• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

What happened - and why

Originally posted by Blue Wizard
1. Except for a single quote where Jackson states he would stay true to the books you have nothing to go on.
2. Jackson legally had every right to do what he has done.
ONE quotation? PJ centred the whole enormous lead-up to the making of the films on them being "true" to the books!
Then he devoted huge resources to making physical details "true" to the books - though he seems not to have read the books properly in some matters, such as hobbit feet!
It seems reasonable to expect everything else to be equally "true".
Where does the law come into it?! By this reasoning he could have forgotten about the JRRT books altogether.
 
Originally posted by joxy
ONE quotation? PJ centred the whole enormous lead-up to the making of the films on them being "true" to the books!
Then he devoted huge resources to making physical details "true" to the books - though he seems not to have read the books properly in some matters, such as hobbit feet!
It seems reasonable to expect everything else to be equally "true".
Where does the law come into it?! By this reasoning he could have forgotten about the JRRT books altogether.
This is not the first time that a book adaptation has been done and has not been true to the original. See?

Once the movie rights are sold, the person that bought the rights has the legal right to do "anything" he wants with the story. See?

Given that, you can blame Jackson till the cows come home, that's fine he is the most at fault, it doesn't change the fact that Hollywood only judges itself on one thing.

Money over art.
 
Originally posted by Blue Wizard
Given that, you can blame Jackson till the cows come home, that's fine he is the most at fault, it doesn't change the fact that Hollywood only judges itself on one thing.

Money over art.

It's not like PJ was held at sword-point by New Line!! He was making these movies outside of Hollywood, and was/is in control of what they will turn out like. Any pressure to comform to "money over art" had to be lessened once FOTR became such a critical and financial success. PJ turned from the book and more towards his own "ideas" because he wanted to.

Throwing up your hands and saying "Oh well, I don't like it, but that's just the way things are" is the kind of attitude that put Hitler in power! OK, being a little over-dramatic;) , but y'all get the picture. Why is it so bad to call someone on selling out? Art is important, and being an independant "film-maker", PJ should know that. Bad PJ!
 
Originally posted by Blue Wizard
This is not the first time that a book adaptation has been done and has not been true to the original. See?

Once the movie rights are sold, the person that bought the rights has the legal right to do "anything" he wants with the story. See?

Given that, you can blame Jackson till the cows come home, that's fine he is the most at fault, it doesn't change the fact that Hollywood only judges itself on one thing.

Money over art.
Excuse me, you keep saying "money over art". Please, oh please tell me why that is a problem in these films? What possibly suggests to anyone that remaining faithful to the book would have caused the films to be less popular and thereby lose money? Surely, Jackson sold the whole project to New Line on the basis of the popularity of Tolkien's book! How, therefore, can you equate faithfulness to the book with a loss of popularity and therefore, less revenue while making the case that Jackson's own inventions which deviate from the book will somehow insure more popularity and as a result, more money? I simply cannot see how anyone can make that connection no matter how many times it is presented.

If Tolkien's book was not enough, then why would New Line finance its adaptation to the screen? If, on the other hand, it was popular enough for New Line to finance three films, why was it necessary to change it (with the few exceptions necessitated by the change in medium)? Until someone can prove the assertion that faithfulness to the book would have caused the films to lose popularity and money, I shall reject this particular argument.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
Until someone can prove the assertion that faithfulness to the book would have caused the films to lose popularity and money, I shall reject this particular argument.
Yes, money over art.

It doesn't matter that you believe the popularity of the books would carry the movie. It only matters what Jackson believes. I have said that a hundred times and you have said nothing to refute it. You just keep hammering at the dark.

I am not arguing that the films couldn't have made money if they had been faithful to the book. I am arguing that Jackson believed they couldn't. And since in this instance his opinion is all that matters...............

And even if his opinion doesn't matter, he was the only one given the choice.

Money over art.
 
well, lucas has proven it... it is money over art...do they really need the extra 1 billion or two??

To be an artist is to suffer in poverty i guess

the second is more plausible though....

1. Jackson is completely incompetent.
2. lucas just ran out of creative juice.

The whole problem with the fiasco that is LOTR seems to be the director-by-committee approach....there is NO continuity in the storyline, it appears to be a whole mish-mash of ripped scenes from different movies.

with 10% population growth and the fall of the berlin wall and the rise of the asian tiger countries, all the hype would suck in the younger audience quite easily....notice, it all the actions films that have succeeded, matrix, Star wars.
 
Originally posted by spelling master
well, lucas has proven it... it is money over art...do they really need the extra 1 billion or two??

Thank you. Finally someone understood what I have been saying for months.

