• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

What IS Tom Bombadil?

What do you think Tom Bombadil was?

  • Vala..

    Votes: 25 13.2%
  • Maia..

    Votes: 41 21.6%
  • Nature/Earth Spirit..

    Votes: 85 44.7%
  • Other.. (Post your view below)

    Votes: 39 20.5%

  • Total voters
    190
Well, I don't think that Tom is a Valar or Maiar. I think thats been pretty much proven. And Eomer I agre with you that he is not just a nature spirit because he seems more than that. I think that he is a son of the earth, there is a quote tha supports this somewhere, he was forn of the earth because he is "fatherless." This also fits because he is with Goldberry the rier daughter. I do not think that Tom himself is a personification of Arda but perhaps this union represents ME- you know earth and water.

I guess in the end all youcan say for sure is that Tom just IS. Or, heres an idea for you. What if he was the first living tree, or some such nature thing, and became very ALIVE. :) That would explain why he was iterested in ents. Somewhat like Old Man WIllow.:)
 
Re: who´s Tom?

I think Tom Bombadil is maybe Iluvatar. He is his own master and they say he was the first and he has the eyes to peirce anything ring of Sauron hearts anything. That forest is one of the oldest in M.E and he is also good at making music and controls everything by music didn't Iluvatar do that as well?
 
Is Tom Bombadil the Personification of the Secret Fire itself?

This might sound a bit wierd and I don't know how valid it is but since i started reading these pages this idea just won't leave me alone. I should also say that having read LOTR three times I am just starting The Silmarillion for the first time, so all this could be complete nonsense but I have to get it off my chest. Please let know what you think especailly if you think i'm a complete nutter talking rubbish.

Well here goes...

"and the Secret Fire was sent to burn at the heart of the world"

So Illuvatar sent the Fire into the world and we know that the Ainur concentrated much of their creation on one small planet, Earth. It is reasonable to assume then that that is where the Fire is. But where exactly? The Old Forest?

Tom said that he was the Eldest. Glorfindel also said that Tom was the first but the ents said that they were the eldest living beings. I think the important word here is 'living'. Is Tom not a 'living' thing? The Secret Fire would not itself be alive but the giver of life. And would indeed be The Eldest.

What about Gandalf?

"I am the servent of the Secret Fire..."

After the defeat of Sauron Gandalf was no longer concerned with ME, his work was done. Even his beloved Shire, now under siege, was not of much interest to him. Indeed the one and only thing he wished to do before he left was to talk with Tom.

"Such a talk as I have not had in all my time. He is a moss-gatherer, and i have been a stone doomed to rolling...and we shall have much to say to one another"

Is Tom where Gandalf gets his power from, is Tom the Secret Fire? i really don't know about this but then again...
 
>>>>Even his beloved Shire, now under siege, was not of much interest to
him. Indeed the one and only thing he wished to do before he left was to talk
with Tom.


No, it's not a lack of concern or interest.
Gandalf tells the Hobbits 'you are among the great of ME" & that they can handle things themselves, that's what they've been trained for & my time is over. "I was the enemy of Sauron."

He IS concerned, he tells the Hobbits to hurry to the Shire before the gates are locked for the night.

On the Secret Fire thing, interesting.
But, how's Goldberry fit into that?

And, Gandalf's power isn't from a source, it's inherently in him from his creation.
 
I find it very hard to belive that Aule himself had any interest in walking upon the earth. I do belive that Tom was a maia and that the reason that the ring didn`t have any effect on him was that he had not by far the same interest in Arda as the maia Olorin and Curumo,maybe because he he lived in "his own little corner" of Arda for so long (probably since the Ages of Starlight). Anyway it`s the most common opinion that Tom was the maia Iarwin Ben-adar. Please exusce me for my bad english and grammar. I`M TIRED!!!:eek:
 
Bucky as for Gandalf's interest in ME after Sauron's defeat I think you are right, of course he was concerned. What i was trying to say was that his work was done and he wanted to go to the west but he greatly wanted to talk to Tom and i find that very interesting.
 
