• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Shallow “Representation”

Trevaduin

New Member
Joined
Aug 24, 2022
Messages
10
SHALLOW "REPRESENTATION"
By Trent Lynn Clark

Amazon’s “The Rings of Power” cost billions and delivered a 100 million person audience that isn’t shabby among today’s streaming options. But the series fell painfully short of replicating the Tolkien legacy with storytelling of multi-generational appeal and deep personal meaning.

This may disappoint Amazon founder Jeff Bezos, a Tolkien fan personally involved in securing the creative rights for “The Rings of Power.” His hopes for the project are hinted at every time he recounts his son’s marching order, “Dad, don’t eff this up.”

But the script for “The Rings of Power” commits the ultimate Tolkienian taboo: talking down to its audience, most notable in how shallow and ham-handed it treats ethnic, racial and cultural representation. This disappointment is profound given that Professor Tolkien teaches the master class on the subject.

Tolkien, a native of Bloem, South Africa’s judicial capital, was the most race-conscious of the Oxford Inklings, a mid-20th-century writer’s club meeting on campus and later at a local pub. The Inklings vowed to fight the cynicism and godlessness of their counterparts at the Frankfurt School in Germany.

While the Frankfurt School spawned doctrines that would eventually become critical race theory, Tolkien and colleagues advocated racial equality as later advanced by the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. in his “I Have a Dream” speech. The former deconstructs the “American Dream” to ensure no oppressor class owns it. Tolkien and King both see a future where all participate in it.

Superficial Tolkien critics argue that “The Lord of the Rings” touches only lightly on race. That view proceeds from ignorance of Tolkien’s personal history, his clash with Aryan faux-supremacy and his denouncing of the politically power-hungry who foment race hatred and violence.

Tolkien readers find his world “white” only because they overlay their own prejudices on his stories, a shallowness allowed only since Tolkien doesn’t declare melanin skin content for his characters. How light or dark is a Hobbit? That is left to the reader’s imagination. Tolkien tells us the “race” of Hobbits resulted from merged ethnicities and genotypes, and that anciently their ancestors were marked by distinct differences in complexion, stature, hair and speech.

“The Lord of the Rings” is, in its essence, a study in racial conflict and comparative merit in coexistence and cooperation. “Representation” is a thing in Tolkien as each member of his Fellowship is selected to “represent their peoples.” Peter Jackson’s film adaptation makes the group look superficially homogenous. But Tolkien’s version stitches together a “Fellowship” whose families don’t intermarry, comprising races at fierce bloody war with each other for most of known history.

Few modern stories offer us the relatable drivers of race reconciliation as well as Tolkien’s “Tale of Legolas and Gimli.” Backdropped by a history of race hatred over millennia, the two characters do not immediately warm to each other. It takes time, shared challenges and eventual understanding of strikingly different cultures before the two characters make peace. Even at the end of their story arc, each clings to dramatically different values, but they accept, even celebrate, those differences.

The actress and comedienne Whoopi Goldberg stunned her audience last year by declaring that the Holocaust wasn’t about race. “It was white-on-white violence,” she later apologized for saying.

Her commentary revealed ignorance that Nazis still persecuted equally meaningless “racial” aspects, like smaller variations in skin tone, facial features and accents stereotypical of “Jews.” It is the reason many non-Jews became misidentified casualties.

“The Rings of Power” makes Whoopi’s same mistake: suggesting melanin content is the essence of race hatred so “representing” it solves all. Tolkien fans rightfully expected a deeper dive skipping the superficiality of “skin color” and portraying actual victims of discrimination.

In that alternative script, Bezos gets his legacy as audiences today, and decades from now, cheer when a character succeeds despite irrational prejudice. That is true “representation.”
 
“The Lord of the Rings” is, in its essence, a study in racial conflict and comparative merit in coexistence and cooperation.
An interesting perspective, the whole writing above.

Regarding just the part I copied out here, I personally feel this sells the essence of LoTR quite short. It is far more than just a study in racial conflict, diving much deeper into the core of humanity and what makes not just us, but all around us, who and what things are.

