really connected with anything when the scene was over. It was just like an add on fyi. Dont get me wrong, i loved it. I think it barely squeeked by the fellowship because of the intense battle and the emotional connection it had, but that one particular scene didnt set 100% with me. It would have been better if PJ connected it with the Next scene like Having gollum mumbling it to himself and weeping or what not. Another minor thing was when Legolas said, "A DERVERTION" Its like, um ok, i got the point, u didnt need to say that! but I give it a 100% rating. BEst Movie of all time! Viggo also looked like a true King when his beard was a little thicker!

ROTK had the best looking, Hardass Leader. The Witch King. He looked unbelievable. Each time i saw him, chills went down my spine. Very well done. When Eowyn Killed the witch King, it was exactly how i pictured it. I dont think it could have been better.
 
Yeah, that was weird. Frodo would NEVER do that. But in the film they made him do it in a way for Sam's own protection, so that made it more or less acceptable. But still, a stange deviaton from the book that I had a hard time to understand.
 
Rhiannon complained that they were green, but rotting dead people are a bit *****...
But these dead people weren't supposed to be! And it destroyed the wonderful tension of the dead following, which is one of the my favorite elements of the sequence. And I couldn't stop hearing the Indiana Jones theme in my head.

You know what, the scene between Éowyn and the Nazgul worked and was done effectively- it was of minor detail that her helm was taken off at the wrong moment, they used the same script pretty much and did an excellent job. Girl power!
I didn't think so- It just felt all wrong. Of course, I know the scene backwards and forwards, but all of us here agree that her taking off her helm at the wrong moment ruins everything. It's like an afterthought. No pause of sudden doubt, no shrill wailing that fades away, no deadly gleam of fiery eyes...the Nazgul was totally not scary, and Eowyn's valor was equally diminished. This doesn't mean that I didn't whoop at the top of my lungs, but I know with absolute certainty that with reptition the scene being wrong is going to drive me crazy.

there was not enough of Éomer (the most emotional scene in the book for me was him finding Éowyn on the field)
I thought of you as they skipped that scene, Dain ;)

Éowyn talking to Théoden before he died (I think if it was just like the book where Merry talked to him with Éowyn lying nearby it would be much more effective and more heart-rending)
Agreed, although it kind of fit with the film's upping of the relationship between Theoden and Eowyn- I just wish they'd given some of that to her relationship with Eomer as well. I think as far as the film goes, Merry speaking to Theoden would have been less effective because we never see him and Theoden interact like they do in the book. No 'as a father you shall be to me'.

the absence of the Houses of Healing (it was a bit wierd to leave the Fields with Éowyn and Merry 'dead' on the field
NO KIDDING!

Oh I see! You must have read the book while you were watching the movie, so you not only missed the whole greatness because you were in your own little world, but also you were able to squeeze every little thing to complain about on this board!
Pause. Breathe. Don't get your panties in a wad. I'm not making a personal attack on your flesh and blood. I didn't enjoy the film. I'm annoyed because I saw that it could be better, and it should have been better- in my opinion. But you're free to think differently. So breathe. I'm not going to throw rocks at you for liking the movie.
I had the book read to me immediately prior to seeing the movie, because it is a deeply held tradition in my family that my dad reads LotR outloud in the fall, and this is a major part of my life. This is something that's important to me. I feel justified in being annoyed that someone got it wrong- in my opinion. I missed the greatness because there was none- in my opinion. I like my little world. I prefer my little world to reality. But you don't have to come hang out in my little world if you don't want to, that's fine. I won't be offended. Have a cookie anyway. I didn't 'squeeze in every little thing to complain about', I hit the main reasons I disliked the movie. I was maybe a little scathing, but I was honestly scathing. Relax.

I´m sick of hearing people complain about the differences and saying the film stinks, because that actually makes you believe it stinks. Which has nothing to do with the truth!
I DO believe the film stinks. I think I said so quite eloquently, in fact. But it's okay of you don't think the film stinks. Have a cookie.

