• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Return of the King Reviews Thread

What did you think of RotK?

  • I am completely speechless due to its glory

    Votes: 54 37.2%
  • Extremely Impressive

    Votes: 48 33.1%
  • Great movie

    Votes: 23 15.9%
  • Alright, but not the best movie I've seen

    Votes: 14 9.7%
  • Boring

    Votes: 1 0.7%
  • Complete waste of my time and money

    Votes: 5 3.4%

  • Total voters
    145
Pippin/Frodo:

But what really made me mad was all the modernizations of lines.

Bingo!

I knew we were entering dangerous waters when in the second scene Aragron asks Gandalf what he feels in his heart about Frodo's current fate.

Movie Gandalf: "That he is alive."

Ugh!

That's the way any New Yorker would answer the question on a street corner in 21st century America.

True Gandalf: "That he lives."

This is the first of many such language modernizations. I don't know why, because the reaction I get from a wide range of movie viewers is that they really enjoy the scenes in which original dialogue from the book is used.
 
Originally posted by Brytta
That's the way any New Yorker would answer the question on a street corner in 21st century America.

Actually, the answer you'd get is, "Dude! He lives!" :p ;)

Anyway, I noticed a wonderful absence of cringe-worthy lines in RotK. A definite improvement.
 
Thank you Rhi, I love cookies and these are especially good.

Brytta, I so agree. Thank you. Very worth reading your quote was.
I found it true and to the point.

Some of my favortie books are because of wonderfull lines like that. That's a good reason why I really enjoy medieval adventures and what I call "Olden day" books. Before modern day technoligy. I love how they get along. And honestly I'de much rather watch a war with swords and creative 'old' wepons than big bombs and stuff.
 
WOW! That was a great movie. Yes, the effects were cool, but they also had a lot of growth with the characters and especially the 4 hobbits and Aragorn. I really think that the movie stayed closer to the book than the other two did. That can be a good thing and a bad thing. The good part about that is that people who had read the book were able to relate to what was going on and those who haven't read the book can get an idea of what the idea of the book was. The bad part about this is that while staying closer to the book, PJ did go off course a little bit and made some particular parts of the movie feel like they didn't belong.
> I did think that Denethor could have been played a little bit better at the beginning, but his role at the end of his time was played almost to perfection. I do agree that having him jump off the wall to his death would have not been the best way to go, but heck, that's one tinsy think out of 3 other great hours of movie.
> I believe that the Legolas and Mumak scene could have been a lot better or done not at all. If you go back and look at it, it did kind of seem like PJ was trying to insist that he was able to climb on its legs using the arrows stuck in it. Now, I'm not trying to be a NPW here by saying that I actually inspected the scene. While in the the theater, I took that part at face value only. But now that I have some time to think about it, I realize that there was really no way he could have climbed on it.
> I enjoyed Frodo's stuggle throughout the storyline [ not that i am saying I liked seeing him struggle.] I thought that it was portrayed exactly the way JRR envisioned it. I especially liked his battle with himself at the tip of Mount Doom. The scene of Sam realizing that they had come all this way and then that it could all be destroyed by Frodo not casting the Ring away is awesome. He just is kind of standing there with this surprised kind of disbelieving expression saying "No, Mr. Frodo. No." And he is just sighing while he says it.
> What I didn't like about that scene at Mt. Doom is when Frodo pulls a Gandalf while he is dangling on the edge of the cliff. Actually, that entire sequence was screwed up when PJ didn't have Gollum dance around and fall in on his own accord. I think that Frodo wouldn't have had enough juice left to attack Gollum like that. I did think that when Gollum and Frodo fell that Frodo had actually gone into the fires with Gollum. Then we see him hanging on for dear life and I am like" Oh Lord, he's pulling another Gandalf on us."
> One thing I though was awesome was the Ghosts of the Men of Gondor. Even though that any hope of a good battle scene was pretty much dashed when they came along a swept every body away, it was still cool how only Aragorn could touch them or kill them and he had no purpose to.
> So, that is my review on first impressions. I will definately have more to say when I have had time to think about it, but for now, I just got back from seeing it 1 1/2 hrs. ago and that is all off the top of my head. All in all, I really enjoyed it. Oh yeah, you can e-mail me at [email protected] if you want to talk to me personally. Or you could IM me.
 
