Well, I had a heart leap all four times I watched the movie at the cinema when there was the water avalanche with
Arwen's deep voice calling for the waves to drag away
the black riders, it really filled me with emotion even though I hated the fact that
Glorfindel had been wiped from the original story in favor of Liv Tyler's character.
But I think the scenes that really, really got to me were
the one where
Frodo tells
Aragorn that he's going to have to leave on his own, and
Boromir's death. This one made me cry, just like when I read the book.
Anyway, even though I like the extended version and I'm grateful for all the details it returns from the book to the screen, I have to say that the cinema version in my opinion has a big point in the plus column, the way it breaks from the prologue to the beginning of TFotR with Frodo surrounded with green, sitting under that tree while
Gandalf's singing announces that the wizard has come. That was really beautiful