There are many laudable comments made in the above... I recommend a careful reading and selective pondering.
 
Unfortunately I believe that these days it seems no matter what is said, written or done (past and present) can be and is twisted to suit the agenda of the commentator without due consideration to context, life experience and countless other factors that impact inspiration (or even intended meaning) at the time.
I am not commenting on the above narrative per se which is reasonable and excellently written, but others could easy create a counter argument that would be equally convincing and actually equally valid.
For example, I am not remotely religious and see no religious links in Tolkien (other than maybe paganism) yet others suggest Christianity is a main structure within the writings. That said, given JRRT was religious it is likely I am missing his religious references given that I am not. It is still wonderful to read.
My take has generally been to take things at face value (Tolkien writes great stories inspired by events in his life) and assume people are smiling when making comments unless they make it clear they have malicious intent, in which case I dont need people like that in my life. Personally I could not care less about the ethnicity of a character. It's their story in which I am interested.
My view on Rings of Power is that whilst certainly not standing up against the books (like virtually every book turned film ever made including Lord of the Rings) it was nice to see aspects of Middle-earth brought to life. I enjoyed it.
Let's face it, despite the efforts of authors such as GRR Martin and JK Rowling, making the effort involved in reading books is falling dramatically in popularity in the population as a whole so we may be stuck with less vivid/detailed screen versions.
Ironically though some of the best series and films are coming via Netflix and Amazon as well as UK terrestrial channels, as far as my recent watching goes. I agree it's a pity that ROP does not match some of the others.
 
SHALLOW "REPRESENTATION"
By Trent Lynn Clark
Who?

Amazon’s “The Rings of Power” cost billions and delivered a 100 million person audience that isn’t shabby among today’s streaming options. But the series fell painfully short of replicating the Tolkien legacy with storytelling of multi-generational appeal and deep personal meaning.

This may disappoint Amazon founder Jeff Bezos, a Tolkien fan personally involved in securing the creative rights for “The Rings of Power.” His hopes for the project are hinted at every time he recounts his son’s marching order, “Dad, don’t eff this up.”

But the script for “The Rings of Power” commits the ultimate Tolkienian taboo: talking down to its audience, most notable in how shallow and ham-handed it treats ethnic, racial and cultural representation. This disappointment is profound given that Professor Tolkien teaches the master class on the subject.
Yes.
Tolkien, a native of Bloem, South Africa’s judicial capital, was the most race-conscious of the Oxford Inklings, a mid-20th-century writer’s club meeting on campus and later at a local pub. The Inklings vowed to fight the cynicism and godlessness of their counterparts at the Frankfurt School in Germany.
It has been a long time since I read up on The Inklings, so I may have forgotten, but I don't recall any particular vow about the Frankfurt school in particular,

While the Frankfurt School spawned doctrines that would eventually become critical race theory, Tolkien and colleagues advocated racial equality as later advanced by the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. in his “I Have a Dream” speech. The former deconstructs the “American Dream” to ensure no oppressor class owns it. Tolkien and King both see a future where all participate in it.

Superficial Tolkien critics argue that “The Lord of the Rings” touches only lightly on race. That view proceeds from ignorance of Tolkien’s personal history, his clash with Aryan faux-supremacy and his denouncing of the politically power-hungry who foment race hatred and violence.

Tolkien readers find his world “white” only because they overlay their own prejudices on his stories, a shallowness allowed only since Tolkien doesn’t declare melanin skin content for his characters. How light or dark is a Hobbit? That is left to the reader’s imagination. Tolkien tells us the “race” of Hobbits resulted from merged ethnicities and genotypes, and that anciently their ancestors were marked by distinct differences in complexion, stature, hair and speech.

