• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Who came with Aragorn when he captured the ships?

krash8765

Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2002
Messages
117
When Aragorn road with the dead men of dunharrow and the dunedain he captured the corsair fleet at Pelargir. What confuses me is that did he bring reinforcements from the fiefs of Gondor, or just the dead men of dunharrow or both? His arrival definately turned the tide of the battle so he must of brought alot of troops with him at a minimum of around 4,000. do you think is right?
 
The Dead were released following the assault on Pelargir. Aragorn led the men from the fiefs of Gondor who gathered to him after the fear of the Dead was removed, and turned the tide of the Battle of the Pelanor. This was partly because of the soldiers he brought with him, yes, but also because of the surprise and fear factor. He arrived in ships which should carry the allies of Mordor, not their greatest foe!
 
So about how many forces did aragorn bring with him? 5,000 or 7,000? He would need alot of forces to turn the tide of battle because there must of been atleast 30,000 forces of mordor, southrons and easterlings and reinforcements came from Cair andros and reinforcements from osgiliath such as the men from far harad. According to the size of the forces of Minas Tirith they were the free forces were outnumbered i would say atleast 3 to 1 if not 4 to 1. I dont see how the forces of sauron could not simply flank all of them and crush them with their sheer numbers.
 
I'm resurrecting this old thread (which came up as an Internet search result) because I got into a debate with someone on Quora over this same basic question. This person argues that the movie's version of the Battle of the Pelennor Fields is more believable with the Dead turning the tide of the battle, and giving absurd numbers like 100k of the enemy and 12.5k of Gondorians and their allies. Anyway, here's the question:
But the numbers are rather vague. What are the numbers of the enemy laying siege to Gondor and at the Battle of the Pelennor? And how many men did Aragorn bring on the ships he took from the Corsairs?
 
I'm resurrecting this old thread (which came up as an Internet search result) because I got into a debate with someone on Quora over this same basic question. This person argues that the movie's version of the Battle of the Pelennor Fields is more believable with the Dead turning the tide of the battle, and giving absurd numbers like 100k of the enemy and 12.5k of Gondorians and their allies. Anyway, here's the question:

But the numbers are rather vague. What are the numbers of the enemy laying siege to Gondor and at the Battle of the Pelennor? And how many men did Aragorn bring on the ships he took from the Corsairs?
Well...it wasn't JUST 12.5 Gondorians. There were the Rohirriam, the Gondorians were in a fortress, Aragorn arrived with a FLEET of ships manned by the men the commanders had to leave behind. There's also the layout of the field, Aragorn was coming up on the rear, meaning the enemies were caught between two forces.
 
Well...it wasn't JUST 12.5 Gondorians. There were the Rohirriam, the Gondorians were in a fortress, Aragorn arrived with a FLEET of ships manned by the men the commanders had to leave behind. There's also the layout of the field, Aragorn was coming up on the rear, meaning the enemies were caught between two forces.
There's also the psychological factor which Tolkien mentions... the soldiers of Mordor were thrown into confusion when, instead of the expected southern reinforcements, Aragorn and scores of allies disembarked from the ships in a flood. The orcs thought some "wizardry" was at work.

So not only are they unexpectedly facing an increased number of the enemy (and now with no additional help forthcoming) they think magic (wizardry) is being used.
So their strategy that relied on reinforcements from the south is now useless; their leaders are forced to improvise on the spot and that puts them at a disadvantage, and the rank and file are now in disarray.

Confusion in battle begets more confusion which leads to fear and breakdown of discipline.
It doesn't guarantee Mordor forces would be defeated, but their leaders now have to expend time reorganizing (and remotivating) their own soldiers, making them more vulnerable while they try to establish order and battle plan(s).
Not a good position for any field commander to be in.
 
Last edited:
There's also the psychological factor which Tolkien mentions... the soldiers of Mordor were thrown into confusion when, instead of the expected southern reinforcements, Aragorn and scores allies disembarked from the ships in a flood. The orcs thought some "wizardry" was at work.

So not only are they unexpectedly facing an increased number of the enemy (with no additional help forthcoming) they think magic (wizardry) is being used.
So their strategy that relied on reinforcements from the south is now useless; their leaders are forced to improvise on the spot and that puts them at a disadvantage. and the rank and file are now in disarray.

Confusion begets more confusion which in battle lead to fear and complete breakdown of discipline.
It doesn't guarantee Mordor forces would be defeated, but their leaders now have to expend time reorganizing (and remotivating) their own soldiers.
Not a good position for any commander to be in.
Not only that. But they had just lost the Witch King. Biggest surprise of all. And demoralizing.

They had begun by feeling invincible.

By the time they saw that the ships were foes, and not friends - they felt VERY vincible. "I'm Vince, you're Vince... we're ALL Vince!"
 
It may also have to do with the Orcs generally only being successful when employed in overwhelming numbers - perhaps at least 10 to 1. Remember when Fingolfin's forces, freshly landed in M-e - after enduring the Grinding Ice! - swiftly reduced a numerically superior force of Orcs ambushing them (and thus having the advantage of surprise) into so much Orc hamburger patties, and driving them back to the gates of Angband.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top