Thank you.
 
dont get too excited though....Lucas hasnt released any of the original on DVD, which shows some sort of integrity on his part (more to do with pirating probably) but still honorable...

jackson on the hand shows a complete lack of knowledge of use of the film medium.....i doubt he had much input in the CGI
 
also, referring back to the original post, i have to disagree that the director shouldnt re write the story, in many case they should.

case 1; arwen

PJ had to have a female lead (obvious); sword-waving from my perspective was not important cos we (the audience) would never get the full story on film, and many readers would miss the importance.

case 2; faramir
1. the defence of "noone can resist the ring" is complete indication that Jackson doesnt know the story, has no clue of his film flow and sequence.

case3: haldir

Prologue says its the "LAST" Alliance. enuff said.

case4: Saruman.

TTT is all about saruman and the Ents. Both NON-entities.

case5: the FULL MONTY or not?

is this a comedy or tragic brain implosion??? if you are gonna make a monty pythonesque version of LOTR then do so, but the half baked attempt is killing me....stick to what you are good at


Case 1 gives support for Pj to create as he wants, but all the other cases and more, show that PJ is rather skillless
 
Originally posted by spelling master
dont get too excited though....Lucas hasnt released any of the original on DVD, which shows some sort of integrity on his part (more to do with pirating probably) but still honorable...

jackson on the hand shows a complete lack of knowledge of use of the film medium.....i doubt he had much input in the CGI
I was wrong. I guess you didn't get it.
 
But you have not explained to me how you know that Jackson believed what you say that he did believe. He chose LOTR for his project on the strength of Tolkien's story. He spent years of effort and money to bring three films to the screen apparently on the basis of that story. Why on earth would he wish to change it so much (and so badly) given the above?

I understand that it is your opinion that he changed the story because he believed it would make more money, but his changes are senseless. He began to "build" the Arwen character into a warrior, but after the fords, he abandoned that aspect of the character and all that we have seen from her since the fords scene has been anything but "warrior like". Of course, from the editing of Helm's Deep to remove the lady's presence, he had obviously at one time thought about continuing along that line and then decided against it!

What you have here is a story in flux being changed willy-nilly as it goes along! Pray tell where does "money over art" come into that sort of situation? It appears as if Jackson is changing his mind about the story almost daily and this has been validated by actors who noted that scripts they learned on one day had been changed by the next day's shooting! If someone has made a hard choice to change something on the basis of a belief that the original will not be sufficiently profitable but will require extensive rewriting, then surely all of that should have been settled before the project began! It should not be a "work in progress" during the filming of the story! No, I believe what has happened here is no so much a matter of "money over art" (in which case Jackson's new story would have at least made sense!) but simply a matter of one man's ego causing him to bite off more than he could chew.

Of course, these films will make gobs of money and gain all sorts of critical acclaim, but eventually their lack of cohesion (which will be blamed on the complexities of Tolkien's story) will become all too painfully obvious and I predict that the ultimate assessment in years to come was that, good though they were, they fell short of what they could have been.
 
If you think Lucas is choosing money over art based on his new films, then where were you when the old movies were released ??

there really is no difference between the movies save for the storyline & actors, it also can't be merchandise because we all know WE were buying those starships back then

Even with his approach to the story, he has kept it simple & "unpopular" just like he did with Empire & Jedi.

If he would really have preferred money over art, we would already have Darth Vader in Episode 1 killing Jedi off in bullettime while Senator Palpatine(who becomes the Emperor mind you) would use his lightning on random bystanders with rock or rapmusic playing in the background. But he didn't, instead he has chosen again for a kind of oldfashioned storytelling that comes off cheesy but gets the job done.

I don't even really see PJ as a "sellout", i think he just doesn't believe in Tolkiens story as us "purists" do. Wich is his right of course but why make the Lord of the Rings movies if you don't want to make Lord of the Rings movies i ask.

And i don't see how anyone can equate the use of CGI to all of this.
 
Originally posted by Sephiroth
If he would really have preferred money over art, we would already have Darth Vader in Episode 1 killing Jedi off in bullettime while Senator Palpatine(who becomes the Emperor mind you) would use his lightning on random bystanders with rock or rapmusic playing in the background. But he didn't, instead he has chosen again for a kind of oldfashioned storytelling that comes off cheesy but gets the job done.


you are kidding me right??? we have a baby darth vader in episode 1 not only knowing everything about the universe, obviously having been conceived by immaculate conception (sic), but is being seduced by an girl 15 years his senior. good for the xmas season dontcha think, with mums and das buying the ship models and games

and the princess, in ep2 gets her gear ripped off to reveal a sports top, which might as well have NIKE written all over it...of course no one gets a scratch. dont even remind of the love seranade at the fireside.

and then we have the ridiculous yoda doing jujtisu with the lightsabre. and we are talking about a wise old yoda, He might train yedis, but i doubt he would have hurt a fly, much less act as a warmonger.