This is just incorrect. Elves are fair, pale or white and occasionally ruddy. Aragorn is pale, as are the Dunedain of Gondor in contrast to the swarthier Middle Men of Gondor (with whom they sometimes interbred), Tolkien is quite specific with Hobbits. The Fallohides are fairer of skin and the Harfoots are browner of skin (and the Fallohides, Stoors and Harfoots are all breeds of Hobbit, so I am not sure what exactly the author means by "merged ethnicites and genotypes"). That is also in distinction to some groups of Men whom the Hobbits refer to as swarthy. The Rohirrim too are fair-skinned. Dunlendings are swarthier.
The first/only black Men to be met are those out of Far Harad at the Pelennor


“The Lord of the Rings” is, in its essence, a study in racial conflict and comparative merit in coexistence and cooperation.

Starting to read as though the author is trying to make it seem an allegory.

“Representation” is a thing in Tolkien as each member of his Fellowship is selected to “represent their peoples.” Peter Jackson’s film adaptation makes the group look superficially homogenous. But Tolkien’s version stitches together a “Fellowship” whose families don’t intermarry, comprising races at fierce bloody war with each other for most of known history.
Which groups of the Fellowship's races are at fierce bloody war with each other?
 
I have to say, I wonder why anyone shares anything here, when everything they share gets shredded mercilessly.

I see little has changed in my absences. Unfortunately.

Oh that we'd learn how to say what we'd like to say without making others feel inadequate, out of place, or otherwise demeaned.

Tiresome. Simply tiresome.

There. After all this time, I finally said it...!

I fully expect to be banned, having challenged the 'status quo'.
 
I have to say, I wonder why anyone shares anything here, when everything they share gets shredded mercilessly.

I see little has changed in my absences. Unfortunately.

Oh that we'd learn how to say what we'd like to say without making others feel inadequate, out of place, or otherwise demeaned.

Tiresome. Simply tiresome.

There. After all this time, I finally said it...!

I fully expect to be banned, having challenged the 'status quo'.
"The only ill will to be found in this valley is that which you bring yourself."
But as per your post, lemme just add that I'm glad you could empty your heart mate.
 
"The only ill will to be found in this valley is that which you bring yourself."
Thanks for the quote mate.
Not sure where it comes from, though I've heard it before.
That said, personally, I find I need to entirely disagree with it. I see many many valleys full of great ill-will and worse decorum.
Though it does have it's applicability in some select cases I'm sure, I fear it does not fit a very broad base of the Human Animal, who carry their 'ill will' with them everywhere they go.
They also seem to feel "if others don't like it, that's others' problem, not mine." An equally errant supposition.

But then... we all share a different sphere of existence, and those spheres interact regularly. The trick is to have them blend, rather than collide. When both work at a blend, good things happen. When only one works at a blend, it takes far greater effort to make work. (And the inevitable question "is it worth it" surfaces)

Such is life.
 
I have to say, I wonder why anyone shares anything here, when everything they share gets shredded mercilessly.
Ent, ol' tree, merciless shredding is something else than challenging statements which may not hold up to scrutiny of "facts" - which for Middle-earth means "what JRRT himself wrote". Which, as we all know (or can learn), can be debatable when JRRT didn't come to a final decision on matters (Galadriel, Gil-galad, ...). @Tar-Elenion is a veteran of the early days of TTF, about which my reading of relevant discussions is far from complete, to put it mildly. A vague impression that I have of (some of) those discussions of yore is that you would have to excuse Tar-Elenion if, comparing his above post to battles royal of the past, he replied to your comment with the title of that old Bachman-Turner Overdrive song "You Ain't Seen Nothing Yet". Don't forget, there was a time probably long ago that even discussions about politics and religion were allowed on TTF, and on on other JRRT forums, too. Easy to imagine why those doors were slammed shut practically everywhere ...
 
"Thank goodness!" said Bilbo, laughing, and handed him the tobacco jar.
I've read a number of those threads from the Elder Days, and while many are amusing, some give way to pettiness and name-calling; hardly entertaining.

