• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

what is your favourite scene in the fellowship of the ring?

Holly

New Member
Joined
May 19, 2003
Messages
24
We've all had a chance to view the extended edition (over and over again!). I was wondering what are everyone's favourite scenes?

Mine are:

1. When the fellowship are surrounded by Orcs in Moria, and they all run away when they hear the Balrog coming.

2. When the fellowship arrive in Lothlorien.
 
Well, I had a heart leap all four times I watched the movie at the cinema when there was the water avalanche with Arwen's deep voice calling for the waves to drag away the black riders, it really filled me with emotion even though I hated the fact that Glorfindel had been wiped from the original story in favor of Liv Tyler's character.

But I think the scenes that really, really got to me were the one where Frodo tells Aragorn that he's going to have to leave on his own, and Boromir's death. This one made me cry, just like when I read the book.

Anyway, even though I like the extended version and I'm grateful for all the details it returns from the book to the screen, I have to say that the cinema version in my opinion has a big point in the plus column, the way it breaks from the prologue to the beginning of TFotR with Frodo surrounded with green, sitting under that tree while Gandalf's singing announces that the wizard has come. That was really beautiful
 
Mine has definatly got to be all of the Legolas fighting scenes in particular,

1. The part at Amen Hen where he has two orcs running at him one right behind the other and he shoots an arrow right through both of their necks at the same time.

2. Still at Amen Hen. Legolas Stabs an orc w/ an arrow and then pulls out his bow and shoots another orc w/ the same arrow.

and number 3:

In Moria, the fellowship has escaped Balin's and is just about to cross the bridge as dozens of speeding arrows from Goblins come at their feet on the steps. He [Legolas] draws the bow and lets fly and hits a Goblin hundreds of feet away in the head. So cool!

Those are my top three. I also liked the scene where Frodo and Aragorn are in the canoe and go by the two statues of the old kings.
 
wait . . . i have more:

1. at the council of elrond when frodo stops the arguing and says he will take the ring but "i do not know the way." i LOVE that part! it gets me all teary eyed every time!

2. i have to say boromir's death as well. its the fact that he keeps fighting with three arrows in him. makes me cry every time.

3. i love the entire lothlorien section of the movie.

4. OMG, i just remembered one! when same goes and chases frodo into the water. it makes my eyes get watery just thinking about it!

the soundtrack always bring the movie flooding back and i find myself getting all emotional. its so embarrassing!
 
ladyoflorien

I have to go with you on Legolas's scenes. He's great with the knives and in the Amon Hen battle with the arrows, I heard when I watched the version with the cast's comments, it was Orlando Bloom's idea to use them to impale the uruk-hai and then shoot the same arrows. He said it was because he had to be very fast and very smooth, elf-like, and in hand-to-hand combat with the bow that required some original move, so he tried that and PJ liked it.
 
hmm let's see

the shire scenes; these were all so good and carefree, they were the lighter scenes in the movie

when Merry and Pippin are hiding in the bushes, and Merry figures out that Frodo's leaving, then he and Pippin distract the orcs so Frodo can get away


on the EE, in Lorien when Legolas finds the lembas, Merry and Pippin made me laugh (again) in this scene. (also, with the commentary Orlando calls it his Lembas commercial, it was funny)

after Frodo recovers in Rivendell, and he and sam walk outside to see Merry, Pippin and they're all happy to see each other, then Frodo sees Bilbo sitting down

The whole Council of Elrond scene

When Frodo is standing on the shore, holding the ring and he's crying, this scene makes me cry everytime i see it
 
yes i'm in the right movie
this was taken from the fotr transcript

FRODO runs away, sees MERRY and PIPPIN hiding.

PIPPIN
Here, Frodo, hide here!

FRODO shakes his head.

PIPPIN
What's he doing?

MERRY
He's leaving.

PIPPIN
No, Frodo!

PIPPIN bolts from his hiding place, only to realize that
he has been seen by ORCS. MERRY determines that they must
provide a distraction so that FRODO can get away.

MERRY
Run, Frodo. Go.

MERRY waves his arms at the approaching ORCS.

MERRY
Hey, you, over here, this way!

MERRY and PIPPIN run, leading a pack of ORCS. FRODO runs
the other way.

PIPPIN
It's working!


MERRY
I know it's working, run!
 
Originally posted by liteheartdmerry
yes i'm in the right movie
Sorry - you said about that right after you said about the shire scenes - didn't realise you'd skipped right through to the end of FOTR!
Even closer to the end, on the river bank, did PJ force yet another itty-bitty tear on to poor Elijah? If you say he did, I believe you:)
And yes Anna, they are two different kinds of orc - thank you.
 
Last edited:
Hey, I was just sayin'.
I had a rerun of this same conversation on a tv forum three days ago. I just think that we have to be all more or less fans of Tolkien to be here, so I dare think we all more or less have clear in mind the difference between an orc and a troll and an uruk-hai, so it may happen every once in a while that a guy might find it easier to give it for granted that all concerned understand little slips for sake of brevity, especially when you have to choose between a three letter syllable and a word that is likely spelled in a different way for any translation of the book.
and that was in no way related to me, nooooo

:p
 
From the extended/extra scenes it has to be when the fellowship are sailing away from Lorien and Legolas asks Gimli what he asked as a gift from Galadriel.
Gimli is so adorable!

From the actual film, I love outside Moria when Gandalf is dead because the landscape is so bleak with the grey and white rocks and the music seems to take over the sound. That always gets me!

And of course any Shire scenes!
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top