Hear hear, Brytta! That was my brother's main complaint as well, and my dad's comment was that they had robbed the characters of their nobility.

- Eowyn. She was more human than in the books, and I loved her character in this one.
I wouldn't agree- She's just as if not more human in the books, but you have to be paying attention. The character development is much more subtle than that of some of the other characters in the book, though she goes through just as drastic a change as any of them. I didn't like that she never became cold and totally unafraid of death- At Pelennor she shouldn't have looked afraid the way she did. "Merry heard of all sounds in that hour the strangest, for it seemed to him that Dernhelm laughed-" (paraphrase, I don't have the book on hand).

Just in case you haven't heard, the EE should fill in the large chunks that seem to be missing, including Eowyn in the Houses of Healing and her getting together with Faramir.
Yeah...But they should have had the brains to put them in there in the first place.
 
aragil said:
But I suppose why look for deeper meaning when it is so much easier to complain about the superficial layers?

How does T saying "you already have" have a deeper meaning when it doesn't even make sense? Luke saved DV's conscience...E saved Theoden from dying 10 minutes sooner. Pj hitting us over the head with that line was just a bad move. besides, he had already made a pretty transparent tribute to Star Wars with the oliphaunt scenes.

Bucky, you said it...Gandalf the Stupid in ROTK. And although I appreciated the spiritual moment between G and Pippin, it seemed very out of place.

Rhiannon, have seen the movie again, you were not kidding around about Arwen's awful green dress...she looks terrible (which is a pretty big feat for the beautiful Liv - although she still couldn't act her way out of a paper bag). And those thin arrows (which caused no bleeding) could never have supported Legolas crawling up the oliphaunt's side. And he then proceeded to defy gravity while being bucked around by olipaunt. Besides, the scene didn't even look very good. CG used much better in other scenes. Better to have left out the oliphaunts all together and PUT BACK IN THE HOUSES OF HEALING!!! Never thought Aragorn was cute anyway...all about Boromir (rrrrr;) )
 
Yeah, I agree with you both on that note. That really was a horrible dress. Between that and her see through number in TTT ( In my opinion elves would have had better taste ) , she's not getting A plus on fashion sense. I really liked that headbandy thing Legolas wore at the end of the movie. It was beautiful.
You know, that's something that's bugged me about two scenes Legolas has dominated. The elephant scene and the one in TTT where he jumps on the horse. Ok, is it just me or were they both so computerized there was no way anyone with half a brain should have included them with all the amazing realistic computerizations. THEY LOOKED TOTALLY FAKE. It was always an akward moment when I was watching both of those scenes. Orlando did a great job as Legolas, he definetly could have supported those scenes with realistic looking fighting, not superhero mumbo jumbo. Wondering what everyone else thought of those scenes. No matter how many times I see them they do not look real. And they look plain stupid in a movie with so many awesome graphics. Perhaps a doggie bone for the ladies ? That's the only reason I can think of. :D
 
Hear HEAR, Elfhelm! I really hate those scenes. I hate massive computer generated stunts anyway, but those in particular because they don't serve a purpose (okay, the 'That still counts as one!' line was funny, but they could have had Legolas bring down an elephant in some slightly more reasonable fashion).

Part of my problem is that the bigger the films have gotten, the more the focus has shifted to massive special effects and big battles and those crazy stunts. PJ started playing to his newly discovered mainstream audience. And I hates it. I'm all for big bloody action sequences- but I don't want to be up in the air looking at a computer generated animal. I want to be down in on the action, ground level, with that kind of personal intensity. I like my epics on a human level, which is what LotR is, and which PJ failed to understand.
 
Yeah, what was up with those TTT and ROTK Legolas scenes? There was much more of an effort to incorporate different TYPES of effects in FOTR, not just CGI. -Doing cool-looking special effects in REAL environments, or at least environments that looked real. That warg attack in TTT and Legolas "twisting" onto that horse? :( And when Leg jumped on that oliphaunt, all of a sudden normal reality is suspended?
 
