Originally posted by spelling master
you are kidding me right??? we have a baby darth vader in episode 1 not only knowing everything about the universe, obviously having been conceived by immaculate conception (sic), but is being seduced by an girl 15 years his senior. good for the xmas season dontcha think, with mums and das buying the ship models and games
knows everything about the universe ??, he's a 9 year old boy who says "he wants to be the first one to visit all the planets", he's yearning for adventure and seems to think becoming a jedi & leaving his planet will grant him that, hence the dissappointment & mood he gets growing up
& PLEASE tell me how Padme is seducing him in Episode 1, if you think she is flirting in the Phantom Menace you are a very sick sick man, & she is 5 years older than him - not 15
did you even see the movie ??
and the princess, in ep2 gets her gear ripped off to reveal a sports top, which might as well have NIKE written all over it...of course no one gets a scratch. dont even remind of the love seranade at the fireside.
no one gets a scratch ?? what do you mean by that ?, she has 3 scars on her back - Anakin get his arm chopped off - ObiWan gets his arm & thigh pierced - dozens of Jedi die - Jango gets beheaded - Anakins mom is seen tortured & dying - Anakin slaughters a village
have you even seen the movie ??
and then we have the ridiculous yoda doing jujtisu with the lightsabre. and we are talking about a wise old yoda, He might train yedis, but i doubt he would have hurt a fly, much less act as a warmonger.
his most beloved student & the chosen one were getting their a-s-s-es kicked, he had little choice but to fight, & look closely, he NEVER attacks Dooku he just holds him off, plus he doesn't participate in the war, he gives the clones advice while the rest of the jedi fight
have you even seen the movie ??
yes Lucas has borrowed themes to fit his movies, but to call that "ripping" them off is just ridiculous, it's a basic fairytale story he took for a New Hope & he expanded it with his own creativity. Even Lord of the Rings has borrowed from common mythology
I suggest you actually pay attention to the movies when watching them, "no plot" & "no themes" ?? c'mon now
and Ewan McGregor, Liam Neeson,
Sam Jackson, Iam McDiarmid, Hayden Christenson and Christopher Lee gave bad performances or are bad actors ?? mesa no think so(i'll give you Natalie Portman, but she's a senator & has been all her life so she had to be stale in some parts, same with some Jedi)
i agree on the Jackson part, it's pretty obvious he got overwhelmed & i think he doesn't even notice it or he simply doesn't care
But point is, Lucas and Jackson(well, Lucas moreso than Jackson) don't even need the money. So call them out on bad writing, directing whatever makes sense(everybody is entitled to their opinion) but "money-over-art" is a pretty bold statement to use so lightly. Especcially when their movies(the Star Warses & LOTR) aren't even remotely following the "popular" guidelines set by millenium films by Quentin Tarantino or the Wachowskis, but take a more "classic" approach to the storytelling(like it or not).