I just read OVER 200 REWIEWS ON THEONERING.NET WERE THEY GAVE IT A 5 CLAIMING IT`S THE BEST MOVIE OF THEIR LIVES, TAKING YOUR BREATH AWAY NOT ONLY ONE TIME AND YOU DON`T GET IT BACK UNTIL YOU`RE ON YOUR WAY HOME.
That's great for them. I'm glad they enjoyed it. I'm genuinly sorry that I didn't enjoy it- but I still feel justified in being scathing. Besides, being scathing is fun, as you obviously know. I hope none of those people had to go to the emergency room. No oxogyn to the brain can cause brain damage.

Rhi has her right to complain- since the movie didn't include Faramir/Eowyn scenes and didn't follow the Witch-King battle line by line, that's like a slap in her face!
Thank you, Dain- I'm glad someone understands where I'm coming from! ;)

I think this says it all, let me guess, you favorite movies of all time have to be the "Revenge of the Nerds" movies, right?
Never heard of them. I do enjoy Kevin Smith films, if those count. My favorite movie is probably Casablanca, if I had to pick one.

Rhiannon
Some of the 200 equal rewiews I found at theonering.net
How nice for them. Unfortunately, other people saying they liked the film does not make me like the film. If this were so, I would like Charles Dickens much more than I do.

The Eye of Sauron was soo freakin cheesy!! I burst out laughing when that thing started darting around looking for stuff, and made comments like "I can't find my keys!" And "Where's my Contact?!". The movie had it's high points but overall it was just like lame. The Battle of Pelanor Fields was uh, how can I say this, cheap, it was nothing like the grand fight that it is in the books. As far as the movies go I prefer FotR over TTT and RotK.
Thank you! I was starting to think Tal and I were the only ones that didn't like it. It's nice not to be a lone negative voice (why do I always end up on the extreme end? Oh well...price of being interesting).

O Gigantic-Titanic-fanatic,

I guess we all get sick of things at these forums from time to time. I can relate to that. For example, one thing that I get sick of is hearing people say that anyone who doesn't like or even love these movies has something wrong with them, or is doing something wrong. It's indicative of denial really. Inablity to accept that the films could be short of perfect in the eyes of others.
Thanks, Nom (glad to see you back around!). There are actually, as difficult as it may be to believe, people who don't like Casablanca. And I can deal with this. Everyone have a cookie.

Look at the bright side, Rhi:

You can always work on your homework instead of going to see ROTK again.
I HAVE no homework! My semester is over! Hurrah! So I'll write an article on Eowyn and a profile thing for Dain instead ;)

Rhiannon,

After that review, I would be convinced that your ability to view anything in your life without dissaproval has been taken away from you. Here is a half-empty glass of milk that you can enjoy while you wear your awesome costume.
Why, thank you. I'll treasure it forever. I still feel justified in hating the movie. I'm happy for people who enjoyed the movie. Go you. I didn't enjoy the movie. I expressed my honest opinion on the subject. Now that we've both done so, we can go our seperate ways, you minus your glass, and me going to lock myself in my room with a copy of LotR. Have a cookie.

Hey, enough with the snide remarks. Just because someone doesn't like the movie doesn't mean you have to be rude about it. It's just a bloody movie after all.
Hear, hear. I'm sorry I ticked you all off. Have a cookie. Take a deep breath. Tal, I love the signature!

Overall, it had a more modern feeling to it. All characters (except perhaps Gandalf) have flaws. I missed the heroism, the honor, the sacrifice for the common good.
That's it exactly. What I feel in a nutshell. Brytta is profound. I'm going to go sit next to her. Have a cookie.
 
I won't repeat my scathing comments (which you can find in the Reviews thread), but I think everyone knows I wasn't happy. I didn't exactly violently hate it, though there were moments when I came close, but I definitely found it Boring.
 
What I thought of RoTK

First of all I have to say that I am a Tolkien purist! My overall opinion of Return of the King is that it was a good movie, BUT
there where some things that really pissed me off and some things that could have been made better. Example, Gandalf BEATING Denethor twice (Denethor is the ruler of Gondor for Chrits sake) and then ,with the aid of Shadowfax, "throwing" him in the pyre. The Shelob-scene was not how I pictured it should be: You just can´t go kicking a giant spider in the face! One scene that I really looked forward to see was the confrontation between Witch-King and Gandalf and surprise surprise!! it was missing. I hope that it will be in the extended version. But afterall it WAS a good movie, I just think it could have been better if it had sticked more to the book.
Ps. It was just an amazing feeling hearing 6000 rohirrim shouting "DEATH"!
 