I have seen the light!

Ah yes, I have seen that epic masterpiece aptly titled “The Return of the King”. Now, where to begin describing its awesomeness? That is the question…I haven’t read the other reviews in this thread because I don’t really want to be influenced too much in what I’m going to say about the film, so please bear with me if I go over a few points that have already been addressed ( which they probably have, but oh well ).

First off - everything about it was incredible. The screenplay was much better in Return of the King than in the Two Towers, and perhaps even the Fellowship. Sean Astin was an amazing actor - he gave so much emotional impact to the film, especially on the way to the final arduous trek to Mount Doom. In fact, all actors were fantastic ( except perhaps for John Noble, but that was more to do with his character than anything else ) .Gollum / Smeagol, of course, was perfect – who could expect any less? That beginning sequence was an unexpected twist, but a good one nonetheless – Gollum’s actions and thoughts really needed a background, and it provided it well. The costumes were brilliant, but that was predictable. Shelob was brilliant, much better looking than the spider that featured in Harry Potter, but that too was predictable. ;) That scene with Gollum and Frodo at the Cracks of Doom was also done well - although I had to laugh at the sight of Gollum looking like he was just hanging about in mid-air in such a serious scene.

The Witch-King looked incredibly cool…the scene in which Eowyn slays him really did justice to the book. And the scenery and the architecture was AMAZING – Minas Tirith was almost exactly how I had imagined it to be. My favourite moment was probably Pippin’s song. He has an excellent voice, and having that juxtaposed with the riders going to war further enhanced the sadness in what he was singing ( if only Denethor could show some respect )…And also, that final scene with Frodo and Sam, lying on the rock surrounded by lava, expecting to die but ending up being rescued by the eagles – it was just so poignant. I love how they added in Sam’s marriage to Rosie, especially after his "dying" wish.

The music was done exceptionally well – more overtones from the Fellowship, which was suitable. It made it more bitter-sweet. It further enhanced the fact that even with darkness comes light and the end to shadow. The final scene at the Grey Havens was the magical finishing touch – Frodo looked so happy and innocent again when he finally took the ship to leave. That, and Sam’s return home, was the best possible way to end the film. Peter Jackson really was right when he said he saved the best scene until last.

I really only have a couple of minor ( very minor ) gripes. The first is the portrayal of Denethor. Now, he did lose his mind in the books – but he wasn’t quite as crazy, foolish and ungrateful as he was in the film…he had no nobility at all. To be such of a let-down to his people that he actually had to be knocked unconscious by Gandalf for any resistance to actually happen is going a bit over the top, IMO. The second is gravity-defying Legolas. I have no problem with the fact that he took down an Oliphaunt by himself – but did he really have to do it standing horizontally? :eek: They’re the only downsides though, and they’re incredibly small compared to the film in general.

Return of the King felt a lot more like Middle-Earth than the Two Towers did, and about the same amount as the Fellowship did. It had a much stronger atmosphere to it – it wasn’t wholly dark like the Two Towers, but it still managed to combine such despair and hope. It was by far the most emotional of the three.

In short, my general verdict is that it is my favourite of the three. However, I’m not sure if I can call it the best of the three – each was good in its own way. The Return of the King provided the fitting conclusion to the magnificent beginning and near breath-taking sequel. This could even be seen in the credits – having the character’s faces with the actor’s names was the best touch possible in the end. I expect that the EE will be even better - there is so much to be added! The only thing it needed was to be longer, and less rushed. Then it would be perfect.

A definite 5 star rating. ( Surprise surprise )

 
simbelmyne said:
And when Leg jumped on that oliphaunt, all of a sudden normal reality is suspended?

This is a difficulty in fantasy literature and films, where on some levels the normal laws of physics no longer apply. Legolas can walk over snow where others sink into it. This suggests that somehow gravity has less on an effect on elves than on other creatures, or else he is much lighter than he appears. Yes, normal reality is suspended for a moment. Should this be a surprise in fantasy?

