• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

What IS Tom Bombadil?

What do you think Tom Bombadil was?

  • Vala..

    Votes: 25 13.2%
  • Maia..

    Votes: 41 21.6%
  • Nature/Earth Spirit..

    Votes: 85 44.7%
  • Other.. (Post your view below)

    Votes: 39 20.5%

  • Total voters
    190
Every Maia that is in the story is affected by the Ring. If you want to suppose that other Maia's are not, go for it.

Tulkas BUIILT ME. That means a lot to me. Pride in ownership. His power and his laughter remind me of TB. There is nothing inconsistent with Tuklas, as opposed to all the other suggestions. That is not a proof. Just a statement of plausibility. Repeating irrelevant objections and ignoring what I posted earlier isnt likely to change my mind.

And as far as the power of TB (Tuklas) remember he not only bested Old Man Ribber...er Willow, but he also turned the Barrow Wight into a "long trailing shriek." While laughing.
 
"your a looney" -- John Cleese

Your evidence is weak man!

Every Maia in the story

hmm

Gandalf (well ok if we count the Istari as Maia), Saruman (same thing), Radagast -- oops well ok he wasn't in the story much, I guess we could say he would have been

Even in your attraction/addition thread, you show how the EFFECT is inconsistent right?

Certainly Saruman is affected. He is a maia of Aule, he likes devices... Devices have no effect on someone who is concerned with growing.

BTW I think you are the only one stating what Tom definitively (in the words of Greenwood) is... I'm not ignoring your posts you just know your evidence is weak.

Give me a few more quotes
 
You know very well that isnt my thread..its Foe's. Every Maia...including the Balrogs..just a guess.

And I made a PLAUSIBILITY argument. I expect more quotes any time now.
 
HAHA I forgot! You got screwed out of some of the best threads. I like very much your POV...

plausibility i can deal with. I am not even up to that point yet, just an Ann Elk
 
I enjoy this discussion very much, and I am not even going to try to give arguments for either side. There's just one question: I notice that one side (almost) consistently uses Tuklas, and the other side Tulkas. Are you talking about the same guy?
 
Bill, I am the one that posted all the quotes from the author and these quotes make it apparent to me that Tom is "None of the Above." But that's just me. It seems anytime and everytime I read something written by the author that is clear to me, someone else thinks it means something else.

The author has said that Tom is an "enigma" and was not created for this story but that he wanted to include him for this story. (Maybe to please his children to whom the original tale was written. ***Gronds opinion***) Given this premise, it appears that the author didn't consider Tom's status in including him in the tale. That would make him an "other". He doesn't fit. He's not Maia, Vala, Eru or anything spoken of in the Silmarillion. He is something that came out of the third theme that only Eru sang. That's my opinion and apparently no one elses. Just like the old song, "Alone again, naturally!!"
 
Originally posted by Bill the Pony
There's just one question: I notice that one side (almost) consistently uses Tuklas, and the other side Tulkas. Are you talking about the same guy?

Originally posted by Harad the White
Tulkas BUIILT ME. That means a lot to me. Pride in ownership. His power and his laughter remind me of TB. There is nothing inconsistent with Tuklas,

Being a liberal sort, I use both in the same paragraph.
 
After I read 'The Adventures of Tom Bombadil', it was clear that Tom was not just an amusement figure for Tolkien's children. Some of the poetry has too much Middle Earth mythology and a seriousness which does not make it a children's book. Therefore, even though Bombadil is an enigma, it is clear that he was deliberately woven into Tolkien's mythology.
 
Grond wrote:
He is something that came out of the third theme that only Eru sang. That's my opinion and apparently no one elses. Just like the old song, "All alone again naturally!!"

You're not alone. I agreed with you in my post on page 10. To me it is the best explanation, though it doesn't explain much.

And after reading your excerpts from Tolkien's letters I am more convinced of it. Although if I read Tom's tales I might have a better idea of who Tom is or if I knew who Goldberry is.

. . . .