Too simple......

If that was the case, close down the discussion board.


Tolkien pondered MANY of his own creations himself, searching for answers.

Was it the same Glorfindel who helps Frodo escape to the Ford as the Glorfindel in Gondolin (who dies with the Balrog)?

He states in UT that the idea that the Black Riders were afraid of water was a difficult idea to sustain.

Many others, like the previously mentioned Blue Wizards, etc...

If Tolkien has Tom ask "Don't you know my name yet"?, then there is an answer.
 
INWE,

I like that idea. If Tom is whoever we want him to be then it is more interesting, it creates discussion. Such as this thread which is now 4 pages long.
Perhaps Tolkien wanted people to argue over just who or what Tom is.
 
Tolkien only had a vague idea of the meaning and plans for many of his characters. Many of these characters he meant to explain/develop at a later point in his life. This point he sadly never reached. I think Tom was one of the characters in that kathegory. But it is beyond almost any doubt that Tom was a maia or a vala. My money is on the maia part.
 
>>>But it is beyond almost any doubt that Tom was a
maia or a vala. My money is on the maia part.

I'd say there's great doubt.
Read some of my posts.

Tom's words have to be interrpretted in a very precise way to even open the posasibility that he IS a Vala or Maiar.

I go with....

Reading the beginning of the Silmarillion again.

That idea about the Secret Fire needs to be looked into.....
 
If Tom should be the secret fire,I don`t think he would have had so much contack with elves and ents in the Ages of Stairlight,as it is implied that he had.
 
Bucky, what words have to be precisely interpreted BESIDES "Don't you know my name yet" in order to interpret him as a Maia? I have read your posts and I say there isn't "great doubt".

You haven't even considered the fact that Frodo has met with Farmer Maggot, who has had many conversations with Bombadil re:don't you know my name yet
 
That bit about Farmer Maggot's a bit of a stretch.
Go back & read the text & see if Tom hasn't already told them his name is 'Tom'.

If you wish to claim Tom is Vala or Maiar, you must read his words of 'knowing the Dark under stars before it knew fear, before the Dark Lord came in from the outside" to mean the 1st or 2nd time Morgoth returned to Arda.

If Tom means the 1st time, Tulkas is out.

If Tom means before Melkor ever came to Arda, all the Maiar & Valar are out.

Also, I haven't seen anyone, including Eonwe, refute the claims in the Council of Elrond that 'If power to withstand the enemy isn't in the earth itself, it isn't in Tom'.
That would seem to indicate a conection to the earth...

BTW, If the Valar forsook Middle Earth (except Ulmo, mostly in the sea), how could one of them stay there through ALL the Ages?
That makes very little sense in the continuity of the whole ME history.
 
"Also, I haven't seen anyone, including Eonwe, refute the claims in the Council of Elrond that 'If power to withstand the enemy isn't in the earth itself, it isn't in Tom'.
That would seem to indicate a conection to the earth... "

Well this quote is OK, but Glorfindel saying that if the full power of Sauron exerted against Tom, Tom would also fall is not an OK quote to use to say he is less than Sauron in might? If Glorfindel says "I think" vs. "isn't" it means the quote is applicable? Who's splitting hairs now? :) You just told me because Glorfindel says "I think" it don't mean much? HAHA

What I am trying to say regarding the quote you keep referring to Bucky is that it seems like you are reading more into it than it deserves. MY opinion. Why can't he say what's there to tell more than my name instead of I must not be a Maia or Vala?

Forsaking ME is a fine point, except Istari come back, Sauron sticks around, and Tom is limited to just his small patch of forest.

Have you explained the interest in Ents yet ;)
 
Whatever.
Where's Harad when I need him?

I do agree that the 'unless the power is in the earth itself' is also conjecture.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top