If we accept his snow-walking I don't see why we would not also accept him making a very high and quick jump onto a horse, or climb up the Mumakil by using the arrows as steps. It seems consistent to me.

Odo
 
Rhiannon said:
Hated it. I thought it sucked. I'm growing more irritated as I type.

I didn't like the use of the opening sequence about Smeagol. Sure, it's good to have it, but I don't like it as the opening, and I found the murder sequence to be extremely horrific- I need to call home and warn my dad before he takes my younger siblings.

The plot was incoherent. The jumps from thing to thing don't make sense, nothing seques- one minute Theoden is whining because Gondor didn't come to their aid, and in his next scene he's rallying Rohan to because some pretty fires got lit- and because Aragorn guilted him in to it. We never see why he changes his mind.

The palantir looked like one of those electric balls you can get from novelty stores, which took away from a scene that might otherwise have been very effective.

Denethor was disgusting. As much as I hate the character's slimy nasty guts, even I recognize that he still has shreds of nobility and dignity- he isn't completely nutzo from the get-go. The pyre scene had every chance of being excellent...until Denethor hops off the table and goes running away to jump off the wall. What the hell was that? I'm still hoping I dreamed that part.

The Battle of Pelennor was 1) broken up because they kept stopping the action to have Theoden shout orders and 2) totally and annoyingly dominated by those freaking stupid elephants. Okay, they're big, they have tusks, they're stomping on people, but can we get a shot of something ELSE maybe? Just a little? If they were trying to be realistic by having Theoden keep control of the attack, they shouldn't have bothered. It just broke up the scene. And by focusing on the elephants the battle was transformed in to a flashback to Star Wars. Where's an X-wing fighter when you need one? Also, Legolas' stunt with the elephant was absolutely ridiculous. I only thought his jumping up on the horse in an absolutely physically impossible way was bad, but the jumping all over the mumakil's legs was too much. What was he supposed to be holding on to? Arrows stuck in the elephant's skin? um....no.

And the clencher. My scene. MY SCENE. My scene that had every chance of completely dominating the screen because it's the coolest thing ever. It could have been. So. Much. More. The dialogue was altered- which I was expecting, but I wasn't expecting to have it completely robbed of its power. And not only was it altered, but it was out of sync. Eowyn doesn't remove her helmet until after Merry has stabbed the Nazgul, what is with that? It ruins the entire premise of the scene, that she's doing this because she's a woman. And the elephant corpse kind of ruined things for me, too. And where was the cloud of darkness? And WHY DIDN'T THE NAZGUL'S FREAKING HEAD COME OFF? WHERE WERE THE FLAMES FOR EYES? WHY DID THE NAZGUL LOOK LIKE BLOODY EVIL EMPEROR ZURG JUNIOR?
Rhi is Not Happy.

And following that, Eowyn just gets left at Pelennor at we skip to Aragorn in Minas Tirith. Eh? Where was Eomer's big scene? So Aragorn (who, now that he's king, is suddenly not-sexy; I'm not sure how this happened. Maybe it was the beard. He should totally have stuck witht he sexy stubble) takes his army to the Black Gate(s), they stand in a little group in front of it and...let the bad guys come out and surround them. Oh yeah, that's bloody brilliant. Good move, Aragorn.

And, of course, there is no mention of the fact that Eowyn and Faramir fall in love except they smile at each other during the coronation (which featured Aragorn's corny touchy-feely speech- yawn- and Arwen hiding behind a banner in an icky seafoam green colored dress). Other travesties include Elrond showing up in Rohan and the bizarre close up as he whips Aragorn's brand-spanking new sword out- a cinematic mistake if I ever saw one- no sign whatsoever of Saruman, and the Paths of the Dead.

The Paths of the Dead REALLY sucked. They were freaking green. And glowy. And the entire sequence gave me Indiana Jones flashbacks crossed with the Haunted House ride at Disneyland. Eeeeew. They sucked rocks. They sucked dead bears. They seriously and deeply sucked.

