• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Why did the Watcher go for Frodo?

The Watcher wasn't much protection from an army, wasn't much a spy either -- the spies have to get back to their mastet to give him tidings. The Watcher could only be useful by turning off a small group, but Saruman did not need that -- he had spies and Orcs to deal with small groups. I do not think that Watcher crept from the ocean -- what are the chances he will stop so far inland. Moria is a much better guess IMHO.
 
Is it possible that Sauron could have created it then given baby Kracken to the Witch King to deliver to the West Gate as a further deterent to gain passage to Moria or for the soul purpose of nabbing the Ringbearer should he chance to pass through Moria which it turned out he did, if he got the Ring Kracken would hardly creep into the tunnels and hide for half a century like some. Yes I'm clutching at straws but ya never know
 
The "baby" watcher wouldn't have time to grow by them. Besides, Sauran had orcs in Moria waiting for anyone that should wish to pass.
 
Originally posted by Gamil Zirak
How did the watcher get out of Moria then?

Like Wesley Snipes got into White House in "Murder at 1600" -- Crawled.


The Moria wasn't an abyss with the passage above it. It was an interconnected set of passageways on different level.
 
How many of these different levels lead out? As far as we know, there were three ways out (the east gate, the west gate, and the tower on top of Moria). None of those three have access to water.
 

It seems like everybody insists that this thing must have been created by Sauron or Saruman or Morgoth? I don't see why. Didn't Gandalf said right there and then that there are more asncient things that Sauron not connected with him. Why it can't be some carnivorous creature that had to eat every now and then (like Shelob).
 

And where does it say thay the creature could not live on dry land?
 
Yes, but what about what on happend on Weathertop? The Ringwraiths seemed to know exactly where they were.
On Weathertop Frodo puts the ring on his finger. That is what attracts the Nazgul to him specifically. The Ringwraiths are enslaved, via their own Rings of Power, to the One Ring and to Sauron. Sauron used the One Ring to enslave them. It's unsurprising that when a few feet from one activating the One Ring by donning it,. much as Sauron their master would do before losing the Ring, they would become aware of its presence.

Frodo isn't wearing the Ring when the Nazgul fails to detect him literally a foot or two away on the road which contradicts the notion that the Ring, absent being worn, attracts Ringwraiths. Likewise the Nazgul attack Crickhollow despite Frodo having departed days prior. They attack mattresses and pillows in the Prancing Pony, and rely on human intel to track the Hobbits to that Inn, despite the fact that the hobbits aren't in the room they attack. Very clearly thay can't detect the Ring even if in very close proximity to it, unless someone is dumb enough to put it on their finger. And even then, the must be close to the wearer to be attracted to it. Frodo dons the Ring when he falls off the table in the common room, and no Nazgul materialize. It's much later after an Easterling or even a half orc sees Frodo's stunt and (Tolkien makes a point) slips quickly out of the inn (to tattle to the Nazgul).
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…