• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

What IS Tom Bombadil?

What do you think Tom Bombadil was?

  • Vala..

    Votes: 25 13.2%
  • Maia..

    Votes: 41 21.6%
  • Nature/Earth Spirit..

    Votes: 85 44.7%
  • Other.. (Post your view below)

    Votes: 39 20.5%

  • Total voters
    190
I wonder if Tom was Aule,then wouldn`t his interests be more in direction of his original interest as a vala,and not in the direction of trees,flowers and growing things? This in fact indicate that if he was a maia he would be a maia under Yavanna.
 
...couldn't Tom be some,um,ents' relative?...I mean at some points he is so 'entish':he doesn't care about the War of the Ring(just like Treebeard,untill his forest was damaged);the Ring doesn't attempt him;he is very fond of nature;ents interest him very much....
alright it's probably a nonsense,but I'm just trying to think of something new...:)
 
I cant remember having read any place that Tom had a special interest in ents. And when Treebeard heard that the little Hobbits had encountered Tom,Treebeard`s interest didn`t go any furter than of one who`s heard news from an old friend.
 
I don't think Tom is a Valar or a Maia as has been said a Valar would not stand for Sauron's efforts to control ME. I also don't believe him to be an Ent with his dashing and singing and his ability to appear when called.

If he was -here i go again- the Secret Fire this would explain a great deal. Think about Glorfindel's assertion that he would fall against Sauron's might. And this...

"(Melkor) had gone often alone into the viod places seeking the flame imperishable; for desire grew hot within him to bring into being things of his own"

Melkor knew that if he found the Fire he would not only rule over the world but be able to create a new one, the song would be sung according to his mind, not to Illuvatar's. Melkor was also Sauron's master for a long time and he would have known of his master's desire and after Melkor's defeat he would have began to desire this for himself.

Now if Tom is -and it's a big if- the personification of the Fire, Sauron would want to know where he was. And if found would indeed use him to his own purpose's. Then surely Glorfindel's assertion would ring true. Maybe even the purpose of the ring itself is to help in seeking the Fire.

When Gandalf at the Council of Elrond disuaded everyone from taking the ring to Tom, he gave some very good reasons. But maybe he had some secret ones of his own like not turning the Eye towards the Old Forest.

As for Goldberry i think she is as she says she is the Daughter of the River, and what a better marriage than between Fire and Water forever singing to each other in the Forests of the world.

Okay I'm not completely sure about all of this but Tolkien obviously found the character of Bombadil fascinating and important. And I share that.:confused:
 
Well Hi I am new at the forum, well about Tom, I remember that in council of Elrond, Glorfindel says (I think he was I dont have my Fellowship copy here) that he coud stands Suoron if the power of earth could do that, But that even Sauron could make horrible things to the hills. well for me that states Tom is related to Earth somehow.
Bye
 
Actually, Camille, it's Gildor or Erestor that says that.

As for Tom being an Ent or 'Entish' in the beginning, that logic flies right in the face of Treebeard being called 'The oldest living creature on earth".
Tom calls himself 'Eldest, that's what I am".

So, there must be a difference in their origins, or one of their claims is false.

Besides, if Tom were an Ent, wouldn't he be taller?
That is unless he was just a sapling......
 
Branwen, I had forgotten about those words of Gandalf:

'I'm preparing for a long conversation with Bombadil,a conversation I've never had before. He is moss-grown, and I am a rolling stone. But my rolling has stopped, we'll have lots to tell to each other."

This further confirms my opinion that Bombadil unlike the Valar and Maiar is not at all concerned with the happenings and changes in the world about him, or I should say doing anything about them. Gandalf's entire purpose in Middle Earth is to help in the fight against Sauron. He is constantly in action with little time for rest (which he seems to have enjoyed especially in Hobbiton -- in that respect like Bombadil who visits Farmer Maggot). The contrast of Gandalf is excellent. Gandalf is constantly at motion, deeply involved in the commotion of MiddleEarth in this dark hour. Bombadil is completely at rest, seemingly unaffected by the changing world about him and uninterested in things changing from their current form.

The difference is even more striking when you consider what Gandalf wishes, now that his affairs have come to an end: to have a conversation that he has never had before . It is a conversation such as he has never had before with anyone, not merely with Tom. But it is one he expects to have with Tom. It seems that so long as Gandalf was on his mission, he has never had a chance to really rest and to speak with Tom about things except as they pertained to his mission. Now at last Gandalf will be able to speak with Tom Bombadil speech like Tom Bombadil's, perhaps simply to speak (or sing) about things. And here perhaps we arrive a little closer to Bombadil's nature. He is not concerned with the ephemeral -- and ephemeral for Tom can mean all the happenings of Arda; since he is the oldest, all changes even those that take a whole age, must seem ephemeral to Tom.