And, of course, we were introduced to a few new Middle Earth Products- In addition to the Gandalf Top (not for children under three), the Dark Lord Eye Drops (Are your eyes inflamed? Are they constantly red? Do they look evil and sinister?), and the Lembas Bread (as seen on TV, endorsed by Orlando Bloom!), we have Galadriel's Insect Repellant and the Sauron Spotlight. The phial was cool, however, while the Sauron Spotlight was...not. It was one of the most gruesome travesties of a special effect ever.


THINGS I LIKED-

Yes, I did like some things. I liked Eowyn's scene with Theoden before they left Rohan. I liked Faramir- it was a huge relief to be able to be on Faramir's side. Not being able to root for Faramir was one of the worst things about the last movie. And (since Aragorn wasn't even hot in this movie), my affections are totally transferred to Wenham. My favorite part of the movie was- you guessed it- the five seconds of Eowyn and Faramir standing next to each other. And (I'm a purist, but not purist enough to be incensed over the lack of the Scouring, because frankly I don't like that part of the book. I can appreciate it, but I don't like it because it's painful and sad and I don't read it as often as the rest of it) I loved the scenes in the Shire. At least we got one wedding! And the Havens were excellent, except for Celeborn- where the heck do you think you're going?

So overall I thought it sucked. But I'm going to put off going and ripping PJ's entrails out until the EE comes out.

Amazing how much energy you put into not liking this film.

Lotho
 
Lotho_Pimple said:
Amazing how much energy you put into not liking this film.

Lotho

I'm a person of extremes- I do nothing halfway.

As for accepting Legolas' impossible stunts because LotR is a fantasy, there is a line where the believably impossible crosses over in to the merely impossible. As a movie goer I am jolted out of the world of the film when a guy walks up the leg of an elephant in a way that I am not by a guy walking on the surface of packed snow. And an explanation is given for that; it was his shoes that made the difference, not his gravity. The other men were wearing heavy boots.
 
Rhiannon said:
there is a line where the believably impossible crosses over in to the merely impossible. As a movie goer I am jolted out of the world of the film when a guy walks up the leg of an elephant in a way that I am not by a guy walking on the surface of packed snow. And an explanation is given for that; it was his shoes that made the difference, not his gravity. The other men were wearing heavy boots.

How is it that when it happens in a book you're not bothered, but when it's put into a movie you are? I would think that if something strikes you as illogical or impossible, it would strike you no matter from which of the two media it came.

Lotho
 
Just seen ROTK, left cinema feeling better than TTT. What a relief!!

Quick review...

Pacing of movie a little rushed. It was always imposible to fit everything in that amount of time, which at first glance appears ample, yet again the cinema release will benefit from the EE.

Last hour of movie in particular very close to book, which is a very good thing!

Smeagol intro a nice touch

Cinematography awesome, as u come to expect.

Frodo/Sam confrontation totally STUPID, why PJ did u do this??? I love this section when the hobbits are approaching Cirith Ungol, and what happens to them in the book. For some reason PJ destroyed it for me.

No shots of Sam with/using Ring.

As Lotho said in earlier post, the EE will smoothe a few things out and slow down some.

Minas Morgul-where Sauron's orcs leave, and their crossing into Osgiliath fantastic!! Powerful vision!

Legolas and his incredible agility WAY WAY OVERDONE!!! Although Gimli comment after L slay the Oliphant was his one genuine GOOD "funny" line

Minas Tirith looked very impressive, wish they would have explained about how each level of the 7 tier kingdom has its gates on opposing sides.. Anyone else think that??

Mt doom great.

The eagles coming was well done.

Denethor a little too crazy, yet the tension between himself and Faramir was good.

Gandalf, what the ****. G seemed to lose the plot a few times, hesitant on advice and almost gave up hope toward the quest.

Grey Havens wonderful, moving part for me, as it was when I read LOTR.

Riders of ROhan march and subsequent attack was well done.
------------------------------------------------------------

Overall on par with FOTR as a cinema release, but much improved when comapred to TTT. Will see ROTK again several times, post a more thorough review later.

