Who are we in Tolkien's Middle-Earth?

[Ithrynluin]

Which character are you most like in Tolkien's ME? Please concentrate on the 3rd Age,but if you really cannot find an equivalent for yourself or for others there,you can go back to the first two ages.
What do you think - how do other people perceive you? Which character do you bear the most resemblance to in your opinion?
What about other members - could you identify them with anyone?

On another forum, I was told I am the most like Celeborn or Gildor Inglorion. I'll let you be the judges.

I have made some choices about certain members already :

Grond = Elrond. Very knowledgeable,wise,kind and powerful (being a mod and all)
Our webmaster Dave = Ilúvatar or Manwë, the creator of our universe here. He rarely takes part in our discussions here, but he intervenes if something goes amiss.
Confusticated - one of Gildor Inglorion's company maybe.... I could be wrong of course.

I have more but this should be enough to get us started.

This will hopefully be a lot of fun.

 

[Kementari]

Heres who i think the staff are most like :

Dave (WM): Manwe
Anc: Gandalf
Grond: Elrond
Cir: Faramir or Boromir
Lanty: Legolas (or another elf)
Mike (Beorn): Frodo
Tal: Eowyn
RangerD: Tom Bombadil
ReadWryt: Denethor.. (or the Balrog)

 

[Anamatar IV]

hmm. Im sure confy would LOVE to be compared to one of them ( ) Lets see...WM---eru

Anc: Manwe
Grond: well...I dont think a giant hammer is a character so Orome (yes I am having the staff be the valar---if i can remember the names )
Cir: Tulkas
I dont remember any more names so Ill get back to you on the other 5.

 

[Confusticated]

One that I have thought for awhile is:
Maedhros = Feanor
No one else stands out so greatly as reminding me of a charactor though. These next are not accurate because they are based inconsistently.
ithrynluin = Saruman
Aule = Smaug
Grond = Sam
Anamatar = Pippin
Gothmog = Cirdan
Beleg = Caranthir
Turgon = Turgon
Ancalagon = Thingol
Walter = Gwaihir
Celebthol = Merry
Eriol = Curufin
Inderjit S = Amrod
Rangerdave = Tom Bombadil

 

[Ithrynluin]

Originally posted by Anamatar IV
hmm. Im sure confy would LOVE to be compared to one of them ( ) Lets see...WM---eru

Anc: Manwe
Grond: well...I dont think a giant hammer is a character so Orome (yes I am having the staff be the valar---if i can remember the names )
Cir: Tulkas
I dont remember any more names so Ill get back to you on the other 5.

Though the moderators do have the function of the Valar here, I don't agree with your choices.

Kementari - RD as Bombadil? Wow,that's fabulous!

RangerDave is a merry fellow
bright blue his hat
and his socks are yellow

Lanty makes a great Legolas and Anc could pass for Gandalf.

Anamatar, you remind me most of Pip or Merry.

My Confy, how come you see Grond as Sam? Finrod is a bit strange too but I think I know what you mean!

 

[Anamatar IV]

Thats insulting

And since Orome and tulkas are the only 2 valar I remember I just picked the 1st 2 mods that came to mind. *mutters*pippin!? Merry!? I am NOT a clutz.

hmm. how about YAYGollum as Smeagol?

 

[Ithrynluin]

Okay, YayGollum as Smeagol (now that was a toughie!)
Talimon can be a bit Sarumanish so I nominate him as Saruman.
Nenya Evenstar= an elven maiden...maybe Nimrodel
Elgee (HLGStrider) = Goldberry...or Eowyn - I can't decide.

Any comments?

 

[Ithrynluin]

Originally posted by Nóm
ithrynluin = Saruman *hides*

Wow, you see me as Saruman? Why is that?

