• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Was Haldir at Helm's Deep?

Gilthoniel

Speak to the hand...
Joined
Feb 16, 2005
Messages
153
I was halfway through the Fellowship of the Ring when it came out on film, and I therefore rushed my reading of the other books, so as not to be caught out again.
Therefore, upon seeing TTT, I could not remember, Haldir coming to help at Helms Deep. So I re-read the series of books, (at a more respectable pace), and yet I still could not find reference to Haldir's being at Helm's Deep. Is this just me, or did Jackson use his 'poetic license' to kill off an important character, and if so what else has changed in this scene from the book?
 
Gilthoniel said:
...did Jackson use his 'poetic license' to kill off an important character, and if so what else has changed in this scene from the book?

Jackson used plenty of poetic license, many on this board argue "way too much." His films are his version of LOTR and in spots differ quite drastically from the books. That said, I still enjoy the films mightily for what they are, and do not compare them to the books at all.

Most important: if you want the "real stuff," read the books! And, welcome to our little asylum! :)

Barley
 
The Elves at Helm's Deep is wrong on at least a couple of levels. First, why is Galadriel asking Elrond for permission to send elves from her realm? But, more to the point, how do the Elves even get there? It's a goodly distance from Lórien to Helm's Deep. According to the map, it's nearly 300 miles.

lotr map.jpeg


Unless Elves can teleport there's simply no possible way they'd get there in time. And they'd have to teleport to be able to get past enemy lines. It's just another stupid and unnecessary change to the tale.

That said, I'm not sure Haldir is very important. I think Jackson killed him off to inject 'pathos' into the story.
 
Last edited:
Interestingly (maybe!), there is a character called Haldir that was killed by orcs in the First Age:

Here Haldir Orodreth's son of Nargothrond was
trapped and hung on a tree by Orcs. Thereafter the Elves of
Nargothrond were yet more wary and secret, and would not
suffer even Elves to stray in their lands.

This is from the Grey Annals entry for 488, and also appears in the Later Annals of Beleriand.
 
Yeah but I'm pretty sure he wasn't at Helm's Deep either 😁
I had to watch the films several times before I even worked out his (Haldir's) name (is it actually mentioned in the dialogue?), there was just this "mystery elf" that was apparently great friends with Legolas(!) that turned up mob-handed and got killed.

Since Legolas only met Haldir when they entered Lothlorien, this is just another layer of Jackson ;)
 
I had to watch the films several times before I even worked out his (Haldir's) name (is it actually mentioned in the dialogue?), there was just this "mystery elf" that was apparently great friends with Legolas(!) that turned up mob-handed and got killed.

Since Legolas only met Haldir when they entered Lothlorien, this is just another layer of Jackson ;)
No, Haldir is canon - he's mentioned by name in FotR.
 
I think Jackson "layered" at least two versions of Film One. And I think in the longer one (run away!)
-- or maybe it was cut -- in any case I think there's a Haldir o Lórien uttered somewhere.

If the name's not mentioned elsewhere in the films, that is 🐾
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top