• Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is over two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you.  Register

Character Analysis and Discussion - Eowyn Shieldmaiden of Rohan

Eowyn was always one of my favorite characters from the books and I think she was portrayed beautifully by Miranda Otto. As already mentioned, the tomboy side and the feminine side were both portrayed. She was both lovely and cold and I liked how her friendship was shown with Aragorn.

I also hope that her part will be kept the same length or longer in the next movie. Also, I hope that they make her act of killing the Nazgul as important as it is, since that is such an important event.

It's good to see other people who liked Eowyn in the movie and didn't mind her expanded character from the books.

I thought Miranda Otto portrayed Éowyn quite well in the movies. She captured the essence of book Éowyn in my opinion. I also thought her chant in the extended Two Towers was a good addition of Éowyn memorializing her cousin Théodred.

Sadly, twenty years on, and Miranda's Éowyn is remembered for this terrible 'stew' scene. It was terribly disrespectful of the character, and is a prime example of a Peter Jackson low-bar.

 
I thought Miranda Otto portrayed Éowyn quite well in the movies. She captured the essence of book Éowyn in my opinion. I also thought her chant in the extended Two Towers was a good addition of Éowyn memorializing her cousin Théodred.

Sadly, twenty years on, and Miranda's Éowyn is remembered for this terrible 'stew' scene. It was terribly disrespectful of the character, and is a prime example of a Peter Jackson low-bar.

The stew scene is one of my least favorites of the movie and IMO totally unnecessary.
 
You know, when I think of [movie] Eowyn the first scene that comes to mind is with her facing off with the Witchking.
It's also the second scene that comes to mind, and the third and....well, you get the idea.
I had totally forgotten about the stew scene, which never comes to mind.
 
I had totally forgotten about the stew scene, which never comes to mind.

It's primarily on fecebook groups and pages. Someone will post something about either book or movie Éowyn, and no matter what the OP on Éowyn is about, sure as warg-dung the 'stew' comments will start piling up. I made it a sport of blocking the people who feel the need to bring it up. 😆


The stew scene is one of my least favorites of the movie and IMO totally unnecessary.

I agree wholeheartedly.
 

Today's events

Similar threads

Back
Top