Looking forward already to the EE.
See ya HH :p
 
How is it that when it happens in a book you're not bothered, but when it's put into a movie you are? I would think that if something strikes you as illogical or impossible, it would strike you no matter from which of the two media it came.
What makes you think I am not bothered by illogical events in books? It depends on the environment of the books- Patricia McKillip often writes about thoroughly illogical, magic events, but they suit the environment of the story and do not bother me. The Lord of the Rings, on the other hand, while being fantastic is still grounded in a strong sense of realism- the characters get tired and dirty and crabby, and it takes weeks to get an army moving, and there is a vast amount of history and depth to the world. This is a real world- not a world such as the one we live in, an older, more noble world, but still real. Legolas walking on snow is an acceptable fantastic element in this real world. Legolas waltzing up the side of an elephant, however, is not.
 
Rhiannon said:
Legolas walking on snow is an acceptable fantastic element in this real world. Legolas waltzing up the side of an elephant, however, is not.

Why not? What if it had been in LOTR, would you have accepted it then? Where do the rules stop and start with you? Why is one acceptable and the other not?

And, it ISN'T a real world, it's Tolkien's fantasy! He had an inner sense of what was and wasn't possible, but I doubt if he was conscious of it or sat down and codified it somewhere — Christopher Tolkien most likely would have published it way before now. So if we have no idea of what "Tolkien's Laws of Reality" were, I can say beyond fear of contradiction that they may have included elves walking up elephants, even though he never wrote of it's happening.:)

Lotho
 
Hehe. First of all guys, if anything I say has already been said, I'm just going to repeat it, because frankly after reading the seventh page of reviews I just got a little bit bored. They were all interesting, though! :)

IAN MCKELLEN WAS FANTASTICALLY BRILLIANTLY AWESOME! HE IS THE BEST ACTOR IN THE WORLD! AND I MEAN THAT!!!!! HE DESERVES AND OSCAR FOR HIS PERFORMANCE! HE ACTS BETTER THAN RIVALDO!

I find it extremely difficult to either like it or not like it. I thought that blatant and sometimes quite infuriating plot deviations were countered with moments of incredible poignancy, intense and exciting battle scenes and wonderful visual effects.

I'm going to write the things I didn't like first so I can end on a good note, because IMO the movies certainly did. So don't get bored and cynical and just assume that this post is just another semi-purist being pedantic, OK? These were the things I didn't like:

Arwen's fate being tied the the Ring. That is just a really really really really stupid thing. I talked to my sister (who hasn't read the books) after the movie, and she said that it didn't even make sense to her, so we who have read the books know how ludicrous it is. Elrond was just kind of like,

"Hi there Aragorn. Just came to give you this ridiculously over-sized novelty sword. Oh, and become King. And also go and take the the path that no living man may tread. Oh yeah, and your girlfriend's dying. Hope everything works out! See ya 'round! Actually, no, I probably won't, you're most likely going to die, too. Bye!"

I didn't like those big dinosaur things. What the hell was the point of even putting them in? They were just kind of there for one scene, and then they were gone, and we didn't see the point of them. I guess PJ was editting the movie, and he came to a sudden realisation: "Hey, we haven't filled our quota for plot deviations for this movie! Quick, let's put in another one! Let's think...what can we do?...I know! I great big dinosaur thing!"

I didn't really like Gollum's framing of Sam with the Lembas bread. A bit petty it was, really. I think Shelob was not good, though. She should have been bulkier in the body, and skinnier in the legs, like in the illustration by Alan Lee.

But I did like the sequence with Frodo vs. Shelob and Frodo vs. Gollum in the Lair, and I did like how Sam came back and saved the day.

I loved the short scenes in the Tower of Cirith Ungol. They were very true to the book, except for the fact that Sam didn't use the Phial of Galadriel against the Watchers. But I have a feeling that it'll be in the EE. Then again, it's going to be difficult to bring across on screen that the Watchers have a will.

I didn't really like the Dead People. They should not have been glowing, and they should have been less opaque. But I did like how they held true to the legend that Isildur cursed them - I was afraid that they would leave that out.

