• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Tolkien Artwork

Also for this again 2 alternatives:

Ted Nasmith:
TN-A_Song_in_The_Trollshaws.jpg


Although I have a high regard for Nasmith, I don't like this one as much.
Alan Lee does it better:

Alan-Lee-s-illustration-jrr-tolkien-34057247-964-1600.jpg
 
Do you mean some differences in pronunciation?
Yes, there used to be some differences in dialect and culture that made communication somewhat difficult. In modern times, hardly any more, especially not in the cities. But the cliché has remained and people on both sides like to make fun of it.

I definitely like dialects, and there are a lot of them in Germany. At the same time, unfortunately, they are disappearing faster and faster. The younger generations hardly speak any dialect anymore.
I only came up with this because the hobbits somehow remind me of the former Bavarian rural population, similar to how - as originally intended by Tolkien - they were supposed to reflect an idealized, English rural population from times past. They are down-to-earth, work a lot (if by chance they haven't inherited a dragon treasure), but also value comfort and coziness, good beer and like to party. And are hardly interested in what's going on outside their borders.
 
Yes, there used to be some differences in dialect and culture that made communication somewhat difficult. In modern times, hardly any more, especially not in the cities. But the cliché has remained and people on both sides like to make fun of it.

I definitely like dialects, and there are a lot of them in Germany. At the same time, unfortunately, they are disappearing faster and faster. The younger generations hardly speak any dialect anymore.
I only came up with this because the hobbits somehow remind me of the former Bavarian rural population, similar to how - as originally intended by Tolkien - they were supposed to reflect an idealized, English rural population from times past. They are down-to-earth, work a lot (if by chance they haven't inherited a dragon treasure), but also value comfort and coziness, good beer and like to party. And are hardly interested in what's going on outside their borders.
Thanks for explaining! That's really interesting.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top