Sons of Fëanor, in order of Nastiness?

[ZehnWaters]

I agree that Feanor did decide that nothing in the world wasn't his. And that is exactly what I imagine Feanor saying. He had problems, and he was too possessive, of his father, of his sons, of everything. Oddly enough he didn't seem to care much for his own wife.

I think he did, but he wasn't willing to actually harm her when she rejected him. TBH I see him calling her something much worse than "woman", even though I don't think Tolkien would ever use those words. Fëanor would probably just be like "Good luck finding someone better than me!" (Nerdanel was described as "not the fairest" Noldo out there; Nerdanel, the plain lol.)

 

[Beleg_Cúthalion]

I think he did, but he wasn't willing to actually harm her when she rejected him. TBH I see him calling her something much worse than "woman", even though I don't think Tolkien would ever use those words. Fëanor would probably just be like "Good luck finding someone better than me!" (Nerdanel was described as "not the fairest" Noldo out there; Nerdanel, the plain lol.)

Aye, at least Feanor didn't try to kill Galadriel or Nerdanel

 

[Elthir]

OOOOOO I see what you're doing.

LOL! I must have been
a little transparent yes
terday!

That makes sense since Maglor exits history at that point. Legends could crop up around him.

Agreed!

side note: I first read Legolas for "Legends" here. Apparently just seeing leg kicks off some sort of Tolkienian reaction in my skull-chamber

 

[ZehnWaters]

Aye, at least Feanor didn't try to kill Galadriel or Nerdanel

So I suppose he's doing better than Maeglin and Eöl in that regard?

 

[Beleg_Cúthalion]

So I suppose he's doing better than Maeglin and Eöl in that regard?

Aye, at least he didn’t force Nerdanel to go with him. All the elves who were grump and dark in personality and too prideful are not great though.