• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

The Rings of Power Has Five Seasons

Persephone

Formerly known as Narya
Joined
Apr 22, 2002
Messages
1,383
Five seasons of The Rings of Power are already meticulously planned out, including exactly how the show will end. "We even know what our final shot of the last episode is going to be," Payne says. "The rights that Amazon bought were for a 50-hour show. They knew from the beginning that was the size of the canvas – this was a big story with a clear beginning, middle and end. There are things in the first season that don't pay off until Season 5."

"It was like Tolkien put some stars in the sky and let us make out the constellations," Payne says. "In his letters [particularly in one to his publisher], Tolkien talked about wanting to leave behind a mythology that 'left scope for other minds and hands, wielding the tools of paint, music and drama.' We're doing what Tolkien wanted. As long as we felt like every invention of ours was true to his essence, we knew we were on the right track."

It begins during a time of relative peace following the defeat of Morgoth, Sauron's master. The series chronicles the lives and adventures of its ensemble cast and promises to visit the Misty Mountains, the forest elf-capital of Lindon, and the shores of the island kingdom of Númenor.

THOUGHTS? I don't like that they took it upon themselves to meddle in the actual storytelling... saying, "...every invention of ours was true to his essence," will only have bearing if they were true fans of the book who have more or less understood the mythology correctly.

SOURCE: https://comicbook.com/tv-shows/news/lord-of-the-rings-the-rings-of-power-five-seasons/
 
It is as I have always thought it would be. A five year fanfic developed from their interpretation of Tolkien's works. They say as much. This was never going to be, or was it ever planned to be, some exact presentation of the words of Tolkien. This doesn't say that they are changing what Tolkien wrote. It will be interesting to see what they come up with within the framework of Tolkien's world. It's also good they have thought the whole thing out for a five-season run.
 
It is as I have always thought it would be. A five year fanfic developed from their interpretation of Tolkien's works. They say as much. This was never going to be, or was it ever planned to be, some exact presentation of the words of Tolkien. This doesn't say that they are changing what Tolkien wrote. It will be interesting to see what they come up with within the framework of Tolkien's world. It's also good they have thought the whole thing out for a five-season run.
that's what I'm expecting as well.

Well, hopefully they make it entertaining ...
 
In these final weeks running up to the premiere, It's looking to me to be a rather impressive production. I think it will be enjoyable and likely bring a whole new generation of fans to know Tolkien's works. Of course, they will be the ones bitching that everything is all wrong when the Silmarillion is made into a TV show in 2044... ;)
 
Why shall Hope be lost so soon, so swiftly? Not e'en in the slightest?
If RoP makes millions of dollars then it will be open season on the Silmarillion. And just like Amaz*n, the producers won't have any respect for Tolkien's legacy or the fans. You can guarantee it.

200.gif
 
The one thing that concerns me most about 5 years of RoP is the 6 years of complaining about its having been done in the way it was done.
And if this time leading up to it is any indication, the complaining is going to continue to be the major discussion point on every platform, group, page, forum, channel and whatever else can be named that hits the public eye. It will be almost intolerable.
I much look forward to the specific discussions about specific points that people like or don't like, with their reasonings regarding why - so we can move past this "it is to be hated because it is not purist" or "it is to be loved because it is going to be a great effort".

I appreciate everyone who already hates it, by predetermined choice.
I appreciate everyone who already loves it, by predetermined choice.

I just don't appreciate having to listen to it all the time, nor being told how I must think about it, nor - quite frankly - continuing to see such sweeping generalizations derived from such a limited perspective on any side of the coin being what constitutes the makeup of one's enjoyment or dislike of a thing.

Sadly, such an approach to something leaves so much out of one's perspective and picture of life at large, and how to deal with it, take it in, and view it, that such narrowed perspectives demonstrate a fundamental nature that is quite lamentable in and of itself. - at least from my perspective.
 
Well spoken, Enting. I know well that your decision will not be colored by the thoughts of public.

Indeed, 'tis true.
As the newly appointed Curator of the Great Halls of Speculation, you see, I still house RoP therein. Though it sits in my own little special section, in the southeast corner, back of the 9th floor. The tag on the shelf says "Curator's Shelf".
It belongs to no one else, just as no one else's dedicated shelf belongs to the Curator.

There are SO MANY LEVELS upon which to judge what is being done with RoP that this Enting is amazed how narrowed some people have set their blinders.

But then... that is the beauty of 'individualism', is it not? We choose to be who we are and what we are. We choose how we perceive things, and what filters we will set in place to make the universe we create for ourselves 'tolerable'. And from within that universe we interact with all others' universes, and by that interaction - and the flexibility we have built into our own universes - many determinations are already predetermined as well.

this is an incredibly deep subject that takes extensive pondering to begin to assimilate, and be able to see the impacts of as they occur (and better, before they may occur.) Yet most, sadly, don't ponder on them at all, and if they do, it is only after the fact, when alternative results from the initial and 'most opportune moment' are now both in the past, and beyond curing.

But this is a topic for the Floating Log, rather than here, I should think.
So I will leave off any further comment.
 
I much look forward to the specific discussions about specific points that people like or don't like, with their reasonings regarding why - so we can move past this "it is to be hated because it is not purist" or "it is to be loved because it is going to be a great effort".
Indeed. It's why I've been hanging out in The Hall of Fire in discussing Rings of Power. Reasoned discourse on what is being presented instead of the usual crap.
 
Given that people are still complaining about PJ's LotR after 20 years, it's a little optimistic to expect the grumbling about RoP to last only 6 years

Indeed. And yet one can hope. (Which most often leads to disappointment, as mentioned elsewhere.):)
 
Ah, yes. Expectations tend to be premeditated disappointment.

Indeed.
But more specifically:
Unmet expectations lead to frustrations.
Unmet hopes lead to disappointments.
(So says a study by some business magnate whose name I cannot recall..!)
 
Well, I’m two episodes in, and other than Galadriel being given an ordered by Gil-Galad that (to my memory) defies the Ban, I’m still open to the next episode.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top