• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

What IS Tom Bombadil?

What do you think Tom Bombadil was?

  • Vala..

    Votes: 25 13.2%
  • Maia..

    Votes: 41 21.6%
  • Nature/Earth Spirit..

    Votes: 85 44.7%
  • Other.. (Post your view below)

    Votes: 39 20.5%

  • Total voters
    190
and i personally think that christ is not the perfect human beiing, in fact he isn't one.

Don't make a statement like that unless you are going to give reasons for your statement.

I, believing that the Bible is the ultimate source of truth, say that Christ was the only perfect human being who ever existed. He never sinned and He was and is entirely selfless. He is the Son of God.

As for Tom Bombadil, I still say that he was not perfect. Also, he wasn't human, LOL. He was neither man nor hobbit. I believe he was a Maia, but I may be incorrect in that statement. Anyone know?

~Ariana
 
Here is an interesting quote I found when I was browsing through The Fellowship of the Ring.

" 'Fair lady!' said Frodo again after a while. 'Tel me, if my asking does not seem foolish, who is Tom Bombadil?'

'He is,' said Goldberry, staying her swift movements and smiling.

Frodo looked at her questioningly. 'He is, as you have seen him,' she said in answer to his look. 'He is the Master of wood, water, and hill.'

'Then all this strange land belongs to him?'
'No indeed!' she answered, and her smile faded. 'That would indeed be a burden,' she added in a low voice, as if to herself. 'The trees and the grasses and all things growing or living in the land belong each to themselves. Tom Bombadil is the Master. No one has ever caught old Tom walking in the forest, wading in the water, leaping on the hill tops under light and shadow. He has no fear. Tom Bombadil is master.' "

~Ariana
 
sorry, i know that i don't have any statements to prove my ideas, but it is just an idea in my mind about christ, who, ias i think also was like a mayer or istari, more than only a human being. but just let this subject rest.

but to my opinion Tom B. is an example of total happiness and freedom of mind and the parting mith anything material, exept love.
isn't this something bouddhists and hinduist have tried to reach for thousends of years?
 
If Tom was a nature or earth spirit, wouldn't that make him (in all probablility) either a Maia or a Vala? Has Tolkien written anywhere of Illuvatar sending spirits to the earth that were not either Maia or Vala? Even if they ended up being something different later (like Olorin or Sauron) ?

--Mike
 
ask grond. He'll take the time to look through the exact right letter, the exact chapter in the exact right book and he'll post a quote so long that youll just have to beleive him.
 
I can't vote:mad:

but anyway i was discussing this just the other day with my sister's boyfriend and i was gonna post this thread but telchar beat me to it.

Anyway I would say bombadil is a spirit of some kind put there by the valar in the beginning to help others in small ways when they need it, and to watch over everything. Hey does anyone think he'll be allowed to sail away into the west? I can't decide on that one.
 
When I first read LotR, I thought Tom was evil to start with. It was the way they had no idea of time in his home and he was so eager to try on the ring. Also, he was doing something while they were asleep and having nightmares. Once I got further into his part of the story, began to quite like him.
 
The Witchking of Angmar

Tom and teh witchking are the same person. the witchking feels uncomfortable as evil servent of the Dark Lord and occasionally takes secret vacations with false identity, only Elrond is aware but in his wisdom keeps it secret.
 
maybe i said it before, but i will say this again.
the link below shows a rather funny explanation of tom being the reader himself, its quite good. But beware, its rather exeedingly long but special.


bombadil discovered
 
Re: The Witchking of Angmar

Originally posted by Gloer
Tom and teh witchking are the same person. the witchking feels uncomfortable as evil servent of the Dark Lord and occasionally takes secret vacations with false identity, only Elrond is aware but in his wisdom keeps it secret.

If that is true then why did gandalf tell the hobbits that he wanted to speak to him again at the end of LOTR?:confused: But it is an interesting thought.:)
 
Tom Bombadil is compared unto a Buddhist. Ugh!