Overall, it's by far the best theatrical version of the three, but I can't wait for the EE!!! They left so many obvious gaps that are going to need filled in.
 
Originally posted by Legolam
Overall, it's by far the best theatrical version of the three, but I can't wait for the EE!!! They left so many obvious gaps that are going to need filled in.

Indeed, it felt so rushed, i expect at least another hours worth on the EE.

Anyways, its the best film ever created ever on the face of the planet ever! :D
 
In the words of Keanu Reeves, "Woah."

What am I going to do next year when there's no LOTR movie to watch? Will I have to have an LOTR day, when I watch all three EE's back-to-back?

Anyway, to ROTK. Overall, I thought it was the best film of the three - by far. TTT REALLY disappointed me because it deviated from the book. However, ROTK is a much simpler book in terms of plot and, therefore, was easier to reproduce on the screen. As ever, the film worked best when sticking to the book, so most of my complaints are PJ changes (not that I'm a die-hard purist or anything, it's just the way it worked out).

Things that could've been done better
Eowyn - the line is "No living man am I", not "I'm not a man"!!!!
No houses of healing - the film REALLY needed this.
Aragorn and Arwen being reunited - rubbish.
Denethor dying - why couldn't it have happened the way in the book? After all, it NEARLY did. Gandalf could have beat him up less overall, I thought.
Legolas - his stupid stunts could have been pulled out of TTT and ROTK. Just makes him more effeminate that he really deserves.
Mouth of Sauron - I think it'd have been really effective to have him appear with Frodo's clothes instead of just another battle, which was never going to live up to the last.
The roving eye of Sauron - I know that's the quote from the book, but did they really have to make Barad Dur a flipping evil lighthouse???

Things I didn't really miss
Saruman - I wondered about him, but his absence from the film doesn't detract from my enjoyment.
Destruction of the ring - I'd have liked gollum to fall rather than be pushed, but the rest of the scene made up for this.
Elrond bringing Anduril - Despite this weird change, I can understand the need for simplicity in the film, so this one was OK.
Scouring of the Shire - didn't even notice it was gone!

Things I loved
The opening Smeagol/Deagol scene - a rare example of a change that works.
Eowyn - yes, she's in two sections here, but she still kicks butt even when she's saying the wrong lines, and Miranda Otto got it perfectly.
Frodo, Sam and Gollum - I loved everything they did. It was just as I imagined it.
Shelob - scared the c*** out of me. Fantastic!
Battle of the Pelennor fields - woah!
The grey havens - really moving ending, and I loved the fact they put the last line in the book in - "Well, I'm back!"

So there you go; my opinion on movie 3! :)
 
Last edited:
MacAddict, you are the perfect example of the kind of people I can't stand at a movie. Why do you feel the need to ruin it for other people, by speaking out loud, just because you're not having a good time? People who make comments out loud (not even going into the fact that your jokes were bad and I wouldn't recommend a career in stand-up) are losers.

Hate it, love it, don't care either way, but don't try to ruin the experience for other people.
 
Thôl's take on ROTK

This was without a doubt the best film ever made!

- Merry and Pippin REALLY grow up in ROTK, (well Merry then Pip soon after) Pip is scared and doesnt want to fight tho he must now, Merry wants to fight but isnt allowed...there is SO gonig to be more on his talk about this with Théoden in the EE
- The paths of the dead! Absoloute magnificance! The king of teh dead when he tries to attack Aragorn and Aragorn standing up to him and holding Andúril to his throat.
- The Rohirrim THE ROHIRRIM!!!!! SO PERFECT!!!! The spuring talk my Théoden, the roar of the men, the charge, the look of terror on the eyes of the Orcs on seeing what is about to hit them! WOW!!!
- The lighting of the signal fires to call Rohan for aid! WOW!! There was no action in this, but the anticipation went THROUGH THE ROOF!!!
- The bit at the harbour where Legolas, Gimli and Aragorn jump over the sides of the boat and face the orcs then they charge at them and the ghost hoard charges with them and the look of terror in those orcs eyes aswell!!
- Legolas on the Mumak!! :D Cheesy as hell, but Gimli's follow up line once the Mumak is dead after that long (and amazing) scene that Legolas just went through: "It still only counts as one!" :D
- The witch-king! (though i dont know why Gandalf was scared of him :confused: ) And where he got killed (perfectly) by Éowyn!
- Minas Tirith!!! IT WAS PERFECT!!! And the white tree part garden was so wonderful! It was the only grass in the whole city and it just stood out amazingly.
- SHELOB!!! AND WHAT A LOB SHE WAS!!!!! WOW!!! She was perfect in everyway possible!!
- Frodo's final surcumsion (sp) (it its a word) to the ring, i actually believed it this time, the look on his face was perfect for the part.
- The Eagles!!!! WOW!!!! I loved this scene, where they come in and attack the fell beasts!!!! WOW!!!!!

