Grond wrote:
He is something that came out of the third theme that only
Eru sang. That's my opinion and apparently no one elses. Just like
the old song, "All alone again naturally!!"
You're not alone. I agreed with you in my post on page 10. To me it is the best explanation, though it doesn't explain much.
And after reading your excerpts from
Tolkien's letters I am more convinced of it. Although if I read
Tom's
tales I might have a better idea of who Tom is or if I knew who
Goldberry is.
. . . .
Another thought has occurred to me concerning Tom. I agree with Tolkien completely that Tom is a kind of natural philosopher though perhaps not quite a philosopher since he is more interested in the things of earth than abstract things and yet he has a very deep knowledge of those things which is why the word philosopher came to my mind. This interest in even the seemingly insignificant things like the water lilies is in harmony with his very homely and jovial manner (consider his entertainment and care for the
hobbits during their stay).
But this interest in watching and observing and to some extant knowing sets him apart from the
Valar. The Valar already know a great deal about the things of
Arda, for they created them. Indeed their interest is in creating and tending the
creatures of Arda and in learning from, teaching and working with the Children of Illuvatar. You see the Valar already have knowledge of the things in Arda (except those hidden from them by Eru). They know them because they made them. Tom to contrast seems to have spent his time learning the tunes of things. He is a quasi-philosophic person, concerned about the things around him and not the stars. He is almost a manifestation of the human soul that desires to know the other, but unlike
men Tom seems to have succeeded.
The word philosopher means love of wisdom and the greatest philosophers knew they did not possess it but loved it and ever pursued it. But Tom seems to really know things deeply and intimately. He knows the harmonies that hold things together and can unbind them. Perhaps, Goldberry is simply a manifestation of Tom's knowledge. Tom is completely devoted to her and spends all his time tending her every need. His devotion is single minded and consuming. But it is also very satisfying, hence his constant singing and unceasing jovial manner.
Just a couple more thoughts.