I do believe that Tom has reached a state of wonderful care freeness, but was he or was he not created that way in beginning? What is he anyway? Is he man, hobbit, maia, spirit, or is he perhaps someone unique and special without the need for an indentification?

~Ariana
 
Originally posted by Ariana Undomiel
Tom Bombadil is compared unto a Buddhist. Ugh!

I do believe that Tom has reached a state of wonderful care freeness, but was he or was he not created that way in beginning? What is he anyway? Is he man, hobbit, maia, spirit, or is he perhaps someone unique and special without the need for an indentification?

~Ariana

Why the 'ugh'?

Tom Bombadil fits perfectly into the idea of a Buddhist master -- even to the degree that he cannot be placed into a category of Maiar, Human, etc.

Do you know much about Buddhism, or is your reaction based on "not-knowing" much about Buddhism?
 
I am currently studying about a great deal of World Views including Buddhism. And what I do know about Buddhism is that they often talk in circles. For example they believe that Jesus Christ was a great person, and yet they deny that he is one with God. Well as Christ said that he is God, it shows that Buddhists call him a liar and yet they deny this as well.

Actually the reason that I said ugh! was because Bombadil did not make me think of a Buddhist at all, and it does not really answer my question about who he really is.

~Ariana
 
Originally posted by Ariana Undomiel
I am currently studying about a great deal of World Views including Buddhism. And what I do know about Buddhism is that they often talk in circles. For example they believe that Jesus Christ was a great person, and yet they deny that he is one with God. Well as Christ said that he is God, it shows that Buddhists call him a liar and yet they deny this as well.

Sounds to me like you might not understand Buddhism completely (and who does? :D). "They often talk in circles"... The point is to get you to see what is beyond the words, beyond just what is being said to "what is".

I have never heard any Buddhists deny that Jesus Christ was one with God. In fact, one of the first precepts of Buddhism is that we are ALL "one with God" -- a very accurate perception, since we are all God's sons and daughters, and since we are all God's creations.

If I have heard a Buddhist ever say anything that could be perceived as negative about Christianity it was: "Don't believe everything you read, everything you're told." However, this was not specifically in the context of a discussion about Christianity -- but a general discussion about life in general. I just tend to believe that it applies just as well to Christianity as the rest of life.

Why should I believe in the Bible? I really have no reason to -- my belief in God comes from PERSONAL experiences, and PERSONAL observations, not because a book told me too.

That is not to say that a person can't read the Bible and experience God, but it is DEFINITELY to say that the Bible is not the exclusive key to Him, as far as I am concerned.

I really have no evidence that Christ said that he was God, nor that any Buddhists have called Christ "a liar"... if you read the Bible and consider this sufficient evidence -- then that is your choice and I certainly do not condemn it. But I do note that the Bible is a text written by human hands, that has been translated (by human hand) many, many times from the original Hebrew/Greek (depending on which parts of the scripture you're reading), and that these translators were under MUCH duress from their lieges (such as King James of England) to ensure that the Bible did NOT speak *too* overtly against the power structure. the changes were NOT great -- just the shifting of an adjective here or there to allow for a slightly different interpretation.

As such, while I might tend to believe that much in the Bible *is* true and accurate, it is also important to realize that there is a lot of 'spin' and interpretation going on there as well.

One of the beauties of Buddhism is that it teaches self-reliance. Don't believe that X is true just because it's been told to you. Find out for yourself! I think that that is a beautiful attitude, and one that early Christians (and this is revealed through Roman -historical- documentation) HEARTILY embraced. You don't find the institution of the church becoming so conservative and dogmatic until several hundred years after the death of Christ. In fact, you don't find any institution of the church at all until Jesus is "dead". Jesus himself doesn't advocate a church, etc.