That kind of stuff was all very well, maybe, when dozens of people could be online at any time, but these days, with reddit, quora, Facebook, and other social media available, an old-style forum like TTF can ill-afford to lose people. I hope everyone will keep that in mind. I personally don't want to lose any of our members.

It's possible to disagree in a civil manner.
 
I have to say, I wonder why anyone shares anything here, when everything they share gets shredded mercilessly.

Lets see, I asked who the author (Trent Lynn Clark) of the piece was, Never heard of him.
Not much shredding there.
I agreed with one portion.
No shredding, merciless or otherwise.
I questioned one portion, as I can not recall any specifics.
Nothing shredded there either.
I pointed out factual errors in one portion.
That could be considered shredding. Merciless even.
I then observed that the author seemed like he was making Tolkien's work out to be some sort of allegory.
I don't know if that would be shredding, If so, not merciless.

I see little has changed in my absences. Unfortunately.

I had not noticed.

Oh that we'd learn how to say what we'd like to say without making others feel inadequate, out of place, or otherwise demeaned.
How was Trent Lynn Clark demeaned and made to feel out of place? The author of the article is not even a member, as best I can tell.

Tiresome. Simply tiresome.

Pointing out what Tolkien wrote about his world, as opposed to what others claim he wrote is tiresome...

There. After all this time, I finally said it...!
You have been here for 7 months.
Not a lot of time...

I fully expect to be banned, having challenged the 'status quo'.
Maybe just shredded.
 
Who?


Yes.

It has been a long time since I read up on The Inklings, so I may have forgotten, but I don't recall any particular vow about the Frankfurt school in particular,



This is just incorrect. Elves are fair, pale or white and occasionally ruddy. Aragorn is pale, as are the Dunedain of Gondor in contrast to the swarthier Middle Men of Gondor (with whom they sometimes interbred), Tolkien is quite specific with Hobbits. The Fallohides are fairer of skin and the Harfoots are browner of skin (and the Fallohides, Stoors and Harfoots are all breeds of Hobbit, so I am not sure what exactly the author means by "merged ethnicites and genotypes"). That is also in distinction to some groups of Men whom the Hobbits refer to as swarthy. The Rohirrim too are fair-skinned. Dunlendings are swarthier.
The first/only black Men to be met are those out of Far Harad at the Pelennor




Starting to read as though the author is trying to make it seem an allegory.


Which groups of the Fellowship's races are at fierce bloody war with each other?
(1) Which races "have been at fierce blood war for millenia?" Elves and dwarves obviously, from even before the battles that destroyed the Kingdom of Doriath and slew its King, Thingol. If you recall in the Hobbit, the Battle of the Five Armies ensued interrupting a battle that clearly would have pitted the men of Laketown and the Elves of Mirkwood against the Dwarves of Erebor. Hobbits, had, for their part been afraid of and sought to hide from all three of the other races. The Lords of Numenor, from whom Aragorn descends, had fallen after declaring war on the Elves of the Undying Lands. The Steward of Gondor had rejected the claims of the Dunedain of the North, something that, had Arvedui survived, could have led to warfare between those two branches of men. The Elves of Mirkwood (represented by Legolas) had taken territorial control of their corner of the forest, earning the reputation of being hostile of all other travelers, men and dwarves. . . . . I could go on, but assume the point is made.

(2) This is just "incorrect." Easier to respond if you then pointed to something said that was "incorrect." The fact that Fallohides were described as "fair of skin," doesn't mean "white," and even if interpreted that way only signals that Harfoots and Stoors were less so, thus my point is made. At the time of Bilbo, the three ancestral branches of hobbits had merged, so that "resemblances" to the key characteristics of each was all he could claim. And we know from Bilbo's own genealogy that the three intermarried often and were intermingled into the major families throughout the Shire.

(3) The views of Tolkien and Lewis on Marxism are not hard to discover. A "western enlightened counterpoint" to Hitler's socialism and Stalin's communism was one of the unifying objectives of the Inklings.