Another thought has occurred to me concerning Tom. I agree with Tolkien completely that Tom is a kind of natural philosopher though perhaps not quite a philosopher since he is more interested in the things of earth than abstract things and yet he has a very deep knowledge of those things which is why the word philosopher came to my mind. This interest in even the seemingly insignificant things like the water lilies is in harmony with his very homely and jovial manner (consider his entertainment and care for the hobbits during their stay).

But this interest in watching and observing and to some extant knowing sets him apart from the Valar. The Valar already know a great deal about the things of Arda, for they created them. Indeed their interest is in creating and tending the creatures of Arda and in learning from, teaching and working with the Children of Illuvatar. You see the Valar already have knowledge of the things in Arda (except those hidden from them by Eru). They know them because they made them. Tom to contrast seems to have spent his time learning the tunes of things. He is a quasi-philosophic person, concerned about the things around him and not the stars. He is almost a manifestation of the human soul that desires to know the other, but unlike men Tom seems to have succeeded.

The word philosopher means love of wisdom and the greatest philosophers knew they did not possess it but loved it and ever pursued it. But Tom seems to really know things deeply and intimately. He knows the harmonies that hold things together and can unbind them. Perhaps, Goldberry is simply a manifestation of Tom's knowledge. Tom is completely devoted to her and spends all his time tending her every need. His devotion is single minded and consuming. But it is also very satisfying, hence his constant singing and unceasing jovial manner.

Just a couple more thoughts.
 
Last edited:
*Spits coffee on the screen* Holy Sh....

Bombadillodillo,

I allways thought that this was a silly thread and that people were wasting far too much time concerning themselves with a matter dealing with a character that was invented for the Oxford Magazine and not Lord of the Rings, but what you just said has completely changed my mind. Um, nice post...man was I ever wrong.
 
Grond, Bombadillodillo -- help me out here...why does he, and Goldberry say at least a few times, he is Master and "no one has ever caught Tom". I see what you are saying, just that piece of the puzzle seems strange to me, reading the book. What does that mean, he is Master, no-one has ever caught him? (I am not saying this thinking I know the answer, I really don't know)Something that Carl Lewis would say?
 
Eonwe, my only thought on the matter is that Tom, being something apart from the start in the mind of JRRT may have been a type of Leprachan. You know.... "Catch me and get a pot of gold." That would have been like JRRT to add something that had not application in the story much as Tom himself had no real applicability to the story. Just a thought.
 
I think this point is quite clear:
When the Ainur had ended their song in the Ainulindale Iluvatar / Eru "showed to them a vision, giving o them sight where before was only hearing; and they saw a new World made visible before them, and was globed amid the Void"
So before that there was nothing!

Not even good old Tom existed then. But then he came into the world somehow.

I like the thought that he is a Ainu / Vala just as all the others that came into the world "officially". Perhaps he just slipped down into Middle-Earth with the others but went his own way and was forgotten by his "brothers and sisters".

What I want to say: Of course he is acreation of Iluvatar just as the Ainu are.
 
I have to say, apart from the occassional crap post thrown into this thread, it has generally been a pleasure to read. Bombaldilololllloooowwwwww? has shed clarity on this enigma that I must subscribe to. Grond has been accurate in defining who he wasn't
He's not Maia, Vala, Eru or anything spoken of in the Silmarillion. He is something that came out of the third theme that only Eru sang
which stands alone for all to appreciate.

Therefore, we are left with trying to define him in our own understanding of how Tolkien may have considered him. Subconsciously I believe Tolkien created Tom as the heart and soul of middle-earth, encapsulated within his own domain. The personification of free-will without hinderance and without ill intent. Tom was the epitomie of all that should be in life; nature untamed, forgetful, care-free, considerate, yet wise beyond comprehension, responsible and master of all within his realm. Goldberry was a wandering, free-minded, free-spirited, devine creation of nature and partner to nature himself. A marriage made in heaven one might say.

Tom is Master and Goldberry is River-Daughter.
 