His interest is in the things that are and also the things and people that were. He desired to keep the brooch of the Barrow Downs to remind him of the beautiful Lady who once was. And note it is an interest not in an event but a person. Nor is it an interest in a thing of nature which seems to indicate that Tom is more than a mere nature spirit. Certainly he is interested in nature but he is also interested people. His interest in the Ents in particular seems to stem from his similarity to them. They too are unconcerned with the great events about them, they are almost eldest and they love their own home the woods. But to contrast with Tom they are uninterested (except for the elves who taught them speech) in Children of Illuvatar.

But to return to the "rest" of Tom. It is characterized by his love for Goldberry and his almost single-minded concern with her. Tom is completely domestic. His only cares seem to be for Goldberry. I have always been struck at Tom's parting words at the edge of the East Road: "Tom has his house to mind, and Goldberry is waiting." It is quite remarkable. For Tom, tending to his house and Goldberry are not merely more important but almost more urgent than the rescuing of the hobbits. The entire of MiddleEarth is on the verge of collapse and his rescue of its only hope is less important than retrieving the last lilies for Goldberry. Only since it "happened" to be on his way he helped the hobbits from their willowy doom. He is the archtypical homebody. He is indeed called "master," a domestic term and not "lord" which is is extradomestic.

And it is at his home that Gandalf wishes to take his rest, at least for a while and engage in talks with Bombadil. Indeed, it is for the sake of this very rest that all of Gandalf's endeavors are purposed. Not merely for Bombadil's home or a fireside chat, but for all the homes of MiddleEarth and perhaps especially for homely little holes and houses of the likes of Farmer Maggot and the Gaffer. The great action of the age is to dispell the hopes of Sauron whose bent is on destroying the homes of all. But for Bombadil, in order to preserve the home, it is more important to be at home than to be worrying about those outside who wish to destroy it. It is enough of a task for him just to preserve the home he has.

The question must come to everyone's mind at least when we first read the trilogy: if Tom Bombadil is master, if he knows the tune of every creature of Arda, then why doesn't he do anything about the evil pressing all about him? The response seems much easier now. If Tom spent all of his time fighting the great evils of every age, when would he have the time to learn the tunes of each thing? It is only because Tom is perrenially at rest that he has the time to learn the tunes, or as I would argue, the nature of all things: for since Arda was created by music, then to know the tunes of things is really to know things. And Tom knows them deep down and from their beginnings. His business is to learn the tunes of things, to sing and dance. These are the things we can do when we have leisure, not when we are off chasing orcs and balrogs and rings, which is also why Sauron can never understand Tom Bombadil; for he is always in motion, always trying to grab more power, ever building more armies and greater machinations. Bombadil is the antithesis of Sauron. It is also why he does not seem to be any of the Valar and the Maiar. For they are more similar to Melkor who was one of them. They came to Arda to fashion and furnish it and to mingle with the Children of Illuvatar. Tom is truly at home in Arda. And it is this homeliness that makes him more akin to those whose home is Arda. It would seem that he is more akin to the hobbits even than the elves. For as Ranger above quoted, Frodo's first encounter with him seems to indicate such:

Frodo "stood as he had at times stood enchanted by fair elven voices; but the spell that was now laid upon him was different: less keen and lofty was the delight, but deeper and nearer to the mortal heart; marvellous and yet not strange."
 
Last edited:
lemme ask a question I don't know the answer to:

Why is Valinor revealed to Frodo in the dream at Tom's house? (i.e. the rain curtain that goes away to reveal a land in sunshine, the same as that at the end of LoTR)
 
A truly masterful post and one of the best I've ever had the pleasure of reading on this or any other forum Bombadillodillo. I stand in awe of your writing style and the content. The author says that Tom is an enigma...something outside the normal rules and laws of Middle-earth. I feel (after reading your post) that the author is himself wrong. He created in Tom nothing less than the great Eru/Iluvatar come to Earth. I've never felt that before, but I see no other explanation.

Eonwe your post only further illustrates my conviction that Tom is Eru. It is he that gives Frodo the vision of his reward for bearing the peril of Middle-earth.:)
 
OK, very good points.



You do a good job of describing Tom, but, did I miss the answer in there to Frodo's question:
"Who are you, Master"?
 
I have read every post that I could find about old Tom. I must commend many of you for researching this so deeply. I think to find the final answer however would mean to look, not into the history of middle earth, but into the mind and heart of it's creater. The writer himself. I think Tom has served his purpose as a true enigma and a very rich field for debate. Since Tolkien never lets us in on the secret of how Tom got to ME we can envision him however we want. Tom is not ment to be explained and his origins are not ment to be uncovered. (Although the essay and many of your comments have made me raise an eyebrow and wonder "Is that what Tolkien was thinking?") I like the idea of something or someone who falls outside our realm of understanding. I personally (just my opinion) see Tom as a living embodiment of some ancient power that outdates ME. When the singing was begun I think he just hitched a ride... the boundaries which he placed on himself were typical of his character. He was an observer who did not want to directly influence those beings that roamed ME. That is why, in the council of Elrond, it is mentioned that there would be no place for Tom in the world of Sauron. Tom would be forced out by his own rules.. he would have to leave ME rather than directly fight Sauron. He knows of the ring and even has power over it... In my mind he could have taken it and carried it to mordor himself but for the limitations that he had put upon himself. He would have been the first incarnation of life on ME and would be the last to leave. He would stay in his own boundaries as Sauron advanced until Sauron stood unopposed at the border.

