I saw ROTK Sunday evening. And I read the reviews before hand , so that I could brace myself for , um...alterations. And i must say, this worked very well. As I am somewhat of a Purist meself, I really don't like change, but I also Realllly wanted to enjoy this movie, so I went into it as a movie as well as i could.
As a movie,....
I LOVED IT !
Great Stuff
-
Frodo and
Sam: Everything Frodo and Sam.. In TTT, which I loved, I found that often during the parts with Frodo, or
Merry and the
orcs, I was tapping my fingers a bit wanting to go back to what was done incredibly well- The Battle sequences, so anything to do with
Gandalf,
Aragorn,
Legolas, and
Gimli. All things
Arwen were just fluff, and even the
hobbits and awesome
ents didnt hold my attention for long.
In ROTK, while there was much less of Aragorn and Comp, I found I didnt mind at all because Frodo and Sam ....the emotion, and the bonding, and all their scenes....they were INCREDIBLE!
- Merry and
Pippin. They were incredible in this film. Incredible.
-
Gollum. Unbelievable.
- Gandalf. Well, I love Gandalf, anyways, so I expected an incredible performance. And got one.
-
Eowyn. She was more human than in the
books, and I loved her character in this one.
Great Scenes:
- Pippin and the
Palantir. Pippin was amazing here.
- Crazy
Denethor. Whether right or not, Denethor was CRAAAAAZZZZY and I found myself enjoying it.
- The battle at the Black Gates. Unbelievable.
-
Shelob. Awesome.
- Frodo, Sam, and Gollum climbing the narrow staircase.
Merry and Eowyn with the
Witch King.
-
Theoden's death while Eowyn was there.
- Frodo and Sam . All scenes.
- Aragorn and comp. in the
battles.
- Gandalf's talk to Pippin about death. Touching!
Bad Scenes
-
Elrond's " Arwens fate is tied with
the ring. " speech. Stupid and unnecessary. It didnt fit with the plot, and that has been done in sooo many action movies. it was cheese that didnt need to be there.
- Um, where did Eowyn go after her battle ? Her arm was hurt, but she disappeared until the end where she is smiling happily watching Aragorn( and as far as the audience knew she was still head over heels in love with Aragorn) get married to Arwen ? No explanation whatsoever of how she fell for
Faramir and let Aragorn go. Obviously a big scence was cut out of there. Poor editing.
- The ending. It felt like huge chunks of certain scenes had been cut out and there were empty gaps here and there. Maybe thats the book getting the best of me again.
Anyhoo, small stuff compared to the overall awesomeness! I loved it and am excited to go back soon !