(4) The fact that the main story of the LOTR is a war between races of men and orcs makes my comment NOT allegorical. Its interesting to hear people still today deny that Tolkien was highly race-conscious. His mother left South Africa because of race conflict, and Tolkien introduces a "racial" motivation in many of his stories, i.e. economic class disparity, envy of differing physiological traits like lifespan and stature, and just pure generational blood feuds. What distinguishes his treatment is that he makes heroes out of those who overcome racial barriers, who show empathy to other cultures and who break out of the ruts of "traditional enmity." In doing so, I believe Tolkien was ahead of all us in pointing a path toward reconciliation and mutual respect amid difference.
 
(1) Which races "have been at fierce blood war for millenia?" Elves and dwarves obviously, from even before the battles that destroyed the Kingdom of Doriath and slew its King, Thingol.
The claim made was that they were "at fierce bloody war with each other for most of known history".
The example you give would be some Elves (the Sindar of Doriath) and some Dwarves (those of Nogrod, the Dwarves of Belegost were not involved) in a war or battle some 6500 years before. While it did adversely effect relations afterwards, with some Elves long holding a grudge against all Dwarves), the Noldor got along rather quite well with Dwarves. See Eregion. The was even alliance between them.
So there is one 'bloody war' millenia ago, rather than being 'at bloody war for most of known history'.

If you recall in the Hobbit, the Battle of the Five Armies ensued interrupting a battle that clearly would have pitted the men of Laketown and the Elves of Mirkwood against the Dwarves of Erebor.
That would be a 'bloody war' that did not happen. So one bloody war six and a half thousand years before the events of The Hobbit and LotR, and one not bloody not war in the time of The Hobbit.
While in the time before Smaug, there seems to have been good relations between the Men of Dale and the Dwarves of Erebor.
Indeed, Tolkien also writes of the alliance between the Dwarves (the Longbeards in particular (Gimli, a member of the Fellowship, was a Longbeard)) and Men of the North during the Second Age (there were no Northmen in the Fellowship, and I don't recall any bloody war between the Dwarves and the Dunedain).

Hobbits, had, for their part been afraid of and sought to hide from all three of the other races.
Not seeing any 'fierce bloody war for most of known history' there.


The Lords of Numenor, from whom Aragorn descends, had fallen after declaring war on the Elves of the Undying Lands.
So one declaration of war by the King's Men of Numenor against the Valar (a war that did not happen because Eru intervened), while Aragorn was descended from the Faithful of Numenor, (who did not declare war on the Elves of the Undying Lands, and remained Faithful (as the name suggests)).


The Steward of Gondor had rejected the claims of the Dunedain of the North, something that, had Arvedui survived, could have led to warfare between those two branches of men.
"Could have", means did not. So another lack of fierce bloody war for most of known history.

The Elves of Mirkwood (represented by Legolas) had taken territorial control of their corner of the forest, earning the reputation of being hostile of all other travelers, men and dwarves. . . . . I could go on, but assume the point is made.
Not trusting strangers. Though they seem to get along well enough with the Men of Laketown.
I'm not sure how not wanting intruders, unannounced, in your lands becomes a fierce bloody war for most of known history.

But, I think my point is made...

(2) This is just "incorrect." Easier to respond if you then pointed to something said that was "incorrect."

The claim that "Tolkien doesn’t declare melanin skin content for his characters."
As I noted, Tolkien does describe the skin-colour of his characters. Elves are white or pale or fair or, on occasion, ruddy.
Aragorn and the Dunedain are pale complexioned (and the Rohirrim). While some Men are described as swarthy (Dunlendings, Haradrim, some Gondorians). And one group is black (men out of Far Harad).
So the claim made is incorrect.
.

The fact that Fallohides were described as "fair of skin," doesn't mean "white,"
What does it mean?


and even if interpreted that way only signals that Harfoots and Stoors were less so, thus my point is made.
As I noted, Tolkien says the Harfoots were browner of skin. While Hobbits refer to some Men as swarthy or Swertings.
Indicating a darker complexion than the Harfoots, who are browner than the Stoors and fairer skinned Fallohides.
So your point: "How light or dark is a Hobbit? That is left to the reader’s imagination.", is refuted by Tolkien's description.
Or just look at Tolkien's drawings of Bilbo in Pictures (e.g. 9, 14, 20) or A&I.

