- Joined
- Apr 9, 2018
- Messages
- 11,496
Not a derailment at all. Looking forward to seeing the example you provide after that tasty second breakfast (or whichever meal it may be.)Sorry about the derailment, Eljorahir. 😢
If one has to search and dig contort words and phrases to show an "association of imagery" , I'm going to say "it ain't there".I'm not disagreeing with you either, necessarily; sometimes a flower is only a flower. I'm saying only that some of the associations we make really are intended, and some of the meanings we see really are "meant".
I can give a couple of examples of the "association of imagery", but that will have to wait a bit; right now it's time for pancakes, corned beef hash, and coffee. In the meantime, you might find this relevant (or at least amusing 😄):
As you can see, Mr. O also comes down on the "skeptical" side of the question.The "Rule of Threes" As a Structural Principle in Tolkien
I'd noticed the occurrence of groups of threes in a casual way, over the years, but a couple of things caused me to take a closer look. One was Douglas Anderson's note on Bilbo's "third time pays for all" in The Annotated Hobbit, where he says it is a Medieval proverb, and gives a quote from a...thetolkien.forum
Sorry about the derailment, Eljorahir. 😢
Oh, I certainly believe any author (good, bad, mediocre) will unconsciously make associations, in addition, of course, to conscious ones.OK, I agree with you there too, as far as the "obscurity" or otherwise of the words in the list being compiled here; many of them are far from obscure, and the average educated reader will be familiar with most of them. Even the use of obsolete or archaic terms or definitions is nothing new -- it's been a feature of romance writing going back to Homer. One example that came up on another thread is "wain", which apparently passed out of general use around 1600, but was still being used by the Romance poets in the 19th century.
Still, I'm finding this list interesting and useful. Citing just "will-o'-the'wisp", that set us off here, I'd forgotten the use in Moria. Perhaps we've been talking past each other, especially about "associations"; what I mean is that repeating images in different contexts can cause the reader to make connections between those contexts. Maybe those connections aren't "really" there, maybe they are. Maybe they weren't intended by the author, maybe they were. It's fact, not invention, that the image appears in scenes where the party is being led in darkness through a place of danger, and further, in both cases, being led toward a "monster". The circumstances are different, yes, but the parallels are striking-- at least to me.
Weird/Wyrd and Doom are two sides of the same coin.While perusing the list I came across this one and remembered our recent discussion about doom and fate. Here's another synonym for fate (even stranger sounding than doom.) I thought you might find it interesting.
weird The Fall of Gondolin, The Original Tale: “And Ulmo said: ‘O Tuor of the lonely heart…fare now on thy destined journey and tarry not, for far from hence is thy weird set.’”, [Definition: fate, destiny.]
Shakespeare called the the Three Witches on the heath the Weird Sisters....
Shakespeare had some influence upon “Weird” meaning “Odd” via MacBeth (The Son of Life/Birth), in that the Norns as they appear are referenced as the “Weird” of Macbeth, where their appearance was suggested to be “Strange” or ”Odd” or “unknowable” and shifting constantly, as would a person’s “Fate” as they made different choices in the Judaeo-Christian conception of “Fate/Doom/Weird.”
Which, not unsurprisingly, is the conception and definition that Tolkien would choose.
MB
(My own edit)Shakespeare called the the Three Witches on the heath the Weird Sisters.
They were certainly odd, but they also predicted the fate of Macbeth (I, iii) to become Thane of Glamis, Thane of Cawdor, and King.
Cf. the apparitions they showed him (IV, i):
an Armed Head ("beware Macduff"),
a Bloody Child ("...none born of woman shall harm thee...")***
a Child Crowned, [holding] a tree [branch] in his hand ("...Macbeth shall never vanquished be until Great Birnam Wood... shall come against him.")
*** Tolkien borrowed this prophecy (modified) to bring about the destruction of the Witch King at the hands of Eowyn and Merry
I thought you already did "rowan"....Today's triumvirate includes a twain of botanicals collected along the path to Gondolin:
View attachment 22043
Whin (aka: gorse, ulex, or furze)
View attachment 22044
Mature European rowan tree
welter The Fall of Gondolin, The Last Version (Tuor and Voronwe come upon the ruins of the fair pool of Ivrin): “All now was but a welter of frozen mire, and a reek of decay lay like a foul mist upon the ground.”, [Definition: a chaotic mass or jumble.]
whin The Fall of Gondolin, The Last Version: “Desperately he stumbled and crept forward with Voronwe at his side, up a long slope deep in whin and whortleberry among knots of rowan and low birch.”, [Definition: a spiny yellow-flowered European shrub of the legume family.]
rowan The Fall of Gondolin, The Last Version: “Desperately he stumbled and crept forward with Voronwe at his side, up a long slope deep in whin and whortleberry among knots of rowan and low birch.”, [Definition: mountain ash shrubs or trees (of the rose family).]
I think it was only you who mentioned Rowan and Martin along with Funk and Wagnel in one of the refreshing "comedic interlude" portions of our thread. 😁I thought you already did "rowan"....
I think I could talk him down to only enveloping my ears (a lesser punishment). My inferior dictionary did include a more generic definition for triumvirate: a group of three persons or things having something in common.He would have boxed your ears.
