Top several strongest characters of ME-good guys

[Elthir]

I'll mentally add Galadriel.

So you're not using Qenta Noldorinwa as it stands? Or do I misread the QS part?

 

[m4r35n357]

The chapters on Beren & Luthien, Turin, Gondolin, Fall of Doriath and the start of Earendil are the only bits of Quenta taken from the QN (HoME 4). Everything else is QS (HoME 5). In fact the QN version of Gondolin is partially marked up in line with QS and the Later Annals of Beleriand, (ie changed to have Gondolin already existing before Unnumbered Tears)!

 

[Elthir]

Ah. I see. But we have Galadriel in what I call QS1 (early 50s) . . . so maybe I still don't see?

Just wondering by the way. Not arguing about anything.

Wait. The QS1 part of your post is gone!

 

[m4r35n357]

You are right about Galadriel appearing in the early 50s; I mentioned the Annals of Aman which were about the same time as QS1. The point was that "my" Quenta (no Galadriel) is QS from HoME 5 filled in with bits of QN from HoME 4, not QS1 or QS2 from HoME 10/11. Hope that is all cleared up now

 

[Elthir]

Yep. Got it now!

Now add at least one sentence about Galadriel or I swear I'll finish all the chocolate cake in my fridge!

 

[m4r35n357]

Yeah I made a pigs ear of the explanation. I edited it, but decided another post would be a lot clearer.

Save the cake, I also have a "side version" that mentions her by name as the sister along with Finrod's (sic!) sons. That version also contains a "version" of the Fall of Numenor, and "Fingon sends his son Gilgalad to the havens" (one sentence from the Grey Annals).

 

[Elthir]

You mean Gil-galad son of Arothir son of Angrod

I'm eating this 🎂

 

[m4r35n357]

Since you did not claim him to be son of Felagund (with all the collateral damage that would cause), I will not begrudge you the cake

 

[Elthir]

I assume you mean Inglor Felagund sorry I can't stop. I'm sugared-up on cake.

But we did bring up Gil-galad . . . maybe he can go on the list somewhere?

 

[m4r35n357]

Yes, Inglor the Faithful of course! I much prefer that name, one less Fin* to remember

As to the topic, my votes go to Fingolfin, Luthien, Hurin and Turin.

[EDIT] Oh, and of course the Darwin Award goes to Feanor

 

[Jorlan Elükar]

Of the Hobbits:
Bilbo
Merry
Pippin
Sam
Frodo

 

[Hisoka Morrow]

Of the Hobbits:
Bilbo
Merry
Pippin
Sam
Frodo

Oh, yes, I even forgot these horrible bad ass, some of them even could teach Shelob a lesson.