At the time of Bilbo, the three ancestral branches of hobbits had merged, so that "resemblances" to the key characteristics of each was all he could claim. And we know from Bilbo's own genealogy that the three intermarried often and were intermingled into the major families throughout the Shire.
The claim was: "Tolkien tells us the “race” of Hobbits resulted from merged ethnicities and genotypes, and that anciently their ancestors were marked by distinct differences in complexion, stature, hair and speech."

What Tolkien tells us:
"Before the crossing of the mountains the Hobbits had already become divided into three somewhat different breeds: Harfoots, Stoors, and Fallohides."
LotR, Prologue
So, rather than the three breeds merged resulting in Hobbits, the three breeds were already Hobbits, who later merged (primarily, it seems, in the Shire).


(3) The views of Tolkien and Lewis on Marxism are not hard to discover. A "western enlightened counterpoint" to Hitler's socialism and Stalin's communism was one of the unifying objectives of the Inklings.
I am aware of Tolkien's views. However the specific claim was that the Inklings took a vow to fight the Frankfurt School. I don't see anything in what you wrote that has Tolkien taking a vow about the Frankfurt school.
Perhaps you can provide this vow, properly cited.


(4) The fact that the main story of the LOTR is a war between races of men and orcs makes my comment NOT allegorical.
The claim:
“The Lord of the Rings” is, in its essence, a study in racial conflict and comparative merit in coexistence and cooperation."

LotR, in its essence, is about Death and Immortality and love for the world by a race that is fated to leave it, and a race that is fated to remain. The war is just a setting for the characters.

Its interesting to hear people still today deny that Tolkien was highly race-conscious. His mother left South Africa because of race conflict,
His mother was visiting relatives in England, with JRRT and his brother, when her husband, the manager of a bank, who had remained in South Africa, died suddenly of a fever. As I recall. And so Tolkien's mother did not return, but rather remained in England.
I don't recall it having to do with racial conflict.

and Tolkien introduces a "racial" motivation in many of his stories, i.e. economic class disparity, envy of differing physiological traits like lifespan and stature, and just pure generational blood feuds. What distinguishes his treatment is that he makes heroes out of those who overcome racial barriers, who show empathy to other cultures and who break out of the ruts of "traditional enmity." In doing so, I believe Tolkien was ahead of all us in pointing a path toward reconciliation and mutual respect amid difference.
 
I see what some of the other commenters mean when citing “criticism for the sake of disagreement” rather than enlightenment. Your parsing of the words “vow” and “bloody” by questioning whether Frankfurt was named aloud while arms held to the square and that some race conflicts were more “cold war” than “bloody” makes great “distinctions” but very little “difference.”
 
The Inklings vowed to fight the cynicism and godlessness of their counterparts at the Frankfurt School in Germany.
I own an have read perhaps a dozen books about JRRT which might have touched on such a subject.
They include:
Humphrey Carpenter's "Biography" (1977), "The inklings" (1978), and "Letters" (1981).
Tom Shippey's "The Road to Middle-earth" ( 1992 2nd and 2003 3rd edition), and "Author of the Century" (2000).
Christina Scull & Wayne G. Hammond's "J.R.R. Tolkien Companion and Guide" (2006 two-volume edition).
Catherine F. Crabbe's "J.R.R. Tolkien" (1981).
Patrick Curry's "Defending Middle-earth" (1997).
Joseph Pearce's "Tolkien - Man and Myth" (1998).
Verlyn Flieger's "A Question of Time" (1997).