I did look up triumvirate prior to making my post, and did see more or less the same "multi-definition".I think it was only you who mentioned Rowan and Martin along with Funk and Wagnel in one of the refreshing "comedic interlude" portions of our thread. 😁
Side note: I was quite pleased when I noticed we had both wain and garth on the list. Now that we have rowan I'm really really hoping to find a martin somewhere in the stories (maybe someone mentions the bird along the way.) Common bird or not...it will be listed!
When I listed ken, I thought: wouldn't it be great if I could only find a barbi or barby somewhere? Still keeping my eyes peeled. Maybe someone could admonish Mr. Grima: "Begone from my sight! Thou speakest with barbied tongue."
I think I could talk him down to only enveloping my ears (a lesser punishment). My inferior dictionary did include a more generic definition for triumvirate: a group of three persons or things having something in common.
Admittedly, I should have left out the welter and substituted whortleberry.
Ah yes... the great difficulty with language.they conveyed the precise meaning that he needed;
Very well explained. Thank you. It would seem my just weird is to have my ears boxed. 😀I did look up triumvirate prior to making my post, and did see more or less the same "multi-definition".
But here is my objection to that (and I will bet our friend, the Prof, would have the same objection):
When a definition for a word starts "mutating" (usually due to misuse) then in short order the word is lost to the use for which it was originally intended.
Let me use an example (and it is a religious one, but it illustrates the problem very well. And my thanks to CS Lewis for first discussing this).
There is the word "Christian" which meant (and still does mean) a follower of Christ; that is, a person who believes all the claims made by Christ as recorded in the Bible. Not just someone who believes in his teachings , but a person who believes everything...his divinity, his resurrection , all the miracles., etc
However, there are folks who will say of a person they know that "he is a very Christian person", despite the fact that the person in question doesn't believe Christian doctrine at all, and may in fact be an atheist.
What you finally DO figure out (having asked the folks who said it to be more explicit) is that they mean the person has a lot of the good qualities of character that Christians have (or are at least supposed to have/practice).
But there are already two perfectly useful and accurate words that describe such a person: good and virtuous.
A pagan (a non-believer) can be just as good and virtuous as a [good] Christian but not believe any doctrines specific to Christianity.
So if my friend says someone is a good person or a virtuous person, then I know with certainty what he is saying of this third person ( and I would probably trust him [the third person] without having even met him.)
But if my friend says this other person is a good Christian (when he only means that the person is good/ virtuous) then my friend has actually confused the situation, by applying a word, Christian (that has a specific meaning) to a person who is not Christian at all.
And to make matters worse, he has made useless the ONE WORD that is needed to describe a follower of Christ, because he has used Christian to mean virtuous, using them interchangeably.
So I now ask my friend what is the word to describe a follower of the Biblical Christ, and he replies: Christian.
And then I ask him what word he just used to describe that third person in question--whom he knows is not a Christian--- who is good, virtuous person, and he says: Christian.
But then he goes on to explain what he means by using "Christian", yet making the word now useless for what it originally meant, because you can't tell if the person he talking about is really a Christian or not.
Further clarifications and explanations of what one means would be unnecessary if one just used the accurate word for the situation.
So ... triumvirate.....A government of three men, originally used in ancient Rome.
So I use "triumvirate" as "oh yeah, that government was a triumvirate", and someone who has been exposed to the mutated form thinks: a government of three...what?... three parts? Like the US government?"
No, three men (I have to explain), all equally sharing power.
But now the word "triumvirate" which originally described the aforesaid government has been made useless.
And if I want to describe the government of ancient Rome I have to say "A government with three men sharing equal power" which is a whole lot more words (8 to be exact) than the ONE word that says it all: triumvirate.
Which leads me to Tolkien using archaic words...
Did you ever consider the possibility maybe he used those archaic words because they conveyed the precise meaning that he needed; and didn't use a more modern term that at one time would have conveyed the same meaning, but through mis-usage has mutated to the point that it would only confuse the reader?
He was, after all, a philologist...😉
Once boxed, Ent has the shipping label handy..!to have my ears boxed
Do you think jet and malachite really need to be on the list, they are fairly common words.Today’s treat. A trio of tantalizing trinkets and Tolkien terms:
(I always thought chalcedony sounded like a word Tolkien invented for the poem. It makes such a beautiful rhyme. Now I know it's a real word.)
View attachment 22092
A malachite vase at the Hermitage Museum, St. Petersburg
View attachment 22093
Jet mourning jewelry, 19th Century
View attachment 22094
Chalcedony cameo of Titus head, 2nd Century AD
malachite The Fall of Gondolin, The Last Version (Tuor and Voronwe approach the Fifth Gate): “…but above the Gate upon the midmost globe stood an image of the White Tree Telperion, wrought of silver and malachite, with flowers made of great pearls of Balar.”, [Definition: a green mineral that is a basic carbonate of copper.]
jet Farewell to Lorien (The Fellowship sees Galadriel and Celeborn’s swan boat): “It’s beak shone like burnished gold, and its eyes glinted like jet set in yellow stones; its huge white wings were half lifted.”, [Definition: a black or dark brown lignite gemstone derived from wood that has changed under extreme pressure.]
chalcedony Many Meetings (Bilbo chants his song of Earendil in the Hall of Fire): “…his arrows shorn of ebony…his scabbard of chalcedony…”, [Definition: a translucent variety of quartz of various colors and waxy luster.]
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Are you happy to accept cookies and these technologies?