I could SOOOO go on here!!!

However there were a few things to pic up on:

- Aragorn not being able to control the Palantir :( big no no
- Elrond seem much weaker in comparission to Aragorn as he had done, and it made so sense to me as to why he came to Aragorn...
- Gandalf for the first part seemed out of control and no one listened to him, he wasn't as wise a tacktitioner (sp) as he was in the book
- Why the heck was Denethor like that?!?!! He ate like a pig and was dribbling and then he took the final leap which made no sense! :mad:
- It was too rushed and will SO be built out by at least another hour if not more, in the EE
- The eye acting like a spotlight :( it looked good yes, but it wasnt very Saurony
- No Saruman :(

A few other things:

- Faramir and Éowyn will SO get it together on the EE the way they stood next to each other smiling and stuff, it was so obvious.
- There was not enough of anything, not enough fighting, not enough Sam and Frodo, not enough dialogue etc it has so much to be built out on, i expect a massivly long EE after seeing that. :)

All in all, its the best film in the world ever, you have to see, and i SO will be again!!! :D

Also when Aragorn got crowned is it me or did the dwarve(who had that pillow)'s hair go from grey to browny-orange? (Like Gimli's....it may have been Gimli, im not to sure)....

Well there it is! Ill as more as i remember more and see it again! :D

~Joey~
 
Rushed? It didn't feel that way to me and definitely not compared to TTT.

What really, really, really got me into this one was the character interaction. Frodo, Sam, Gollum; Merry and Pippin; Gandalf and Pippin; Denethor and Faramir; Eowyn and Theoden; all brilliantly done.

I wasn't surprised, per say, by the plot twist with Frodo, Gollum, and Sam. It went along perfectly with what had been building in TTT.

And I just can't say enough about Sam and Frodo's journey into and through Mordor. So brilliant it takes my breath away. I've said it before, I'll say it again, Sean Astin was simply awesome. Period.

This movie had all the feeling of FotR, with the action of TTT, yet both elements done even better.

Amazing
 
w00t yeah!!! it was the greatest movie I've ever ever ever ever seen!! It was completely AMAZING!!!

:eek: and the EE will be even better!!
 
Can someone show me an obvious gap? I'm still somewhat starstruck from the wonder of it all...:eek:

Rhiannon, was it you who voted that it was a complete waste of time and money? :confused:
 
To those of you complaining about character development between Merry & Theoden, Eowyn & Theoden, The Houses Of Healing, etc., there just wasn't time for all that.
We're talking ten hours in the standard versions without that stuff.

I thought Gandalf should have confronted the Witch-King too.
Could that scene have been a bit betteer where he's destroyed? yeah, but if that bothers you, forget watching the movie because EVERYTHING will drive you nuts.....

I did find it odd that PJ couldn't fit 7 minutes with Saruman in but almost immediately after leaving Isengard, he cut to Merry & Pippin dancing & singing on a table in Edoras for almost one of those 7 minutes......
 
Great movie, i've seen better

and there's this little gap called Saruman whose presence could've spun this movie into the "speechless" department
 
I've never seen a better movie ( and that's a major understatement!). I couldn't believe it. After all the reviews, I was really expecting an awesome movie, but nothing could prepare me for the best movie ever created. Minas Tirith was perfect, the battle at Pelennor Fields was perfect, the battle at the Black Gate, perfect. I have to hand it to PJ, he really came through.
And to tell you the truth, I'm still in shock. :)

(Now another six months of torture, waiting for the EE. GROOOOOOAANNNN!!!:rolleyes: )
 

Today's events

Back
Top