• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Return of the King Reviews Thread

What did you think of RotK?

  • I am completely speechless due to its glory

    Votes: 54 37.2%
  • Extremely Impressive

    Votes: 48 33.1%
  • Great movie

    Votes: 23 15.9%
  • Alright, but not the best movie I've seen

    Votes: 14 9.7%
  • Boring

    Votes: 1 0.7%
  • Complete waste of my time and money

    Votes: 5 3.4%

  • Total voters
    145
Rhiannon, was it you who voted that it was a complete waste of time and money?
Not me...I voted for boring. I'll still be buying the EE the day it comes out, but I'm a completist.

To those of you complaining about character development between Merry & Theoden, Eowyn & Theoden, The Houses Of Healing, etc., there just wasn't time for all that.
Rhi has got a totally brilliant idea. Cut out the opening sequence with Smeagol, the Dead swarming over Minas Tirith, Legolas' stunt with the elephant, the thing with Pippin lighting the warning fire thingies, and Denethor jumping off the wall. Use the time saved to insert the Houses of Healing.

Hey RHI, I just found something that could have made ROTK worse:


In the words of Keanu Reeves, "Woah."

Just imagine how much worse it would have been if that wooden indian disguised as an actor had been in ROTK.....
SHUDDER! Don't even say such things! *eye twitch* I'm going to have nightmares!

I reserve the right to dislike a movie without any particular reason other than that I failed to enjoy it. Aside from being a book purist, I just didn't like it.

I think the cup of coke would be more disruptive, personally...

Except for the fact the RotJ sucked and RotK rocked? What exactly did you want the oliphaunts to do?
Get less screentime? I refuse to give them any kind of proper name because they annoy me. Elephant Elephant Elephant! Once there was an elephant who tried to use the telephant...no no! I mean an elephone who tried to use the telephone...

When did he defy gravity? Not going up the oliphaunts legs...
Totally physically impossible.
Still unreasonable. Arrows aren't strong enough to hold the weight, and javelins wouldn't have stuck in deep enough to hold it either.
 
As one moves through these movie threads, one will see that I have defended many of Peter Jackson's actions in his attempt to bring The Lord of the Rings to life on the big screen and for a much wider audience than that of the fantasy book reading public.

I must state that, although the movie was good, I was disappointed by some of the scenes and many of the same problems that Rhiannon brings up. It did not kill the whole movie for me, and I admit to tearing several times, but I did come away feeling that the movie was much too high on special effects and action sequences to the spite of dialogue and character acting.


I agree for the most part. I would have much prefered the Saruman death scence to begin the film and not as many last action hero scenes.

I liked Fellowship of the Ring much better, but I did enjoy The Return of the King.

Maybe my expectations were set too high. Maybe I am more a purist than I would have thought. Maybe it was the guy who smelled like smoke seated next to me. I just did not have as much fun watching this film as I had with the other two films of the trilogy. I still give it 4 of 5 stars, which it well deserves.
 

ROTK was an action flik. Gandalf and Legolas were action figures. Am I the only one comparing Legolas with Luke in the Empire Strikes Back taking on the Imperial walkers at the Battle of Hoth? Luke Elfwalker!


Could be. I was comparing Eowyn to Luke myself......

The way she was darting in & out between the legs remnided me of Luke & the Impereial Walkers long before Legolas showed up.

As for that famous SW quote Theoden & Eowyn usesd, I tend to believe itr wasn;t plagerized, but done on purpose as 'a tip of the hat' to George Lucas. Everyone knows the line from ROTK, so it's not like PJ was tying to slip it by us.

Besides, it hardly fit there. As someone early said, what has Eowyn saved Thoeden from? Being eaten alive by a really big featherless vulture?
 
Originally posted by Bucky
[BBesides, it hardly fit there. As someone early said, what has Eowyn saved Thoeden from? Being eaten alive by a really big featherless vulture? [/B]
That, or maybe it was a reference to the fact that she still showed love to the King in his decripitude. But I suppose why look for deeper meaning when it is so much easier to complain about the superficial layers?
 
ALRIGHT RHI! YOU ROCK GIRL!

I am totally agreeing here. There was so much deviation in this movie that could have been avoided and that time used to bring all the wonderfull things from the book but it wasn't just the Devations that bothered me. (One of the worste being when Frodo told Sam to go home.)