What I am most delighted about are the number of lines taken directly from the book. I loved Gandalf's scene with Pippin when the Orcs are about to break in, and he talk about dying (going to the Blessed Realm).....("a far green country under a swift sunrise"....beautiful)

I loved Pippin's song - Billy Boyd really has a great voice!

Denethor was really gross though in that scene with all that grape juice or whatever it was spilling out of his mouth. Blargh! I didn't really like Denethor - his madness seemed to be already on him when Gandalf and Pippin first came to see him, and he didn't really show any kindness or dignity of nobility at all.

I laughed hysterically when Denethor was yelling about how the Line of the Stewards was ended:

"My line is ended! My line is ended! Death tak --- THWACK! THUNK! CRACK!"
(OK so they aren't the exact lines from the movies but hey)

That was hilarious.

Speaking of hilarious, I loved how Merry and Pippin were drunk and smoking at the Flotsam and Jetsam of Isengard. That was so funny! :D

I really liked the palantir scene. It was fantastic the way Legolas said "he is here" when he felt the presence of Sauron through the Stone. Even though it looked a bit stupid with everyone tossing around the Eye of Sauron ("Here, you have it! No you have it!"), I think it was generally done quite well. Gandalf sleeping with his eyes open was funny. As someone else mentioned, it was silly how Aragorn couldn't control the palantir when he wrenched it from Pippin.

I can understand that they had to change the Mount Doom scene, scene but I think they should have made it that Frodo threw Gollum into the chasm rather than them having a Gandalf-Mufasa-Scar scene...I thought it was cool how Frodo's hand was too bloody to grab Sam's hand though - it provided a good reason for why it not just a "give me your hand and I'll pull you up" situation.

I am glad that they didn't spend a long time on the Battle of the Pelennor Fields. I think it would have just been boring - it would have left too long for Legolas to single-handedly climb to the pinnacle of the White Tower, jump off and do some cool karate move that would chop Grond in half or something.

Speaking of Grond, I thought he was awesome! I loved how the Orcs were chanting "Grond! Grond! Grond!" when it was nearing the Gate.

I thought the confrontation with the Witck-king was really well done, but I thought they ruined Eowyn's line by turning it into "I will kill you if you touch him" rather than "I will smight you if you touch him".

What really was a mistake was leaving out Eomer for so much of it. They should have put in the scene that's in the trailer with Eomer holding (I suppose) Eowyn. I hope this scene will be in the EE.

I very much liked the Shire scenes. I can fully understand how anti-climactic it would be if the ruffians had been in the Shire when they got back. So I can excuse PJ for that.

Probably my favourite scene (it's in the top two with the Gandy / Pippin one I mentioned above) is the Grey Havens. Although I was rather disappointed that there was no Cirdan (as there was in the FotR), I thought that the visuals of the place were wonderful. Every light and colour mingled into a scene that was incredibly beautiful and serene. It just seemed so Elvish. I loved it. The water was rich, and the building were very natural and well.........Elvish, really.

And what a travesty it would have been if they hadn't ended the movie with "Well, I'm back." And so I shall end this post.
 
Lotho_Pimple said:
Why not? What if it had been in LOTR, would you have accepted it then? Where do the rules stop and start with you? Why is one acceptable and the other not?
This is kind of a silly question, since my whole point is that is wasn't in the book, and did not fit within the world of the book. The rules stop and start with what Tolkien wrote [insert flashing red lights reading 'Purist alert! Purist alert!'].
And, it ISN'T a real world, it's Tolkien's fantasy! He had an inner sense of what was and wasn't possible, but I doubt if he was conscious of it or sat down and codified it somewhere — Christopher Tolkien most likely would have published it way before now. So if we have no idea of what "Tolkien's Laws of Reality" were, I can say beyond fear of contradiction that they may have included elves walking up elephants, even though he never wrote of it's happening.:)

Lotho
Tolkien's world was real in the sense that he gave it a depth of detail and specificity- he went to great pains to make it real- and since he based it on our world we can assume that, with some exceptions, the same limitations apply. It is rational for a light footed person to walk on heavy snow. It is realistically possible. It is not rational for anyone, even a light footed person, to climb up the side of a rampaging elephant.
 

Today's events

Back
Top