Flammifer
Dagnir-en-Ancalagon
- Joined
- Jun 14, 2003
- Messages
- 515
This may sound quite ignorant to some people but after reading the Silmarillion and obviously LOTR I've found no conclusive evidence that the Istari were Maiar, unless the answer to this is in UT or Letters or something!
I know that Gandalf's name was Olorin in the uttermost West, and that Olorin was the wisest Maiar, but due to the history in Tolkien's works of giving characters names that have been used before, could this not just be a coincedence? Also, in a very reliable source, Robert Foster's The Complete Guide to Middle-earth, it says that Olorin is not conclusively the same as Gandalf!
It says "He may have been a Maia", but is there any conclusive evidence? Surely with a character of such great importance, if Tolkien wanted his readers to know what Gandalf was he would have made it blatantly obvious?!?
I have used Gandalf as an example as he is the most well-known of the Istari and we have the most information on him, and I am assuming that all the Istari were of the same sort also.
P.S. I don't wish to sound blashpemous or anything, because personally I want Gandalf to be a Maia, albeit one of less power than Sauron, but I just wondered bout it!
I know that Gandalf's name was Olorin in the uttermost West, and that Olorin was the wisest Maiar, but due to the history in Tolkien's works of giving characters names that have been used before, could this not just be a coincedence? Also, in a very reliable source, Robert Foster's The Complete Guide to Middle-earth, it says that Olorin is not conclusively the same as Gandalf!
It says "He may have been a Maia", but is there any conclusive evidence? Surely with a character of such great importance, if Tolkien wanted his readers to know what Gandalf was he would have made it blatantly obvious?!?
I have used Gandalf as an example as he is the most well-known of the Istari and we have the most information on him, and I am assuming that all the Istari were of the same sort also.
P.S. I don't wish to sound blashpemous or anything, because personally I want Gandalf to be a Maia, albeit one of less power than Sauron, but I just wondered bout it!

