Not me...I voted for boring. I'll still be buying the EE the day it comes out, but I'm a completist.Rhiannon, was it you who voted that it was a complete waste of time and money?
Rhi has got a totally brilliant idea. Cut out the opening sequence with Smeagol, the Dead swarming over Minas Tirith, Legolas' stunt with the elephant, the thing with Pippin lighting the warning fire thingies, and Denethor jumping off the wall. Use the time saved to insert the Houses of Healing.
SHUDDER! Don't even say such things! *eye twitch* I'm going to have nightmares!Hey RHI, I just found something that could have made ROTK worse:
In the words of Keanu Reeves, "Woah."
Just imagine how much worse it would have been if that wooden indian disguised as an actor had been in ROTK.....
I reserve the right to dislike a movie without any particular reason other than that I failed to enjoy it. Aside from being a book purist, I just didn't like it.Lighten up some of you! Quite a bit of your comments are not purist-should-have-been-more-like-the-book, but plain old NPW. I can't see how anyone can truly find favor of the other two movies over this one (from a purist perspective and as an adaptation). It was a better movie and adaptation overall.
I think the cup of coke would be more disruptive, personally...I know if I had someone in the theatre yelling "Where's my contact?" at the eye of Sauron, there would be a cup full of coke coming in that direction. I despise when people feel so righteous that they have to ruin the experience for everyone else.
Get less screentime? I refuse to give them any kind of proper name because they annoy me. Elephant Elephant Elephant! Once there was an elephant who tried to use the telephant...no no! I mean an elephone who tried to use the telephone...Except for the fact the RotJ sucked and RotK rocked? What exactly did you want the oliphaunts to do?
Totally physically impossible.When did he defy gravity? Not going up the oliphaunts legs...
Still unreasonable. Arrows aren't strong enough to hold the weight, and javelins wouldn't have stuck in deep enough to hold it either.
Rhi has got a totally brilliant idea. Cut out the opening sequence with Smeagol, the Dead swarming over Minas Tirith, Legolas' stunt with the elephant, and Denethor jumping off the wall. Use the time saved to insert the Houses of Healing.
That, or maybe it was a reference to the fact that she still showed love to the King in his decripitude. But I suppose why look for deeper meaning when it is so much easier to complain about the superficial layers?Originally posted by Bucky
[BBesides, it hardly fit there. As someone early said, what has Eowyn saved Thoeden from? Being eaten alive by a really big featherless vulture? [/B]
Um, how many other characters besides Frodo touch the Ring in the book (not counting flashback)?
Originally posted by scotthed41
Did the paths of the dead really happen like that with them coming into the battle with him that way? I remember something about it but am vague on it and it just didn't seem right to me....
....Also, wasn't shelob supposed to be large and fat and hardly able to move but just lures people in and then eats them?...
...and whoever wrote about the eye comment and what they said in the theater when it came on like a spotlight - don't go to movies anymore or talk during them, people hate you when you do, whether they tell you to shut up or not, you are ruining it for all....
WHOOHOO! You come sit with me, I'm totally on your side. The modernization of the dialogue was I think (on reflection), what really bothered me most, and ruined things for me over all. What draws me to Tolkien most is the elegance of the language, the sheer grace and nobility that you don't find in this world.ALRIGHT RHI! YOU ROCK GIRL!
Ha Ha Ha(Duck, Buck, here comes the power puff girls....)
She's 24, she wasn't really in love, and she didn't face death to impress her 'new love'. So hah. Hah! *sugar high* I wrote an essay on this subject.Eowyn: Teenager meets Royalty & falls in love instantly, ready to face death to impess new love......
No kidding. Aragorn was totally not hot in this film. What's with that?one more thing
VIGGO LOOKED SEXY WITH STUBBLE...WHY DID HE HAVE TO GET A BEARD?????????
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?