• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Just when is "The Hobbit" movie coming out and...

Freebooter

New Member
Joined
Oct 20, 2008
Messages
8
Hello all,
Just when exactly is "The Hobbit" movie coming out and who is directing it and who plays who in it?
Thanks,
Freebooter
 
I'd love to know the real reason Del Toro chose to delay The Hobbit until 2012. Could it have anything to do with him possibly directing the Dr. Strange movie at around the same time?

In my opinion, they should give it to someone else to direct. Sir Ian ain't gettin' any younger!
 
What? They won't release the Hobbit until the year the world ends? No fair! We'll be too busy screaming and sacrificing to Mayan Gods to bother going to the theatre!
 
What? They won't release the Hobbit until the year the world ends? No fair! We'll be too busy screaming and sacrificing to Mayan Gods to bother going to the theatre!

At least the Mayan Gods don't charge 9 bucks for a medium popcorn :D
 
Sure they do. They just accept payment in the blood of Christian babies. and $9 can get you a lot of baby blood.
 
and $9 can get you a lot of baby blood.

-> my point exactly :p

That said, I'm disappointed about the delay. I was getting excited and am/was feeling pretty optimistic about it
icon14.gif
 
I'd love to know the real reason Del Toro chose to delay The Hobbit until 2012. Could it have anything to do with him possibly directing the Dr. Strange movie at around the same time?

In my opinion, they should give it to someone else to direct. Sir Ian ain't gettin' any younger!

You are quite right - Sir Ian is the only one who can play Gandalf and gosh !!! - he is not getting any younger. I read a while back that he only agreed to come back if Peter Jackson was involved - since Jackson is producing - why doesn't he just pick up the director's baton again - 2012 is unbelievable !!!!!!!:mad:
 
Delayed to 2012? Maybe that's to coincide with the Obama re-election...

Seriously though, I wouldn't be surprised if that's only the first postponement and the whole thing eventually just disappears into the fog: project that just never happened — and maybe that's for the best.

Barley
 
I wouldn't be surprised if that's only the first postponement and the whole thing eventually just disappears into the fog: project that just never happened — and maybe that's for the best.

Barley

Barley, why so despairing? Assuming the story about a delay is legitimate, this franchise is soooo lucrative there is no way these films won't be made.

Sooner or later they will be made and whoever does it will have the resources to do a good job.
 
I just read an interview given by Del Toro to Wired and he says he wants the split between the two movies to happen after the death of Smaug.:eek: Which means I'll have to have someone help me get home because I'll still be traumatised.:(

Is it just me, or does that seem like an extremely weird place to stop, with the "bridge" movie starting with the Battle of Five Armies?
 
Last edited:
Is it just me, or does that still like an extrememly weird place to stop, with the "bridge" movie starting with the Battle of Five Armies?

I always figured that would happen. It's an obvious climax.....

The second supposeded 'bridge' movie will not be so much filling 80 years (60 in the movies, excuse me) between The Hobbit & TLOR, but will show the events such as the 5 armies gathering, the White Council driving out the Necromancer & end with the Battle of the Five Armies & then Bilbo returning home to find the sale of Bag End going on & probably (possibly) Sauron establishing himself in Mordor or something like that.

All this speculation on Aragorn & Arwen, Moria & Balin - Ain't Happenin'.
It would so convolute the story into different directions that it would be all over the place.
 
Originally posted by Bucky
The second supposeded 'bridge' movie will not be so much filling 80 years (60 in the movies, excuse me) between The Hobbit & TLOR, but will show the events such as the 5 armies gathering, the White Council driving out the Necromancer & end with the Battle of the Five Armies & then Bilbo returning home to find the sale of Bag End going on & probably (possibly) Sauron establishing himself in Mordor or something like that.

That actually sounds like a pretty smart approach to the script; I like it. I would actually begin the second movie with a flashback (much extended from the first film - kind of like the Smeagol opening in RoTK) of Gandalf’s visit to Dol Guldur; showing a spooky, graphic depiction of the dungeons and the inner workings of the stronghold (really dark, horror, nightmare stuff for sure). Gandalf would then discover a tormented, starving, delusional Thráin II who babbles a bit, then gives him the key and the map. This would also be Gandalf’s dramatic realization that Sauron is the culprit; and not one of the Nazgûl (flash forward to real time, with the Necromancer's forces beginning to gather). A cozy little ultra disturbing opening to shut up the little pre-13 motor mouths right from the start :D.
 
Originally posted by chrysophalax
I like the way you think, Illuin! :D *toothy Dragon grin*

I think they can get away with a much darker approach in the second film. I can picture Gandalf creeping down a dark corridor, with the wailing and screams of unfortunate prisoners echoing throughout the halls. Maybe have him peek into a few dungeons. In one he sees a couple of nasty looking Goblins laughing as they are brutally beating a captive tied to a pole with whips and sticks. In another, maybe showing a prisoner lying face down on the ground with his legs tied up; his hands tied behind his back; with venomous snakes, spiders, and other creeping things slithering around by his face (maybe cut the scene when a big ol' rattlesnake is ready to pounce - i.e. close up of the snake rearing back - cut the scene, but hear the fateful scream in the background as Gandalf moves on). And then he peeks into another, and sees a couple of vicious Wargs chewing on the mutilated remains of one of their recent kills. Yes….good stuff. Does the dragon have a wish list? Any detailed ideas chrys?
 
And how about prisoners with bloody eye holes like Depp in Once upon a time in Mexico? That would be coo ... especially if they also had machine pistols and a hemp leaf belt buckle
 
That actually sounds like a pretty smart approach to the script; I like it. I would actually begin the second movie with a flashback (much extended from the first film - kind of like the Smeagol opening in RoTK) of Gandalf’s visit to Dol Guldur; showing a spooky, graphic depiction of the dungeons and the inner workings of the stronghold (really dark, horror, nightmare stuff for sure). Gandalf would then discover a tormented, starving, delusional Thráin II who babbles a bit, then gives him the key and the map. This would also be Gandalf’s dramatic realization that Sauron is the culprit; and not one of the Nazgûl (flash forward to real time, with the Necromancer's forces beginning to gather). A cozy little ultra disturbing opening to shut up the little pre-13 motor mouths right from the start :D.

Dear Illuin,
Your above posting was great - I hope that the Hobbit will be somewhat similar to those wonderful ideas:cool:
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top