Anyhow, this is not meant to challenge your belief -- but to explain a different perspective that I honestly do not think that you understand. Buddhism is VERY different from Islam, Christianity, Hinduism, Judaism, etc. There is no concept that you must "worship God", there is no "dogma", there are NO REQUIREMENTS. The idea is that any way you can come to understand your place in God's universe is the RIGHT way for *YOU*. The many, many types of Buddhism are all various *devices* to help one attain that understanding, but the devices (burning incense, or the multitude of meditation techniques) are of themselves unimportant. One must be able to discard all that is NOT real/original in ourselves in order to discover that which is real -- which some would refer to as "God". This is not to say that Buddhist's believe "I am God" -- if you hear a Buddhist say that, they are merely acknowledging that "God created me, the Universe, everything. We are not separate from God, or the Universe, or any of it.".

If they happen to say it in a way that you don't understand, or don't agree with? That's okay, because the importance is NOT what is said, it's what lies in the meaning...

To a Buddhist, the idea that God would care whether we refer to Him as "God", "Allah", "Jehovah", "Vishnu", or "Chi-chi" is silly. The important thing is that one *reverance* whatsoever you call God -truly- from your -heart- and not from the cluttered bureau drawer of the mind. That one allow God to enter into one's life and not resist (as so many do).

Anyhow, this is just to try and explain a Buddhist perspective. *I* am not a Buddhist -- but not many people who understand Buddha's point about 'be a light unto yourself' would really bother to be a Buddhist. Or any other religion for that matter.

To me, and to a Buddhist, it's all about "God" and our connection. How you get to that connection is irrelevant.



Actually the reason that I said ugh! was because Bombadil did not make me think of a Buddhist at all, and it does not really answer my question about who he really is.

~Ariana

*LAUGH* Then you really really could use more experience of Buddhists. Tom Bombadil's actions, speech, and deeds in the LotR are PURE ZAZEN!!! Now I would never insinuate, nor believe, that Tolkien did this intentionally, but that is the case.

Once again -- this is just to try and explain a bit about Buddhism's perspectives on things...
 
Well, I must admit that you do appear to know more about Buddhism than I do. As I said before I am only learning. However, I would challenge you this. what do you believe? I believe that Bible is true and that even though it was written by the hands of men it was inspired by the Holy Spirit of God dwelling in them. Therefore, even though the Bible has things that we do not always understand and tend to argue about, it is true. I also believe that Jesus Christ is the Son of God and one with God. We are called the children of God because we were created by Him, but we are not His equals. We are sinners and unholy and unworthy to even stand in his presence. We deserve death and eternal separation from Him, but because He loves us, He died on the cross for us to pay for our sins. We can do nothing to save ourselves save to accept the free gift that He offers us.

Thanks for the information about Buddhism, I will definately look farther into it.

~Ariana
 
Originally posted by Ariana Undomiel
Well, I must admit that you do appear to know more about Buddhism than I do. As I said before I am only learning. However, I would challenge you this. what do you believe? I believe that Bible is true and that even though it was written by the hands of men it was inspired by the Holy Spirit of God dwelling in them. Therefore, even though the Bible has things that we do not always understand and tend to argue about, it is true. I also believe that Jesus Christ is the Son of God and one with God. We are called the children of God because we were created by Him, but we are not His equals. We are sinners and unholy and unworthy to even stand in his presence. We deserve death and eternal separation from Him, but because He loves us, He died on the cross for us to pay for our sins. We can do nothing to save ourselves save to accept the free gift that He offers us.

Thanks for the information about Buddhism, I will definately look farther into it.

~Ariana

Hi Ariana -- my beliefs are actually based on my personal observations and experiences, which means that what I profess is a pretty eclectic and odd assortment of ideas from across the philosophical/scientific/religious spectrum of thought.

I can respect and appreciate your beliefs -- but must note that I personally have never had any experiences that lead me to believe that God believes us to be unworthy to stand in his presence, nor that we will receive any special punishment for closing our hearts and minds to God. My experience is that those who close their hearts and minds to God (or the Universe, Life, etc. He doesn't only go by the English moniker "God") are punishing themselves quite effectively enough.