Rúmil = Rúmil.....j/k Prolly Elrond or Círdan (Finrod?)
gate7ole = Turgon
Gil-Galad = Fingon or Gil-Galad
Wonko the Sane = Bill the Pony or Pippin

 

[ILLOTRTM]

hoooooo boy..... well...hmmm... uuuhhh... uumm... oh I dunno. I must say, RD as Bombadil? That's a GREAT comparison! heeheehee....
hmmmmm... Anamatar, I want to say Eru... but... I dunno. I don't know who to compare myself to. Any ideas?

 

[Ascamaciliel]

I'm not saying you're like him, but all those "hmmmmmmms" in your post reminded me of Treebeard

 

[Ithrynluin]

Anamatar as Eru? Huh?

And yes, ILLOTRTM does remind me of Treebeard with all the "hmms"!

 

[Anamatar IV]

yes...me as Eru

Imagine what I could do with that power. omg I was coughing for hours when I read that caps person.

I would have to say Sting and Azog as merry and pippin though

 

[Rangerdave]

And just how did all of you come up with this mysterious opinion of little ole me? I would love to know

The only way to get a straight answer from Rangerdave was to look every reply in a mirror while hanging upside-down from the ceiling."

"Did it work?"

"Oddly enough, yes. Or, after a while you passed out and had a vision. Either way, the result was pretty much the same.

yes, I guess that does sound like me

RD

 

[Dragon]

I don't know about everyone else, but my friends would say I'm most like aragorn even though I think I'm like bill the pony... following people around... carrying all there stuff... not smart ehough to spell "their" right... can't count....

but then, that's just my opinion

 

[ILLOTRTM]

I suppose I just kind of saw Anamatar's personality close to Eru's. Heh heh.... yeah, I say hmmmm a lot... oh boy, now my friends are going to start calling me Treebeard! I dunno, but I for some reason always saw myself a little bit like Eowyn.....

 

[Frodorocks]

I've always been like Eowyn, the way she dressed up like a man to do battle and whupped @$$. But I love trees so Im like Quikbeam. Wonko the Sane is a good pippin. Snaga is like a wanna be Sauron. HgLStrider is more of a Goldberry than a Eowyn because she's more light hearted. Ulairi, the mouth of Sauron.

 

[Lantarion]

Me as Legolas?! Why didn't you just spit in my face and kick me in the shin and get it over with?!
I think I'm more like Tilion (Hooray for the Wayward!), or another Maia. But Check-Out-My-Leggings Legolas? No thank you.

 

[Beleg]

Shakes head.

This is insane stuff.

Anyway,

Nom=Andreth or Isfin.
Meadhros=Finwe
Lhunithieliel=Lobelia Sackwille Baggins.
Inderjit S=Pippin
Aule=Pippin
Rhiannon=Ewoyn
Celebthol=Bill the Pony
Snaga1=Gandalf
Yaygollum=Gollum, not Smeagol.
Ciryaher=Lotho or Searos

 

[BlackCaptain]

I wonder what I'd be...

 

[HLGStrider]

Obviously, BC, you're Ioreth. . .the nurse in the House of Healing.

Elgee (HLGStrider) = Goldberry...or Eowyn - I can't decide

Depends on my mood.

HgLStrider is more of a Goldberry than a Eowyn because she's more light hearted.

When you write HGLStrider I am Eowyn. . .and you're a certain Nazgul. . .

Eriol is Faramir.
Elbereth could be Melian if she'd just go for motherly more. . .which she can do very decently when she wants to.
Mrs. Maggott could easily be Rosie. I can see her giving Sam a lecture when he gets back from roving and then keeping the Mayor's house perfectly.
Dr. Ransom is my Sam. . .does that mean he has to marry Mrs. Maggott? I think Mrs. Maggot is already married. . .and he's a bit young for her.
Hmmmm. . .
Grond is my Gandalf.
(You don't mind me owning all of you, do you?)
I'm keeping this mostly Lord of the Rings because I know I will make less spelling mistakes that way. . .

Personally, I could be Goldberry but not as well as I could be Queen Bethriel. . .by way of the cats. . .and the appeal of Eowyn's love for Aragorn makes her also appealing.