What Lucas did was rip an old Hindu story for the original trilogy, and had good actors in alec guiness and harrison ford to carry a thin plot....

in the prequels he had no plot, no themes to call on, and his choice of actors sucked.

Jackson on the other hand, had a great story and just had NO clue what he was doing with it.....the story overwhelmed[\b] the poor guy, and he got lost
 
Originally posted by spelling master
you are kidding me right??? we have a baby darth vader in episode 1 not only knowing everything about the universe, obviously having been conceived by immaculate conception (sic), but is being seduced by an girl 15 years his senior. good for the xmas season dontcha think, with mums and das buying the ship models and games


knows everything about the universe ??, he's a 9 year old boy who says "he wants to be the first one to visit all the planets", he's yearning for adventure and seems to think becoming a jedi & leaving his planet will grant him that, hence the dissappointment & mood he gets growing up

& PLEASE tell me how Padme is seducing him in Episode 1, if you think she is flirting in the Phantom Menace you are a very sick sick man, & she is 5 years older than him - not 15

did you even see the movie ??

and the princess, in ep2 gets her gear ripped off to reveal a sports top, which might as well have NIKE written all over it...of course no one gets a scratch. dont even remind of the love seranade at the fireside.

no one gets a scratch ?? what do you mean by that ?, she has 3 scars on her back - Anakin get his arm chopped off - ObiWan gets his arm & thigh pierced - dozens of Jedi die - Jango gets beheaded - Anakins mom is seen tortured & dying - Anakin slaughters a village

have you even seen the movie ??

and then we have the ridiculous yoda doing jujtisu with the lightsabre. and we are talking about a wise old yoda, He might train yedis, but i doubt he would have hurt a fly, much less act as a warmonger.

his most beloved student & the chosen one were getting their a-s-s-es kicked, he had little choice but to fight, & look closely, he NEVER attacks Dooku he just holds him off, plus he doesn't participate in the war, he gives the clones advice while the rest of the jedi fight

have you even seen the movie ??

yes Lucas has borrowed themes to fit his movies, but to call that "ripping" them off is just ridiculous, it's a basic fairytale story he took for a New Hope & he expanded it with his own creativity. Even Lord of the Rings has borrowed from common mythology

I suggest you actually pay attention to the movies when watching them, "no plot" & "no themes" ?? c'mon now

and Ewan McGregor, Liam Neeson, Sam Jackson, Iam McDiarmid, Hayden Christenson and Christopher Lee gave bad performances or are bad actors ?? mesa no think so(i'll give you Natalie Portman, but she's a senator & has been all her life so she had to be stale in some parts, same with some Jedi)

i agree on the Jackson part, it's pretty obvious he got overwhelmed & i think he doesn't even notice it or he simply doesn't care

But point is, Lucas and Jackson(well, Lucas moreso than Jackson) don't even need the money. So call them out on bad writing, directing whatever makes sense(everybody is entitled to their opinion) but "money-over-art" is a pretty bold statement to use so lightly. Especcially when their movies(the Star Warses & LOTR) aren't even remotely following the "popular" guidelines set by millenium films by Quentin Tarantino or the Wachowskis, but take a more "classic" approach to the storytelling(like it or not).
 
Lucas introduced Teddy Bears into Return of the Jedi for the sole purpose of MERCHANDISING!!!!!!!!

Money over art.

Making the prequel has not "art" factor at all. It is money over art by design.

Jackson making his Dungeons and Dragons movie using LOTR as the story and disregarding blatantly very important parts of the story so he can introduce Warg riders and elf-warrior princesses, and huge batte sequences is...............

Money over art.

As long as Hollywood cashes in they could give a rip about anything else.

Mrs. M believes over time they will be assessed as being "short" of what they could have been. None of the people making the film care. They're all rich fat cats who are drunk with their own success.

The Matrix producer quote that I saw on here in a thread highlights it best. Paraphrasing: How can you argue with a billion dollars in ticket sales?

My answer: After the first one your movies sucked.

His answer back: How can you argue with a billion in ticket sales.

Money over art.

This basic premise highlights my astoundment at everyone's expectations. Peter Jackson quite frankly has exceeded my expectations for the films because I knew somehow the Hollywood folks would screw it all up. By all your complaining about the film I have been proven correct over and over and over again.
 
Originally posted by Blue Wizard
This is not the first time that a book adaptation has been done and has not been true to the original.
Once the movie rights are sold, the person that bought the rights has the legal right to do "anything" he wants with the story.
This isn't just any old book; it's one of the best and the most popular books of the last century.
As I said, PJ centred the whole enormous lead-up to the making of the films on them being "true" to the books. You originally said there was only ONE quotation to that effect. No-one now claims the films ARE true to the books, so what does that say for PJ's expansive claims that they would be?
Of course he had the legal right - that's a fact, about as significant as the fact that the sky is blue.
We're talking about a whole lot of other "rights", that the original author and his readers could claim.
 