The Frankfurt School is not mentioned in the index of any of them. And the whole concept of "The Inklings" (do you know who was a "member" of that group for which duration and with what kind of an attendance record?) taking any kind of "vow" seem rather ludicrous. Carpenter in his book concentrates on the three that were the main figures: C.S. Lewis (the gravitational center), JRRT, and Charles Williams. Lewis might be the most prone to such a thing- which does not say much. JRRT doing any such thing is extremely improbably. And with Williams, it is all but certain that he would not.

A claim such as yours that I picked out needs some some seriously reliable and verifiable sources for quotes. This is not a case for interpretations.
 
I own an have read perhaps a dozen books about JRRT which might have touched on such a subject.
They include:
Humphrey Carpenter's "Biography" (1977), "The inklings" (1978), and "Letters" (1981).
Tom Shippey's "The Road to Middle-earth" ( 1992 2nd and 2003 3rd edition), and "Author of the Century" (2000).
Christina Scull & Wayne G. Hammond's "J.R.R. Tolkien Companion and Guide" (2006 two-volume edition).
Catherine F. Crabbe's "J.R.R. Tolkien" (1981).
Patrick Curry's "Defending Middle-earth" (1997).
Joseph Pearce's "Tolkien - Man and Myth" (1998).
Verlyn Flieger's "A Question of Time" (1997).

The Frankfurt School is not mentioned in the index of any of them. And the whole concept of "The Inklings" (do you know who was a "member" of that group for which duration and with what kind of an attendance record?) taking any kind of "vow" seem rather ludicrous. Carpenter in his book concentrates on the three that were the main figures: C.S. Lewis (the gravitational center), JRRT, and Charles Williams. Lewis might be the most prone to such a thing- which does not say much. JRRT doing any such thing is extremely improbably. And with Williams, it is all but certain that he would not.

A claim such as yours that I picked out needs some some seriously reliable and verifiable sources for quotes. This is not a case for interpretations.
There's reference to the Inklings in Letters of JRRT. Don't really have time to read much but here's a start.
16748603240808728823079296640531.jpg
 
Last edited:
(4) The fact that the main story of the LOTR is a war between races of men and orcs makes my comment NOT allegorical. Its interesting to hear people still today deny that Tolkien was highly race-conscious. His mother left South Africa because of race conflict, and Tolkien introduces a "racial" motivation in many of his stories, i.e. economic class disparity, envy of differing physiological traits like lifespan and stature, and just pure generational blood feuds. What distinguishes his treatment is that he makes heroes out of those who overcome racial barriers, who show empathy to other cultures and who break out of the ruts of "traditional enmity." In doing so, I believe Tolkien was ahead of all us in pointing a path toward reconciliation and mutual respect amid difference.
None of which makes Tolkien into some sort of a modernist progressive. Least of all would he be accepting of any sort of globalism, considering his views are best described as anarcho-monarchism, as I also described here.
 
There's reference in Letters of JRRT. Don't really have time to read much but here's a start.
To quote Carpenter from "Inklings":

"Tangye Lean named it (a mainly undergraduate club) "The Inklings".
No record of its proceedings survives, though Tolkien recalled that in its original form the club soon died, probably when Tangye Lean left Oxford in 1933 for a career in journalism and broadcasting."

When the participants of the later Inklings adopted this name for the group Carpenter wrote his book about remains obscure.
 
I see what some of the other commenters mean when citing “criticism for the sake of disagreement” rather than enlightenment.
I tend to think of 'enlightenment as involving facts. If what you are presenting is not factual then it is not enlightening.

Your parsing of the words “vow” and “bloody” by questioning whether Frankfurt was named aloud while arms held to the square and that some race conflicts were more “cold war” than “bloody” makes great “distinctions” but very little “difference.”
I will take it that this is a way of admitting you were incorrect advance the claims that the "“Fellowship” whose families don’t intermarry, comprising races at fierce bloody war with each other for most of known history."
When the only 'fierce bloody war' was a battle 6500 years prior, between a group of Dwarves who were not Longbeards, which the Dwarf rep. in the Fellowship was, and some of Legolas relations. Perhaps you should choose your words more carefully when making claims, as there is quite a difference between a fierce bloody war that has gone on for most of known history and some mutual distrust or dislike.
I did not even bother mentioning the intermarriage, Frodo, Merry and Pippin were relatives, so there was inter-marriage in those families (and post War of the Ring some inter-marriage with Sam's family). Elves and Men on occasion intermarried Aragorn is, at long removes a product of just one such (and if Legolas is in some way related to Thingol, then he would be some sort of distant relation to Aragorn).
Or did you expect some sort of inter-marriage between Dwarves and Elves or Dwarves and Men (when they are evidently not biologically the same race)?