Eonwe wrote:

why does he, and Goldberry say at least a few times, he is Master and "no one has ever caught Tom".

I gave an account of Tom's mastery above, but now you've caused me to reconsider that view. For I said there that Tom is called master as opposed to Lord because master is a domestic term, not a political term. But it still leaves the question, of what is he master. I would contend that he is most of all master of himself. He has no desire to use his knowledge to rule over others and this takes great self-mastery. As Tolkien wrote, he has taken a sort of vow of poverty, though to Tom it is almost natural. If he ever had a struggle with power, that struggle was long ago resolved and has left no traces in the Tom we see. Tom has great knowledge, certainly greater than any elf or man or hobbit. And yet to Tom knowledge is not power as Francis Bacon declared. Knowledge is for its own sake and yet it can be used on occassion to do many great things, though this aspect of knowledge Tom considers insignificant and perhaps rightly. Tom is master, whereas Sauron is Lord. But Tom's knowledge is greater and so is his mastery for he has mastered himself whereas Sauron's lust for tyranny rules him and leads him to his ultimate oversight (namely that others do not share in his lust for power) and final destruction.

This leads us to the other quote, "no one has ever caught Tom." I do recall the quote but couldn't find it. It must be in the Barrow Downs chapter. There is a similar comment by Goldberry that Tom "has no fear." This is because he is very wise and does know, but we only fear what we do not know or what can harm us. This brings us to Eonwe's quotation again. He fears no one because no one can harm or catch Tom. It is because of his knowledge that Tom is unable to be caught. Tom has a great knowledge of most things, and this is what ennables him to command the barrow wight and old Man Willow. But note Tom threatens to sing Old Man Willow's roots off or sing up a wind to blow his branches away: but he doesn't act on these threats. Tom doesn't use his knowledge to control anything or destroy anything. He only commands or rather scolds and then only in another's dire need, again an example of his self-mastery. But this leads us to why Tom cannot be caught. Whereas Tom seems to know so many things intimately and so has the power to evade the ill will of others, no one knows Tom or understands him. He has a twofold advantage: he knows them and they don't know him. Moreover, just as Tom seems not to be concerned with the affairs of the world about him, the world takes no notice of Tom or has forgotten him or only considers him as an afterthought (as at the Council of Elrond).

Sorry, I had every intent of writing a short post, but they just have a way of growing.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the answers again Bombadillodillo. The interesting part I see is the master over himself part. So at least *he* is immune to what others attempt to do to him. A mastery of his soul, his ability not to "sin" as it were?

I guess this would reconcile the part of the Barrow-downs where he is asked by the Hobbits to ride with them to protect them from Black Riders, and he says he has no power over the black riders. But they have no power over him, and neither would Sauron. And again, this would help reconcile what the CoE feels would happen if Bombadil kept the ring (if all the free peoples begged him), that in the end he would fall. I would take this to mean that, in the end there would be no mastery of Sauron over him, but the ring would not be protected by him in that case??

I should just leave this thread alone, but I find that I can't...
 
Eonwe wrote:


That is interesting. Bombadil has no power over the Black Riders, probably because they, like their lord, know only power, one thing Tom knows nothing of. Yet just as Tom does not know the Black Riders, the Black Riders cannot understand Tom or anything not having to do with dominion. Likewise, the ring has no power over Tom and Tom has no interest in the ring. Since he has no interest in power, he has no interest in the ring of power. To him it is a mere trinket.

This is also probably why if Sauron were to conquer all, Tom would be last, because to Sauron he is most insignificant and unintelligible. They are mutually unintelligible. It is why, as Eonwe already pointed out so well, the ring is unsafe with Tom, just as a lily would be unsafe with Sauron. In the end Tom would fall, because Sauron would have destroyed all that Tom loves. Sauron would not conquer Tom since I don't think he could. Rather, he would destroy all that Tom loves, and Tom's jovial singing would turn to a funeral dirge or his singing end altogether, a great loss indeed.
 
Last edited:
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…