If we are talking about "money over art", remember that the two are not mutually exclusive. There have been many high-grossing films that are rightfully considered cinematic "art": The African Queen, Ben Hur, Casablanca, The Godfather, The Wizard of Oz etc. It isn't as if a film has to be a travesty to be popular. Indeed, it is often exactly the opposite - audiences reject even high-budget effluvia (Cleopatra, Heaven's Gate etc.).

Therefore, I must again ask why anyone could possibly have arrived at the conclusion that remaining as faithful as possible to Tolkien's book meant that the film wouldn't have been commercially successful? This is especially true as Jackson got his funding on the basis of the book and not his past performances as a director! There was nothing to suggest that had Jackson remained true to Tolkien, these films would have been any less successful than they have been. Indeed, they might have been even more successful.
 
Originally posted by Mrs. Maggott
If we are talking about "money over art", remember that the two are not mutually exclusive. There have been many high-grossing films that are rightfully considered cinematic "art": The African Queen, Ben Hur, Casablanca, The Godfather, The Wizard of Oz etc. It isn't as if a film has to be a travesty to be popular. Indeed, it is often exactly the opposite - audiences reject even high-budget effluvia (Cleopatra, Heaven's Gate etc.).

Therefore, I must again ask why anyone could possibly have arrived at the conclusion that remaining as faithful as possible to Tolkien's book meant that the film wouldn't have been commercially successful? This is especially true as Jackson got his funding on the basis of the book and not his past performances as a director! There was nothing to suggest that had Jackson remained true to Tolkien, these films would have been any less successful than they have been. Indeed, they might have been even more successful.
Name one book to film adaptation, in the fantasy or sci-fi genre that has been done in the last ten years, that has the complexities of The Lord of the Rings that has been art over money.

You can't do it.

In fact name one Fantasy Film (other than Harry Potter which is a children's story for the most part) that has been made that is art over money.

You can't do it.

Name one franchise of the fantasy or sci-fi genre that has been art over money.

You can't do it.

I have never stated that the movie could not have been successful as a "true" adaptation. Obviously the director didn't believe it could and they never do. Hollywood's propensity to screw things up is legendary and gets worse as time goes on.

Money over art.
 
Again, I don't get the "money over art". I cannot name what you ask simply because I don't know of any sci-fi fantasy books that I would consider literary masterpieces that have been made into films (or even that I would consider literary masterpieces!). Dune was made into a film but never having read the book, I don't know whether the book was good or the adaptation was true or if the film was considered good.

If Hollywood is interested in money, then it would seem to me that they wish to produce a good film which will earn money. If they make changes to a literary work in order to bring it to the screen (and Columbus had to do that with H.P.) then if those changes are not too gross, the books' audience will accept it assuming that the film remains true to the book otherwise.

I would say that "money over art" might explain why a particular book was not filmed rather than why a particular book was fundmentally changed as it was adapted to film. For instance, Houston took a chance on filming Moby D-i-c-k which was not a very "Hollywoodish" story. He made a very good adaptation of the story and an excellent film, but it wasn't particularly successful at the box office (nobody wanted to see Gregory Peck ugly and dead!). It's a Wonderful Life was also not very successful when it was released although it is now considered a classic. Of course, it wasn't a book to begin with (I believe) but there are many good films which only achieve commercial success over time and others that begin wildly successful which sink beneath the radar scope fairly quickly after their initial popularity.

My problem is not with your assumption of Hollywood's choice of money over artistic merit, it is your further assumption that the changes made in LOTR and even in some other book adaptations were made for that reason. If a story is extremely successful to begin with, what possible reason could be put forward for extensive tinkering given the probability that the original would succeed without it?
 
Again, I will try and amplify my point.

1. You all expect something that has never been done before to be accomplished by a director who has never done anything remotely good or grand before. Thus your expectations of this film based on what he has said are WAY WAY WAY TOO HIGH.

2. I have cited numerous examples of high budget modern sci-fi fantasy films that have been unmitigated disasters. You cite ancient films from a Hollywood that no longer exists.

3. Dune, just for the record, was a great novel and an absolutely TERRIBLE movie. Terrible. Another example that makes my point for me.

4. Tolkien himself chose "money over art". A fact that you keep pushing into the closet given #1 (your high expectations).

5. I HAVE NEVER EVER EVER stated that the films couldn't have been made true to the book and make money. Never. You keep saying I have but I have not. I am just pointing out over and over and over again that there is no way in green earth that you were ever going to get what you were expecting. Hollywood is incapable of it.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top