But what really made me mad was all the modernizations of lines. Tolkien was wonderfully poetic and Shakespearean and there were some wonderful old fashioned yet kick book lines in there that I was yerning to hear.
Like the one in my signiture. They totally messed up Eowyn and Merry's scene!

They would have had enough time to go by the book if they hadn't put all the deviated crap in there.
And I was reallly really wanting to hear Sam's song for finding Frodo that they completely ditched not to mention him running around all visible in that part, and ......... oh how much longer could I go on?

Anyway I did have lots of dissapointment with this movie but some how I was laughing and applauding with the croud. But you know everyone was saying you are so going to cry bring tissue or this or what-ever.
VO TEARS IN MY SECTION THANKS.
I was totally waiting for a wonderful action packed, by the book, emotional, movie.
 
Blaugh! *recoils* Luke is such a drip!

And Eowyn isn't?

(Duck, Buck, here comes the power puff girls....)

Luke: Teenager meets Royalty & falls in love instantly. ready to face death to impress new love......

Eowyn: Teenager meets Royalty & falls in love instantly, ready to face death to impess new love......

Luke: Faces the BIG evil dude in a mask & cape.....

Eowyn: Faces the BIG evil dude in a mask & cape......

 
Um, how many other characters besides Frodo touch the Ring in the book (not counting flashback)?
Bilbo, Gandalf, Bombadil, Sam, Gollum.
How many besides Frodo in the movie?
Bilbo, Gollum.

In both book and movie the Ring has an immense impact on those who possess it- only in the book version this effect is somewhat inconsistent. I'm a huge fan of the books, but I see no reason why the movie should stay true to the books in the (relatively few) points where the book is not self-consistent.

Not only has Ring-handling been reducd in the movie, but also Ring-wearing. Given the imminent threat which Sauron poses to all who wear the Ring in both book and movie, I think that this is also a case where the movie is more self-consistent than the book. I realize that Tolkien gives an explanation for why Sam can wear the Ring in the book without being spotted by Sauron, but I don't think that his justification is a particularly good one. The 'eye' of Sauron does not seem to be effected by normal physical limitations- it could have spotted Frodo across a great distance at Amon Hen, and it was able to spot Frodo when he was inside a Volcano and protected by the same clouds of Mordor as Sam at Cirith Ungol. Why then doesn't it spot Sam on the borders of Mordor? We just have to assume that this is a 'special case' relative to the events at Mt Doom. I prefer the way the movie avoids this by having Sam not wear (nor even touch) the Ring- again, no point in mindlessly sticking to the book in the few cases where the book does not make much sense.
 
Hahaha!! I was gonna post something like that!! But then i thought it was to riskay for the forum
 
Agh I'm so mad!

I'm probly the biggest Tolkien fan in my city (and it's a big city) and I havent seen it yet! and ALL my friends are like 'Nick this is the best movie i've ever seen!'

AgH IM GONA EXPLODE!


PLUS IM SICK AND CANT SEE IT FOR A WHILE YET!!!aaaaaaaaahhhhhh
 
There are no possible words to describe how incredibly amazing this movie was. i realize there are some complaints (no houses of healing, why are eowyn and theoden smiling at each other suddenly?, denethor is such an a-s-s i the movie what happended?) but if you forget ever reading the books it is phenomenal (sp).

Nothing can ever rival the magnificence of Tolkiens books but PJ comes so d-a-m-n-e-d close it's scary.

All i can realy say at this moment about the movie is:
It NEEDS an Academy Award DESPERATLY!!!
Sean Astin, Viggo, Mortensen, Elijah Wood, Ian McKellan, Andy Serkins (AWESOME JOB AS GOLLUM!!!), and so many more!!!!

I toatally agree that you stop brething a quarter of the way through the movie and don't catch you r breathe until you are back in your car....well wait no...not until after you are out of your car again beeging the ticket guy to let you in for the next sold out screening.

i don't know how i will be able to wait to see it on dvd. Wait i don't have i will demand that my mother take me again!!! i must go again...MUST!!!

no breathe left must leave to replay movie in head and place self on respirator

one more thing
VIGGO LOOKED SEXY WITH STUBBLE...WHY DID HE HAVE TO GET A BEARD?????????
 
Movie thoughts

I will be brief and it has been awhile since I read the books but...

Did the paths of the dead really happen like that with them coming into the battle with him that way? I remember something about it but am vague on it and it just didn't seem right to me.