I will also take it that you inability to provide a quote about the supposed vow that the Inklings took re the Frankfurt School, means there was no vow.
It does leave me curious as to why you would make such assertions...
 
The Frankfurt School were the apologist Marxists who were confronted with the obviousness of Nazism and Bolshevism being catastrophic failures at creating "a workers Utopia." They collectively blamed a new culprit: the "superstructure" composed of religion, culture, family, tradition, race and patrimony that favored oppressors and perpetuated the oppressed. So they recommended "cultural revolution," or a complete deconstruction of every shred of religion, culture, family, tradition etc.

When I say the Inklings "vowed" to counter the Frankfurt School, I did not mean the minutes of the Inklings include a solemn ceremony where all members of the society swore an oath. I mean that literally everything the Frankfurt School stood for, the dismantling of legend, religion, tradition and family, was the exact OPPOSITE of what the Inklings ALL sought to promote, preserve and advance. As a group the Inklings mostly despised politics . . . again, the opposite of the Frankfurt School who famously believed "everything is political." The only discussion I've ever read about the group having any kind of ideological "litmus test" was Williams' notes on the lively debate that occurred when Lewis suggested his wife, Joy Davidman, a former atheist and American communist activist, be invited to join in their regular discussions. Again, that discussion ended with agreement to adopt a liberal western "free speech" approach for the Inklings - another position taken completely opposing the "mind control" propagandization advocated by Frankfurt schooler Erick Fromm. Is it purely "coincidental" that this group of well-educated and wide-world-viewed Oxford dons just happened to take positions routinely opposite the leading think tank in Germany at the time? My research suggests such an assumption severely underestimates the collective brilliance of Lewis, Tolkien, Williams and others.
 
The Frankfurt School were the apologist Marxists who were confronted with the obviousness of Nazism and Bolshevism being catastrophic failures at creating "a workers Utopia." They collectively blamed a new culprit: the "superstructure" composed of religion, culture, family, tradition, race and patrimony that favored oppressors and perpetuated the oppressed. So they recommended "cultural revolution," or a complete deconstruction of every shred of religion, culture, family, tradition etc.

When I say the Inklings "vowed" to counter the Frankfurt School, I did not mean the minutes of the Inklings include a solemn ceremony where all members of the society swore an oath. I mean that literally everything the Frankfurt School stood for, the dismantling of legend, religion, tradition and family, was the exact OPPOSITE of what the Inklings ALL sought to promote, preserve and advance. As a group the Inklings mostly despised politics . . . again, the opposite of the Frankfurt School who famously believed "everything is political." The only discussion I've ever read about the group having any kind of ideological "litmus test" was Williams' notes on the lively debate that occurred when Lewis suggested his wife, Joy Davidman, a former atheist and American communist activist, be invited to join in their regular discussions. Again, that discussion ended with agreement to adopt a liberal western "free speech" approach for the Inklings - another position taken completely opposing the "mind control" propagandization advocated by Frankfurt schooler Erick Fromm. Is it purely "coincidental" that this group of well-educated and wide-world-viewed Oxford dons just happened to take positions routinely opposite the leading think tank in Germany at the time? My research suggests such an assumption severely underestimates the collective brilliance of Lewis, Tolkien, Williams and others.
I see. There was no vow. You just made some claim about how The Inklings vowed to fight the cynicism and godlessness of their counterparts at the Frankfurt School in Germany. But don't know if they ever even spoke about the Frankfurt School.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top