GoldBerry... who is she? Well if you were a great power capable of withstanding the alure of the one ring would you live by yourself? Probably not.. you would probably bring with you a similar being or create one from the earth itself. Wonder if ol' Tom sang Goldberry up from the river itself one lonely night as the elves came to ME.....??
 
Grond wrote:
. I feel (after reading your post) that the author is himself wrong. He created in Tom nothing less than the great Eru/Iluvatar come to Earth. I've never felt that before, but I see no other explanation.

I've given some reasons on the other thread why it seems improbable that Tom is Eru but I will try to clarify them.

Illuvatar, to contrast with Tom is very interested in the doings of MiddleEarth. After all he created the Ainur and directed their music. He is the father of his Children and its his new melodies that overcome Melkor (and Sauron). His influence throughout all the ages was most subtle and yet everywhere. His is the 'chance' prompting that Tom mentions which brings him to Old Man Willow. He is the power greater than the ring who (probably through Ulmo) arranges Bilbo's finding of the ring. The subtlety of Illuvatar seems to work most of all through chance. But Illuvatar is very interested in the affairs of each age. Illuvatar is Lord of all. Tom is merely master of his home, even if his home were all Arda (remember he sets his own boundaries).

Moreover, the fact that Tom is called fatherless and oldest, I think distinguishes rather than identifies him with Illuvatar, who is also fatherless. Tom is called fatherless by the elves. I think they have named him thus because to them it seems he should have a father. They could have called the Maiar and Valar fatherless to but they are from outside Arda, whereas Tom is sprung from it, at home in it and coeval with it. The elves would never call Illuvatar fatherless, they would call him father, who is the father of all.

Tom remains a mystery and Tolkien thought some mysteries must remain unsolved because not all mysteries are knowable. Nevertheless, it is fun to wonder about them. That is I think the point.

(Sorry Bucky, I forgot who brought up the secret fire.)
Bucky, are you talking about the secret fire again? If Tom Bombadil is a mystery, certainly the secret fire is another and greater mystery. However, you could be on the right track. Afterall Gandalf's great virtue is his wisdom along with the encouragement he gives others in the face of things they don't know. And Bombadil does seem to have stored a great wealth of wisdom. But even if Tom is the secret fire, does that explain anything or merely make him more a mystery?
 
Last edited:
Sorry Bucky,
But in this "academic" discussion, Harad the Grey, with whom I agree, (as it was me), thought that Tulkas was as good a bet, as any.

Now all the arguments about whether a Vala would "allow" Sauron to threaten ME are not relevant because in fact ALL the Vala allow Sauron to threaten ME. The Vala change thru time, so Tom as Tulkas would have many of the characteristics as the Tulkas who was one of the chief builders of Arda BEFORE Melkor brought his darkness to it, but not the combativeness anymore. Just the laughter and the power.

Then Tuklas slept, being weary and content, and Melkor deemed that his hour had come.

Later Tom (Tuklas) decided not to be caught sleeping again.
 
Harad, As I said, to even consider Tulkas as a possibility, you must interpret Tom's word's about 'knowing the darkness under stars before it knew fear, & the Dark Lord came in from the Outside" to mean Melkor's SECOND return to Arda.

It does not totally make sense, & a stretch at best.
It's a VERY weak foundation to stand on.

I was referring to that Bomballodillo's (whatever) post that describes Tom in great detail. Great job on that, it was late & I may have missed it, but where is the conclusion as to who Tom is in there?
 
ok another weak argument on my part, but since we are still considering Tulkas **sigh** :)

Are we sure the "Dark Lord" he refers to is Melkor? I seem to remember someone else with that name, that would be very familiar to the hobbits...
 
No chance.
Why?
Because Tom says 'before the darkness knew fear".

That would have to be before Melkor came & started evil, which breeds fear, no?
 
ok that's right.

What in the Sil talks about when darkness changed to fear? When Melkor appears as a horseman (like Orome) to the elves? Its kind of a vague statement to pin a time on eh? :)
 
Bucky...
Tuklas was one of the main creators of Middle Earth. So he certainly knew Middle Earth before Melkor's FIRST coming. See that quote: Tulkas created ME, fell asleep, and Melkor crept in like poison ivy.
 
Harad -- why would it say in the Council of Elrond that at the end, even Tulkas would fall, if he was the only one left with Sauron around... I mean pretty big stretch eh? He can wrestle Melkor and put him in chains but not Sauron? You have to at least explain *squeek* that *squeek*
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top