Also, wasn't shelob supposed to be large and fat and hardly able to move but just lures people in and then eats them?

maybe I am just way off, but if someone can clarify that would be great

and whoever wrote about the eye comment and what they said in the theater when it came on like a spotlight - don't go to movies anymore or talk during them, people hate you when you do, whether they tell you to shut up or not, you are ruining it for all.
 
Re: Movie thoughts


In the books the Army of the Dead never went to Minas Tirith to fight. Aragorn used them to help him and the Dunedain take over the Corsair's ships, he then released them from their oath and sailed to the battle.

And yes, I believe in the books Shelob was a bit less active. I did think she looked rather bloated in the movies, though. (Fortunately my arachnaphobia failed to kick in for once.)

And amen to that third paragraph!
 
Poor BC!

ALRIGHT RHI! YOU ROCK GIRL!
WHOOHOO! You come sit with me, I'm totally on your side. The modernization of the dialogue was I think (on reflection), what really bothered me most, and ruined things for me over all. What draws me to Tolkien most is the elegance of the language, the sheer grace and nobility that you don't find in this world.

(Duck, Buck, here comes the power puff girls....)
Ha Ha Ha
Despite some generalized similarities in the basic events surrounding their characters, Luke remains a whimpy drip and Eowyn is a kick-butt shieldmaiden.
Eowyn: Teenager meets Royalty & falls in love instantly, ready to face death to impess new love......
She's 24, she wasn't really in love, and she didn't face death to impress her 'new love'. So hah. Hah! *sugar high* I wrote an essay on this subject.

one more thing
VIGGO LOOKED SEXY WITH STUBBLE...WHY DID HE HAVE TO GET A BEARD?????????
No kidding. Aragorn was totally not hot in this film. What's with that?
 
I saw ROTK Sunday evening. And I read the reviews before hand , so that I could brace myself for , um...alterations. And i must say, this worked very well. As I am somewhat of a Purist meself, I really don't like change, but I also Realllly wanted to enjoy this movie, so I went into it as a movie as well as i could.

As a movie,....

I LOVED IT !

Great Stuff

- Frodo and Sam: Everything Frodo and Sam.. In TTT, which I loved, I found that often during the parts with Frodo, or Merry and the orcs, I was tapping my fingers a bit wanting to go back to what was done incredibly well- The Battle sequences, so anything to do with Gandalf, Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli. All things Arwen were just fluff, and even the hobbits and awesome ents didnt hold my attention for long.
In ROTK, while there was much less of Aragorn and Comp, I found I didnt mind at all because Frodo and Sam ....the emotion, and the bonding, and all their scenes....they were INCREDIBLE!

- Merry and Pippin. They were incredible in this film. Incredible.

- Gollum. Unbelievable.

- Gandalf. Well, I love Gandalf, anyways, so I expected an incredible performance. And got one.

- Eowyn. She was more human than in the books, and I loved her character in this one.

Great Scenes:

- Pippin and the Palantir. Pippin was amazing here.
- Crazy Denethor. Whether right or not, Denethor was CRAAAAAZZZZY and I found myself enjoying it.
- The battle at the Black Gates. Unbelievable.
- Shelob. Awesome.
- Frodo, Sam, and Gollum climbing the narrow staircase.
Merry and Eowyn with the Witch King.
- Theoden's death while Eowyn was there.
- Frodo and Sam . All scenes.
- Aragorn and comp. in the battles.
- Gandalf's talk to Pippin about death. Touching!

Bad Scenes

- Elrond's " Arwens fate is tied with the ring. " speech. Stupid and unnecessary. It didnt fit with the plot, and that has been done in sooo many action movies. it was cheese that didnt need to be there.

- Um, where did Eowyn go after her battle ? Her arm was hurt, but she disappeared until the end where she is smiling happily watching Aragorn( and as far as the audience knew she was still head over heels in love with Aragorn) get married to Arwen ? No explanation whatsoever of how she fell for Faramir and let Aragorn go. Obviously a big scence was cut out of there. Poor editing.

- The ending. It felt like huge chunks of certain scenes had been cut out and there were empty gaps here and there. Maybe thats the book getting the best of me again.

Anyhoo, small stuff compared to the overall awesomeness! I loved it and am excited to go back soon !
 
Just in case you haven't heard, the EE should fill in the large chunks that seem to be missing, including Eowyn in the Houses of Healing and her getting together with Faramir.
 
Oh, good ! Because I was a wee bit confused there . But that's great news then eh, Ill just wait for the EE.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…