I do find the idea that God would create us, breathe independence into us, and then condemn us for straying in our ignorance, somewhat hard to swallow -- but again that is just ME personally, and that based upon my personal experiences, which only encompass one human beings relatively short lifespan. :)

I guess that I personally feel that God will simply put us into the same hard situations over and over again until we choose to overcome them by opening ourselves to Him/The Universe... I DO think that this is true in the context of our individual lifespans -- but I also would speculate that this might be the case after death as well (indicating reincarnation)... and this is backed up by the spectacular body of scientific evidence that I've gathered to . . . oh wait, no it isn't. I have no idea what happens when we die, obviously. :D

I would agree with you that we are NOT His equals -- in the same sense that no part of a human body is the equal of the whole. But I would state that my personal (limited, but deep and meaningful!) spiritual experience is that the Creator is NOT separate from His Creation -- we are ALL "God" in our own way (in the same sense that a blood cell in your body is also "You" to some degree), and the sum of all of us is "God", "The Universe", "Existence", etc -- which is obviously somehow a much greater value than merely summing up all of the various bits. :D

IMHO, it's not even possible for us to be separated from God -- not even for the slightest bare moment... even though it is quite possible for us to pretend that we are separate (which, IMHO, causes a lot of pain and suffering)...

Thanks for the thoughtful reply!
 
but must note that I personally have never had any experiences that lead me to believe that God believes us to be unworthy to stand in his presence, nor that we will receive any special punishment for closing our hearts and minds to God. My experience is that those who close their hearts and minds to God (or the Universe, Life, etc. He doesn't only go by the English moniker "God") are punishing themselves quite effectively enough.

Upon what do you base these beliefs? How do you know that what you are saying is true?

I do find the idea that God would create us, breathe independence into us, and then condemn us for straying in our ignorance, somewhat hard to swallow -- but again that is just ME personally, and that based upon my personal experiences, which only encompass one human beings relatively short lifespan.

Why is that hard to believe? When a good father has a son, he will teach him the right way to live. He lays down laws that he expects his son to follow. If the son does not follow them, then he will have to face the consequences. It is the same way with God. He created everyone and gave them instructions that can be found in the Bible. When people fail to follow those rules and guidelines then they and others suffer the consequences. God doesn't want His people to suffer, but nor is he a dictator who forces people to obey his every whim. He is gentleman, and gives us the right to choose if we will obey him or not.



guess that I personally feel that God will simply put us into the same hard situations over and over again until we choose to overcome them by opening ourselves to Him/The Universe... I DO think that this is true in the context of our individual lifespans -- but I also would speculate that this might be the case after death as well (indicating reincarnation)... and this is backed up by the spectacular body of scientific evidence that I've gathered to . . . oh wait, no it isn't. I have no idea what happens when we die, obviously.

What do you believe will happen to you when you die? I mean have you actually sat down and seriously thought about it? And if you haven't, don't you think you should? And if you believe in reincarnation, once again, how do you know that what you are saying is true?



I would agree with you that we are NOT His equals -- in the same sense that no part of a human body is the equal of the whole. But I would state that my personal (limited, but deep and meaningful!) spiritual experience is that the Creator is NOT separate from His Creation -- we are ALL "God" in our own way (in the same sense that a blood cell in your body is also "You" to some degree), and the sum of all of us is "God", "The Universe", "Existence", etc -- which is obviously somehow a much greater value than merely summing up all of the various bits

What makes you think that we are all part of "God" "The Universe" etc? And what makes you think that the universe and God are all one thing? Is it not a possible concept that before there was time or life there was and still is an intelligent, omnipotent, omniscient being who created time, the earth, the universe? It sounds to me that you have a very New Age view of life and "God".



IMHO, it's not even possible for us to be separated from God -- not even for the slightest bare moment... even though it is quite possible for us to pretend that we are separate (which, IMHO, causes a lot of pain and suffering)...

So you believe that we suffer because we are pretending that we are separated from God? Upon what do you base this belief? Do you believe that you and I and the universe and all that exists are "God" as a whole but as separate units?

Thank you for taking the time for such a drawn out reply. I hope you don't take offense by mine.

~Ariana
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top